News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by i_am_proteus on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:22AM (#30148865)
>With this pilot, some stations are now accessible to Non-Tesla EV drivers in selected countries via the Tesla app

Why should it be necessary to install software in order to fuel a vehicle? What benefit exists for the consumer?

I have noticed this as a trend in physical services, I was asked by a grocery store to install software prior to purchasing groceries, however they were gracious after I declined, and permitted me to purchase groceries using only my debit card.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by FractalParadigm on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:25AM (#30148925)
I'd wager it's the same reason they're getting rid of parking pay booths and parking meters - it's a hell of a lot cheaper for people to install your app and pay through that, than installing traditional payment options. Why would you pay for the debit/credit terminal, then the monthly fee to connect it to the internet? If people want to use your service so badly they'll install your app.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by haspok on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:34AM (#30149074)
You mean of course it is simpler and cheaper for the provider, not for "people" (the users).

For actual users nothing beats the simplicity of paying via contactless card (or mobile) payment solution. Right now I have probably over a dozen apps installed just for paying for various services like parking (of course, each city/country has its own), it is _madness_, and I'm not even using anything special. I hate this passionately and would actually pay for simplicity!

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by KptMarchewa on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:57AM (#30149417)
It's also easier for me to pay for parking on app rather than - look 5 minutes for parking meter - type car plate number on an antiquated unergonomic keyboard that doesn't work really well in winter - go back to car and put the paper behind windshield, which accidentally is opposite the direction I want to go - few hours later realize that I want to stay longer than I've bought parking for, and go back to prolongate it

>Right now I have probably over a dozen apps installed just for paying for various services like parking (of course, each city/country has its own), it is _madness_, and I'm not even using anything special.

Here in Poland I can do this in my banking app for pretty much every parking in my country. Blame your shitty parking providers rather than technology.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:51AM (#30149315)
If it’s cheaper for them, why isn’t it cheaper for us?

> For actual users nothing beats the simplicity of paying via contactless card (or mobile) payment solution.

Not true. The next level of simplicity is not having to do anything at all (eg just plug in to charge and have the money deducted automatically). NFC or fiddling with an app on a phone is definitely worse than that. But now we need more standards to enable it for anyone other than teslas.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by pm90 on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:43AM (#30149196)
It’s sorta also creates a situation where you need to have a smartphone with a decent specs to access basic services like parking and fuel. Whereas earlier it was any legal tender.

I wonder if a lawsuit could be brought against companies that restrict how they accept payment for services. It would seem like something like cashless stores would be illegal if cash is legal tender.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by tsimionescu on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:04AM (#30149507)
No business is required to do business with you. Now, if you incur a debt and then they refuse to accept your money, that could potentially be a problem, but otherwise it's perfectly ok for them to refuse your cash at the register and tell you to leave without the products you wanted to purchase.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by KptMarchewa on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:59AM (#30149445)
You also need to read and write to access basic services.

I wonder where we could just provide all stubborn people with basic government endorsed smartphone just to shut up this argument.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by pm90 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:14PM (#30150550)
The Government does provide free public education to cover the read/write parts.

And yes, absolutely a subsidy for folks to get a decent smartphone would be just fine.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:53AM (#30149336)
The constitution only specified that cash can be used to settle debts or pay taxes. Stores can (and many do) refuse cash.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by lapetitejort on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:44AM (#30149217)
I have two apps for EV charging, one app for finding charging stations, two apps for parking, one app to connect to the car, and another app to connect to an OBDII bluetooth dongle. My PTSD flairs up (slight exaggeration) whenever I see a new company offering chargers or parking.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by fastball on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:40AM (#30149157)
I disagree. It's easier for me to have my payment method attached to an account and that account to be automatically debited whenever I connect my car.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by _ph_ on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:47AM (#30149262)
Higher costs for the provider translate into higher costs for the customers.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by haspok on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:51AM (#30149307)
Which is fine by me.

