News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by throwaway09223 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:29AM (#30234006)
"you can’t get an injunction to prevent someone from publishing something."

You can't, in theory.

In practice this sort of thing happens all the time. I had a judge issue a clearly unconstitutional order limiting my speech (there was no action on my part leading up to this, it was a broad order applying to more than just me). My lawyer's take was that while it was clearly not allowed, it wasn't particularly important so best to just ignore it.

It's really, really common.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by lettergram on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:15PM (#30234487)
Was about to say something similar.

FISA court orders, family court, settlement agreements, arbitration, civil lawsuits, criminal trials, etc

There are so many different ways you can be “gagged” it’s very common.

There’s a reason they tried to get the publication stopped - because it often works.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by datavirtue on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:59PM (#30235019)
And then you publish anyway to prove you are a "real American." (TM)
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by pueblito on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:43PM (#30237312)
Rights are like trademarks, if you don’t defend them aggressively then you’ll lose them
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by ajsnigrutin on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:50PM (#30237868)
Sadly, there are many movements against free speech, specially in the usa, because some people might say something, that someone doesn't want to hear.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:36PM (#30234769)
Family court telling a father not to tweet mean things and any court telling a journalist, with a track record of publishing, not to publish, are clear and separate things.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by pyuser583 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:53PM (#30235639)
Yes, one violates freedom of the press, and the other violates freedom of speech.

Both are protected by the first amendment.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by thaumasiotes on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:10PM (#30237033)
No, they both violate freedom of the press.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by smorgusofborg on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:13PM (#30237554)
No, only one violates the generally accepted freedoms of the press:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_figure

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by thaumasiotes on Sunday February 06, 2022 @09:21PM (#30239430)
Legally they are the same action, and they obviously violate the same laws. Specifically, they violate the prohibition on restricting someone's freedom to engage in the mass-production of speech, which is known as "freedom of the press". What are you trying to say with the public figure link?
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by pyuser583 on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:12AM (#30241323)
There’s a very different case history for “freedom of the press” than “freedom of speech.” Legally, they’re different.

“Freedom of the press” has focused on the need for an informed public and institutional autonomy of the press. It is a public, not private, right.

The freedom of the press also has a commercial element. It’s controversial to say “corporations have freedom of speech.” It uncontroversial and obvious that corporations have freedom of the press.

“Freedom of speech” has focused on individual speakers. There’s a public element, but private speech is still incredibly important.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by thaumasiotes on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:35AM (#30241910)
> There’s a very different case history for “freedom of the press” than “freedom of speech.” Legally, they’re different.

That is true.

> “Freedom of the press” has focused on the need for an informed public and institutional autonomy of the press. It is a public, not private, right.

But that's wildly wrong.

https://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/press.pdf

> Blackstone, for instance, wrote in 1769 that “[e]very freeman has an undoubted right to lay what sentiments he pleases before the public: to forbid this, is to destroy the freedom of the press.” Jean-Louis de Lolme, an author widely cited by 1780s American writers, likewise wrote in his chapter on “Liberty of the Press” that “[e]very subject in England has not only a right to present petitions, to the King, or the Houses of Parliament; but he has a right also to lay his complaints and observations before the Public, by the means of an open press.”

> State supreme courts in 1788 and 1791 similarly described the liberty of the press as “permitting every man to publish his opinions,” and as meaning that “the citizen has a right to publish his sentiments upon all political, as well as moral and literary subjects.”

> Several early state constitutions echoed this as well, providing that “[e]very citizen may freely speak, write and print on any subject, being responsible for the abuse of that liberty.”

The difference between freedom of speech and freedom of the press is that the press involves mass production, making it easy to communicate a message to large numbers of people at low cost. When people rephrase "freedom of speech" and "freedom of the press" as "the freedom to speak, write, and print on any subject", the freedoms to speak and write come from the freedom of speech, and the freedom to print (or publish) comes from the freedom of the press.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by daenz on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:40AM (#30234113)
If you feel comfortable elaborating, can you explain broadly the purpose for the judge's order? I have heard stories of judges doing things like that during the time period of a divorce or custody battle.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by throwaway09223 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:47AM (#30234180)
I'm not going to elaborate other than to say my speech was restrained due to someone else's actions, but family court is definitely an area where common practice has strayed very, very far from anything resembling constitutionality.

One such example: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by bladegash on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:26PM (#30234614)
Yep, ex parte family law orders should be available for extreme situations, but they are widely abused, only need to meet a legal standard of preponderance of evidence, do not require underlying criminal conduct, and can deprive a person of constitutional rights for months or more. They were technically temporary orders pending a full hearing, but those hearings can be delayed for a variety of reasons. In one order based on allegations, a person can lose access to their property, children, and more, all without being able to defense themselves or even participate in the hearing. It’s messed up.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by throwaway09223 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:37PM (#30236137)
In my case, it was not issued ex-parte. In fact, it was not even requested relief. My impression is that these sorts of prior restraints are so normalized that they're applied as a matter of course.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by bladegash on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:05PM (#30236421)
Wow, sorry to hear that. Can definitely introduce significant mistrust in the system and for good reason. Hope things have worked out better in the long term for you though!
[dead]
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by ozfive on Sunday February 06, 2022 @04:12PM (#30237049)
C'mon now ... This is inappropriate at the very least.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by xeromal on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:02PM (#30234338)
You can't bring up an anecdote as a counterpoint then refuse to explain the anecdote. It's a bit unfair.

