News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by system16 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:32AM (#29891819)
Say what you want about China, but their ability to weaponize capitalism and make multi-billion dollar companies cower and self-censor in ways they would never do for Western governments is remarkable.

"When it comes time to hang the capitalists, they will vie with each other for the rope contract".

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by syki on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:15AM (#29892397)
In China the government tells companies what to do in the furtherance of state aims. In America and elsewhere companies tell government what to do in furtherance of corporate aims. For instance the overthrow of governments on behalf of banana companies and oil companies. What we see now is China exerting influence and power and we aren’t accustomed to having another country do this toward our companies/interests.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by mlindner on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:36AM (#29892695)
This is a rather skewed and incorrect view of history. In America and elsewhere companies do not dictate policy. They can help edge it in a direction they want, but the large swings of policy are out of their control. More so you're generalizing America to the entire west and excluding other Asian countries like Japan.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by iterati on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:29AM (#29893605)
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by jeff303 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:37PM (#29894708)
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by syki on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:50AM (#29892923)
Clearly what I wrote was a broad over simplification but I think the essence is roughly correct. As it stands now companies in China are definitely subservient to the state. The communist party there is definitely in the driver seat. In America corporate interests dominate policy making. U.S. foreign policy has definitely been bent to serve corporate interests and domestic policy in many areas are enacted to serve corporate interests. There are many instances of corporations mostly dictating policy in the U.S. I don’t claim all policy is at the behest of corporations.

Roughly speaking one can view the difference between China and the U.S. as follows. In China corporations serve CCCP interests and in the U.S. government serves corporate (highest bidder) interests.

I should not have said “other countries” in my original post. There are, currently, no other countries than China and the U.S. in terms of scale and influence.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by nicoburns on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:24AM (#29893526)
> I should not have said “other countries” in my original post. There are, currently, no other countries than China and the U.S. in terms of scale and influence.

One might perhaps reasonably compare the EU, which I would suggest is somewhere between the US and China on the where the control lies.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by erdos4d on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:14AM (#29893344)
>In America and elsewhere companies do not dictate policy.

Huh? In the US large corporations commonly write the laws that get passed. They literally do dictate policy.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by mlindner on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:39PM (#29894738)
That's a myth.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:36AM (#29891872)
Intel shareholders can now vote to ensure Intel takes a stand against China, if they choose. But it seems those individuals do not want that. So Intel is doing what it is supposed to do -- operate in accordance with wishes of the shareholders.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by burkaman on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:47AM (#29891991)
Counterpoint: the human beings that run Intel are not "supposed to" do everything possible to make their shareholder more money, regardless of the cost. I accept that they're going to do that, but there's nothing forcing them to, there's just a general cultural acceptance of greed.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:34AM (#29892668)
No one is saying that. They do what the shareholders want because that's who they legally work for. Shareholders can say screw China, take a stand and they will. They can't unilaterally say screw the shareholders we're going in this direction.

A company is a group of people coming together for a purpose. Management can't destory the group in pursuit of their own values. A ship's captain can't risk the ship because of their own values.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by burkaman on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:38AM (#29893799)
> They do what the shareholders want

They haven't even asked what the shareholders want. They don't think they need to, because they believe that everyone will naturally share their belief that money is their highest priority.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @03:31PM (#29897403)
Management doesn't ask shareholders for approval on every decision.

They have a duty to act in the best interest of the shareholder. Generally that means not having reduced revenue. This is what most people accept. If shareholders want them to do something different they can let them know.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by burkaman on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @03:57PM (#29897755)
> Generally that means not having reduced revenue.

I think this is the fundamental disagreement we have, and it's probably too big of a conversation for a comment thread. In my philosophy of determining "best interest", revenue is an important consideration, but not the only one and not the most important one. There is certainly no legal duty to increase revenue or stock price or anything like that.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by reaperducer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:04PM (#29894194)
They do what the shareholders want because that's who they legally work for.

