News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by matthewowen on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:27AM (#30207098)
The devils advocate answer:

Statistically, some of your employees probably aren’t good enough to be worth employing. But managers are human, hard conversations are hard, there are lots of incentives to not manage those people out.

By having an attrition target and forcing people to cut the bottom 10%, you basically skip over the soft fuzzy human factors keeping people around, and instead fall back to the statistical truth that the worst 10% probably are negative value employees.

Not saying I agree with this, but I think that’s the strongest case you can make for it.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by praptak on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:59AM (#30207535)
There is a gap in this reasoning though. "X% of employees are not worth their salary" does not imply "mandatory firing X% employees is good for the company".

In particular quotas flow down into teams with zero percent of people who should be fired. The effect on the remaining 100-X% employees morale is negative.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by steveBK123 on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:56PM (#30213073)
Sure, at a given point with low attrition this may be true. However if you are forcing the "bottom" 10-15% out every year, you tend to run out of "bottom" people to exit.. unless you are very bad at recruiting (or purposely hiring to fire).

Further, in any big organization the weak performers are not evenly distributed. However the PIP / attrition % rates are uniformly forced. So the over performing team has to start cutting into good performers within a year or two, whereas the low performance team can cut and still have many lower performers..

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by efitz on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:43PM (#30211105)
> the statistical truth that the worst 10% probably are negative value employees.

Why is this a statistical truth? In a large, Gaussian distributed population MAYBE this is true (but hiring isn’t random, is it?). But the thresholds are not applied to large populations anywhere I’ve worked. It’s pressure applied to management at all levels.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by AtlasBarfed on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:02PM (#30211347)
It assumes that you have perfect measurement. Anyone who knows corporate politics, middle management machiavellianism, and inability to properly instrument development, requirements, scheduling knows this is a fantasy.

That means people will devote SUBSTANTIAL amounts of their day-to-day labor in jockeying and positioning.

People will be hired (wasted money and time) explicitly to be fired/PIP'd.

The jockeying will result in disruption of team development.

People will sabotage their coworkers.

Trust disappears.

Paranoia grows.

Blame deflected.

Difficult problems won't be tackled because why risk it.

Bandaids rather than solutions will result.

YOUR BEST PEOPLE WILL LEAVE. Let me emphasize this. You are selecting for people that aren't good, because good people will have OPTIONS and THEY WILL LEAVE.

What are you left with? A management hierarchy of sociopaths. A subpar set of employees that furthermore will not cooperate in good faith (in the best case) or actively engage in institutional sociopathic behavior. You will have a cesspool, and cesspools repulse good people.

And the signal is right in front of people that apply: the hiring process is abusive hazing with the "raise the bar" bullshit.

Staff turnover means abandoned systems. Abandoned systems will be avoided as bad career risk, or reimplemented before the org has gotten good ROI from them.

THAT IS NOT GOOD MANAGEMENT.

Remember: AWS had a CRAP Christmas. Crap. This is starting to boil up.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by throwbigdata on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:10PM (#30213264)
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by AtlasBarfed on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:58PM (#30214665)
It's even worse than that. The Office at least had people do their jobs and keep their heads down, cooperate to get things done, ride out the management bullshit.

Amazon management practices will breed sociopathy at the root worker level.

I agree that is kind of the average-stage evolution of an enterprisey company. Amazon is worse.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by ltfey on Friday February 04, 2022 @07:33PM (#30215663)
The Office was utopian compared to real-life Corporate America.

The kind of mean-spirited pettiness that drives actual post-2000 capitalism, and it gets worse the higher you go, is so depressing and repugnant that it can't be put on TV.

Also, characters with no redeeming qualities are considered bad writing. But most coprorate executives are people with no redeeming qualities. You can't put them in fiction; unlike a well-written villain, they'll suck everything into a hole. Even Bill Lumbergh on Office Space had his charms.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by AtlasBarfed on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:47PM (#30217040)
And thus the "banality of evil"
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by throw_nbvc1234 on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:39PM (#30212815)
Amazon's hiring criteria is that a candidate must be better then 50% of current employee in their role (the bar); this is where the "bar raiser" concept comes from. So from their perspective statistically, half of their current employees wouldn't make it through the interview process if they went through it again.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by steveBK123 on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:01PM (#30213128)
This is magical numbers thinking by shape rotators.

How does one qualify the new candidate being better than 50% of current team. Better than 50% at what?

Every role has many dimensions, and most members of the team have a mixed set of strengths. You form a cohesive package if you hire complementary people and get 2+2=5 type of output.

The idea that everyone can be treated as an interchangeable cog and objectively, quantitatively ranked is pure silliness.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by graycat on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:55PM (#30212098)
> In a large, Gaussian distributed population

Where do we get one of those?

The central limit theorem doesn't give us one of those. Not even the Lindeberg-Feller central limit theorem. Neither does the strong law of large numbers. Nor the weak law of large numbers. Nor the martingale convergence theorem.

