News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by bschne on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:28AM (#30190793)
If there's any merit to these figures, this is pretty crazy. I'm tempted to side with apple b/c I generally think they're at least less bad than FB and I value any platform taking steps to further privacy.

But the fact that a company can do this to another company at the flick of a switch by changing the rules of the game on a whim is still kind of scary, even if I think it's for the better in this instance.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by JustMarco on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:05AM (#30191008)
Apple is asking users if they want any specific app to be able to track them. Users can still say it’s ok to track me, Apple just gives me the option instead of being on by default. Apparently a lot of people are saying don’t track me? And that’s important, I should be given the choice in regards to privacy.

Not saying Apple is a saint, however it’s not that Apple changed the rules they provide options that weren’t available before (and imho should have been available already for years).

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @08:33AM (#30192150)
And the fact that this makes their own (mostly losing) app store search ads product lots of money is just a total coincidence.

Like, I could accept these changes if they applied to Apple too, but they don't, so the privacy stuff is a smokescreen for moves designed to keep their services revenue growing, and their stock price heading up and to the right.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by Elidrake24 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @09:45AM (#30193045)
They applied to Apple before they applied to third party apps: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202074
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @10:01AM (#30193250)
And does a scary warning come up when you first open one of the Apple apps to disallow cross app tracking?
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by jatone on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:22PM (#30199079)
this feature alone would make me switch from android to an iphone if it wasn't for things like pine phone being on the market.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by darrenf on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:51AM (#30190919)
> the fact that a company can do this to another company

I don't necessarily believe Apple are being deliberately adversarial here. Perhaps I'm being overly naive, but to me Facebook's woes are a side-effect, not the primary aim. Apple's change is to improve privacy for their paying customers, and if Facebook (or anyone else) relies on invading that privacy to make money ... tough. The window has closed. Time to figure out an alternative.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by nikanj on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:57AM (#30190951)
Fortunately the other major smartphone provider is much more ad-friendly
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by theshrike79 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:48AM (#30191278)
It's as if The Other Provider is an ad company themselves =)
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by gnz11 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:45AM (#30190882)
What rules of the game? Apple has no obligation to make Facebook a profitable company. If anything, the lesson here is to not tightly couple core parts of your business model to a third party.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by rbanffy on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:03AM (#30190999)
> a company can do this to another company at the flick of a switch

I briefly started a service. It was an automated tool to track how your tweets affected followers and traffic to one or more sites. It was neat.

Then Twitter changed the auth API. A month later, the throttles changed. Then something else changed in the JSON objects the API returned.

We decided to give up when Twitter announced their own analytics tool, after about two months or part-time work.

So yes, companies can and do that routinely. Sometimes, as it seems to be the case here, they are just acting in their (and their customers) best interest and completely ignoring the effects on other companies.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by BLKNSLVR on Thursday February 03, 2022 @08:11AM (#30191943)
> But the fact that a company can do this to another company at the flick of a switch by changing the rules of the game on a whim is still kind of scary, even if I think it's for the better in this instance.

You've got it back to front. If one company is $10b dependent upon another company not having the option to disable privacy invasion, then that company has chosen to build their castle in a swamp. It deserves to sink by $10b.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by kergonath on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:26AM (#30191138)
> But the fact that a company can do this to another company at the flick of a switch by changing the rules of the game on a whim is still kind of scary, even if I think it's for the better in this instance.

They did not flick the switch, the users did. They merely pointed out the existence of the switch.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by ubermonkey on Thursday February 03, 2022 @09:40AM (#30192967)
I think that's overstating the issue here.

Facebook built their empire on browsers being super super permissive about tracking. Critically, this tracking was (a) something most users weren't aware was happening and (b) something that was very very possible to curtail, because it wasn't something Facebook controlled.

People started noticing, and they didn't like it. Browser makers and platform makers moved to make these unhappy people happier. Facebook got caught out, because their whole business is built on this invasive tracking.

