News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by Bayart on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:22PM (#30016849)
Aranese is fairly normal Gascon speech, I don't think it qualifies as its own subdialect [1]. This being said, there's something to be said about Gascon as a whole potentially being its own language, as is considered Catalan. Among Occitan dialects, it's highly eccentric.

As for Aranese speakers, to me (I have some amount of Limousin and Provençal) native ones [2] are understandable to the same extent as other Gascon speakers, but new speakers who bring Castellan phonological features are incomprehensible. If it manages to survives in this environment, it could truly be a new language in the making.

[1]: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Isoglosas_gasc%C3%B3...

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdYpvY6Efos

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by frogulis on Thursday January 20, 2022 @09:14PM (#30018369)
There's a pretty apt phrase that applies here: a language is a dialect with an army and a navy

Compare with the Serbian/Croatian "languages" that are far more mutually intelligible than varieties of the Chinese "language".

I've heard that Arabic also has far more variance than is between Serbian and Croatian. Even though we often refer to it as a single language, it's actually a very diverse selection of varieties that are not all mutually intelligible.

In short, the distinction is pretty arbitrary.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by danjac on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:41AM (#30021748)
It's the same with Scots (as opposed to Scottish Gaelic). Is it a dialect or a separate (although closely related) language to English? If Scotland becomes independent, Scots would very likely gain full language status for as much political as linguistic reasons.

Then we have "Italian" and "German". If these countries had not undergone unification in the 19th century would Duolingo be offering courses in Venetian and Bavarian?

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by Bayart on Friday January 21, 2022 @07:59AM (#30022826)
>Is it a dialect or a separate (although closely related) language to English?

As I see it, Scots and Standard English are two dialects of the same language.

>If these countries had not undergone unification in the 19th century would Duolingo be offering courses in Venetian and Bavarian?

Tuscan and High German became the standard with the Renaissance and the printing press, centuries before nationalism.

Different areas of Italy in particular had different literary vernaculars over time. One's that's particularly amusing to me is Franco-Venetian [1].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franco-Italian

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by danjac on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:21AM (#30023827)
> As I see it, Scots and Standard English are two dialects of the same language.

It doesn't matter how you personally see it. Linguists and other scholars are divided on the issue. It's recognized as a regional language by UNESCO and the Council of Europe as well as the UK and Scottish governments. There's also a spectrum from "Standard English spoken with a Scottish accent with some odd words thrown in" and broad Scots.

Danish and Norwegian (or at least Bokmål) are perhaps as close as Scots and English (I only have a passing familiarity with these so native speakers can confirm), but are considered distinct languages on as much political as linguistic grounds, which is my point - the distinction is as much political and historic as linguistic (i.e. there used to be a language only a few decades ago called "Serbo-Croatian").

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by ivanbakel on Friday January 21, 2022 @10:04AM (#30024428)
>Tuscan and High German became the standard with the Renaissance and the printing press, centuries before nationalism.

It depends on what you mean by "standard". Tuscan was certainly the literary dialect, but most areas of modern Italy did not speak standardised Italian from the Renaissance period onward, except at the level of government.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by pedro1976 on Friday January 21, 2022 @09:02AM (#30023564)
"High German" is basically the dialect spoken in the Hanover area.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by marsa on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:23AM (#30019878)
when you compare serbian and croatian and find them fairly similar it's worth keeping in mind that only holds true for the standard versions of those languages.

thing is these standard versions were developed and agreed upon more or less at a time -- mid 19th century and the whole nationalist movements thing in europe -- when there was a unitarian tendency among south slavic nations. so the standard versions are (1) essentially artificial, and (2) politically motivated to an extent.

once you get on the ground level of spoken language you find far more variance within each of the two -- the regional and even local dialects are very different from each other, to the point of seemingly being whole different languages were it not for the developed standard versions that tie them together.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by twelvechairs on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:11AM (#30020615)
Yes but historic dialect boundaries didnt follow modern national boundaries at all - see link below

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shtokavian#/media/File%3ASht...

