It seems safe to assume that Apple doesn't like user APN traffic being tracked any more than the rest of their traffic, and so I would imagine this is essentially the roadmap for all Apple Services provided to their users over the next few years.
It's also possible the Beta is just to see what happens when they make the traffic visible and possible to block, and having seen the carriers tending towards "block anything that inhibits tracking", they might simply target Private Relay 2.0 as "HTTP3 over 443/udp to http3.apple.com" and have that be an N-way reflector point for all customer-provided Apple services, including Private Relay and the rest as different channels over that multipath HTTP3 layer. They chose to implement Private Relay in a way that could be detected, and are measuring how neutrality-hating carriers respond. Assuming it's their final answer is not a bet I'd take.
It isn't a forceful use of power by Apple and it clearly informs just the simple truth that the users carrier is hostile and maybe they want to switch.
Does your carrier implement this? If not, will you switch carriers? It’s unclear what degree of importance you assign to your expectation, as it could be anything from “for the tasks I care about” to “in every possibly way without exception”. (For me: It’s not important eniugh to switch carriers on its own, though it’s certainly a factor if I have greater reasons.)
By the way, your parent comment hypothesizing about http/3 and Apple services likely being routed via Private Relay was also very insightful. The http/3 part seems quite speculative, but I could easily see the Apple services being routed over Private Relay as part of any standard "dogfooding" roadmap.
It’s absolutely speculative to consider http3 a viable replacement for ”a VPN”, as many consider Private Relay to be^, but that’s not due to any technical limitation. We could benchmark Squid-over-http3 versus Wireguard VPN in various latency and packet loss scenarios today (if implemented), and get productive and interesting results. We could do the same with varnish / nginx versus openvpn / pptpd. Whether or not it supports CONNECT is worth noting, but is no obstacle for “let’s assume that everything is HTTP”, as appears widely applicable to both Apple’s services to their customers, and a significant majority of consumer VPN traffic, today.
Have those benchmarks been performed yet? Are we all doing it wrong by using wireguard et al. to Mullvad et al. for 99% HTTP traffic and we just don’t realize it yet? I look forward someday to finding out the answer :)
ps. iOS carrier APIs and functionality are NDA’d so I don’t have any other information or useful examples to offer, as my experience with carriers as their customer is very limited. Perhaps others will know; apologies.
^ I haven’t seen an FP yet titled “If it can’t carry SSH traffic, it’s not a VPN”, but certainly there’ll be one someday. I can’t predict when, though, anymore than I can guess when someone else will realize to seriously ask, supported by benchmarks and encapsulation overhead charts, “Should tcp be deprecated in favor of http?”. (I have no opinion on what the correct answers are at this time.)
https://tmo.report/2022/01/t-mobile-blocking-icloud-private-...
> However, many of the users we’ve heard from, and tested ourselves, do not have any such content filtering enabled. We’ve followed up with T-Mobile for additional clarification, but have not yet heard back.
> Visiting secured web sites (https) because encryption prevents Web Guard from seeing the content of those websites
I guess T-Mobile should start downgrading HTTPS to HTTP /s
https://www.theverge.com/22878885/verizon-att-t-mobile-apple...
That ad would be candy to the Apple PR team trying to push the “Apple is secure and respects your privacy” campaign. I bet we’ll see Apple use the court of public opinion here, and win with it.
Apple trys to manipulate public opinion constantly.
Again though, rupturing this conversation is mutually assured destruction. The reason why Apple won't call T-Mobile's bluff is because it's better for them to look like a symbiotic company than an adversarial one, and T-Mobile can get away with this because data protection in the US is a moot-point anyways. It's about as unremarkable as news gets.
Hell, Apple was even nice enough to give T-Mobile a special error message when you try to use Private Relay:
> "Your cellular plan doesn’t support iCloud Private Relay. With Private Relay turned off, this network can monitor your internet activity, and your IP address is not hidden from known trackers or websites."
I wouldn't call it security theater if I couldn't see the curtains on the left and right.
Your suggested response doesn't change my mind at all, it seems quite desperate and pathetic. And I want to see a stronger moral stance on trade with China.
If I were any of the carriers, I wouldn't worry about this in the slightest.
Apple attempting to gain ownership of a mobile carrier in order to impose it's will on the market would be met with incredibly harsh regulatory scrutiny.