Edit: someone posted the rules that says we should accept people's comments in good faith. I'll try to do that. Leaving this comment for posterity.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by borski on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:09PM (#30234420)
Sure they can, if: a) it might get them in legal hot water, or b) it is personal and they don’t want to get into it.

You’re not owed anything by anyone here, and they did bring up an example about family court and link to an article about it. :)

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by xeromal on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:23PM (#30234589)
Seems like a lame way to bring up an example to me.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by throwaway09223 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:25PM (#30235993)
Imagine how it feels from the perspective of the person constrained by an illegal court order.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by wizzwizz4 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:35PM (#30234743)
I disagree, but fair enough. Doesn't mean any of us are entitled to elaboration, though.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by pyuser583 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:34PM (#30236705)
When someone says “I’m legally prohibited from saying certain things,” you can’t reasonably expect then to detail those things.

This is why censorship is so dangerous … especially in a society that presumes freedom of speech.

There was a fascinating article (can’t find it) about the recipient of a NSL complaining to their congressman about being censored.

Their congressman told them such censorship was impossible under the current law so they shouldn’t worry about it.

They wanted to say “yes it’s possible, it’s happened to me.”

But that would have been illegal. So it was impossible to convince their congressman to look into it, and therefore impossible to get the law changed.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by salawat on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:58PM (#30236935)
They should have followed through and popped open the can on their Congressperson then, rendering it now a political issue.

If you want to see the Judiciary rein it in, get a Congressperson involved. The Executive is fudged for, the Legislative can rewrite the entire corpus with due process.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by chris_wot on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:21PM (#30234556)
They absolutely do not have to explain themselves further. They owe you (and us) nothing.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by xeromal on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:22PM (#30234571)
I just mean from a debat/argument standpoint. How can someone say "No, that's incorrect, but I refuse to elaborate". Why even talk? lol
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by borski on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:33PM (#30234717)
Because this isn’t a formal debate, and generally we trust in others’ firsthand experiences, especially when they link to a related article, even if it isn’t precisely the story that happened to them. The GP is, in this case, an original source and as per the HN guidelines [1] we assume good faith.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by KennyBlanken on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:39PM (#30236153)
The sentence you conveniently left out leaves out the context of "assume good faith":

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

That does not, in any way, say "assume anecdotes are trustworthy." Nowhere in the rules does it say or even imply this.

It is also laughable to suggest the HN community assumes good faith; the comments section has a substantial amount of comments from software engineers thinking they're qualified to rip apart the work of people who are professionals in their fields, usually with high levels of derision.

Regardless of what HN rules say, anecdotes are literally the worst way of supporting an argument, subject to no end of observer biases.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by catlifeonmars on Sunday February 06, 2022 @06:07PM (#30238017)
> It is also laughable to suggest the HN community assumes good faith

Do you have examples of similar forums that are better examples? This isn’t a rhetorical question; I haven’t been able to find a better forum where the commentary is (mostly) full of honest, thorough, and respectful discourse. If HN is “laughable”, I’m certainly interested in recalibrating.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by borski on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:08PM (#30236461)
1) I am not saying it is proof or a valid argument. I am saying we should not assume the poster is lying just because they’re uncomfortable providing details about something that is likely personal or legal in nature.

2) That there are HN commenters who don’t follow the guidelines doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try.

3) I did not “conveniently” leave out that sentence, which implies malice on my part. I left it out because I deemed it irrelevant to the point I was trying to make. The strongest plausible interpretation of the GP’s comment is that they are telling the truth but can’t or are uncomfortable sharing details due to legal or personal matters, especially given that it was posted with a throwaway account, which the guidelines also specify is OK for sensitive information, implying that the GP was posting… sensitive information. As before: please try to assume good faith.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by KennyBlanken on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:39PM (#30238695)
> I left it out because I deemed it irrelevant to the point I was trying to make.

The scope of that sentence assigned to it by the only other sentence in that paragraph was indeed "irrelevant" to your claim "assume good faith" is a general policy for HN comments.

It was beyond disingenuous, and you're still being disingenuous; you're now shifting the goalposts.

> As before: please try to assume good faith.

You selectively quoted in a way that radically changed meaning in order to chastise another user making a comment you didn't like. This isn't a matter of "faith." You're running around telling other people how to act.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by borski on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:25PM (#30239956)
No, I didn’t. If you read it even with that sentence attached it still applies, as I clarified in my followup comment to you. It just wasn’t needed for that particular reading, and your reading was not the strongest plausible interpretation. The goal posts have remained unchanged.

