News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by Terry_Roll on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:55PM (#30236912)
Something not mentioned is the additional security built into the obvious wax seal.

So in order to test couriers credibility and trustworthyness to deliver wax sealed parchments, a courier would be required to collect and deliver said parchment in a controlled experiment. So the route would be lined with spies in on the test who could report back anything untoward. The wax seal would be laced with Atropa Belladonna[1] which when inhaled from melted wax would cause the pupils to dilate and the delivery point would be dark. So when the courier handed over the parchment a lantern would be held up to the couriers face to see if the pupils constricted in the light. If the courier had melted the wax laced with belladonna, their pupils would look like saucers and the recipient would know the wax seal had been melted & vapours inhaled. It was a measure to protect against counterfeiting wax seals.

I dont think this knowledge made it to the US, but it was very common in Europe.

Loyalty & trustworthy tests still go on today, but they have evolved somewhat with the times, but you may not even realise you have been tested!

[1] https://www.historyandwomen.com/2012/07/fatal-beauty.html#:~....

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by brnaftr361 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:56PM (#30236337)
I really like tally sticks[0]. Obscenely simple, but profoundly secure. You've got the species of wood, the unique grain, exact dimensions, the exact partnership between the two pieces, the human scrawling... This multi-dimesional identifying mechanism and it's little more than a couple of mundane pieces of wood with some contract etched into it.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tally_stick

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by dredmorbius on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:40PM (#30237293)
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by marvel_boy on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:32PM (#30236688)
Here is also more about split tally sticks in medieval times: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DkyahZplFo
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by Biganon on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:46PM (#30238742)
What's stopping the debtor from just defacing their half? Making it slightly incompatible with the half of the creditor?
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by brnaftr361 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @09:46PM (#30239646)
The video Marvel_boy[0] posted details one of the conventions. In that case it's a subtractive process, so defacing the receipt in that case would be of no benefit, perhaps even disadvantageous. In other cases, such as tax records, it would only be to someone's disadvantage to destroy. Of course this all depends on the convention used to draw it up.

Speculatively:

There could simply be an ass whoopin' dished out, theft is a sin, or a threat to credit. From my understanding the vast majority of people never travelled very far, the estimate I heard was about 30mi being the known world to most folks. So having a bad reputation is a pretty good disincentive. It's also my understanding that debt, rather than barter, was the predominate mode of exchange (a la Graeber), but that would've been trusted neighbors and necessities in communal self-interest; so bad credit and the consequent marred reputation could spell disaster. I don't imagine that most documents recorded on tally sticks were Josiah giving neighbor Jebediah five carrots for future remuneration of seven; rather strange gentry arranging commercial exchanges, and the state issuing and recording taxes. I'm not an expert, though.

[0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DkyahZplFo

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by daenz on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:25PM (#30234613)
Impressive but honestly I am more impressed by the quality of handwriting at that time. The penmanship appears flawless and beautiful. I'm not seeing any typos or corrections. The authors must have had incredible focus and a crystal clear vision about what exactly they were going to communicate (certainly from many previous drafts). It makes me think that we lost something valuable when our published words became so "cheap" by comparison.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by hhs on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:43PM (#30234839)
If interested, there was a post on Timothy Matlack’s great penmanship with writing the Declaration of Independence: https://prologue.blogs.archives.gov/2021/07/01/the-power-of-...
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by lelandfe on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:12PM (#30237539)
> The formality and skill of the engrossed copy strengthened the persuasiveness of the Declaration by distancing its arguments from any individual. The document [also] helped protect the identities of the signers — the names were kept secret until 1777

This is a fascinating aside that I'd never considered before (and I did not know that the signatories were kept secret for some time). Thanks for the link.

I wonder if keeping the signatories secret was done to temporarily give the appearance of unanimity, since some congressmen refused to sign.

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by NoSorryCannot on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:15PM (#30235216)
If it helps, these documents were not written down by the authors but by a professional scribe whose job it was to write a beautiful page, or to keep trying until it was just so.

The handwriting in historical letters, while still often beautiful, was not perfect and had errors.

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by Pinus on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:43PM (#30236188)
There is a legend in Sweden, that during some power struggle in the 16th century, several high-ranking persons had put their seals on a document which, after a change in political tides, put them at a very real risk of losing their heads in the event now known as "the Stockholm bloodbath". One of them — the bishop Hans Brask — then cracked open his seal to reveal a note saying (in 15xx Swedish) "I'm being forced to do this". He got to keep his head, and the word "brasklapp" (literally "Brask note") now means a reservation or caveat.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by timwis on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:32PM (#30234706)
It strikes me that when we say we’re “signing” a file/commit/etc. (using a key), a “seal” is probably a more appropriate analogy, since someone could steal your key just as someone could steal the seal.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by NoSorryCannot on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:35PM (#30235445)
The essential property of seals is that they are fragile and offer tamper evidence. Removing a seal or opening a sealed document is supposed to be destructive to the seal, the document, or both. Seals are still used for this purpose.

