News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by 0x12 on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @06:27AM (#3021423)
> Stefan Weitz, Microsoft's director of Bing, believes that if Bing can change the way people think about search, sooner or later users will switch over from Google.

For that to work people would have to change the way they think about microsoft as well, not how they think about search.

Right now there are several ecosystems on the web that you can be part of. There is the 'social' ecosystem which governs you interactions with other people rather than with other services. Facebook, twitter, google+ etc. Then there is 'mobile', which is a gateway to a bunch of data and to information. Then there is your work and the applications you use to do that work. Finally there is search.

Search is different from all the others in that you could switch overnight to a new provider, but just like any other good infrastructure component, you probably will not do that if you are satisfied with your current provider. Search is not visible enough to warrant a conscious decision until you are dissatisfied.

Changing your thinking on search is one hurdle that is going to be hard to cross without say google going down for a couple of weeks or some major mishap that would make their search results unusable for any period of time. That would give an upstart a better chance at a first shot at retaining the users.

Changing the way you think about microsoft is going to be a very hard obstacle to clear as well. Microsoft is synonymous with software that you use on your desktop and with several botched attempts at doing search. Before you try them again you'd have to see google performing worse than the best that microsoft has ever presented in this field.

Frankly I'm surprised that they keep sinking money into this, they've clearly failed to establish a profitable beach head, meanwhile google is making money hand over fist in the exact same domain. I'm happy they do, more competition is better but for now google seems to be acing them. Microsoft will have to be very careful that 'search' does not turn in to their Afghanistan.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by credo on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @03:47PM (#3023389)
>>For that to work people would have to change the way they think about microsoft as well

This thread is a great example of the problems Microsoft faces among HNers, but I don't think the general public has such a blatant bias against Microsoft.

For instance, this topic was submitted 9 hours ago, has 128 points and is on the front page. It also has a false title.The title asserts that "Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing". However, the CNN article doesn't have this title. The article says that Microsoft "has lost $5.5 billion on Bing since the search service launched in June 2009".

Now, HN moderators often heavy-handedly change submission titles on the grounds that the title violates some obscure HN rule (like for example, the rule that "X ways to optimize your app" is inappropriate)

In this case, we have a much more blatant rule violation - changing the original title of the story and substituting it with a false assertion. Yet, none of the moderators have changed the title of this story.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by cshenoy on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @05:30PM (#3023775)
If you kept reading the paragraph you quote, it also says "since Microsoft began breaking out that unit's finances in 2007, the company has lost a total of $9 billion." While the title of this post is not stating a clear timeline for the loss, it still is technically correct.

And the original comment you're referring to isn't stating a clear bias against Microsoft, per se. It's more that they're stating a general perception: that Microsoft is Windows and that it's mostly a desktop software provider. I think we can all agree that the general public agrees with that.

Don't worry - not all of us are out to get Microsoft.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by credo on Thursday September 22, 2011 @02:10AM (#3025057)
Wrong again.

The online services division has lost $9B since 2007.

"online services division" is not the same as "Bing". It is a division which (over the years) has included several different products/services. Bing (created in 2009) is one of those services. MSN used to be (and may still be) part of that division.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by epo on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @05:37PM (#3023799)
Agreed, the $9Bn refers to declared losses by the online services division.

However you come across as claiming that Microsoft is being victimised by a conspiracy of unreasoning and unreasonable hatred by HNers and the mods. "Blatant bias"? Really?

I would suggest that people (not just HNers) know exactly what Microsoft is like and how badly they have behaved, if people are biased against Microsoft it is for a good reason. Microsoft have earned their reputation.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by billybob on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @09:11AM (#3021838)
"Microsoft is synonymous with software that you use on your desktop"

This is insightful. While some of us geeks have a grudge against Microsoft, most people don't. They probably do, however, have a mental separation between the desktop and the web.

