How about you argue with the points made in the article? Do you disagree with anything in the article? Is their dreaded "misinformation" in it. If so point it out and ideally provide some evidence.
I am pro transparency especially when it comes to a global pandemic. I've always been that way. I'm not going to change my opinion because some other person has the same opinion. I don't give a rats ass who wrote the article. It could have been Santa Claus. I like to read articles and do my own research and form my own opinions. People like you who want to try to discredit people so you can silence debate are the biggest problem in this pandemic.
Oh, and you know who else got AIDS and HIV completely wrong? Dr. Fauci.
Absolutely, yes. I believe there to be an acute public health interest in not letting antivax nuts run wild on raw data like they do with VAERS, despite clear disclaimers not to do so. Additionally, as a participant in a couple of trials, I see a significant benefit to careful review before the release of data that might inadvertently reveal my identity, conditions, medical history, etc.
Conspiracy theorists usually do go nuts with this stuff, but usually there's no need for an organized "conspiracy" when class or professional interests are at stake.
For example, that's one very clearly stated reason why US government officials running scientific agencies shut down scientific discussion of the lab leak theory, and why most scientists went along with it: because of the risk that the public backlash might harm their funding - the same sort of backlash that led to restrictions on gain-of-function research in the first place, that they ended up working around.
> ‘I share your view that a swift convening of experts in a confidence inspiring framework (WHO seems really the only option) is needed, or the voices of conspiracy will quickly dominate, doing great potential harm to science and international harmony…’”
People quite naturally and regularly act in a way that appears coordinated without any actual coordination.
Privacy matters, you don't just get to look at people's health data for free or without caveats and conditions, namely their consent.
I unequivocally support it for healthcare workers.
Most real world scenarios involve rights that may conflict at times, like the right to free speech running into libel. As a society, we wind up having to decide how to resolve those conflicts.
Now here you are, asking ceejayoz loaded question after loaded question. You sure look like you're trying to find some reason to dismiss what he says. That's not cool, especially since you started us down the "discuss the actual points" path.
ceejayoz said they're pro medical privacy but thinks that people should have to let people know if they're vaccinated. It makes no sense.
They also want people to be fired from their jobs for not taking a vaccine whose data isn't being released.
In summary I find it hypocritical to be against vaccine transparency but for mandates. It's also hypocritical to be for medical privacy but be for vaccine mandates.
Mandate does not need to include public display of compliance at irrelevant points. The current implementation seems to be driven by assumption that many could be shamed into compliance. I believe it is very misguided policy, which works in a completely opposite way with people it aimed upon. Also, believe it or not, many people technically compliant are at the same time pretty disgusted with the privacy-breaking aspect.
I appreciate how antivax people love to share this fact like this is the ULTIMATE argument as to why the vaccine is actually BAD.
That question applies in literally every case and therefore doesn't change change the optimal strategy.
> What if it requires some domain expertise to detect a reasonable-sounding, but actually false claim?
That question applies just as much to links from "sciencebasedmedicine.org" as it does to the OP.
Sure, which is why being aware of both is valuable.
Sure, which is why I find it useful to know about the source, and criticism of their past work, when evaluating an op-ed just published in a field that requires substantial domain knowledge to fairly evaluate claims. I linked an article not very charitable towards the author because I consider it valuable in exactly this sort of determination.
> You don't need an expert to tell you transparency is good.
You don't need an expert to tell you complete transparency can have downsides, especially where patients' medical data is involved.
HN usually takes a dim view of "if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to worry about", but the rapid release of raw medical records is the sort of scenario where people may have lots to hide.
If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
Crossing into personal attack and snark, besides being against HN's rules, has the effect of discrediting your own point of view. That is a poor trade to make in exchange for a momentary bit of venting. Not only that, but if your view happens to actually be correct, then it has the side effect of discrediting the truth, which is not in any of our interests. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
Can you please not create accounts to break the HN guidelines with?
> Indeed, Doshi has history of playing footsie with the antivaccine movement, amplifying antivaccine conspiracy theories, downplaying the severity of influenza and thus feeding antivaccine narratives, using sleight-of-hand to downplay the effectiveness of flu vaccines, and generally playing the role of a false skeptic with respect to vaccines. At this point, I can’t help but note that Doshi also once signed a petition “questioning” whether HIV causes AIDS.