News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by staticassertion on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:01PM (#30029177)
Not really. I remember it being a pretty huge deal and everyone talking about how it could have been so much worse.

What more did you want?

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by mrguyorama on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:09PM (#30029290)
Pretty sure they were implying we never got the how they were hacked.

It seemed very unlikely to be credential stuffing or other common things. It seemed more like a rogue inside person or back office hack.

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by aharris6 on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:22PM (#30029456)
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by jjulius on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:23PM (#30029481)
>Pretty sure they were implying we never got the how they were hacked.

>The Twitter incident began when the hackers connected last year in an online forum focused on buying and selling rare user names, some of the individuals involved told The New York Times at that time. They then broke into Twitter’s systems by tricking employees into providing login information, according to legal filings. The hackers used an administrative tool to take over accounts belonging to political figures and celebrities, including former President Barack Obama, Kanye West and Elon Musk, using the accounts to conduct a Bitcoin scam, the filings said.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/21/technology/twitter-tiktok...

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by staticassertion on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:22PM (#30029466)
I know how it happened but I don't remember if it's public knowledge or not. I'm pretty sure at least some details made it out.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by slg on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:10PM (#30029297)
I guess I phrased that poorly. Yes, there was some discussion about how it could have been worse. However I wanted that discussion to be more than us shrugging our shoulders and saying "we dodged a bullet". There was no real discussion either about standards in the tech industry or political discussions regarding legislative changes in order prevent that worse version from happening in the future. We didn't seem to learn anything from it.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by basisword on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:04PM (#30029978)
How is this a tech issue? The issue is powerful politicians using private social media companies as a means of communicating with the public. Politicians and other can instantly prevent the risk by only communicating through official means.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by slg on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:40PM (#30030350)
Government communication has no value if it doesn't reach it audience. They need to be where the people are.

This also isn't a problem limited to governments and politicians. It calls into question the authenticity of every account on Twitter and that includes other important accounts which can cause damage if compromised such as journalists and news organizations.

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by mulmen on Friday January 21, 2022 @07:11PM (#30031670)
Everything on Twitter should be questioned. It's a private company. They only have their reputation. It is not and should not be suitable for important communication. Imagine if all official communication came through CNN, or the NYT. It's completely nonsensical.

Anyone with access to Twitter has access to whitehouse.gov. Twitter isn't delivering value here, they are a huge societal risk.

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by riffic on Friday January 21, 2022 @07:01PM (#30031604)
> They need to be where the people are

And as a corollary, the people will go to whatever channels exist.

This has been something done many times as mediums change. Newspapers to Radio. Newsreels to Television.

Then to the internet, we started with everyone telling you their AOL keyword. Then the web, and then social media.

If authenticity is the concern, these players (journalists/politicians) should adopt W3C recommendations and stand up social media services from their own web presence.

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by BeFlatXIII on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:10PM (#30030614)
Good. Trust nothing you see. It's all kayfabe.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by azinman2 on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:57PM (#30029886)
What legislative changes could have prevented this or something worse in the future? Every security breach is different and often nuanced.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by slg on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:40PM (#30030358)
I wanted a discussion about it. I'm just a random developer who doesn't have the perfect answer. Yet some obvious things that might help would be to increase penalties for breaches and potentially require more stringent security auditing for companies of a certain size.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by azinman2 on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:47PM (#30030432)
I think the reality is security is really hard, and you only need 1 weakness for someone to drive a truck through. The biggest weakness time and time again is humans, and that's exactly what was attacked here with Twitter via social engineering. You can put all the penalties you want, but ultimately business needs and reality will make it so certain humans have powers that are high-up, which then creates unavoidable weaknesses. Just look at what happened with Ubiquiti and their head of cloud basically blackmailing the company in secret... they were attacked from within. How could that have been prevented assuming the person passes background checks and has years of relevant experience?

