News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by MattGaiser on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:49PM (#30109766)
Local politics is absurdly corrupt in many cases as nobody pays attention.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by dayvid on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:14PM (#30110647)
Billy Corben's Instagram has better reporting on local Miami politics than our city newspaper! (https://www.instagram.com/billycorben/?hl=en)

The current mayor's father was also a mayor of Miami and was subject to intense fraud in his election campaign (https://www.nytimes.com/1998/03/05/us/fraud-ruling-invalidat...). They also hired a police chief recently who was almost immediately fired when he exposed how corrupt the city commission is (https://www.local10.com/news/local/2022/01/19/fired-miami-po...). The same city commission is being sued and investigated by the feds for extorting and trying to shut down a local business one of the commissioners didn't like (https://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/miamis-joe-carollo-sued-f...).

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by enkid on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:27AM (#30110968)
This is why the federal government is important. People talk about the "swamp in DC" not realizing how swampy it is in their local courthouses, and would be a lot swampier without the federal government looking over it.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by KennyBlanken on Friday January 28, 2022 @04:00AM (#30112299)
Yup, this sort of thing likely falls under the FBI's color of law investigations.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by 0xbadcafebee on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:50PM (#30110801)
Corruption is just part of Miami's character, like cuban coffee, and needles on the beach.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by thr0wawayf00 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:09PM (#30109905)
Local politics is also absurdly boring which, I would argue, is why nobody pays attention. It's such an inconvenience to participate in the local political process because we're so used to the theatre that is Federal politics. I mean honestly, can we all name the members of our city council, our mayor, etc.?

Our culture is so addicted to stimulation that we just don't want to spend time on something as boring and banal as a city council meeting.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by CrazyCatDog on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:18PM (#30109976)
With all due respect—I have something which will blow your mind!

The city of Santa Monica broadcasts city council meetings. And both the items being adjudicated and the members from the public stepping up to the mic, are every bit as colorful as the brightest Hollywood blockbusters. I listened for years after leaving LA… KCRW Thursday evenings, grab some popcorn and enjoy!!

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by thr0wawayf00 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:02PM (#30110251)
My town also broadcasts their meetings, and they're pretty darn tough to actually watch and focus on. Not that I expect my public officials to entertain me or cater to my interests, but it's not a particularly engaging format for a variety of reasons.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by kelp on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:10PM (#30110301)
Yeah and it's cured me of any idea of ever running for one of those offices. No way could I handle sitting in every one of those meetings for several years.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by Nbox9 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:55PM (#30110212)
> The city of Santa Monica broadcasts city council meetings

Tangential —- a lot of cities/towns stream city council and other committees on the internet.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by vel0city on Friday January 28, 2022 @10:49AM (#30116106)
I've never lived in California and yet I love KCRW. So many good live music sessions. Top notch public radio!
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by csomar on Friday January 28, 2022 @06:24AM (#30113293)
Link to 25 Jan meeting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qi2Ee4766-E

Santa Monica City has around 100K population. That video has ~500 views and it's on the Internet. The public barely cares.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by HWR_14 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:32PM (#30110072)
With all due respect (seriously) - you're making the problem worse. The problem is national politics sucks all the attention in the political arena away from local politics. Suggesting that people add yet another competing attention grab that occupies not only the politics but the local politics itch is just another push away from listening to what city hall is doing in their town.

There's also the fact that if Santa Monica's politics are that interesting, then people are more likely to be disappointed with how boring their local politics are.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:39PM (#30110116)
> I mean honestly, can we all name the members of our city council, our mayor, etc.

Of course I can. Off the top of my head:

City Council:

Lisa Herbold - neighborhood

Teresa Mosqueda - at large

Sara Nelson - at large, newly elected

Mayor:

Bruce Harrell - newly elected, replaced Jenny Durkan after one term. Was previously on the city council for 13 (?) years.

City Attorney:

Ann Davison - newly elected, replaced Pete Holmes who failed to advance through the primary after 12 years.