Furthermore, I read through some of your other comments and might add: I haven’t found one in which you’ve been anything but negative. Please consider reading through your comments and adjusting your general demeanor on this forum; I’d argue there’s a reason every third or fourth comment of yours gets downvoted.

That said, I think we’re done here. Enjoy the rest of your night; or day, wherever you are. :)

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by xeromal on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:35PM (#30234746)
Thanks for linking the rules. I'll accept that.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by Espressosaurus on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:35PM (#30234747)
They gave an example with an article. That much is enough to say "this is a thing that happens" without divulging sensitive information.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by throwaway09223 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:28PM (#30236022)
I'm not debating with anyone. I'm just sharing a personal experience.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by dv_dt on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:32AM (#30234044)
That makes we wonder how many essentially invisible to the public cases this kind of restraint we have in the system.

It seem like all it takes is a plausible legal theory that could be dragged out combined with enough financial clout to make the defendant give.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by throwaway09223 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:42AM (#30234123)
This same judge said something along the lines of "there are no limits on my ability to issue orders until an appeals court overturns them."

He was keenly aware that the issue wasn't significant enough to appeal and that his power was essentially unchecked.

Lawyers are very aware of this dynamic.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by daenz on Sunday February 06, 2022 @11:53AM (#30234238)
This is why it is so important to have wise judges that are held to a very high moral standard.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by jdasdf on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:31PM (#30234688)
No, this is why it's important to have checks and balances against unrestrained judicial power.

These checks and balances must include legal as well as practical costs and difficulties in having those orders implemented.

The system should assume malice on all parties, and work accordingly.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by daenz on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:15PM (#30235214)
The checks and balances here is the appeals process, which fails when the cost of appealing isn't worth it. It will always be the case where a judge can calibrate a decision to be under the cost of appealing. Which is why it is important to have judges be moral and wise...who don't let their egos get in the way and restrain themselves, instead of forcing you to pay any cost to check them.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by whatshisface on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:41PM (#30235504)
There could be a system that punished judges for overturned rulings and rewarded people who put in the effort to overturn them.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by BurningFrog on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:05PM (#30235772)
But "who judges the judges?", to paraphrase the ancient wise question.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by shadowgovt on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:17PM (#30234515)
... and, in jurisdictions that allow it, for the public to bother to research judges and vote them in our out of office.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by dv_dt on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:27PM (#30234638)
In an area where I can vote for judges, I do google searches on all the candidates and rarely get good information. If you’re lucky you can get some very rudimentary assessment of if they have any legal background at all.

But to really research a judge candidate I think would take access to a legal case database and a fairly sophisticated understanding of law, and far too much time.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by fires10 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:26PM (#30235354)
I am not a fan of voting for judges. Judges should be determined by technical merits and skills more like hiring a developer. This I think would be better handled by having a diverse group of judges routinely review all decisions by a judge and issuing corrective actions against the judge. This review should be done periodically and not require an appeal.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by Spooky23 on Sunday February 06, 2022 @02:24PM (#30235981)
I disagree. Attorneys are a fairly tight group in general that rely on peer opinion to get jobs.

Nobody is going speak about about Judge A because the political machinery and peer pressure are very powerful. When Judge B rats out Judge A, all of the sudden those appellate court opportunities or various other lucrative appointments suddenly are out of reach.

Judicial elections are a good way to get bad judges out and mediocre or better judges get to mostly do their thing. The places where the broader political environment is corrupt are no more corrupt than if judges were appointed. There’s the benefit with an election that the local party leaders can just opt to not support a bad judge versus making a decision to oppose him.

If any change were to be made, I think making the clerks protected civil service employees would probably blunt the judges power, particularly if cousin Rufus get appointed to be county judge because he’s drinking too much at the law firm.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by shadowgovt on Sunday February 06, 2022 @05:11PM (#30237536)
There's a definite information gap here waiting for someone to step in and fill it. Practically speaking these days, it's currently filled by special interest groups like the state bar and various voting leagues; they will do the heavy lifting of evaluating the candidates and issue recommendations.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by pessimizer on Sunday February 06, 2022 @01:14PM (#30235211)
And don't forget the part where you have to get the majority of your neighbors to do the same.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by shadowgovt on Sunday February 06, 2022 @12:12PM (#30234448)
It's more that the bar is extremely high, but yes, prior restraint on speech is not impossible. There has to be a direct through-line from the speech itself to probable irreparable harm to the beneficiary of the restraint.

"Dear mobsters, this is the address where the FBI has sequestered a witness" is around the place the bar is.

"That report might be defamatory to a corporation because we can argue it is untrue" is nowhere near the bar (truth is an affirmative defense, and the possible harm is reconcilable in law via monetary compensation and damages).