News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by cossatot on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @11:31PM (#30081741)
Nature pays their editors, unlike most society journals. But they are a for-profit business, and are clearly just looking for more profit.

The expected lifetime value of any article in Nature Neuroscience for the authors is well above $11,390, as that is probably 1% of the typical grant that will produce the article, and getting published in this venue makes it much easier to continue to get grants funded, to get top PhD students and postdocs, and to get promoted.

To be clear, though, the authors are not paying for this out of pocket. The funding agencies (i.e. the national government that supports the authors' research) is paying for it. Because many funding agencies now require authors to publish open-acess, Nature can more or less ask whatever price they want.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by lultimouomo on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:32AM (#30083142)
> The expected lifetime value of any article in Nature Neuroscience for the authors is well above $11,390

This. Authors are the customers of the journals; the service they are buying is a push towards tenure and more funding. This has been true for a long time; open access only makes it more explicit.

When readers are the ones paying, you can argue that they are paying the journal so that it makes sure that they are reading serious, properly reviewed articles.

When authors are the ones paying, how do incentives align?

I think journals are now in a situation similar to the one of rating agencies and accounting firms. I don't think it will work out very well.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by xuhu on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:58AM (#30083624)
> I think journals are now in a situation similar to the one of app stores [only without the costs, and with all the benefits].
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by cheonic8492 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:50AM (#30083259)
> I think journals are now in a situation similar to the one of rating agencies and accounting firms. I don't think it will work out very well.

Students aren’t paying for college, the government is.

The researchers aren’t paying Nature, the government is.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by dash2 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:45AM (#30083923)
This is absolutely true in many cases. If I had myself to pay £2000 for journal submission, no way. But it comes out of research funds. And that in turn comes from whoever funds the University – government, or student fees.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by matthewdgreen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:51AM (#30084411)
Universities often limit what you can spend on OA, and even if there isn’t a hard limit, that money comes at the expense of other research items like student salaries and equipment. Funding agencies don’t write a blank check for publication costs.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by ta988 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @09:34AM (#30085856)
Not sure why you are downvoted, most colleges, at least in US, have more money coming from research, industrial partners and clinics than tuition.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by cblconfederate on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:19AM (#30083077)
To be clear: they pay their own editors, the ones who do the coordination, not the authors (who actually edit the paper) or the reviewers.

11000 is the annual pay of a Phd student in southern europe, it's incredibly high amount. the $5000 that elsevier asks is already enough. prestigious EU grants run for > $1m. National grants may be $100000.

As an EU citizen i hate the fact that even more EU money is siphoned to enrich the NPG. We ve had enough and this must stop. I hope both them and elsevier get outright banned, because clearly open access is another revenue stream for them

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by einpoklum on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:41AM (#30083203)
> 11000 is the paycheck of a Phd student in southern europe,

A Ph.D. candidate (don't call them students please, they're researchers more than students) in southern Europe does _not_ get 11,000 USD / month. Something between 2,000 and 4,500 AFAICT.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by jkhdigital on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @07:13AM (#30084593)
As an aside, apparently there is a technical difference between “candidate” and “student”. A PhD candidate is one who has passed the qualifying exam, which occurs 2-3 years into the process. This usually coincides with the point at which all required coursework is complete, so “student” is probably a suitable label during that initial period.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by ta988 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @09:38AM (#30085913)
This is not how it works in most parts of Europe.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by dariosalvi78 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:47AM (#30083240)
he meant per year...
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by einpoklum on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @08:48AM (#30085290)
What, less than 1000 USD per month? But that's a joke. In the Netherlands it's something like... 2800 EUR or 3000 EUR per month, so let's say 3000 - 3300 USD / month. I know the Netherlands PhD candidates have it relatively well (in relative, not absolute, terms), but I find it hard to believe people are expected to live off of 900 EUR / month. Is it really that bad these days?
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by dariosalvi78 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:43AM (#30101127)
I have been a PhD student in Spain for quite some time and my salary started with less than 1000€/month and ended at around 1500€. Of course cost of living is much lower too.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by cblconfederate on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:45PM (#30090658)
Is that without social contribution?

Minimum wage in greece is 730 usd. Many if not most phds earn less than $1000, if they are lucky to have stable funding. Hence brain drain

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by einpoklum on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:27AM (#30099686)
What I quoted is the gross salary according to the national collective employment agreement. A more recent version than the one I worked under is here:

https://www.europeanpolarboard.org/fileadmin/user_upload/cao...

but more specifically, see page 3 here:

https://www.maastrichtuniversity.nl/sites/default/files/en_2...