County Executive:

Dow Constantine - narrowly re-elected. Recently granted additional power to appoint the county sheriff.

These are the elected positions I vote on. I am also aware of appointed positions like parks, police, and city transit. I’m aware of the the parts of the council I don’t vote for.

I’m also aware of policy. Hazard pay for grocery workers. Attempting to stop catalytic converter theft. Fixing the bridge. Mask mandates. Public transit expansion. Defunding police.

I get a lot of my coverage of these events from the hyperlocal blog that covers my neighborhood. I have their number saved to text reports when I see them. They publish coverage of most local government meetings. I visit that site as often as HN.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by arcastroe on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:05PM (#30110590)
> Of course I can.

But are you aware that most people cannot?

This reminds me of a strategy I once heard on how to assign weights to people's votes according to their knowledge. You want to assign a high weight to those with relevant knowledge and low weight to those with little relevant knowledge.

So how do you know who has good relevant knowledge? Rather than just collecting the response to a question: "How many beans do you think are in this jar?" you also ask the _meta_ question: "What do you think will be the average response to the first question above?" For those who perform well on question 2, you assign higher weight to their answers on question 1.

If you just average all the answers to question 1, you are likely to get a close approximation to the true number of beans in the jar. But if you assign weights according to performance on question 2, you can get an even closer approximation to the true answer.

I may have gotten some details wrong, but the idea is that if you are aware of your peers' level of knowledge about a topic, then you are likely to be knowledgeable about the topic yourself.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by renewiltord on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:17AM (#30110925)
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by arcastroe on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:24PM (#30155525)
Thank you for this. Looks like I got A LOT of details wrong. And thinking about it some more, I don't think my original example holds. Many thanks
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Friday January 28, 2022 @04:20AM (#30112437)
Sure or people could just participate locally instead of being apathetic trolls on the internet. You get back what you put in. Nobody owes you anything. Do the work.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by thr0wawayf00 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:01PM (#30110243)
That's great that you know, that probably puts you in the top 1-5% of engaged citizens in the country.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Friday January 28, 2022 @04:16AM (#30112415)
It’s not hard. Just a simple choice. Democracy in action. Or perhaps inaction.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by Aeolun on Friday January 28, 2022 @09:22AM (#30114906)
I could care about them if they were people I knew. For the most part I’m happy to leave the running of my city to the people interested in doing the job (with all the perks and mind numbing boringness it brings).
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by throwaway98797 on Friday January 28, 2022 @08:54AM (#30114560)
some folks are time poor
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by techsupporter on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:15PM (#30110329)
> These are the elected positions I vote on.

What about Port of Seattle, Seattle Public Schools, King County Council, and King Conservation District?

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Friday January 28, 2022 @04:08AM (#30112349)
I don’t know the names but port of Seattle has two new representatives. They are the first minority-only representatives for the port. This is after a multi-year renovation of terminal 5 which is just now seeing new businesses from MSC.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by ghaff on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:22PM (#30110687)
That assumes you even live in a city. I have no idea who our town manager or whoever sits on the various boards of our 7K person town are. And, yeah, there's no hyperlocal blog. Maybe whatever filers through NextDoor and Facebook.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Friday January 28, 2022 @04:16AM (#30112409)
Then start one. My hyperlocal blog is sponsored by local businesses and promotes events like art walk where people walk around the local shops and purchase or view art created by local artists. If your community sucks it’s because of the people, not the government.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by Eextra953 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:10AM (#30127431)
Can you link the blog you are talking about? I'm interested in starting one for my area but I haven't found any great examples.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @05:09PM (#30131072)
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by datavirtue on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:41AM (#30111028)
All we have is Facebook and lots of batshit bitching.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by e4e78a06 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:11PM (#30109919)
That's because local politics is dedicated mostly to establishing inane bureaucratic blockers for policies that would benefit everyone except the existing homeowners in the city.