I am 100% untroubled by the way this is playing out. It's not a general case problem. It's very specific to Facebook's dependence on an accidental aspect of the web that, when explained, most people are horrified by -- and that was fairly easy to rework.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by KoftaBob on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:15AM (#30191071)
> But the fact that a company can do this to another company at the flick of a switch

In this instance, the flick of the switch added a prompt asking users whether they want to opt in/consent to Facebook tracking their activities on other apps.

If Facebook is truly taking that much of a hit from that, it tells you how many users opted out. If their advertising model only succeeds by tracking users without their explicit consent, then their model is a failure.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by pfortuny on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:54AM (#30190928)
As it is said here frequently, if your revenue depends essentially on a single actor (as is the case), your business is doomed by definition.

Cf: all those people who depend on a google project to survive.

This is the same, but at scale.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by franczesko on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:35AM (#30190831)
In the meantime Apple is growing it's own advertising business. Apple's privacy claim cannot be trusted (e.g. China).
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by cloutchaser on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:54AM (#30190931)
This is the crucial point I think. Apple claims its on the side of privacy when it suits them. When it doesn't they don't care. In fact as the only big tech company allowed in China, you could argue they have a much worse effect on privacy overall for humanity than any other tech company.

It's all bullshit, and marketing. Apple is doing this to grow apple ads. That's it.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by kergonath on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:32AM (#30191179)
> In fact as the only big tech company allowed in China, you could argue they have a much worse effect on privacy overall for humanity than any other tech company.

I would argue that it would be far worse for humanity if they decided that they did not have to follow local laws. Regardless of what you might think of our laws here, I do not want a foreign company feeling entitled to ignore them and impose their American views. They do it far too often as it is already.

If you want Apple to provide better privacy, change your laws and make sure they are followed.

In the meantime, until Apple is found to have violated local data protection laws, the whole “but China” argument is a red herring.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by strikelaserclaw on Thursday February 03, 2022 @07:03AM (#30191392)
All companies are sociopaths that are only after the dollar. If Apple does something "good", it is basically benefitting them in some way, if it stops doing so they will change. Name me one company which sacrificed profitability for ethics.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by lucian1900 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:58AM (#30190958)
China has very strong privacy laws, though. In fact, Grindr recently stopped operating there because their business model was made very difficult by the new PIPL law.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by treeman79 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:02AM (#30190990)
Seems like a sick joke as people have zero privacy from the government in China.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by simondotau on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:14AM (#30191062)
One could be reductive and say that the Chinese Government has given themselves a monopoly on privacy invasion. Is that strictly worse than privacy invasion as a capitalist business model? I think the answer to that is highly subjective and highly culturally dependent.

Obviously the the ideal would be to have neither.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by treeman79 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:38AM (#30191218)
Private companies are usually not allowed to make you disappear
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by endisneigh on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:06AM (#30191016)
source?
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by treeman79 on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:04PM (#30213177)
[dead]
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by endisneigh on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:13AM (#30191057)
that doesn't mean Chinese people have zero privacy, lol. Would you say USA citizens also have no privacy, as the US government does the same thing?

it would be fair to say that Chinese are monitored, yes. not that they have zero privacy. what a ridiculous, unsubstantiated claim.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by treeman79 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @07:36AM (#30191668)
Not to dismiss what the US does. But China is on a completely different level.

Look at what happened to one of their athletes after she complained about being a assaulted at the last Olympics.

US is probably a few decades that level. Hopefully longer.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by marcellus23 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:59AM (#30190963)
What ad business? Don’t they really only show ads in Apple News? How is that comparable to what FB and Google do?
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by jsnell on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:18AM (#30191089)
Their $5 billion / year ad business in the App Store, News and Stocks. The one where they track you by default in many Apple apps, build a cross-app ad profile based on your behavior, demographic information you are forced to enter to even reate an account, geographic location, and so on. And then they allow ads to be targeted against you using fairly high granularity user segments (minimum 5k users).

See https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/data/en/apple-advertisin... for the details.

Want to opt out of this? It's a OS-level setting in an obscure place, rather than what Apple requires from 3p apps.

