The expected lifetime value of any article in Nature Neuroscience for the authors is well above $11,390, as that is probably 1% of the typical grant that will produce the article, and getting published in this venue makes it much easier to continue to get grants funded, to get top PhD students and postdocs, and to get promoted.
To be clear, though, the authors are not paying for this out of pocket. The funding agencies (i.e. the national government that supports the authors' research) is paying for it. Because many funding agencies now require authors to publish open-acess, Nature can more or less ask whatever price they want.
This. Authors are the customers of the journals; the service they are buying is a push towards tenure and more funding. This has been true for a long time; open access only makes it more explicit.
When readers are the ones paying, you can argue that they are paying the journal so that it makes sure that they are reading serious, properly reviewed articles.
When authors are the ones paying, how do incentives align?
I think journals are now in a situation similar to the one of rating agencies and accounting firms. I don't think it will work out very well.
Students aren’t paying for college, the government is.
The researchers aren’t paying Nature, the government is.
11000 is the annual pay of a Phd student in southern europe, it's incredibly high amount. the $5000 that elsevier asks is already enough. prestigious EU grants run for > $1m. National grants may be $100000.
As an EU citizen i hate the fact that even more EU money is siphoned to enrich the NPG. We ve had enough and this must stop. I hope both them and elsevier get outright banned, because clearly open access is another revenue stream for them
A Ph.D. candidate (don't call them students please, they're researchers more than students) in southern Europe does _not_ get 11,000 USD / month. Something between 2,000 and 4,500 AFAICT.
Minimum wage in greece is 730 usd. Many if not most phds earn less than $1000, if they are lucky to have stable funding. Hence brain drain
https://www.europeanpolarboard.org/fileadmin/user_upload/cao...
but more specifically, see page 3 here:
https://www.maastrichtuniversity.nl/sites/default/files/en_2...
PhD candidates are on the type-10 salary scale, and the current scale by years of experience is here:
https://www.staff.universiteitleiden.nl/binaries/content/ass...
Naturally you pay a bit of income tax and health insurance, but on the other than you may be eligible to reduced-rent accommodation, and there's an extra month's pay once a year, and retirement benefits allowance, and some remuneration for Internet access costs etc. etc.
Had I required immediate open access then it would have cost!
But with both full versions in bioRxiv and Pubmed Central, I felt access was essentially complete.
My experience was that the editor and reviewers were more focused on the impact of the work rather than the technical quality. It was all about whether the work was Nature-level status; there were no changes to any of the analysis or the body of the paper, just the intro and conclusions. It felt slimy so I decided to only publish in non-profit society journals from then on.
I attended an ACM webinar some years ago on the topic of open access, and while the OA fees weren’t as high as this one, I asked how they could defend these fees… the answers weren’t entirely satisfactory to me — in general they claimed obviously admin costs, but also that such funds were used to support other well-meaning things ACM deals with such as scholarships/workshops etc for young and female researchers among other things… Personally, while these are good things for ACM to support, I dislike the somewhat arbitrary connection to OA publishing… PS: I’m not sure if this is still their policy.
ACM has an authorizer service that allows you as an author, to publish special links on your personal website, that will offer all visitors of your personal web-site free downloads of your papers.
Those who are interested in your paper don't need an account, they just need to click on the special links published on your website and the paper will be free to download in PDF.
It's extremely unfortunate that the ACM has been degraded into being a "publisher" rather than a learned society, and I agree that as long as they think of themselves that way, they will continue to obstruct progress and reproduce patterns of social and economic inequality in the way they are currently doing.
(1) Editors will not send you garbage, but they will try at first
(2) You, in turn, torture yourself to find a path for the worst papers in your field (see “garbage” above) to make it through to publication—as in you do sooner of the work for the authors—anonymously of course, and you package it nicely in your review letter
(3) Editors still think: wow, that’s incredible—still going to reject this paper but this referee has skills
(4) Letter writing time you say? Good news, there’s a stack of editors that think you walk on water
(5) Tenure earned
(6) QED?
> ... we pay 10000 in case of a mistake ...
Now please apply the same standard to software.
> reasonable effort
for many hours/days/weeks. Otherwise known as "work". Why is it absurd to pay for work?
Is ground-breaking neuroscience research only performed at tier 1 universities?
Absolutely not. I'm just sharing my perspective. People don't seem to realize the sheer amount of money that circulates in these institutions. A decent confocal microscope costs $500k, and core facilities aren't cheap either.
We get $937,500. That's not far off, and center grants, large cooperative agreements, etc. probably give the distribution a decently long tail.
Yes
> Their reviewers?
No, not as far as I’m aware.
> The authors?
No, not as far as I’m aware.
> Do they pay their typesetters?
Yes
> Do they offer their print journal for free?
No, but in most of the world it is pretty cheap.
> Do they have expensive contracts for cloud hosting?
Yes. Well, yes and no. They mostly have a lot of expensive on-premise servers. At least as of 3.5 years ago.
I think partially it’s that they can get away with it, but there’s certainly a lot of work going into this on the Nature side as well (mostly for print publishing). And these articles are never going away. They stay online forever.
The thing with these journals is that they have name recognition that makes people want their research to be published in them. Getting published is good for their career. Combine that with a desire to support open access, and you have a product that you can charge for.
It's doubly good, because it's not like authors are using their own personal funds to pay this fee. It just comes out of their grant. Whenever someone buys something with someone else's money, you know you're going to be ripped off. See also, Wifi at businessey hotels.
Anyway, if the taxpayers are paying for this, we should ask authors to just host the papers on their websites. If you need the $5 for a VPS or whatever, I'll give you the $5 personally.
2. In a market of commodities, prices are determined by multiple aspects of the surrounding social power relations.
3. In a market, there tends to be a concentration of capital leading to an oligopoly or monopoly; this is more likely than a shrinking of prices to the cost of production.
Honestly, I wish more journals mandated open for a fee—I want my work open, but the choice makes it easy for universities to decline to pay—if mandatory, they would gladly pay 3x to have their researchers publish in top outlets (I’m in administration for a large R1)
BTW, "this is nuts" isn't a claim you can make if you don't know the answer to questions you posted.
From their website: "an article is submitted and is assessed by our editors. If suitable it will be put through Peer Review". That peer review process could quickly exceed the $11.4k for example.
[edited] added the BTW paragraphs after responses were received to the question in my first paragraph.
1) Result in a PDF attachment with a short note.
2) Probably be the highlight of my day.
However, that's not a reasonable way to distribute science. Most research requires you to skim through many different articles, so introducing a latency of a few hours/days each time you want to open an article makes the process unreasonable.
See also: Sci-Hub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sci-Hub
https://holly.witteman.ca/index.php/2017/12/11/getting-acces...
How much did Nature Neuroscience pay to produce these articles? Do they pay their editors? Their reviewers? The authors?
Do they pay their typesetters?
Do they offer their print journal for free?
Do they have expensive contracts for cloud hosting?
Is the expected lifetime value of any article, let alone every article, anywhere close to $11,390?
Most journals already allow authors to distribute copies by request. This is nuts.