I do not know the answer to your question, but I would venture to say that the target audience would have known either way. The adult game cognoscenti are obviously dialed into magazines, blogs, etc. Kids are of course in the know as well, and in cases where they do not have purchasing power, they will undoubtedly provide the necessary counsel to those above them that do :)
That might've played a big part in it's success. Or at least a big part in giving it a fair shot.
My opinion is that the XBOX's success was largely due to the quintessential launch title, Halo: Combat Evolved. This is one of the driving factors behind the XBOX's sell-out launch in North America.
Meanwhile, the Halo torch has been passed to Microsoft's 343 Industries, with their sights set on developing Halo 4.
Yes, good point. The modem was an industry-first in a game console, and definitely forward-thinking on Sega's part.
Unfortunately, Sega was forced to cease production of the pioneering Dreamcast in 2001. At that time, the company refocused their resources on game development. This was sometime after the PS2 launched in North America, and sometime before the XBOX launched in the same territory.
On a related note, I remember playing Jet Grind Radio for the first time. The cel-shading was really cutting-edge!
They had the foresight to include a NIC (Network Interface Card) in the XBOX, right out of the gate. It was also the first game console to include a hard disk.
The PS2 did not initially include a NIC, and Sony offered the add-on PlayStation Network Adapter in order to compete with Microsoft. In addition, Microsoft launched XBOX Live approximately four years ahead of Playstation Network.
Regarding missteps, Microsoft has experienced their share of technical hurdles [1].
Regarding financial losses, Sony has experienced the same [2].
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xbox_360_technical_problems
[2] http://www.engadget.com/2009/08/25/sony-still-losing-money-o...