News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by smm11 on Thursday January 13, 2022 @01:54PM (#29924970)
Will the music industry sue the 1978 me, with the tape recorder right next to the radio, and me holding the "record" button to catch my favorite songs (along with the banter leading right up to the first lyrics)?
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by belter on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:08PM (#29925194)
They already did: "...A royalty on blank audio tape and tape recorders..."

https://www.nytimes.com/1985/11/21/arts/issue-and-debate-roy...

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by howdydoo on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:13PM (#29925282)
They should also get a royalty on cameras, because someone might take a photo of copyrighted cover art. Oh, and also a royalty on pens and paper, because someone might use them to write down copyrighted lyrics
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by fimdomeio on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:31PM (#29925558)
I believe than in Portugal one pays a tax with every hdd or any device that might be used to ilegally store copyrighted content. So I pay a tax for the eventuality of doing the thing I cannot legally do but at the same time if I already paid for it how can it still be ilegal?
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by bonzini on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:37PM (#29925650)
Pretty much all over Europe but it's not for illegal copies: it's for legal copies as in "copy an LP you own to a cassette for use in a car" (that's the original use case).

Of course everybody knows that it's practically covering missed royalties from illegally copied content, but according to the letter of the law it isn't.

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by vasco on Friday January 14, 2022 @02:43AM (#29931624)
This is correct. Source: Portuguese man with a deep hatred for copyright protection institutions, motivated in large part by the introduction of that law.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by matheusmoreira on Thursday January 13, 2022 @03:15PM (#29926192)
Maybe impose a tax on our brains as well since it stores copyrighted data in our memories. Complete with mandatory brain chips that detect when you remember their data and charge your bank account automatically.

How much more absurd can this become?

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by habeebtc on Thursday January 13, 2022 @05:31PM (#29927882)
They come after bars sometimes for hosting cover bands. True story.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by iqanq on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:22PM (#29925413)
In Spain they get a royalty from everything you can store data on, from hard disks to mobile phones.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by onli on Thursday January 13, 2022 @03:02PM (#29926023)
They also do in Germany, where they are suing. It's mentioned in the article I think - they try to get the money twice.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by spicybright on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:28PM (#29925502)
Does it scale with storage size lol
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by pacbard on Thursday January 13, 2022 @03:41PM (#29926544)
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by iqanq on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:33PM (#29925595)
It scales with price :)
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by smegsicle on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:38PM (#29925678)
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by belter on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:38PM (#29925673)
That is called the Microsoft tax. As you pay extra for your OEM hardware even if dont plan to use Windows.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by steelframe on Thursday January 13, 2022 @03:12PM (#29926143)
Isn't it the case that you can order from some of the more popular OEMs with Linux pre-installed, and they won't charge you the Microsoft licensing fee? I think Dell and Lenovo do this?

Maybe they do charge the Microsoft fee anyway, but I'd be a bit surprised if they didn't fix that issue.

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by belter on Thursday January 13, 2022 @05:01PM (#29927521)
Its still the case that if you are an OEM vendor, you need to make sure your hardware plays nice with the new versions of Windows. You better "cooperate".

Its difficult to describe all the behaviors they were engaged in.

"...The Complaint alleges that Microsoft has used its monopoly power to induce PC manufacturers to enter into anticompetitive, long-term licenses under which they must pay Microsoft not only when they sell PCs containing Microsoft's operating systems, but also when they sell PCs containing non-Microsoft operating systems..." https://www.justice.gov/atr/competitive-impact-statement-us-...

As a reminder...They lost their case "United States v. Microsoft Corp." and June 7, 2000, the court ordered a breakup of Microsoft. They would have to be broken into two separate units, one to produce the operating system, and one to produce other software components. This was overturned on appeal on what can be only described as technicalities...

The Judge said: "...Microsoft proved, time and time again, to be inaccurate, misleading, evasive, and transparently false. ... Microsoft is a company with an institutional disdain for both the truth and for rules of law that lesser entities must respect. It is also a company whose senior management is not averse to offering specious testimony to support spurious defenses to claims of its wrongdoing."

Politics changes in the US and the power of lobbying made everything to end up in a settlement that for most Microsoft has been ignoring or forgetting about.That is how much it took to make them open "some" API's

This one from the EU is one of the best overviews:

"Microsoft: A History of Anticompetitive Behavior and Consumer Harm" http://www.ecis.eu/documents/Finalversion_Consumerchoicepape...