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by hutzlibu on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:55AM (#30021385)
Which sounds like it contributed to the various wars on the Balkans.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by ggrrhh_ta on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:27AM (#30021635)
I don't know if you are referring to other languages also spoken in Croatia which are not Croatian (Istriot). They might not be the same language, but I would bet that if two speakers, one of Croatian (of the three main dialects), and one of Serbian, want to communicate, they will find very little difficulty (like between British English and American English speakers) in doing so.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by marsa on Friday January 21, 2022 @06:41AM (#30022181)
that's indeed very likely if they're using standard versions of their respective languages.

but if someone from let's say east istria and south serbia communicated in the traditional local dialects spoken there there'd be a significant degree of confusion and misunderstanding between them -- that's my bet at least.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by ggrrhh_ta on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:19AM (#30023075)
Yes, a Mancunian and a New Zealander might have similar if not more trouble.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by nradov on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:32AM (#30019942)
The Croatian government is now trying to encourage more linguistic differentiation from Serbian by introducing neologisms that were never used in standard Serbo-Croatian.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by marsa on Friday January 21, 2022 @02:34AM (#30020338)
with little or no practical success. but yes, standard language development is essentially an ongoing political process imo. nation states trying to prove they're unique basically.

i suspect this is the case all around the world to a greater or lesser extent.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by not2b on Thursday January 20, 2022 @10:18PM (#30018739)
They used to say "Serbo-Croatian" before the war.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by UncleSlacky on Friday January 21, 2022 @06:17AM (#30022005)
Only in Serbia, in Croatia it was "Croato-Serbian".
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by Bayart on Friday January 21, 2022 @07:55AM (#30022771)
>In short, the distinction is pretty arbitrary.

Linguistically, the distinction is much more objective (also it's not always clear cut, because there are asymmetries between speeches in terms of how understandable they are to each other) : two kinds of speech that are not inter-comprehensible are different languages. Dialects and sub-dialects are defined by isoglosses, see the map I link in my original post.

Arabic is, much like Chinese, both a linguistic group and a language (Modern Standard Arabic).

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by nekcihc on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:26PM (#30016908)
Imagine my first time discovering when I found out that Limousin(car) (apparently)is named after a region and that there is language named Limousin.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by Bayart on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:37PM (#30017017)
It's also the name of a cattle breed that's native to the region [1] and famed for its meat, as well as the name by which the very language discusses in this thread used to go by during the Middle Ages (as the Limousin dialect formed the basis for the normalized form of Occitan, that was used by the Troubadour movement ever since its inception by Eble II of Ventadorn).

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limousin_cattle

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by mrlonglong on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:00PM (#30017242)
It's also a girl's name - Limousine. We had a French girl by that name stay with us on an exchange visit.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by rjtavares on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:17AM (#30021082)
I mean, it's only a Limousine if it comes fron the french region of Limousin. Otherwise it's just an unnecessarily long sparkling car.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by Schiphol on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:20AM (#30021115)
The funny thing is that Aranese is an official language at Val d'Aran, with all of the requisite legal protections to speakers. This makes Spain the only country where Occitan/Gascon (assuming with you and others that it is the same language; some apparently disagree) is an official language.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by ggrrhh_ta on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:17AM (#30021560)
Your second link is catalan to me... I could understand 100% and I don't know any Gascon language...
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by Bayart on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:26AM (#30023150)
He's got a somewhat Catalan accent and Catalan itself used to be part of Occitan, the boundaries aren't quite clear where they meet (whether in Aran or in Roussillon). It became its own language after Peter the Catholic died at the battle of Muret. Catalonia became culturally and politically cut out from Southern France and Catalan developed its own standard in isolation from the other courts it previously was affiliated with.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by Ostrogodsky on Thursday January 20, 2022 @09:49PM (#30018598)
I dont know how it is in other European countries, but at least in Spain, the slightest change in dialect+ some geographical distance will make people call their dialect a different language, and they may even not be wrong. And it is funny because that guy has a very marked Catalan accent, but they say it is the French side that brought French phonology to Occitan making it very difficult to understand.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by lottin on Friday January 21, 2022 @01:46AM (#30020038)
This only applies to "regional" languages though. For example, Spanish has different dialects yet nobody would suggest Andalusian isn't Spanish, but an entire different language. The political motivation is clear.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by harperlee on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:21AM (#30020684)
Well andalusian does not have different words, just different accent and pronunciation, whilst catalan galician and basque have a different vocabulary, so there’s that.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by ggrrhh_ta on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:37AM (#30021727)
If you put yourself into a descriptive standpoint you will see that Andalusian has distinctive features: in phonetics (the most salient being they use open/close vowel sounds to mark plural/singular), in grammar (inversion of direct object & reflexive), in words and expressions (many of them are known, but never used in other regions, thanks to sharing a cultural background, TV, etc). Although, functionally, it is mutually intelligible (at least 90%) with other variations of Spanish. The functional aspect is what I would use to separate whether two ways of speaking fall into the same language or not.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by elnatro on Friday January 21, 2022 @04:40AM (#30021262)
Andalusian tongues have different words and different tenses. However, these are dialects because they have not been politicized like Catalan or Basque (less the Galician).