Under which law? Plenty of corporate boards do things their shareholders don't like every day.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by FredPret on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:31AM (#29892624)
Management is very much supposed to do whatever the owners tell them to do. If they don’t like it, they can resign in protest.

Having said that, someone at Intel, owners or managers, are way off track here and in need of severe consequences. They picked the wrong side.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by michaelt on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:03AM (#29893141)
Shareholders haven't resolved that Intel must or must not use slave labour.

And a court isn't going to second-guess the management if they judge the cost savings of using slave labour don't outweigh the potential for reputational damage.

As such, management are free to act either way.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by Loughla on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:14AM (#29893333)
I would argue that 'shareholders' aren't able to influence these decisions at multi-national mega corporations, because many don't even know they are shareholders. Think about Joe Blow from the US. He has a managed 401k or some such investment. He has no idea the 'low-risk' fund offered through Edward Jones invests in Intel or Google or whoever. He has no idea he plays a part in this.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by FredPret on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @03:08PM (#29897100)
Very true. Public shareholding is like a parallel democracy, where almost none of the voters are paticipating or voting.

I strongly believe we need more voter participation here.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by reaperducer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:07PM (#29894224)
I would argue that 'shareholders' aren't able to influence these decisions at multi-national mega corporations

There's such a thing as activist investors, and they seem to be gaining influence lately. From what I read in the newspaper, they're behind a lot of the changes that are starting to happen at certain multi-national oil companies.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by FredPret on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:11AM (#29893291)
A flaw in the system to be sure. As a former INTC owner, I dumped my stake a while ago.

I think there should be far more shareholder involvement in general. We are far too acquiescent as a group.

If you polled every direct and indirect INTC holder (you may be one, unknowingly) about slavery and concentration camps, you’d walk away with a near 100% mandate for taking all measures against it.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by reaperducer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:06PM (#29894210)
Management is very much supposed to do whatever the owners tell them to do. If they don’t like it, they can resign in protest.

It's not a one-way street.

Management can do things, and if the shareholders don't like it, they can sell their shares in protest.

Happens all the time.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:11AM (#29892338)
> Intel shareholders can now vote to ensure Intel takes a stand against China, if they choose. But it seems those individuals do not want that.

Too early to conclude this. These tensions present not only a reputational risk for Intel, but financial ones as well, particularly if tensions escalate. Managers might not care, but there is precedence for shareholders taking a longer view [1].

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/09/business/exxon-mobil-engi...

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:35AM (#29892680)
I think the shareholders SHOULD take a stand, at Intel, Disney and other companies. The point I was making was that the power is in their hands, not management.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:05AM (#29893182)
> the power is in their hands, not management

Management absolutely has a say.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by baybal2 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:52AM (#29892063)
> Intel shareholders can now vote to ensure Intel takes a stand against China, if they choose. But it seems those individuals do not want that.

Good question, who are Intel shareholders?

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by michaelt on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:15AM (#29893355)
Intel is chopped up into tens of millions of tiny slices, and everyone with any form of retirement savings has a handful through some sort of fund.

Generally these people barely know they're shareholders, they receive none of the paperwork needed to vote at the AGM, they have a slice several orders of magnitude too small to exert any influence, and they have no way of identifying or contacting other shareholders to take any sort of coordinated action.

Anyone who expects X to be done by shareholders is going to be disappointed.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by baybal2 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:58AM (#29894108)
> Anyone who expects X to be done by shareholders is going to be disappointed.

It's the general problem of public ownership of means of production.

Public companies don't work. Stock market provides heck a lot of wrong incentives.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:13AM (#29892357)
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:39AM (#29892739)
Keep in mind that institutional investors like index funds hold share on behalf of indvidual persons.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by baybal2 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:50AM (#29892917)
That's even worse, as this means somebody takes your money, and pay somebody to stooge for China without you knowing.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:57AM (#29893054)
Well you presumably know what is in your portfolio or can find out if social issues are that important.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by vmception on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:54AM (#29892094)
Those shareholders are going to sell to shareholders that have other priorities.