Microsoft was slow to embrace the web because it threatens their core products. So the web grew without them. Now they're saying, "oh, we're on the web, too!" But when people think of the web, they don't think of Microsoft. They missed the chance to make that association. And it's hard to get it back.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by patio11 on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:19AM (#3022066)
They probably do, however, have a mental separation between the desktop and the web.

I think most users couldn't describe the difference between these two if their life depended on it, FWIW. Ever met someone who referred to Excel as a web site?

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by euroclydon on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:59AM (#3022239)
Yes, for the two CWC customers who managed to find my phone number and call me, my question, "What web browser are you using?" was met with a long pause.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by rmc on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @02:57PM (#3023235)
They were probably using Google for their internet, but they might not have installed a browser yet.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by libraryatnight on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @03:39PM (#3023361)
A startling number of people believe that the internet IS Internet Explorer.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:38AM (#3022149)
I suspect that for most general users the web still equates with the big blue "e".
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by robert_nsu on Thursday September 22, 2011 @01:02AM (#3024924)
I wish I had a nickel for every time someone told me the blue "E" has gone missing from their desktop.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by pessimizer on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:31AM (#3021538)
>Frankly I'm surprised that they keep sinking money into this, they've clearly failed to establish a profitable beach head, meanwhile google is making money hand over fist in the exact same domain.

This seems to be Microsoft's MO, and it seems to have worked with the XBox. Push hard, buy a second place position with massive marketing, investment, and underpricing, and continue to maintain it while losing billions and billions. Then the first place company inevitably, eventually makes a series of horrible, very public missteps, and Microsoft is positioned as "The Alternative."

On one hand, I think it's a pretty sleazy tactic, but on the other hand I rarely ever see any corporation thinking in the long term, especially to this absurd degree. I'm not exactly sure what the strategy is to defend against this, either.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Arjuna on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @09:16AM (#3021855)
Microsoft deserves some credit for the XBOX.

They had the foresight to include a NIC (Network Interface Card) in the XBOX, right out of the gate. It was also the first game console to include a hard disk.

The PS2 did not initially include a NIC, and Sony offered the add-on PlayStation Network Adapter in order to compete with Microsoft. In addition, Microsoft launched XBOX Live approximately four years ahead of Playstation Network.

Regarding missteps, Microsoft has experienced their share of technical hurdles [1].

Regarding financial losses, Sony has experienced the same [2].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xbox_360_technical_problems

[2] http://www.engadget.com/2009/08/25/sony-still-losing-money-o...

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by runjake on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @11:36AM (#3022386)
Didn't Microsoft shun any mention of the word "Microsoft" in XBOX marketing, at least initially? That might've played a big part in it's success. Or at least a big part in giving it a fair shot.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Arjuna on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @12:39PM (#3022673)
Didn't Microsoft shun any mention of the word "Microsoft" in XBOX marketing, at least initially?

I do not know the answer to your question, but I would venture to say that the target audience would have known either way. The adult game cognoscenti are obviously dialed into magazines, blogs, etc. Kids are of course in the know as well, and in cases where they do not have purchasing power, they will undoubtedly provide the necessary counsel to those above them that do :)

That might've played a big part in it's success. Or at least a big part in giving it a fair shot.

My opinion is that the XBOX's success was largely due to the quintessential launch title, Halo: Combat Evolved. This is one of the driving factors behind the XBOX's sell-out launch in North America.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by chc on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @04:34PM (#3023567)
Bungie was always Microsoft's ace in the hole. Online gaming helped, but it was more incremental and more easily copied. Now that Bungie's out of Microsoft's grasp, I'm betting Sony takes back the lead (though in a much closer race) for the next generation of consoles.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Arjuna on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @11:38PM (#3024751)
Yes, it will be interesting to see how the Bungie-Activision relationship unfolds. I am sure that Bungie is happy to have moved on from the Halo franchise in order to work on new projects, but perhaps in a mixed-emotions sort of way that we all feel when we want to move on, but at the same time let go.