Electronic signatures don't have this property.

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by upofadown on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:58PM (#30237931)
Tamper evidence is actually the only thing that cryptographic signatures provide. If either the "document" or signature is modified then verification fails.

Cryptographic signatures don't provide evidence that someone looked at the "document" in transit. For that we use a separate sort of thing called encryption and prevent the problem entirely. The two things work together to provide the equivalent of a sealed envelope or securely folded paper document.

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by timwis on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:45PM (#30235554)
Doh, good point! A stamp of a signature would perhaps be more fitting.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by dredmorbius on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:43PM (#30237319)
Those would be seals (usually royal seals), in European usage.

In Japan, Hanko or Inkan:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seal_(East_Asia)#Japanese_usag...

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by thaumasiotes on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:55PM (#30237909)
> Those would be seals (usually royal seals), in European usage.

Well, the European usage is to call them seals in a European or Near Eastern context. For some reason, exactly the same thing in an Asian context is often called a "chop" in European usage.

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by bigmattystyles on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:21PM (#30235299)
Should this be `before certificates`? The seal didn't stop you from opening or viewing, just tried to establish authenticity and first viewing. (I realize certs don't guarantee first viewing)
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by remram on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:32PM (#30240009)
You would think this is no longer used... I recently got married in the US and had to send proof to my home country of France. I had to request a certification ("apostille") conform with the Hague Conference treaty [1]. I paid Massachusetts $6 and they sent me the fanciest document I have ever seen, with the Great Seal of Massachusetts embossed in it and a ribbon going through the paper (I didn't take a picture sadly but it was kinda like this [2]). It all looked a bit archaic but very cool.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostille_Convention

[2]: https://apostilleonline.com/images/portfolio/img8.jpg

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by sowbug on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:00PM (#30236379)
Tangentially related: digital currencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum have spawned a burgeoning physical-document-security industry. If you don't want your private key to leave the airgapped computer that created it, but you do want a backup, then you might manually etch, engrave, or stamp your key onto metal rectangles. Some companies are now providing kits to facilitate this tedious process. It's a little steampunk.

Even more tangentially related: if you've seen the Rick and Morty episode "Morty's Mind Blowers," do you know the name of the red container that Summer snapped open to reveal emergency recovery instructions? You also see them in old Atomic Age movies. I don't know if they've had any practical application in the last 20-30 years, but they are pretty cool and maybe useful for protecting the secrets mentioned above.

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by aardvark179 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @06:18PM (#30238102)
I believe they are called sealed authenticators. They would provide part of a mechanism to prove a backup code had never been accessed, but I don’t know how you would ensure a code was not used and sealed into a new case.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by sowbug on Thursday February 10, 2022 @12:10AM (#30282675)
Thank you. That's the best lead I've gotten yet. https://www.keysure.net/ is the closest to a real product, but everything else suggests that it's only a product of Hollywood imagination.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by etothepii on Sunday February 06, 2022 @06:17PM (#30238100)
I've always been fascinated by this idea, since surely this introduces a number of other machines that have seen your private key. It is not unusual for the factory default settings on a printer to allow reprints of the last few documents, for example.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by dredmorbius on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:49PM (#30237361)
Some years ago I had the opportunity to visit a switch control tower at a rail yard.

As with much else in the technological built landscape, what I'd not realised before that time was how much of the structure was devoted to, and determined by mechanism. Moving a switch control in the tower itself activated a relay which moved a lever arm, which through mechanical coupling moved the actual rail points.

(This is no longer always the case, but for older infrastructure, and this dated to at least the 1930s, it's quite common.)

The operater interfaces were themselves secured and sealed. The operator rather delightedly showed how the seals could be readily removed without any apparent sign of having done so....

Times, locations, and personnel left intentionally vague, though few of those involved are likely still alive.

Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by 0xbadcafebee on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:14PM (#30236524)
DEFCON has a Tamper Evident Village where you can learn all sorts of ways to defeat tamper-evident seals. There's also some links to papers from Schneier's blog: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/02/security_seal...
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by dano on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:17PM (#30237585)
You maybe interested in the articles at the Journal of Physical Security https://jps.rbsekurity.com
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by shimonabi on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:19PM (#30237099)
As a kid, I would find red vax seal sticks in the drawers, because my mom worked for a bank where they sealed the cash into envelopes for some reason.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by etothepii on Sunday February 06, 2022 @06:16PM (#30238086)
Are you suggesting your mother was taking envelopes of cash home and opening them?
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by shimonabi on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:33AM (#30241458)
I wish. Maybe then we wouldn't be eating pasta every day. :)
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by charcircuit on Sunday February 06, 2022 @06:40PM (#30238283)
I imagine passwords are an older concept than ribbon and seals.
Re:Before passwords - ribbons and seals for document securit... by crumbits on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:38PM (#30236743)
Anybody who finds this interesting should look into tughras.