Look, I'm not saying there shouldn't be an app at all, all I'm saying is that people should not be forced to use the app.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by ohgodplsno on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:53AM (#30149344)
Lower costs for the provider do not necessarily translate into lower costs for the customers, most likely higher profits for the provider.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by HWR_14 on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:10AM (#30149566)
Sometimes. Sometimes it comes out of corporate profits.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by llampx on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:45AM (#30149225)
There still needs to be a terminal of sorts to enable charging, usually with a big touch screen these days, and of course it needs to be connected to power and internet. Can't be cheaper than a gas station style card reader - where gas stations sometimes even save on costs by having one card reader for multiple pumps or the whole station.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by xeromal on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:49AM (#30149286)
There's no terminal on Tesla chargers. You just plug in and it starts charging.

For non-teslas, this isn't an option so you have to use the app.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by tsimionescu on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:03AM (#30149488)
The normal solution is: you drive up, you fill up, and then you go inside and pay when you're done. No app, no smartphone, no problem. You can pay cash or card.

Why in the world would you complicate this?

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by nickv on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:23AM (#30149755)
That requires staffing (at a 24/7 level ideally). I just did a cross country drive in a Tesla and most of them are in stations that are around stores, malls, hotels or restaurants - but none of them are staffed. The costs of these stations are already high, adding a physical building that is staffed by somebody 24/7 will just make it even harder to build and more expensive.

How is getting out of your car, walking to a valet or booth to talk to a person, and paying where they ask "What is your stall number?" less complicated than literally just plugging in your car?

To be clear, if you have a Tesla, there is NO app needed. There's nothing. You literally just plug in and it works. That's better than any gas station I've ever been to.

FYI - This isn't a Tesla EV thing. This is an EV thing. EVERY network basically requires either an RFID card or a smart phone app: ElectrifyAmerica, Chargepoint, SOMA, Flo, EVGo. I can't think of one that doesn't.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by vel0city on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:58AM (#30150250)
> EVERY network basically requires either an RFID card or a smart phone app

My Mach E isn't a Tesla and charges on EA stations by just plugging it in. I don't have an EA app. There's a standard protocol for this negotiation. Lots of chargers don't yet support it, but the technology exists for non-Teslas to have a plug and charge experience.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by xeromal on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:11AM (#30149583)
There's nothing complicated about a Tesla charging.

You drive up. Plug in. Done.

There's no app. There's no wallet.

There's no kiosk or attendant that has to be maintained or paid.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by dagw on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:26AM (#30149796)
go inside and pay when you're done.

Go inside where and pay whom? The vast majority of charging stations I've seen are unmanned.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by llampx on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:13PM (#30150544)
Right. I was thinking of non-Tesla terminals. I'm sure its not an insurmountable obstacle to add terminals to future or current charging points (if they are forced to by regulators)
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by natch on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:41AM (#30149174)
It’s only necessary if your car isn’t designed to identify itself automatically to the Tesla network.

Tesla drivers don’t need to go through the app to charge. They just plug in.

You can also charge elsewhere such as at home. Most public charging stations I’ve seen (I’m in the US) do not have credit card readers and therefore require either a car that identifies itself, or an app.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by meragrin_ on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:30AM (#30149003)
> Why should it be necessary to install software in order to fuel a vehicle? What benefit exists for the consumer?

As far as gas pumps and chargers, less chance of the interface being vandalized? In Tesla's case, I would imagine it is more an easy adaptation to current infrastructure without major changes to the chargers themselves.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by ajross on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:39AM (#30149151)
> Why should it be necessary to install software in order to fuel a vehicle? What benefit exists for the consumer?

In this particular case, it's because Tesla superchargers aren't point of sale terminals. They don't have a display or any means of interacting with the user beyond grabbing the plug connector and sticking it into a car.

That's a feature, not a bug. People who haven't actually supercharged a Tesla imagine this service to be like pulling into a gas station, and it's really not.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by davedx on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:24AM (#30148900)
It's not necessary for regular charging poles, but you do need some way to identify yourself. Using an app is a bit more environmentally friendly than mailing out loads of plastic cards. Personally I don't know why chargepoles don't just support chip and pin, at least in Europe - almost all parking places here do now.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by kzrdude on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:25AM (#30148919)
Why identify yourself? Isn't it enough to use a payment system?
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by davedx on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:29AM (#30148998)
How would that work? Tesla would need to install card readers at every supercharger stall?
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by ajford on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:00AM (#30149455)
You mean like every pay-at-the-pump gas stall has for something like a decade? I hate this app payment system for chargers.