In the case of Galician, one of the first to write in the Galician language was Alfonso X, the Castilian king, so there’s that to using languages as a political tool.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by marcan_42 on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:07AM (#30021481)
Basque is a completely different language, there is no real debate about that one. It is not even a romance language. If you want to look for politicized linguistic debate in Spain, try Valencian vs. Catalan :)
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by elnatro on Friday January 21, 2022 @06:21AM (#30022030)
Basque is a different beast, totally. An orphaned language that some say it has some Iberian or even North-African roots… However, is not an indoeuropeas languages, a gem on its own.

Having said that, the push for normalization of the Basque has mad some Basques angry because they don’t speak “standard” Basque.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by darkwater on Friday January 21, 2022 @06:01AM (#30021902)
I'm probably going against HN rules on commenting but the only one being "politicized" here is you. Saying with a straight face that Euskera (aka Basque) should be a dialect of Castillian is at very least an ignorant position, if not straight a bad faith one.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by elnatro on Friday January 21, 2022 @06:23AM (#30022042)
I never said that Basque is a dialect. I’m saying that some Basque nationalists have used language or even DNA to divide the society between what they consider Basque, and the other ones.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by RobertoG on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:11AM (#30021513)
Catalan is derived from Latin not Spanish, and Basque roots are not even Latin. So, it seems to me, that to say they are not dialects because they have been politicized is a politic statement in itself.
Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by elnatro on Friday January 21, 2022 @06:28AM (#30022088)
No, I never said that Catalan is a dialect, it is indeed a language.

But Catalan nationalists are even trying to remove all Spanish from the education [1][2] even by disobeying court sentences.

If you compare the situation between Catalan and Galicia. You can see it clearly. Galician is not used by most people nor politicians as a political tool. Catalan is sadly being used as such.

[1] https://www.elperiodico.com/es/sociedad/20211123/sentencia-2...

[2] https://www.europapress.es/nacional/noticia-parlament-catala...

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by RobertoG on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:20AM (#30023088)
You literally said that Andalusian and others "are dialects because they have not been politicized like Catalan or Basque", suggesting that what makes a language a language instead of a dialect it's its political weight.

Certainly, Catalan is used as a political tool, but it's a little hypocritical to think that Spanish is not. We all know how political questions should be solved in a democracy.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by elnatro on Friday January 21, 2022 @10:13AM (#30024563)
I explained myself poorly, English is not my first language. Andalusian is a set of dialects were Basque, Catalan and Galician are languages.

Having said that, Catalan and Basque have been used as a political tool for decades, much less the Galician, and not the Andalusian dialects of Spanish.

Hope this comment clarifies what I’m trying to say.

Re:Aranese: Spain's little-known language by lottin on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:10AM (#30021505)
I'm talking about the dialects of these languages (in the case of Catalan, Valencian and Balearic), which according to some constitute different languages altogether. But the same people who say these dialects are a separate languages, don't say that dialects of Spanish (e.g. Andalusian) are a separate languages, even though the degree of differentiation is roughly the same in both cases.