There is some old material, from about 100 years ago, in schools of education that given a performance measure and a large population the measure will be Gaussian distributed on that population, and the larger the population the closer to a Gaussian distribution. An example is supposed to be the size of the largest eigenvalue in a principle components decomposition. Uh, that largest eigenvalue was long called IQ (intelligence quotient). Nothing intelligent about it. Nonsense. 100% total crackpot nonsense. Brain-dead, cult nonsense.

"Low performers" in need of a "performance improvement program" (PIP)? Start with the managers who believe in a Gaussian distribution. Then move to the managers who believe that the "bottom 20%" are always low performers.

A lot is known about how to be a good manager, and the Gaussian probability density distribution is not part of that.

I've seen a lot of bad managers. A pattern is that they are tyrants, have lots of rules and measures, are big on formality over reality, dot i's and cross t's with great reliability, and have everyone with their nose to the grindstone, ear to the ground, shoulder to the wheel and trying to work in that position. But the organization is stagnant, is not changing or keeping up with the market or technology. So, after a few years like that, it becomes obvious to everyone, customers, BoD, stockholders, employees, even nearly all of the managers that the organization is about ready to die, and often that's what happens, e.g., by firing 50% of the people and going downhill from there.

Once I saw a failing organization where nearly all the managers except at the lowest level were part of a tight clique, cult enforcing failure. Finally the BoD installed a new CEO and fairly soon 80+% of the clique, cult were given "PIPs" and demoted out of management or retired.

But there is also good evidence that even such a sick organization does not have to die and, instead, just needs some good management, starting at the CEO level. In particular, with a good CEO, suddenly, wonder of wonders, 90+% of the employees can be seen as great performers.

So, net, as bad as the situation can be, it is fair to say that Darwin is on the case with improvement on the way!

At one time Amazon was a small mail-order book and record shop run by Bezos from a small office. At least looking from 10,000 feet up, Bezos was a good manager, and, thus, I doubt that he was playing with the Gaussian distribution, firing his bottom 20%, stack ranking, etc. Instead he knew all the employees and the work of each. Sooooo, it sounds like now Bezos should leave outer space, return to Amazon, and fix the destructive nonsense that is ruining the company.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by efitz on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:28PM (#30214997)
> "Low performers" in need of a "performance improvement program" (PIP)? Start with the managers who believe in a Gaussian distribution. Then move to the managers who believe that the "bottom 20%" are always low performers.

HAHAHA well said.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by dekhn on Sunday February 06, 2022 @10:56AM (#30233651)
Maybe I missed your point, but qualitative phenotypes caused by interactions of many genes that are measureable, like height, are gaussian distributed.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by graycat on Sunday February 06, 2022 @09:00PM (#30239254)
At best, only approximately Gaussian.

Height cannot be Gaussian if only because height is never negative but every Gaussian density is positive for all real numbers, including negative real numbers.

"interactions of many genes that are measureable"

The interactions of many is commonly used to justify a Gaussian assumption, but there is no such theorem. The main theorem to get a Gaussian density is the central limit theorem which usually assumes an infinite sequence of independent identically distributed random variables (plus some), i.e., i.i.d. The i.i.d. is asking a LOT!!! Asking so much that in practice it is essentially unrealistic.

What people often mean by Gaussian is just a central peak, some symmetry, and long tails, but an actual Gaussian distribution has a lot more, e.g., sufficient statistics (as in a classic paper by Halmos and Savage, with a derivation in M. Loeve's two volumes, from Springer, Probability) which, as I recall, E. Dynkin showed are quite sensitive to deviations from actual Gaussian.

Gaussian is important in a lot of derivations -- a LOT is known. But in practice Gaussian has some utility but only as an approximation where don't need to be very careful about accuracy.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by dekhn on Monday February 07, 2022 @11:33AM (#30247115)
I am not really disagreeing with you, but for a first order approximation, treating human height as a bunch of iids is the simplest approach. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41431-021-00836-7. "At the same time, it is well-understood that additivity of effects and normal distribution of residuals is only an approximation to the distribution of height in human populations. .... However, up until now, no evidence for non-additive genetic interactions was found for height [6, 18]. Moreover, if non-additive effects were to exist for polygenic traits, very large sample sizes would be required to detect them [9]."
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by graycat on Monday February 07, 2022 @10:11PM (#30254517)
> treating human height as a bunch of iids is the simplest approach.

Sounds fine.

If you treat heights as some i.i.d.s, then can use the central limit theorem to argue that in the limit for large samples (we get convergence in distribution) the probability density distribution of the sum of heights expressed as a z-score (mean 0, standard deviation 1) has Gaussian probability density distribution.

But that does not mean that the probability density distribution of heights is Gaussian. Indeed, if include both males and females, then for the density likely get two peaks instead of just one. If also include children, then get a left tail longer than the right one.