I spent something like 30 minutes once trying to get the ChargePoint app to play nice with my phone (didn't want to install on my Motorola phone) then once I finally got it loaded it took another 15 minutes to get my card added and turn on the charger. Then it finally told me the charger wasn't working after it tried to activate the charge cycle.

I eventually gave up and found a hotel 10 minutes away that happened to have a free charge stall. Took the front desk a box of fresh donuts and asked them if I could spend 30 minutes in their lobby so I could get enough charge to make it home in my Nissan Leaf. Luckily they were nice enough to let me use it and I eventually made it home.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by kzrdude on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:25AM (#30149786)
They could go with NFC only (swipe card or phone), that's at least one app-less and standardized payment system.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by iqanq on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:35AM (#30149086)
Is this ironic? Even mcdonalds self-serve kiosks have a card reader each.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by fonix on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:02AM (#30149481)
That's fine that MCD does that but Tesla already has 30k+ stations around the USA with no reader. A retrofit to include that wouldn't be cheap OR fast and it would introduce another point of failure.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by Handytinge on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @05:07AM (#30175714)
You know McDonalds had tens of thousands of locations before they had self service kiosks, right? They had to "retrofit" them in too.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by barelysapient on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:28AM (#30148975)
Probably because Tesla isn't into retail point of sale and would rather reuse existing app based infrastructure.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by natch on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:46AM (#30149241)
Also important to note Tesla drivers don’t need to use the app for charging. Although it does have helpful features if they do, like being able to check on the charge remotely.

The described experience of selecting a charger, pressing start charging / stop charging etc. is only for non-Teslas because they don’t have the integration.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by vel0city on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:03PM (#30150349)
> is only for non-Teslas because they don’t have the integration.

Several non-Tesla models support a standardized protocol to negotiate billing information in the charging handshake. Its a matter of once again Tesla using a proprietary system instead of adopting industry standards.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:11PM (#30150503)
> Its a matter of once again Tesla using a proprietary system instead of adopting industry standards.

Ah, you mean there is already an industry standard around this? That's great, but could you tell us what it is (surely the standard that Tesla isn't following has a name or something)?

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by vel0city on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:50PM (#30153273)
The standard is the easy to remember ISO 15118. Not all EVs support it yet, and for sure many charging stations don't implement it, but there is an international signaling standard to communicate this data which theoretically everyone can implement and participate in.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_15118

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 31, 2022 @03:12PM (#30153590)
Thanks. It looks like 4 or 5 vehicles support it starting in 2021. Hopefully Tesla will join them someday.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by hadrien01 on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:28AM (#30148983)
Ionity chargers (a majority of fast chargers in Europe) are made by a consortium of European car manufacturers, and they strongly nudge you to use their subscriptions (either sold directly or trough the manufacturers). If you try to pay directly, the experience is miserable, most certainly on purpose.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by kzrdude on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:45AM (#30150036)
That's embarrassing. Another benefit to fossil fuels then. If they don't up their game lawmakers might even catch notice and step in?
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by InTheArena on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:19AM (#30149683)
Non-tesla chargers in the US are also awful - different payment models, broken chargers, etc.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by spicybright on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:31AM (#30149024)
Self serve gas pumps solved this >60 years ago. No advantage (except for Tesla's) to collect more data.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by kzrdude on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:24AM (#30149767)
Avoiding card fees is a legitimate thing, I admit
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by HWR_14 on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:25PM (#30150750)
How are they getting paid without fees? Don't you pay via card thru the app? Or do they pay 30% to Apple and Google (unlikely)
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by gwbas1c on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:46AM (#30149245)
> Why should it be necessary to install software in order to fuel a vehicle? What benefit exists for the consumer?

It's a pilot.

But, IMO, we should require ordinary credit/debit card access to high-speed chargers. Every time I use a Supercharger, I spend around $10 bucks, so there's no need to work around credit card fees.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:57AM (#30149418)
POS terminals aren’t cheap, so by require you mean regulation and consumers will bear the costs?

> Every time I use a Supercharger, I spend around $10 bucks, so there's no need to work around credit card fees.

They could always take the Starbucks app approach here and require periodic loading of money to your account, which then only incurs the fee occasionally.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by foepys on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:20AM (#30149702)
> POS terminals

You can get portable card readers for like $50. Everything including the postage stamps for regulatory approval will be more expensive.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:36AM (#30149924)
> You can get portable card readers for like $50.

