This also isn't a problem limited to governments and politicians. It calls into question the authenticity of every account on Twitter and that includes other important accounts which can cause damage if compromised such as journalists and news organizations.
Anyone with access to Twitter has access to whitehouse.gov. Twitter isn't delivering value here, they are a huge societal risk.
And as a corollary, the people will go to whatever channels exist.
This has been something done many times as mediums change. Newspapers to Radio. Newsreels to Television.
Then to the internet, we started with everyone telling you their AOL keyword. Then the web, and then social media.
If authenticity is the concern, these players (journalists/politicians) should adopt W3C recommendations and stand up social media services from their own web presence.
Many sectors (finance, health care, etc) have all kinds of auditing requirements. I've helped answer some of these audits. It's largely just a bunch of checkboxes for obvious stuff, and in general, isn't how anyone would attack a company that's moderately competent. I've seen and fixed security vulnerabilities in startups that no one else recognized where there, despite passing all these 3rd party audits. I don't know what more could have been done without extremely knowledgeable people look at every aspect of your business in absolute depth that in part only comes from actually working/building it in the first place. Such experts are rare finds, yet the number of companies with computers attached is far greater.
I'm not against legislation, and I think good legislation would look like taking companies such as Equifax out of business. We don't need total incompetence continuing to be central to society's function. But we also need to be realistic about what can be achieved.
But either way, you are getting too bogged down in the specifics of my hypotheticals. Like I said originally I don't have the answer on the perfect solution, but the fact that we didn't use this incident as motivation to have a discussion about potential solutions is disappointing. Can you at least agree with that?
> legislative changes in order prevent that worse version from happening in the future.
I’m not convinced legislation achieve your goal having already seen HIPAA in action in law, the systems behind the scene, and the ways in which compliance works. Is it better than nothing? Sure! Does it actually create truly secure systems? I don’t think so.
If liabilities are severe where companies could go under or people go to jail, then I’m still not sure that would be enough to secure systems because you’re always a 0-day away from breach. But if the result is twitter going under or their CSO jailed, all I think that happens is you remove global competitiveness.
I agree with you more should be done. But perhaps in different ways. For example, requiring everyone to take basic security classes before you can be a software engineer might help. Creating societal incentives where bug bounties are required, white hats cannot go to jail or be sued, DARPA spends big on defensive security strategies, and stating the US will take cyber attacks the same as physical attacks are ways that I think would produce better outcomes (but would risk war).