Fun in theory but too bad only Americans tolerate those PE multiples. So, look out below!

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:38AM (#29892721)
Which again goes to my point. People who care about Intel taking a stand against China should actually buy shares from the existing investors and make them.

If no one wants to do that then what is all these kvetch about "capitalism" and "greed" corrupting companies and our values when it is the people who do not care. Certainly not enough to pay up for the shares.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by vmception on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:45AM (#29892838)
ha, a classic prisoner's dilemma.

in my case I was waiting for disgruntled shareholders to sell because an aggregate stance was not taken by management or other shareholders, and then when sold it goes to people more or less apathetic.

in your case you want people to buy the shares at any price but likely a premium, in order to exercise a goal, which I frankly think is absurd.

so guess the market has priced everything in well enough, as an aggregate opinion on its own.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:56AM (#29893037)
Interesting take. Here is my view:

If the American consumers of Intel chips -- the people and government actors -- are unhappy with Intel's stance then they can also not buy their chips. This is basically what the Chinese are doing (without owning shares). Now granted the Chinese people have little say in it but the government is ostencibly acting on their behalf. Even if China was a democractic country and the CCP could not ban Intel outright then the government or the people could say that they would not buy Intel chips.

So if Americans did the same to uphold their own belifes then Intel would suffer here and that would reduce the stock price, which would make it easier for people who want to take them to take the progressive position to buy the stock and force them to reverse their position.

The key take away is that there is no scenario in which both sides actuall care about the issue and Intel stock doesn't drop.

Since it doesn't it means that Americans do not care about it as much as the Chinese, or do not know how to express their displeasure :)

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:34AM (#29893727)
I would fundamentally disagree with the idea that you don't "actually care" about an issue if you're not boycotting people over it. Why can't I genuinely care about Intel doing the right thing here without building a blacklist of Intel-backed AWS instance types I won't use?
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by bravo22 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @02:38PM (#29896666)
I meant it in the sense it is used in economics not in the colloquial sense.

If A cares enough about an issue and is willing to deal with the consequences and B does not then A wins and B loses.

Everyons is willing to commit something for a cause they care about. It could be as little as taking time to convince others by writing an article or a tweet, or as much as being able to commit violence for it and deal with the consequences.

One aspect of life, from negotiations to geopolitics to convince your opponent that A) you would be willing to pay a higher price than they are for your position B) you CAN pay that price.

In case of Intel v China, CCP has something to lose by banning Intel but they've demonstrated or at least convinced them and most other companies that they're willing to pay that price and CAN pay it (by the virtue of being the CCP and having absolute authority). A nation with less resources may not be able to convince a mega corp in order to get concessions.

So in this case if Americans care more about this issue they have to convince the Chinese that they're willing AND able to pay a higher price than they are.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by 4ggr0 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:16AM (#29892411)
I think the shareholders who have this power would probably also be included in OPs quote.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by Steltek on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:17AM (#29892420)
Collective action problems are not solved through capitalism. Unfortunately, Western countries are gripped by misguided reactive individualism right now and governments are very hamstrung.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by eunos on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:28AM (#29892577)
And this happens when the Chinese economy is still smaller than the US along with their lack of mastery in certain state-of-the-art semiconductor and aerospace tech. When the Chinese economy and tech hopefully match the US, the pressure gonna be enormous. Can't wait to see that day, my newsfeed will be so exciting.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by ISL on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:32AM (#29892637)
On that day, your newsfeed might be free of dissent.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by mlindner on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:37AM (#29892718)
Your newsfeed will tell you want to hear and nothing else while the world destroys itself around you and you blissfully ignorant of it.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by eunos on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @01:57PM (#29895999)
> while the world destroys itself