Yes, but we aren't talking about portable readers, we are talking about commercial grade ones that will need their own displays and can stand up to weather and various beatings like gas station POS. So let's add a few zeros to that.

But maybe I misunderstood you and you meant that all the users should get portable card readers for their phones so they can use EV charging with their credit cards?

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by foepys on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:17AM (#30149668)
In Germany newly built charging stations will be required to allow payments with credit/debit cards from July 2023 onwards. There will be no requirement to retrofit existing stations but I think that the pressure from the public will eventually be too high and the app requirement will disappear.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by ip26 on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:57AM (#30149420)
The original brilliance behind Superchargers is how simple the hardware is. Essentially just a 400V cable. The internet-connected car does most of the work. A payment terminal at superchargers is entirely new hardware (overhead) to install (& fail).
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by gwbas1c on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @09:20AM (#30177871)
> The original brilliance behind Superchargers is how simple the hardware is.

In theory. But proprietary technologies that work for people like me have the luxury of being simple.

The simplest example is cash. There are still a lot of "unbanked" people who need to buy gas with cash.

I'm perfectly happy with entering my credit card number into a menu on my car, and then, via an open protocol, billing happening automatically. But, for the people who for one reason or another can't / won't use credit / debit cards, high speed chargers need to accept cash.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by ff317 on Monday January 31, 2022 @11:06AM (#30149524)
Well, one part of the charging problem they're trying to solve is getting cars in and out of slots quickly to increase overall capacity. For the existing Tesla owners in the US, there's virtually zero auth/payment overhead: they already have Tesla accounts and it identifies the car, so you just drive up and plug in and get billed. They also charge idle fees ($0.50/min if there are open slots, $1/min if the whole station is full) for occupying slots unproductively.

I imagine they could have added some kind of reliable payment-card reader, maybe. But then you're dealing with a whole other level of things like people trying 3 different cards until they get one to work and burning time, possible fraud, skimming, etc. You also have new hardware and failure modes in the charger itself (the reader, the screen, the buttons, etc), whereas right now they're featureless, just a tall plastic thing with a charge cable on it, and it's charging to a known card pre-registered in the account.

It seems a reasonable tradeoff (at least in the US, to me, at this point in the industry's evolution) to stick with the system they've got for simplicity and speed, and ask for a Tesla app install. The only other open charging network I've tried in the US (Chargepoint) also needs an app install and account.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by josephcsible on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:05PM (#30150386)
> Why should it be necessary to install software in order to fuel a vehicle?

You're right, it shouldn't be necessary. It should be as easy to Supercharge any EV as it is a Tesla. There's a standard called Plug & Charge that makes exactly that possible, but most EVs don't support it yet, so the app is the temporary solution until they do.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by Tagbert on Monday January 31, 2022 @04:46PM (#30154939)
Hopefully, those Tesla chargers are supporting the Plug & Charge standard that lets different EVs change on various networks without needing separate accounts and apps.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_15118

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by sigio on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:57AM (#30149415)
Simple... tesla's negotiate automatically between car and chargepoint. This doesn't work for non-tesla's, so you need the app to call into a backend system to unlock/activate a charger (and keep track of who needs to pay)
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by awestroke on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:24AM (#30148901)
Because in this case it's 100x faster to start charging via the app, and there are no card readers at Tesla's superchargers anyway - how else would you pay?
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by hadrien01 on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:30AM (#30149005)
So in the end you have one card for all chargers... except Tesla's. In Europe most charging infrastructure can be accessed through most subscriptions, even those from competitors.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by theshrike79 on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:37AM (#30149127)
...At a roaming price, which can be up to 500% of the real price.

No-one uses that roaming crap unless they just bought a new car and either don't know better or have some kind of brand-specific deal for a limited time.

Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by zepto on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:42AM (#30149183)
Why do you justify that conclusion? There is no reason Tesla couldn’t participate is such a subscription. The app is just because there is no card reader at the charger.
Re:Non-Tesla Supercharger Pilot by natch on Monday January 31, 2022 @10:49AM (#30149285)
And because the non Tesla car doesn’t identify the car (and thus indirectly the payment account) to the charger as a Tesla automatically does.