Meanwhile, the Halo torch has been passed to Microsoft's 343 Industries, with their sights set on developing Halo 4.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Umofomia on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @03:27PM (#3023321)
This is probably one of the main reasons why they switched the branding from "MSN Search" and "Windows Live Search" to "Bing".
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by zmonkeyz on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @08:37PM (#3024287)
Dreamcast came with a dialup modem out of the box and an adapter for a NIC. Most people were on dialup at the time but they knew network gaming was the future.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Arjuna on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:43PM (#3024635)
Dreamcast came with a dialup modem out of the box [...]

Yes, good point. The modem was an industry-first in a game console, and definitely forward-thinking on Sega's part.

Unfortunately, Sega was forced to cease production of the pioneering Dreamcast in 2001. At that time, the company refocused their resources on game development. This was sometime after the PS2 launched in North America, and sometime before the XBOX launched in the same territory.

On a related note, I remember playing Jet Grind Radio for the first time. The cel-shading was really cutting-edge!

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by w1ntermute on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:53AM (#3021586)
I don't think you can compare the two situations, because Sony has gone to great lengths to demonstrate that it's a supremely incompetent company (which it is). Google has done nothing of the sort. Plus, people constantly expect innovation from the console makers, but for Google to hold on to its position in search, it just has to stay online.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by markokocic on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @08:21AM (#3021671)
While Google reputation has been superb so far, at least for normal users, their push for Google+ may change that.

It's kind of "all in" move by Google. If Google+ succeeds, their brand will be even stronger, and as king of data, search and social they will stay leaders for the long time, giving them possibility to attack other market segments too.

But if Google+ fails, Google brand will be severely damaged, and normals could go somewhere else.

All Microsoft has to do here is to wait for the outcome and actively try to sabotage Google+ efforts by working together with Facebook.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by sausagefeet on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @09:46AM (#3021949)
I don't think G+ failing really damages Google's brand that much. It will just be another service people don't use on Google while they are searching.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Poyeyo on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @09:56AM (#3021987)
Yeah, the same that Wave damaged Google reputation.

/sarcasm

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by 0x12 on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @02:29PM (#3023149)
Wave failing is my only reason for not even checking out g+ until it is 9 months old.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by muhfuhkuh on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:56AM (#3022229)
"I'm not exactly sure what the strategy is to defend against this, either."

Beat Microsoft at their own game. Initially, people moved to MS-DOS because it was the cheaper computing environment. The first place company in the console wars currently is Nintendo Wii, and lo and behold it is cheaper than the rest.

Pretty damn good + cheap = winner

Nintendo is 1/2 the powerhouse with a 1/3 of the AAA titles, yet dwarfs MS and Sony in console sales (and, with DS portable, completely blows them out of the water).

Another example: Compare how utterly lost iPad competitors are in the tablet space. One had to completely exit the market and slash prices to below cost to even make a dent.

Yet, there is one tablet quietly garnering sales in the millions and is single-handedly keeping a billion dollar company afloat: The Barnes and Noble Nook Color. They're selling these Android tablets like hotcakes. It's well crafted and sturdy, and at a price point ($250) that makes it a compelling purchase. It's making B&N a fortune.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Arjuna on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @11:21AM (#3022322)
I would also add innovation to your equation as a prime-mover in Wii sales. The Wii Remote was like nothing before it; playing a four-player game of Wii Tennis was radically innovative (and an absolute blast!)
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by webwright on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:44AM (#3022174)
Great points.

This guy ( http://worldofsu.com/philipsu/?p=209 ) mentions that users prefer bing results over google results when the put a google logo above them (no source cited, tho). That's got to be maddening... But yeah, it's a brand problem as much as it's a product problem.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by voodoomagicman on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @12:24PM (#3022590)
I would be interested to hear which results users prefer when there are no logos at all. I did a blind search engine test about the time that Bing launched, and oddly enough for the queries I tried, I picked Yahoo (pre bing) as having the best results most often.