PhD candidates are on the type-10 salary scale, and the current scale by years of experience is here:

https://www.staff.universiteitleiden.nl/binaries/content/ass...

Naturally you pay a bit of income tax and health insurance, but on the other than you may be eligible to reduced-rent accommodation, and there's an extra month's pay once a year, and retirement benefits allowance, and some remuneration for Internet access costs etc. etc.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by tomrod on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:25PM (#30090431)
Not a joke. Stipends for US PhD students tend to be low, unless you're in a STEM or business school.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kenich on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:12AM (#30083381)
Sounds about right as an annual figure. My annual stipend in London was ~£16,000 and the cost of living there is commensurately higher than in southern Europe.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by amcoastal on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:35AM (#30084290)
He means per year. Your estimates are generous. For my graduate studies I was paid 8000 a year.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by robwwilliams on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:03AM (#30081945)
Note: Are we sure this is a mandatory charge or just the charge if the authors must publish an immediate open access article. I just published in Nature Metabolism and there was no charge at all. The quality of the review and editing was EXTRAORDINARY! I wanted to thank all of the reviewers for doing a superb job.

Had I required immediate open access then it would have cost!

But with both full versions in bioRxiv and Pubmed Central, I felt access was essentially complete.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by cossatot on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @11:53AM (#30087971)
This is just for open access, not for publication. I haven't published with Nature since it was owned by Macmillan (rather than Springer Nature, the current owner) and I think the publication fees were ~$1500.

My experience was that the editor and reviewers were more focused on the impact of the work rather than the technical quality. It was all about whether the work was Nature-level status; there were no changes to any of the analysis or the body of the paper, just the intro and conclusions. It felt slimy so I decided to only publish in non-profit society journals from then on.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kragen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:14AM (#30082021)
Were the reviewers paid?
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by meling on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:47AM (#30082550)
As an academic (unrelated to this journal and field), I’ve more or less stopped accepting to review papers because of the low reward… that is, there are virtually no incentives to me as a professor to do this and it takes a lot of time to do proper reviews. I have better things to do with my time.

I attended an ACM webinar some years ago on the topic of open access, and while the OA fees weren’t as high as this one, I asked how they could defend these fees… the answers weren’t entirely satisfactory to me — in general they claimed obviously admin costs, but also that such funds were used to support other well-meaning things ACM deals with such as scholarships/workshops etc for young and female researchers among other things… Personally, while these are good things for ACM to support, I dislike the somewhat arbitrary connection to OA publishing… PS: I’m not sure if this is still their policy.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kragen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:26AM (#30082778)
I think the ACM should support young and female researchers by making all their papers open access, publicly endorsing Sci-hub, and committing to send Sci-hub some money every month. That would have a much bigger impact than scholarships and workshops.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by qpiox on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @05:29PM (#30093017)
ACM members can offer their papers open-access legally and for free, helped by the ACM.

ACM has an authorizer service that allows you as an author, to publish special links on your personal website, that will offer all visitors of your personal web-site free downloads of your papers.

Those who are interested in your paper don't need an account, they just need to click on the special links published on your website and the paper will be free to download in PDF.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kragen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:01PM (#30093349)
A lot of the relevant authors are already dead, and many more of them will be in the next ten years, so this is not good enough. It may reduce ACM's conflict with authors but it doesn't particularly help a researcher who's trying to track down a result someone published in CACM 40 years ago.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by mnd999 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @03:02AM (#30082982)
I mean sure, making papers by underrepresented groups open access to increase their reach is actually a nice idea. Not sure what this has to do with sci-hub though, publishers are not going to fund sci-hub in the same way that the RIAA is not going to fund the pirate bay.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kragen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:02AM (#30083317)
I don't mean they should make papers by underrepresented groups open access. I mean they should make the papers researchers need to read open access so that access to those papers isn't conditional on getting into a rich university, thus reducing the barriers to underrepresented groups and everyone else. By "their papers" I meant "the ACM's papers", not "the papers of young and female researchers".