I don't realize how vain the America is (I assume). Losing advantage in aero and semiconductor tech means destruction of the world? really?.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by jonnycomputer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:59AM (#29892161)
Where did that quote come from?
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @12:32PM (#29894616)
Quote Investigator says that Major George Racey Jordan was the source of this wording in 1955, but he attributed it to Lenin. In 1931, however, S. Dmitrijewski wrote something similar (while talking about Maxim Litvinov):

> In the autumn of 1905 he founded, together with Krassin, the newspaper New Life; the necessary money being given by millionaires, who thereby helped weave the rope from which many of them should hang later on.

https://quoteinvestigator.com/2018/02/22/rope/

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by smachiz on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:07AM (#29892263)
Karl Marx or Lenin, Gretzky, or Michael Scott. It's often attributed to Lenin and Marx, but no actual evidence that I've seen.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by jonnycomputer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:12AM (#29892343)
The best quotes are usually non-attributable. lol.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:39AM (#29891897)
Intel wouldn’t massage the wording of their shareholder report to avoid criticism from the American public? I’m skeptical. They almost certainly have review processes designed to anticipate and prevent that from happening in the first place.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by vmception on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:51AM (#29892046)
Now they have better review processes.

Its pretty clear what happened, Intel doesn't have an aggregate stance on anything, US legal saw the new US federal law regarding Xinjiang and wanted it included in US securities regulatory risk statements and also needed that in circulars. That happened, then reality set in that there are consequences - something lawmakers are shielded from - and at that point Intel took a look at the circumstance holistically and reworded it.

Companies are going to have to hire geopolitical experts to play cross cultural word games now that they are being saddled with it the consequences.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by sorethescore on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @09:54AM (#29892085)
Who do you think taught them how to do that?
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by Aunche on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @11:25AM (#29893549)
My previous comment got flagged, so I'll rephrase in a way that's less sarcastic.

Intel is doing the exact same thing to help Xinjiang as the government which is absolutely nothing. Yet somehow anti-capitalists will only focus on the former. Governments do tend to virtue signal more, but that's because they don't face any negative repercussions for doing so.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by toolz on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:00AM (#29892183)
I'm not sure I understand you correctly. Are you blaming capitalism for the moral failures of a communist regime?

Maybe you're just suggesting capitalism isn't capable of "solving" the wrongdoings of communism? If so I would agree. A society that accepts the evils of communism is a difficult thing to solve externally.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by me_me_me on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:07AM (#29892273)
what he is saying is that chinese gov adopted capitalism but state is actually controlling it them - semi indirectly.

And they are big enough to be able to influence other big countries and foreign corporations to the point that they are now setting directions of where things are going.

Case and point Holywood and self censorship in movies to pander to chinese market

They are not saying comunism is good or bad, just stating reality of what is happening

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by toolz on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:14AM (#29892377)
The Chinese gov't adopted capitalism? I'm not sure I can believe that anyone believes that, much less agree with it.

This is a very direct example of a communist government controlling the messaging of a company, which is antithetical to capitalism.

As I understand it, this is happening because Chinese corporations are coerced by the communist regime such that Intel would lose business if they didn't follow the rules coming thru their Chinese partner corporations. Intel is still very much capable of freely choosing to obey those demands or not, which makes them capitalists, but the Chinese corporations being coerced into doing PR for the CCP is not capitalism.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by me_me_me on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:44AM (#29892834)
> I'm not sure I can believe that anyone believes that, much less agree with it.

You can believe in whatever you like, it doesn't change the reality and facts.

Its not my opinion, china is a capitalist country run by communist (with Xi totalitarian) government.

The companies adhere to market laws/regulations and operate like any other capitalist western corporations.

Of note is the fact that as corporation gets to certain size their board must hire certain number of party official who will oversee the business operations.

Those people ensure the company is heading in the broad direction set by the party. If they dont, party will bring out the knives and it doesnt matter if you are jack ma or not.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by 4ggr0 on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:18AM (#29892444)
Yes, their party has communist in its name and socially they portray (Authoritarian!-)Communist ideals. But calling their economy communist is really not the whole truth.
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by jpgvm on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:33AM (#29892653)
It's closer to a highly regulated semi-free market like Singapore, many European countries etc.

