- The accuracy of current epigenetic clocks suggests it might not be a dead-end with average error of 2-3 years, across multiple tissues (and even Chimpanzees).
- The variability of an aging phenotype is not that high. We all loose bone density, loose teeth, hair turns white, memory degrades, wrinkles appear, etc. In other words - aging follows a pattern.
- The car analogy assumes that aging is caused by damage over time. But there is an alternative explanation: aging provides and evolutionary advantage for a species and hence is predetermined.
People age at different rates depending on a wide variety of factors.
Progeria, over consumption of alcohol, too much stress, too much radiation from sunlight, etc.
The things you point to are measures of a biological age, not a wall clock age. While they do correlate, they're not 1:1. Some people age faster.
> But there is an alternative explanation: aging provides and evolutionary advantage for a species and hence is predetermined.
I don't buy this. We don't have a pre-programmed death. It's rather that we haven't had any genetic pressure to live beyond our current lifespan as it doesn't increase our offspring's chances of success.
There's little pressure from competing with children for resources. Look at how many people there are in the world today - the world supports billions of humans. There are far greater pressures being exerted in other ways.
Also, whatever we think about these epigenetic clocks, there are few things to come to terms with: 1) they work across pretty much all individuals (and people with progeria do exhibit older epigenetic age [1]) 2) they work across pretty much all tissues. I don't see how this could be explained through "damage over time". The way I see it damage should be random and not lead to something so predictable that we could use it to guess a persons chronological age with 2.5 year accuracy.
Look at the tortoise. We know some that have lived two centuries. They have their niche, do what they do, and live a very long time.
During their evolutionary journey to their current local maxima, I wonder whether they lived shorter lives?
Huh? The only requirement of evolution is that organisms sometimes reproduce.
The immortal organism would not evolve. Imagine you and I lived 100K years from now. Other humans would evolve somewhat during that time but we would be fixed. Climate change might happen, new humans would adapt to the changing environment via evolution, but we would be stuck suffering the new environment.
The humanity example takes a long time to be noticeable. But for early multi-cellular organisms this would kick in much faster. Thing about micro organism fighting against toxins. The ones that do not evolve and adapt would die off sooner. And while they are still alive they are competing for resources with the newer versions of themselves. So for the colony it is advantageous for the older ones to die quicker since we already know they will be unnecessary sooner or later.
Now we evolved from these primitive creatures. And the mechanisms for things like aging, circadian rhythm, sexual reproduction, etc - we inherited from the early creatures. So regardless if the advantage of dying sooner is beneficial or not to the humanity now - the mechanism itself is far more ancient than humanity or even mammals.
It might even be that death provides selective advantage(s), which would account for its being a nearly universal feature of known life. A "pre-programmed death" mechanism would be consistent with this.
We haven't found this mechanism in humans. Cancer and heart disease simply don't impact child rearing.
It requires a great deal of optimization to rejuvenate cells after injury and simultaneously tamp down on uncontrolled proliferation (cancer). It's an extremely complex system. The evolutionary gradient to optimize this is probably steep, and we haven't climbed it since our form is more than good enough. (There are billions of us.)
People cite tortoises, but these animals have a slow metabolism. They don't eat a wide variety of things. They don't have many enemies. They're not burning very fast.
We're not comparable.
I'm not sure of that. There's data-supported discussion of possible contribution to offspring survival by grandparents [1]. If true, that would disclose a fitness benefit of familial long lifespan.
[1] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/how-much-did-g... [not a peer-reviewed primary source, but a reasonable commentary on the matter.
People would start reproducing around 17, so around 40-45, you already would be a grandparent with multiple grandkids. This is still early for cancer or heart disease, unless you inherited some unlucky genes.
Why is that supposed to be a problem? Plenty of species will happily eat their own young.
Humans seem to reliably be able to handle environmental changes expected in their life spans. Other species not, and I dare say most other fauna has much a faster generation iteration rate because they are much more sensitive to the environment. Ergo evolution made their lifespans shorter so they can iterate faster and respond with a tighter gene fit to the environment.
Humans have their fitness less correlated by genes so a longer life span is allowed, but not boundless. In a sense every body must die so that new solutions/iterations can be ran.
Note: This is completely outside my expertise, so make of that what you will.
The source of all this is perhaps the suprachiasmatic nucleus which is important to perceiving the passing of time and emits growth hormone releasing hormone which signals the pituitary to make growth hormone.
It's a great example, but if anyone wanted to know more, it's spelled progeria.
[1] - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221112471...
Not universal or at least not easily or affordably. I can test each critical component and get a pretty good idea how much stress that component has been exposed to. Maybe the same could be done with mammals and we just test the critical components to get some numbers then apply a rough estimate of a score. Then perhaps a formula can be applied to the set of scores from all the critical components to assign a health score. I am considering the concept perfect is the enemy of good in this case.
I think these biological age scores are a really healthy way to debate and create broader awareness about a) how our bodies work and b) how we understand aging.
Ageing is relative to a starting point and the variability between people in terms of phenotype is huge.
By way of analogy, would it be possible to come up with a universal measure of ageing for cars? Cars are a complex system made of thousands of components, each of which can age differently over time. Each car make and model will age in a different way. Some of the components even slightly improve in performance over time as they “break in”.
The best way to measure epigenetic ageing is relative to a starting point. There are few studies that follow the same people over time (longitudinal) because it’s difficult and expensive to pull off. We’ll eventually get there though.