My city council recently spent until 1am debating zoning regulations for California's new ADU law instead of doing the sane thing and just letting people build ADUs.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by thr0wawayf00 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:10PM (#30110300)
It's sad how true this is. What makes this particularly challenging is that most people that have the resources to seriously run for office have assets like real estate, which has a major impact on the decisions that you're talking about.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by SyzygistSix on Friday January 28, 2022 @07:34AM (#30113798)
It takes less money than ever to run for office. What they do not have is the network and connections, nor are most of the public engaged. The segment of the public that is engaged and votes in the primaries for local elections tend to be business, real estate, and home owners.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by jozzy-james on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:23PM (#30110010)
our city council tries to do some stuff occasionally - but usually just ends up with the state legislature (90+ other counties) deciding they know best for our city.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by SOLAR_FIELDS on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:11AM (#30111207)
Austin, TX by chance? We have some pretty infamous examples of that here. One of the sillier ones was the ban on plastic grocery bags that was overturned by the state legislature.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by jozzy-james on Friday January 28, 2022 @09:55AM (#30115351)
Indianapolis - state legislature here really hates the idea of us having functional public transit or roads that aren't crumbling
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by HWR_14 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @11:23PM (#30110697)
What did you do to change the outcome? Talk to any of their offices? Donate to a competing candidate?
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by kelp on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:09PM (#30110294)
And also local and even to state politics are incredibly accessible.

It's quite easy to end up having a 1:1 conversation with a serious candidates for local office. Just 2 weeks ago I donated $500 to a candidate for CA state assembly and the next day I got a call from the candidate thanking me for the donation.

And it's pretty easy to volunteer for various organizations involved in local politics and get access to the current supervisor or state assembly member who is aligned with that organization.

And public comment is actually just like it's portrayed on Parks and Recreation.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by MattGaiser on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:18PM (#30109978)
I’m curious why this is downvoted as I agree. It is about garbage and zoning and fire trucks. Not exactly hot issues.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:50PM (#30110175)
Zoning is a huge issue. Houses are unaffordable to all but the upper middle class in my city because we can’t build fast or dense enough. Permits are an equally huge issue.

Garbage trucks provide a critical public service. Without them I would have to buy a different vehicle.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by thr0wawayf00 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:18PM (#30110358)
I agree that things like zoning and trash are important, I don't think anyone disputes that. However, they're not particularly accessible, engaging topics to discuss. That doesn't mean we shouldn't talk about them, but on the issue of a lack of engagement in the community and local government, citizens are asked to devote time to talking about zoning and trash as opposed to whatever else they choose to fill their time with, whether it's entertainment, side hustles, primary job, etc. On top of that, a growing number of people are being priced out of the market as you point out, which I suspect reduces engagement further. Why would the average person who can't even afford a starter home despite working full-time care about an issue like zoning? It feels like somewhat of a paradox.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by vel0city on Friday January 28, 2022 @10:54AM (#30116207)
> Why would the average person who can't even afford a starter home despite working full-time care about an issue like zoning?

Maybe because zoning and permitting are a large part of the reasons why they can't find an affordable house in the area?