It's extremely unfortunate that the ACM has been degraded into being a "publisher" rather than a learned society, and I agree that as long as they think of themselves that way, they will continue to obstruct progress and reproduce patterns of social and economic inequality in the way they are currently doing.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by lstodd on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:56PM (#30093952)
Cannot agree more.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by CrazyCatDog on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:52AM (#30084419)
Whoa! Best advice I ever received: accept everything. Here’s why:

(1) Editors will not send you garbage, but they will try at first

(2) You, in turn, torture yourself to find a path for the worst papers in your field (see “garbage” above) to make it through to publication—as in you do sooner of the work for the authors—anonymously of course, and you package it nicely in your review letter

(3) Editors still think: wow, that’s incredible—still going to reject this paper but this referee has skills

(4) Letter writing time you say? Good news, there’s a stack of editors that think you walk on water

(5) Tenure earned

(6) QED?

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by rvnx on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:58AM (#30082289)
To me it sounds absurd to have to pay reviewers, when you have nothing guaranteed in return. If the publication would give insurance "we pay back 10'000 USD to the buyer of the paper in case we did a mistake because that's our guarantee of quality", then yes, but here, nothing guarantees you the quality / result, only that they tried to do reasonable efforts to somehow review and exfiltrate some of the most obviouses scams.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by diffeomorphism on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @02:30AM (#30082803)
Reviewers are selected not picked out of a hat....

> ... we pay 10000 in case of a mistake ...

Now please apply the same standard to software.

> reasonable effort

for many hours/days/weeks. Otherwise known as "work". Why is it absurd to pay for work?

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kragen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:03AM (#30082314)
I'm just thinking that if Nature didn't pay the reviewers (and I agree it is very unlikely that they did) then the quality of the reviewing probably is not a result of money flowing into Nature, whether from the authors or from the readers.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by ta988 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @09:35AM (#30085878)
Never. I've reviewed for over 30 journals from low to high quality and you don't get a dime. And sometimes get the editor hinting you what they want you to say.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kragen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @09:56AM (#30086185)
I'm thinking that if Nature didn't pay the reviewers then the quality of the reviewing probably is not a result of money flowing into Nature, whether from the authors or from the readers?
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by ta988 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @10:00AM (#30086267)
You have some incentives to review. In the US they are a factor to get visas and green cards. They are used for getting tenure in some places. It is also a way to get in the "club" because now the editor that revuews grants nows your name...
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by kragen on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @06:02PM (#30093365)
I didn't mean to say that no incentives exist. I meant to say that those incentives wouldn't get stronger if authors or readers sent more money to Nature.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by namlem on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:07AM (#30081980)
Is the typical grant for a Nature Neuroscience study really over $1.1 million?
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by oceliker on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:31AM (#30082135)
Graduate student in a neuroscience lab at a tier 1 institution in the US here. $1.1 million for a grant is very normal. I cost my advisor over $100k per year in tuition and stipend, not including the costs of any equipment and reagents that I use.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by tomrod on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:01PM (#30089121)
Tier 1 - dedicated channel for funding, right?

Is ground-breaking neuroscience research only performed at tier 1 universities?

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by oceliker on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @01:50PM (#30089960)
> Is ground-breaking neuroscience research only performed at tier 1 universities?

Absolutely not. I'm just sharing my perspective. People don't seem to realize the sheer amount of money that circulates in these institutions. A decent confocal microscope costs $500k, and core facilities aren't cheap either.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by Fomite on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @12:27AM (#30082113)
If we assume that most studies that get into Nature Neuroscience are NIH R01s, which have a cap before you need to start fleshing out the budget in exacting detail of $125,000 in direct costs per year, and we assume a 50% overhead rate...

We get $937,500. That's not far off, and center grants, large cooperative agreements, etc. probably give the distribution a decently long tail.

Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by bubblethink on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:39AM (#30083526)
There's a lot of funny maths with grants. It's a lot like taking money from one pocket and putting it in another. So a $1M grant is actually a fraction of that when it comes to actual money that a prof gets to use.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by ta988 on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @09:30AM (#30085808)
This is not true most grants do not allow for OA money or you have to take it from other lines (salaries, equipment...) and deal with that internally. But in the end it is taken from your research fund, the university is also taking a portion of the grants as indirect costs and a part of those pay for the yearly increasing secret library contracts (they are confidential you can't even get them with a FOIA). So in the end paying OA to large publishers, you are paying them twice.
Re:Nature Neuroscience offers open access publishing for $11... by cossatot on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @11:46AM (#30087862)
I've never had anyone at NSF question OA fees in grant proposals. This might vary program by program.