Now, Apple isn't uniquely bad in the level of tracking they do. They're just the same as all of these companies are. The place where they are unique is the incredibly brazen self-dealing, using their control of iOS to boost their own tracking ad business over the competitors.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by simondotau on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:24AM (#30191123)
> [Apple] build a cross-app ad profile

Citation? I'm not saying your wrong, but I haven't heard anyone make this claim before.

> rather than what Apple requires from 3p apps

For the sake of argument, even if we assume your prior claim is correct, this is still incorrect. Apple does not require third party apps to notify users or provide an opt-out mechanism from tracking user activity across the apps of a singular developer.

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by jsnell on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:47AM (#30191271)
I already linked to Apple's own privacy policy on ads where they describe exactly this. If that's not a sufficient source, there's nothing better I could do. To quote:

> We create segments, which are groups of people who share similar characteristics, and use these groups for delivering targeted ads.

> We may use information such as the following to assign you to segments:

> ... The music, movies, books, TV shows, and apps you download ...

> ... The topics and categories of the stories you read and the publications you follow, subscribe to, or enable notifications from ...

> ... Your name, address, age, gender, ...

> ... your App Store searches and browsing activity ...

> ... information stored on your device, such as the apps you frequently open ...

There is absolutely no suggestion there that these segments would be per-app. In fact, they cannot be per-app given some of the data they say they're using is only collected from places with no ads. That is not an exhaustive list by the way, but just representative examples provided by Apple. The only data they explicitly promise not to use for ads targeting is:

> No Apple Pay transactions or Health app data is accessible to Apple’s advertising platform

Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by JustMarco on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:07AM (#30191022)
App Store ads are growing fast.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by oefrha on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:29AM (#30191156)
Which part of that require tracking? You search for Facebook, they show you a TikTok ad as the first result (granted, quite annoying more often than not). Same business model as DuckDuckGo.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by KoftaBob on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:16AM (#30191077)
There's a separate setting for its own advertising network that asks the user if they want their activity in apps to be used to target ads they see. Just like for the case of 3rd party apps like FB, it can be turned off.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by soundnote on Thursday February 03, 2022 @08:04AM (#30191894)
I've heard that they toyed with the idea of making iCloud end to end encrypted but government agencies convinced them otherwise.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by threatofrain on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:56AM (#30190942)
What is Apple's most visible marketing initiate as of late?
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by mongol on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:11AM (#30191042)
I don't think it is scary. I think it is evidence that Facebook's revenue is built on ground they don't control. Google at least took step to have some control by creating Android. Given Facebook's bottom line, they could have done something similar.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by lotsofpulp on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:17AM (#30191078)
As could Microsoft. None of the other players wanted to risk as much as Apple by investing in hardware and in person services. Really investing in it, for 10+ years. They certainly had/have the cash.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by MarkSweep on Thursday February 03, 2022 @11:14AM (#30194268)
I suspect one motivation for this “Metaverse” thing is to create a platform that they control. Where they can track people as much as they want and show as many ads as they want.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by grishka on Thursday February 03, 2022 @08:11AM (#30191945)
It tells quite a lot about Facebook's business model when you realize it's threatened this much by user consent. Apple has simply stated asking for consent for something that didn't require it before. It's merely people's choice to not be tracked.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by dotancohen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @07:25AM (#30191563)

  > But the fact that a company can do this to another company at the flick of a switch by changing the rules of the game on a whim is still kind of scary
You should read about what Ford Motor Company did to the horse and buggy industry. Or what email (arguably Hotmail) did to the postal and phone companies. Or what Boeing did to the transoceanic shipping companies.
Re:Facebook says Apple iOS privacy change will result in $10... by ben_w on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:00AM (#30190981)
> But the fact that a company can do this to another company at the flick of a switch by changing the rules of the game on a whim is still kind of scary, even if I think it's for the better in this instance.

As a general principle I agree, but this is more a reason to encourage many small businesses over a small number of trillion dollar businesses (other reasons exist for the exact opposite).

But in this specific case, not only do I agree with you that it’s for the better, but I also can’t see how Apple is even going further than just requiring apps on its platform to adhere to GDPR.