News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by borski on Sunday February 06, 2022 @03:08PM (#30236461)
1) I am not saying it is proof or a valid argument. I am saying we should not assume the poster is lying just because they’re uncomfortable providing details about something that is likely personal or legal in nature.

2) That there are HN commenters who don’t follow the guidelines doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try.

3) I did not “conveniently” leave out that sentence, which implies malice on my part. I left it out because I deemed it irrelevant to the point I was trying to make. The strongest plausible interpretation of the GP’s comment is that they are telling the truth but can’t or are uncomfortable sharing details due to legal or personal matters, especially given that it was posted with a throwaway account, which the guidelines also specify is OK for sensitive information, implying that the GP was posting… sensitive information. As before: please try to assume good faith.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by KennyBlanken on Sunday February 06, 2022 @07:39PM (#30238695)
> I left it out because I deemed it irrelevant to the point I was trying to make.

The scope of that sentence assigned to it by the only other sentence in that paragraph was indeed "irrelevant" to your claim "assume good faith" is a general policy for HN comments.

It was beyond disingenuous, and you're still being disingenuous; you're now shifting the goalposts.

> As before: please try to assume good faith.

You selectively quoted in a way that radically changed meaning in order to chastise another user making a comment you didn't like. This isn't a matter of "faith." You're running around telling other people how to act.

Re:J&J tried to get federal judge to block publication of Re... by borski on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:25PM (#30239956)
No, I didn’t. If you read it even with that sentence attached it still applies, as I clarified in my followup comment to you. It just wasn’t needed for that particular reading, and your reading was not the strongest plausible interpretation. The goal posts have remained unchanged.

Furthermore, I read through some of your other comments and might add: I haven’t found one in which you’ve been anything but negative. Please consider reading through your comments and adjusting your general demeanor on this forum; I’d argue there’s a reason every third or fourth comment of yours gets downvoted.

That said, I think we’re done here. Enjoy the rest of your night; or day, wherever you are. :)