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by thr0wawayf00 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:06PM (#30110275)
A big part of the problem IMO is that as wealth inequality increases, more and more people just don't have a desire to participate in the system because the system perpetually disadvantages them. As the share of the population with enough income to own assets like real estate decreases, the overall engagement in the community decreases, which makes sense.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by s1artibartfast on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:34AM (#30110992)
I think it is mostly cultural. But think it has more to do attention, entertainment, and community breakdown. Most communities are functionally nonexistant. People don't talk or engage with their neighbors.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by acomjean on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:34PM (#30110089)
The fact that local media has been pretty much disappeared doesn't help. I live in a small city and they few times I've tried to see what was going on (I missed a couple infrastructure public information meetings) I was thankful the local university has a student paper.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by mulmen on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:52PM (#30110185)
My hyperlocal blog is awesome. I’m sure not everyone has such a resource but most neighborhoods in Seattle do.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by zetazzed on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:54PM (#30110198)
https://www.berkeleyside.org/ live tweets all of our city meetings. Great summaries. Of course you can always just join the Zoom if you're particularly interested and the live tweets draw you in. Local journalism can play a key role here, so please consider supporting your local paper if they do a good job.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by asdff on Friday January 28, 2022 @01:17AM (#30111247)
The FBI has indicted like four sitting LA councilmembers now over the past 5 years or so. It's amazing how corrupt our public offices are, especially at the local level. It's not just elected officials either. Both Sanitation and the Water and Power department are pretty openly corrupted, many other city departments too. The LA Sheriffs department has multiple gangs within its ranks, and the sheriff himself has been ignoring subpoenas on the issue.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by wahern on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:15AM (#30111584)
Americans don't understand what corruption, let alone open corruption, really looks like. Circa 2008 I was pulled over by a cop in Mexico for "speeding", even though I was in tight traffic driving the exact same speed as everybody else around me, which was half the posted speed limit on account of the cop conspicuously parked in the unobstructed median. After pulling me over, he explained that I needed to pay him $500 on the spot if I didn't want to go to jail. This was a demand to pay "la mordida" for which Mexico was infamous, but by this time had (AFAIU) become much more rare in practice except in this particular region (Monterey), notwithstanding that the infamy among Americans remained undiminished. He even offered to take me to an ATM! It took me a good 10 minutes on the side of the road to talk him down to $20. (I would have preferred to go to jail just for the story, but this being modern Mexico we both knew he'd get in trouble if he tried to bring me into the station.)

A few years earlier something similar happened to me when crossing a rural border station near Organ Pipe National Park in Arizona--the officer demanded I pay an "import tax" for the stuff in my car. (I was moving from DC back to SF, taking the more scenic routes wherever I could. The American border guards were sitting in lawn chairs a mile up the road.) I think I talked him down to $10 after 5 minutes of haggling, at which point his supervisor walks over, smiling, and tells him to leave me alone just as the money was about to exchange hands. The supervisor had been peeling an orange while enjoying the spectacle. I guess he must've been bored that day.

Now that's open corruption. And where there's any amount of open corruption, it's a good guess that hidden corruption is extremely pervasive. But if there's not such open corruption (and it's exceedingly rare if not non-existent in the U.S.), we can't make any wild assumptions about hidden corruption.

If you look at the data, actual corruption is quite rare in the U.S., relatively speaking. As mentioned elsethread, in global terms we're near the tippy top. It didn't used to be this way. Even open corruption was once not uncommon in the U.S. At the turn of the 20th century, as civil service reforms gained momentum across the country--municipal, state, and Federal--some elected politicians openly defended kick-back schemes as being democratic. But they lost. This removed much of the opportunity and incentive except when privately and discretely dealing with elected officials or public-facing servants (e.g. cops, inspectors, etc). Later, private rights of action that permitted people to sue municipalities, and the creation of FBI criminal units to proactively investigate corruption schemes even among high-level elected officials, helped to dramatically reduce remaining corruption by creating very real costs at all levels of government. Your example is literally an example of why the U.S. doesn't see much corruption--it comes with very real risks. The FBI and DoJ are still beyond repute when it comes to corruption, even if state-based enforcement officials still too often look the other way. Every politician sweats even the prospect of drawing attention from the Feds.

Instead, Americans now call "corruption" whatever policies and decisions they disagree with if they don't understand the motivations behind them. It's pure cynicism and, ultimately, fatalistic. (And being illegal doesn't ipso facto make something corruption either; no more than violating copyright turns you into a willful criminal.)

That doesn't mean things couldn't be better. Or that real corruption of the type normally implied by the term doesn't actually exist--the cited conspiracy among some LA councilmen is classic corruption, albeit not open. But like with the term "racism", in order to sustain the same prevalence of accusations people have had to dramatically expand the scope of the term when forced to defend themselves. That doesn't mean what's now being referred to isn't unfair, wrong, or otherwise illegitimate, but we've long since descended into word games. Which is unproductive as within this expanded set of problems, there are no common ways to address and resolve them (e.g. simple, across-the-board reforms or related measures); by equivocating we're hurting our ability to identify causation and meaningfully mitigate and remediate actual, substantive issues.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by Sankozi on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:05AM (#30111933)
I disagree that corruption is rare in USA. You could say USA "solved" corruption problem by legalizing it. If you agree that legal action cannot be corrupt then you probably could say that corruption is rare in the USA, but I doubt many people would agree with that rule.