I still use Google though, so maybe it really is all about the logo for me...

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by moultano on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @01:23PM (#3022880)
The queries people do when testing a search engine are very different from the queries they do in real life. For starters, the first thing people do to test a search engine is to search for their own name.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by finisterre on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @05:23PM (#3023750)
Blekko's "search engine monte" provides blinded results from their own search as well as from Google and Bing [1], so you can perform your own experiments.

1. http://blekko.com/ws/hacker+news+/monte

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by thefool on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @05:48PM (#3023836)
All I know is that at school when I'm on public computers, sometimes I'll accidentally use bing without noticing, do a couple queries, get frustrated by not finding the link that I'm looking for (often a course website), notice I'm using bing, and switch over.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by arethuza on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @06:42AM (#3021444)
"For that to work people would have to change the way they think about microsoft as well"

I honestly don't really care that Bing is part of Microsoft - if they consistently started finding noticeably "better" search results than Google I'd stop using Google in exactly the same way that I stopped using AltaVista/HotBot/etc.

YMMV.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by vegai on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @06:53AM (#3021461)
Then again, Google was new with no baggage of previous wrongdoings.

Many people remember how Microsoft operated in the past (and I suppose, in the present).

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by arethuza on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:02AM (#3021476)
There were loads of search engines around when Google started - as far as I recall people started using them because their search results were dramatically better than what you'd get from other sites. Simple as that.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by mdesq on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @11:29AM (#3022359)
Google's results were dramatically better, but I'm not sure that was the biggest reason most people were switching. I remember it was also out-of-control blazing fast. No more waits at all. Performing a single query would change the expression on most people's faces.

The user experience changed from "tell us what you want, and we'll go out and see what we can find" to "we have everything right here, just let us know what you are looking for."

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by nooneelse on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @03:52PM (#3023402)
That is what I remember people caring about too. And the result page bragged about fast it was. They did well on a metric, and then drew your attention to just how darn well right as you were primed to be impressed.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by 0x12 on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:11AM (#3021499)
Being dramatically better than google is a high hurdle. It's tough for competitors but google pretty much did an end-run around the search problem and to be just like google is not good enough a reason to switch.

Now if someone would do to google what google did to altavista that would move the needle on many fronts.

I suspect DDG is not it, but I'm not saying it is not possible.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by beagle3 on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @04:11PM (#3023481)
The change will not come from being better than Google at their own game (unless they start being incompetent), but rather from winning a different game that Google didn't pay attention to in time.

That's how Facebook happened.

In the mobile search space, pay attention to DoAT.com - it's mobile search done right, unlike google (or anyone else). If they gain enough traction, they can dethrone google eventually. Or it could just be a passing fad.

It's rare to win an established game, like Google did with search (or Microsoft did 20 years ago with word processing and spreadsheets). It's much more common to win at a new game that is being overlooked by the giants. (Some people say the Microsoft takeover of the office space is "a different game" because no one took "office suites" seriously except them; However, Word really was better than WordPerfect and friends at the time; and Excel really was better than 1-2-3, and people were switching one-package-at-a-time. So I think this should be considered winning an established game)

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by timr on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @02:05PM (#3023049)
"Being dramatically better than google is a high hurdle."

Everyone likes to say that...but really, how do you know? By definition, disruption comes when you don't expect it. When Google came along, people didn't know that search could be made better. Likewise, today, people don't see what they're not getting with Google...they just know that Google's results cause about the same level of satisfaction as they always have.

The search engine that gets a toehold against Google is going to do something completely different, and re-define the search game for all of the players. It's not going to be a head-to-head competition on the same playing field.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by noarchy on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @08:33AM (#3021706)
For me it was better results, combined with a clutter-free interface. By that point, Yahoo's page was filled with garbage that I didn't want to see.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by unexpected on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:51AM (#3022209)
You are right, but in order to do this, Bing would have to be DRAMATICALLY better than Google's. This will be tough to do - Google has a large vested interest in making sure that their results are as good as it gets.