So, net, we cannot expect that heights are Gaussian. And we will have a tough time finding a large population that is Gaussian. z-scores in the limit for large samples Gaussian -- sure, can get that. A large population Gaussian, not much chance.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by bathtub365 on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:44AM (#30207331)
And as a nice side effect you begin to collect exactly the types of people willing to fire 10% of their workforce every year.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by sangnoir on Friday February 04, 2022 @12:55PM (#30210175)
Are managers stack ranked too? If not, and assuming the whole scheme works[1], then steady state is accumulation of bad managers, while they keep firing above-average ICs (that are still in their bottom 10).

1. It doesn't work, obviously because they are not in a closed system. Their policies affect their reputation, which will affect their ability to hire ICs who have to contend with an increasingly higher bar to clear.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by malfist on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:35PM (#30212734)
Managers are indeed stack ranked at amazon. Only L7 and above escape this, and typically they don't have an option to PIP/Focus, they're just straight out shown the door.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by sangnoir on Saturday February 05, 2022 @02:22AM (#30218679)
> Managers are indeed stack ranked at amazon.

I wish I could have said that's better than the alternative, but it's not. I suspect the ground is always shifting beneath you at Amazon. Even if your performance is fine, a colleague or your manager could get PIP'd

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by user_named on Friday February 04, 2022 @11:36AM (#30209039)
There is no reason to believe that the lowest 10% performers are the same as the 10% put on PIP/forced attrition.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by sangnoir on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:01PM (#30210253)
...and humans being humans, it's not going to the same 10% year by year. Going through a rough patch in your personal life? Well, your divorce/dealing with a sick child or parent can have a PIP as a chaser.

For a company that's vaunted for it's long-view philosophy, it's a terribly short-sighted policy.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by contravariant on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:46AM (#30207355)
I can't really imagine a normal work environment where 10% (or any significant percentage) is actively harming the company.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by yelling_cat on Friday February 04, 2022 @11:02AM (#30208522)
It would be like middle school with on-call rotations.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by mring33621 on Friday February 04, 2022 @11:20AM (#30208794)
try working at a big bank
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by SNosTrAnDbLe on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:04PM (#30210307)
This becomes more difficult when you have dont adjust for variables like out of work pressure. For example, the year that I had a kid, my performance was not the best. It took me an year to adjust but now I have bounced back. I wonder how this would have played out in Amazon or similar companies.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by geekbird on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:08PM (#30214014)
You would have been PIPed and sacked in April.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by NhanH on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:41AM (#30207294)
That only applies if the bad employees are uniformly distributed amongst all teams in the company. Otherwise it makes more sense to chop the worst 10% teams.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by mjr00 on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:59AM (#30207532)
At Amazon, the target was between 4 to 6% when I was there, but it was applied at the larger department level, not individual teams. It was perfectly fine to have a team of 10 where nobody was on a PIP (yes, such things exist!), but when it came to my entire 250-person department, all of the managers were in a room together ranking every employee they had and using "data" (peer reviews and results delivered, mainly) to fight over which employees got into the top and bottom tiers.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by geekbird on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:10PM (#30214036)
Yep. This creates a lateral sabotage, work stealing and kiss up culture.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by vintermann on Friday February 04, 2022 @11:51AM (#30209256)
W. Edwards Deming posited that management was responsible for more than 85% of the causes of variation. If this is true, I modestly suggest replacing the CEO in roughly 4 out of every 5 months.

(Somehow stack ranking logic never gets applied that way.)

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by rdtwo on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:53AM (#30207452)
That actually makes way more sense. Cutting teams that don’t perform and reforming makes lots of sense
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by evidencepi on Thursday February 10, 2022 @12:43AM (#30282824)
> 1953: * Mao declared that "95 percent of the people are good," leading the party to target 5 percent in many organizations as "bad elements" who should be purged and repressed. At least hundreds of thousands died.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1994/07/17/h...

I also want to point out that a lot ppl who suffered or even lost their lives during such period were actually sabotaged or framed by their peers (neighbors, coworkers), rather than the authority.

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by matthewowen on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:54PM (#30213047)
Too late to edit, but I just want to reiterate: I don’t actually agree with this, I’m just trying to make the case.

All the counterpoints about whether 10% is accurate, whether you get the right 10%, whether they’re evenly distributed, whether there are other costs, why not apply the same logic to managers and execs, etc etc etc, yes, I agree!

Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by allochthon on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:46PM (#30212929)
This kind of performance review funkiness is why I have resisted stepping into managerial roles.
Re:Amazon Pip Horror Story by ltfey on Friday February 04, 2022 @07:43PM (#30215740)
The true (actual, Marxist red pill) answer: work is exploitation of laborers by capital and "not good enough to be worth employing" isn't really a thing. The bosses make off with so much money, who cares. Maybe there are a few useless people at the bottom sucking off salary. What about the useless ones at the top, though?

All this being said, in the context of an organization that actually deserves to exist (a rarity, given that we live under capitalism), it is impossible to say what percentage of people will be ill-fit to their roles, let alone what percentage will be so ill-fit to any role that separation is the only option.