There are many ways you can legally bribe a politician in USA. Those bribes are passed in the open, there are even online trackers of those bribes. There are loopholes allowing corruption in other countries too, but nowhere else I encountered such acceptance to bribing politicians with corporate money.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by musingsole on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:25AM (#30112068)
It's not a bug; it's a feature.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by asdff on Friday January 28, 2022 @02:12PM (#30119021)
>Instead, Americans now call "corruption" whatever policies and decisions they disagree with if they don't understand the motivations behind them. It's pure cynicism and, ultimately, fatalistic. (And being illegal doesn't ipso facto make something corruption either; no more than violating copyright turns you into a willful criminal.)

The corruption I describe is pretty literal corruption at least in LA city hall. It's not policymaking, its literally quid pro quo. Jose Huizar was a councilmember when a developer handed him like 50 grand cash in a paper bag and purchased escorts for him in Vegas. Mark Ridley Thomas was also a councilmember when he got USC to give his son a degree and a position in return for a public grant. They were arrested by the FBI because they broke the law, not because Americans didn't understand the motivations of their policymaking. They did these things because there is a political environment present in LA county and city governments where this sort of behavior is commonplace, and local moneyed interests take advantage of that fact all too regularly.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by dannyw on Friday January 28, 2022 @05:16AM (#30112816)
ha ha ha ha ha.

My friend has about 4 speeding tickets (over 40mph over) that he gets away by talking to the right lawyer and paying for a "consultation".

Another acquaintance of mine bragged about his growth hack of selling his product to <public authorities> through donating to the campaigns of <elected officials>.

Didnt the head of Apple security also get caught giving large gifts to Cupertino police in exchange for concealed carry licenses?

You'd be extremely naive to think hidden corruption isn't pervasive in the USA.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by throwaway98797 on Friday January 28, 2022 @09:01AM (#30114657)
it’s all relative
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by lozenge on Friday January 28, 2022 @09:42AM (#30115161)
What you're talking about is called endemic corruption, which is the state's inability to enforce any policy (eg, speeding, or citizens ability to freely travel) due to the corruption of everybody who would need to action it.

On the other end of the scale you can imagine a paper democracy where all the top positions in government and state owned business are corruptly given to the leader's family, but everybody else follow the law, doesn't take bribes etc. It's still very corrupt, it's just a different kind of corruption.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by myko on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:54PM (#30109804)
Yep. ~10 years ago the case this book is about came to national attention: https://www.amazon.com/Blue-Mafia-Brutality-Consent-Decrees-...

It talks about local PD and politicians protecting individuals from consequences and sweeping their crimes under the rug.

Sadly it is more common than folks think, a similar thing happened at my HS (also in Ohio, a similar small town) in 2002.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by technothrasher on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:05PM (#30109878)
Back in the 1980s, my father was a selectman of our little town (Many New England towns have a board of selectmen instead of a mayor, for those who aren't familiar). The selectmen were also honorary members of the police, and the employment application for police officers asked if you would ever arrest a member of a town selectman's family. If you answered, "Yes", you didn't get the job.

For this and other reasons, after my dad's single term as selectman, he vowed never to be involved in politics again.

Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by nrp on Friday January 28, 2022 @12:23AM (#30110951)
For folks in San Francisco (I assume a disproportionately large chunk of HN readership), Mission Local has been great at shining light on local corruption: https://missionlocal.org/category/local-government/
[dead]
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by MattGaiser on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:18PM (#30109973)
Not anywhere near the same level of blatantness as there is far less oversight.
Re:I won the local election, but my township ignored the res... by the_only_law on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:26PM (#30110026)
Would you please point me to where GP said that?