Compare with the Serbian/Croatian "languages" that are far more mutually intelligible than varieties of the Chinese "language".
I've heard that Arabic also has far more variance than is between Serbian and Croatian. Even though we often refer to it as a single language, it's actually a very diverse selection of varieties that are not all mutually intelligible.
In short, the distinction is pretty arbitrary.
Then we have "Italian" and "German". If these countries had not undergone unification in the 19th century would Duolingo be offering courses in Venetian and Bavarian?
As I see it, Scots and Standard English are two dialects of the same language.
>If these countries had not undergone unification in the 19th century would Duolingo be offering courses in Venetian and Bavarian?
Tuscan and High German became the standard with the Renaissance and the printing press, centuries before nationalism.
Different areas of Italy in particular had different literary vernaculars over time. One's that's particularly amusing to me is Franco-Venetian [1].
It doesn't matter how you personally see it. Linguists and other scholars are divided on the issue. It's recognized as a regional language by UNESCO and the Council of Europe as well as the UK and Scottish governments. There's also a spectrum from "Standard English spoken with a Scottish accent with some odd words thrown in" and broad Scots.
Danish and Norwegian (or at least Bokmål) are perhaps as close as Scots and English (I only have a passing familiarity with these so native speakers can confirm), but are considered distinct languages on as much political as linguistic grounds, which is my point - the distinction is as much political and historic as linguistic (i.e. there used to be a language only a few decades ago called "Serbo-Croatian").
It depends on what you mean by "standard". Tuscan was certainly the literary dialect, but most areas of modern Italy did not speak standardised Italian from the Renaissance period onward, except at the level of government.
thing is these standard versions were developed and agreed upon more or less at a time -- mid 19th century and the whole nationalist movements thing in europe -- when there was a unitarian tendency among south slavic nations. so the standard versions are (1) essentially artificial, and (2) politically motivated to an extent.
once you get on the ground level of spoken language you find far more variance within each of the two -- the regional and even local dialects are very different from each other, to the point of seemingly being whole different languages were it not for the developed standard versions that tie them together.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shtokavian#/media/File%3ASht...
but if someone from let's say east istria and south serbia communicated in the traditional local dialects spoken there there'd be a significant degree of confusion and misunderstanding between them -- that's my bet at least.
i suspect this is the case all around the world to a greater or lesser extent.
Linguistically, the distinction is much more objective (also it's not always clear cut, because there are asymmetries between speeches in terms of how understandable they are to each other) : two kinds of speech that are not inter-comprehensible are different languages. Dialects and sub-dialects are defined by isoglosses, see the map I link in my original post.
Arabic is, much like Chinese, both a linguistic group and a language (Modern Standard Arabic).
In the case of Galician, one of the first to write in the Galician language was Alfonso X, the Castilian king, so there’s that to using languages as a political tool.
Having said that, the push for normalization of the Basque has mad some Basques angry because they don’t speak “standard” Basque.
But Catalan nationalists are even trying to remove all Spanish from the education [1][2] even by disobeying court sentences.
If you compare the situation between Catalan and Galicia. You can see it clearly. Galician is not used by most people nor politicians as a political tool. Catalan is sadly being used as such.
[1] https://www.elperiodico.com/es/sociedad/20211123/sentencia-2...
[2] https://www.europapress.es/nacional/noticia-parlament-catala...
Certainly, Catalan is used as a political tool, but it's a little hypocritical to think that Spanish is not. We all know how political questions should be solved in a democracy.
Having said that, Catalan and Basque have been used as a political tool for decades, much less the Galician, and not the Andalusian dialects of Spanish.
Hope this comment clarifies what I’m trying to say.
As for Aranese speakers, to me (I have some amount of Limousin and Provençal) native ones [2] are understandable to the same extent as other Gascon speakers, but new speakers who bring Castellan phonological features are incomprehensible. If it manages to survives in this environment, it could truly be a new language in the making.
[1]: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Isoglosas_gasc%C3%B3...
[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdYpvY6Efos