Many sectors (finance, health care, etc) have all kinds of auditing requirements. I've helped answer some of these audits. It's largely just a bunch of checkboxes for obvious stuff, and in general, isn't how anyone would attack a company that's moderately competent. I've seen and fixed security vulnerabilities in startups that no one else recognized where there, despite passing all these 3rd party audits. I don't know what more could have been done without extremely knowledgeable people look at every aspect of your business in absolute depth that in part only comes from actually working/building it in the first place. Such experts are rare finds, yet the number of companies with computers attached is far greater.

I'm not against legislation, and I think good legislation would look like taking companies such as Equifax out of business. We don't need total incompetence continuing to be central to society's function. But we also need to be realistic about what can be achieved.

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by slg on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:06PM (#30030577)
You can never eliminate the possibility of a security incident, but there are easy steps that can be made to reduce the risk. Clearly Twitter didn't do enough of them. For example, they had too many people with too wide permissions which increased their surface area for a social engineering attack. They didn't have an enhanced security policy for highly targeted users such as requiring approval from multiple people which would reduce the success rate of social engineering attacks. They also didn't have the proper monitoring of these high permissioned accounts to quickly identify the source of the breach and therefore they couldn't easily stop it after it begun. These might just sound like "checkboxes for obvious stuff", but they would have helped if Twitter checked those boxes.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by azinman2 on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:19PM (#30030690)
What audit has checkboxes for 'do you require approval from multiple people for basic profile manipulation of highly targeted users?' I've never seen one on any security compliance that I was apart of, and the reason being is that this is so specific to Twitter and very few other companies. Every product will end up being like this -- their own domain and product offering will create their own checkboxes that simply don't apply to the vast majority of other companies.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by slg on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:38PM (#30030863)
Regulation that requires signoff from multiple individuals is nothing new. The only piece that is unique is the "highly targeted users" callout, but that can be generalized too. For example, there could be heightened requirements for social media accounts based off their reach. A million followers, subscribers, fans, patrons, or whatever term you use and that account now requires heightened security.

But either way, you are getting too bogged down in the specifics of my hypotheticals. Like I said originally I don't have the answer on the perfect solution, but the fact that we didn't use this incident as motivation to have a discussion about potential solutions is disappointing. Can you at least agree with that?

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by azinman2 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:46PM (#30040671)
My issue is with you saying:

> legislative changes in order prevent that worse version from happening in the future.

I’m not convinced legislation achieve your goal having already seen HIPAA in action in law, the systems behind the scene, and the ways in which compliance works. Is it better than nothing? Sure! Does it actually create truly secure systems? I don’t think so.

If liabilities are severe where companies could go under or people go to jail, then I’m still not sure that would be enough to secure systems because you’re always a 0-day away from breach. But if the result is twitter going under or their CSO jailed, all I think that happens is you remove global competitiveness.

I agree with you more should be done. But perhaps in different ways. For example, requiring everyone to take basic security classes before you can be a software engineer might help. Creating societal incentives where bug bounties are required, white hats cannot go to jail or be sued, DARPA spends big on defensive security strategies, and stating the US will take cyber attacks the same as physical attacks are ways that I think would produce better outcomes (but would risk war).

Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by staticassertion on Friday January 21, 2022 @07:38PM (#30031844)
FWIW, jumping in here, I agree with you that we should be having this conversation. It's just that the conversation is going to be an inherently slow one since it's talking about very sweeping, broad changes. So it happens in little pieces and little changes over time.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by staticassertion on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:39PM (#30029681)
That's true of almost every breach though.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by slg on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:41PM (#30030368)
Should we stop calling out a bad thing just because it isn't the first bad thing of its kind to happen?
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by staticassertion on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:38PM (#30030865)
I guess if your statement is intended to be broad, sure. It seemed targeted to this breach, which yeah I think it's sort of wrong to call out one breach for being exactly like all other breaches.
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by ct0 on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:09PM (#30029280)
How would we even know if someone has pulled this off again with an entirely different motive and hasn't been discovered as a hack?
Re:Twitter shakes up its security team by staticassertion on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:23PM (#30029474)
If Twitter knows about it they're legally obligated to report it.