I heard their ex-CEO is into vaccines now ;-)

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by rasz on Thursday January 13, 2022 @03:15PM (#29926182)
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by cronix on Thursday January 13, 2022 @03:03PM (#29926042)
Didn't they also do that with recordable CD's (CD-R) early on?
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by pomian on Thursday January 13, 2022 @05:13PM (#29927665)
Yes. To this day. You pay extra tax on cdc-r. (Interesting not on DVD -r)
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by EvanAnderson on Thursday January 13, 2022 @04:12PM (#29926932)
I don't know about CD-R media, but DAT media was that way.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by PostThisTooFast on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:44PM (#29925762)
And the bullshit tax on blank CDs, which came later.

The article makes a critical point: We already PAID for the right to download this material, and have been paying for decades.

Also, I've known several friends in bands. So far I've never heard of any of them receiving a check for blank-media taxes collected "on their behalf."

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by standardUser on Thursday January 13, 2022 @05:05PM (#29927568)
Honestly I'm surprised there still is a music industry, considering how many albums I downloaded on Napster in my teens and early twenties.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by tshaddox on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:48PM (#29925823)
Short answer: yes, the music industry (and similar media industries) has historically fought tooth and nail against any technology that allows anyone to consume content in any way not directly controlled and monetized by the music industry. There's a well-documented history of media industries fighting against "time shifting."
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by DrJokepu on Thursday January 13, 2022 @07:51PM (#29929172)
That's right, back in the day, music publishers were up in arms about that outrageous new invention, the phonograph!
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by jacquesm on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:43PM (#29925746)
You don't remember the 'home taping is killing music' campaign?
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by bshipp on Thursday January 13, 2022 @06:54PM (#29928719)
I'm fairly certain record companies have been a decade behind evolving technology since the late 70s, probably earlier.

If their claims were valid they should have all collapsed in ruin 20 years ago.

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by mrweasel on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:09PM (#29925214)
No because that is not a loss-less copy. The quality is severely affect and that amount of damage you can potentially do to sales is minimal. EDIT: Completely forgot about the "tax" on blank media and tape records.

Anyway, if they didn't want people to be able to copy their stuff, then they shouldn't have put it on YouTube. The music industry is being as dumb as they ever where, it's fascinating that they've learned NOTHING in the past twenty years. How much money can they possibly lose on youtube-dl vs. how much money they continue the scam out of artists.

At this point who doesn't have a subscription to a streaming service? Those who don't where never going to pay anyway. They aren't losing money.

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by jacquesm on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:45PM (#29925784)
The funny thing is they did this to themselves. Consumers were perfectly happy with their regular HiFi stuff and records. But the recording companies and the big hardware manufacturers (notably: Philips, Sony, both owners of enormous music catalogs) would love to sell everybody an upgraded HiFi system and get them to buy all their music again. In a format so dense that no computer would ever be able to store that much information on a writable medium so pushing large numbers of lossless copies of music into the world was a no brainer. We all know how that ended.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by tremon on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:26PM (#29925466)
Everything available on Youtube is not a lossless copy. Especially music is lossy-compressed and loudness-optimized, so lossless vs lossy isn't a valid argument here.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by mrweasel on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:28PM (#29925496)
My point was that it won't degree further as you make copies of the file you got with YouTube-dl
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by zamadatix on Thursday January 13, 2022 @03:18PM (#29926231)
YouTube is just another streaming service, they make money by delivering their copyrighted material on it just like every other delivery method and people pirate via it just like every other delivery method. Choosing to put their content on YouTube isn't a dumb choice at all, it's one of the few sane things about the situation.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by PostThisTooFast on Thursday January 13, 2022 @02:48PM (#29925816)
The music industry (in collusion with Congress) killed DAT with this same specious argument, when everyone knew that "perfect digital copies" were the LEAST-likely vector of attack on their industry.

The obvious and dominant form of music copying was with double-cassette boom boxes in dorm rooms and bedrooms around the world.

And in the end, the media publishers' lies about "perfect digital copies" were proven to be just that, as profoundly IMperfect MP3s became the real threat.

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by grishka on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:22AM (#29931196)
Those tape recorders with a built-in radio that are capable of recording it directly should be illegal

/s

Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by agumonkey on Thursday January 13, 2022 @04:13PM (#29926942)
Soon we'll have self rotting audio files to emulate analog longevity.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by hbn on Thursday January 13, 2022 @04:48PM (#29927357)
They don't even really need to do that since most people don't touch raw music files any more.
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by autoexec on Thursday January 13, 2022 @05:02PM (#29927540)
Trusted computing and DRM could make it happen
Re:Music industry is suing youtube-dl hosters by grishka on Friday January 14, 2022 @01:23AM (#29931202)
I love how "trusted" in this context basically means "against the will of the end user, enforced by the technological supremacy of hardware manufacturers".