I feel like Bing would have better success breaking out into new spaces to push its search engine.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by JoachimSchipper on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:26AM (#3021532)
Apparently there is a study around that people actually prefer Bing's results to Google's if you swap the layout (i.e. show Bing's results on a Google page and vice versa). That may just show that Google has the better brand, but Bing's search results are apparently not that bad.

(I don't use Bing and have no conceivable stake in this fight.)

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by majika on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @08:10AM (#3021640)
Your "source" is that blog post from the other day by the guy who worked on Bing three years ago, no? His "source" was an "internal study" that he provided no links to. Just sayin'.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by JoachimSchipper on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @08:48AM (#3021746)
I must honestly say that I forgot where I got this from, which is not a good thing. Thanks for pointing this out.

That said, http://mashable.com/2009/06/07/blindsearch/ (apparently based on http://delicategeniusblog.com/?p=839) suggests that in a blind three-way test in 2009 both Yahoo's and Bing's results got picked as the best regularly (Google gets 41%, which is a substantial but not overwhelming advantage.) Note that that guy works for Microsoft, too.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by 0x12 on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @08:05AM (#3021623)
A link to that study would be greatly appreciated.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by dabeeeenster on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @06:54AM (#3021465)
I bet if you asked 100 people in the street who owned bing, less than 10 would say Microsoft.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by mike-cardwell on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:01AM (#3021475)
You're being generous. At least 98 of them would say, "What's Bing?". Almost certainly more.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by dasil003 on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:11AM (#3021498)
Bing has had pretty heavy marketing. I'm guessing 10% would have at least heard of it in a major city.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by galactus on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @07:04AM (#3021481)
And probably none of them would find that to be bad in itself.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by suivix on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @10:31AM (#3022122)
That's because the other 90+ would have no clue what you're talking about.
Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by Lewisham on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @12:21PM (#3022575)
Frankly I'm surprised that they keep sinking money into this, they've clearly failed to establish a profitable beach head, meanwhile google is making money hand over fist in the exact same domain.

Well, what else are they going to do? It's very clear that in the foreseeable technological future, search will continue to be an immensely important lynchpin of all sorts of services. Microsoft are in this because they realize that. You can't walk away from this table, however much you're losing.

Bing is definitely going to be bouyed by the Xbox, Windows Mobile and Windows 8 integration, so that's good.

FWIW, I like Bing, and I want them to do well. The results aren't as good as Google's yet, but their ancillary properties, like image search are pretty good. Video search is certainly better than Google's half-baked offering.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by TheCondor on Wednesday September 21, 2011 @04:03PM (#3023442)
I think it's more than that. Are they after some holy question in 'search?' Or are they really after the ad money?

To me, it seems like if they think Google has just not delivered or dropped the ball or something regarding search, then Bing really fails to deliver. I have a hard time calling it better than Google and a really really hard time seeing it being better enough to switch. It just doesn't do that much more.

If they're doing search, then the clearly need to do it better right? Not simply as good. Is it just arroagance that they can deliver some that merely matches or approaches Google and expect to eventually win? What makes them think that? It doesn't appear to be supported by any facts.

Re:Microsoft has lost $9 billion on Bing by chakde on Thursday September 22, 2011 @02:08AM (#3025051)
Personally I don't think there's any doubt that Google's search quality has fallen down over the last few years.

There have been a few instances where what I was looking for was not found on Google and I gave up looking for it. Later (after a few months!) when by chance I tried the same query on Bing, the results showed up right on the first page. Surprised by this, I rechecked it on Google and it appears either on the 3rd or 4th page - something I would never check earlier.

Since then I started always doing a backup search on Bing for anything important, to see results I might have missed on Google. By now, I'm using them 50:50.

Also attended a lecture on Bing search, and learnt that their approach is a little different, which could acount for this observation.