China is interesting in that they seem to take a more data-orientated decision making process when it comes to determining areas where free-market like behaviors would increase efficiency while keeping strategic capabilities under public funding (despite the efficiency losses).

I think most other governments manage this balance poorly, in recent decades mostly tending to over-privatize things like utilities and infrastructure.

If China manages to continue on it's path of market regulation and paying attention to health of competition etc (it's recent work on giving the SAMR teeth) they are going to be in a very strong position in the coming decades while others play catchup after the privatisation overcorrection.

People seem to forget that free markets -require- strong regulation. The tending towards deregulation in US markets has lead to a serious degradation of market competitiveness and thus freedom.

My hope is the success of China will drive Western economies to do better so that we can say that democracy is at least as good as autocracy but preferably better. But to do that we need to stop throwing stones from glass houses and actually get down to the business of matching them.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by 4ggr0 on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @03:05AM (#29903669)
> in recent decades mostly tending to over-privatize things like utilities and infrastructure

That's exactly what bothers me about our western democracies, I fail to see why critical things like education, medicine, food and infrastructure(including internet-access) should be privatized. These things should belong to the people. Private companies can feel free to produce and sell other things, but they should, in my opinion, keep their hands from certain things.

> they are going to be in a very strong position in the coming decades

No doubt. What I currently wonder, is how afraid of this I should be. I'm not from the US so I don't really get emotional when thinking about the US getting weaker, compared to China. And although the US do things I find to be absolutely not okay, China seems even less compatible with my values.

> People seem to forget that free markets -require- strong regulation

Yes!

> But to do that we need to stop throwing stones from glass houses and actually get down to the business of matching them.

Totally. All I hear currently are politicians and other high-profile people constantly whining about China, while simultaneously manufacturing everything over there and profiting from their cheap labour. That's also something I find comical about the US - Publicy they denounce China, are constantly fighting in a trade war with each other. But so many things are then imported from China, just think about what Silicon Valley would do if China decides to keep their resources for themselves, or to just block the US.

Of course China would probably also have troubes, if the US would then in turn block them. But all I am trying to say is, that I hate the hypocrisy of this so called trade-war.

And now, to try to prove that I am not a shill for either side,

Tiananmen Square was a tragedy, what's happening with Hong Kong and Taiwan is a bit depressing, Xi Jinping and Winnie Pooh look very similar and what they do to Uyghurs is evil.

The US should face more consequences for their oil-wars which they label as "bringing freedom and democracy", patriot act and guantanamo bay are sickening, Edward Snowden and Julian Assange should be freed and given awards, your political "two-party" system is very outdated and overall the US has a really over-blown ego for all the issues it has. Healthcare, social security, wealth-gaps etc.

Maybe this was a bit unnecessary, but I notice that you can't say anything not 100% Anti-China without raising suspicion of being a state-sponsored troll or whatever. Maybe I could be labeled as a russian troll, but believe me, I could rant about their government as well.

Before I forget, last disclaimer: I am mostly criticizing these countries governments and elites, I have 0 issues with ordinary american or chinese citizens as a whole.

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by toolz on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:35AM (#29892688)
Which parts of the Chinese economy are not subject to a complete hostile takeover from their government, including but not limited to disappearing the companies leaders?

Just because state officials aren't directly managing day to day operations does not mean that company isn't owned by the state, because in China, that company is always owned by the state.

What is this nuance you seem to be referencing but not explaining?

Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by me_me_me on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:45AM (#29892851)
you confuse democracy with capitalism
Re:Intel removes Xinjiang references from shareholder letter by GavinMcG on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @10:04AM (#29892233)
I think they're blaming capitalism for the moral failings of the capitalist companies who willingly submit to immoral demands.