Beyond that, there's a strategic reason Apple hasn't launched their own mobile offering. The minute Apple owns a particular mobile carrier, they would be pretty well cut off from the other mobile carriers, or they would have to negotiate deals that would probably be argued to be collusive trade practices.
The real solution is that the United States needs real data security and privacy laws that prevent network operators from reselling your usage history, location tracking, and other personal details. It's a national security issue at this point.
Also, as a carrier, I’m not worried about Google’s MVNO for one simple reason: Google hates humans.
For all that the carriers are bad to their customers, they at least have a footprint in meatspace. Google’s DNA finds physical footprint and real human interaction anathema.
I would gladly take Google in a customer foot race any day.
There's a difference between temporary sales presence contracted out and a permanent retail presence, though, you're right.
In other words, if they keep this behavior up, Google will begin to compete as well as advocate (fight for the regulation, laws, etc) for other, smaller, new ISPs to enter the market. Or fight harder on the net-neutrality front. Or potentially worst of all for the incumbent/monopolistic ISPs, fight to make them dumb-pipes.
Then again, maybe it's just another google product/service destined from conception for the graveyard...
The article asserts that an error in the settings menu appears: "Your cellular plan doesn’t support iCloud Private Relay. With Private Relay turned off, this network can monitor your internet activity, and your IP address is not hidden from known trackers or websites."
This doesn't appear to just be a situation where T-Mobile started blocking it at the network level; it appears to be one where Apple submitted.
While there's a lot of theories in this comment about how Apple will respond; I don't see that happening (in a public way, of course). Apple's leadership in 2022 doesn't have the same convictions their leadership has had in the past. They're capable of being a positive force for change, in fair weather; but when the weather gets rough, or when forces assert power over their expression of values, they fold.
Alternate phrasing which betrays different expectations: "We could not connect to the iCloud Private Relay servers. This may indicate an issue with your network provider, blah blah blah."
No VPNs is mostly standard-operating-procedure in, say, China. That being said: I'd assume that feature, let alone the settings page to configure it, is hidden in versions of the software distributed in countries like that. This error message is likely for countries where the service is available; just not on your carrier.
But putting that aside and even considering their stance of submission to the CCP; they betray every spoken value their American executives verbalize. That is standard operating procedure for 2022 Apple, and most other gigacorporations. That is the lens that every statement Tim makes, every word spoken at their keynotes, needs to be viewed through; that they're willing to invest their infinite money in whatever projects they believe aligns with their values, but they're wholly unwilling to stand up for those values when those projects are battle-tested in even such an absolutely inconsequential way as this.
Of course, they can prove me wrong by standing up to T-Mobile and using them as an example. I mean my god, you couldn't ask for a better example to make, T-Mobile/Sprint is a fourth-rate bargain bin cellular carrier, we're not talking about a nation state; this is a toddler mad at his parents because they won't let him eat candy for dinner. If they can't even resolve that, what hope do any of their values have?
OTOH, one way to become the most valuable company in history is to not go pulling stunts like that. Nothing the street loves more than predictability.
Edit: Another, "smarter" tactic that Apple might use is by sending messages to the Board of Directors. If Apple can get the Board of Directors on their side (or at least convince them that management is fighting a war they can't win)... another way to freak out execs at the carriers.
I also think it's silly to equate a company's power to the amount of money they have (at least in the first world) but your hypothetical does raise an interesting question: who's deeper in bed with the State, Big Telecom or FAANG? All of them answer to the government, even T-Mobile; but who's got the most favor? Understanding the heinous stuff the American government got away with when they had telecom under their thumb doesn't set a very optimistic baseline of expectations. It might even lead certain people to believe (surprise surprise) that Apple's dedication to privacy doesn't really mean much when there's money on the line. Arguing about how "Apple is better because they have more capital resources" has about as much pragmatic value as a child's crayon drawing.
Unless Apple has one-upped Room 641A, I think you're describing a power fantasy.
Apple would literally capture the entire value chain of the iDevice ecosystem with such a stunt, not to mention have yet another steady stream of income.
I think that was a very different time though. Smartphones were just becoming popular. A lot of other upcoming smartphones also had carrier exclusives at that time (Verizon with the Droid line). I don't know if that would be acceptable in today's world.
A joint move like that by the carriers would be subject to a lot of antitrust scrutiny, where as apple can move on it's own with a lot less scrutiny.
I mean, why isn't this already a thing? This isn't difficult at all. I don't buy my phone from my carrier. When I get a new phone, I simply take the old sim out and put it in the new one. The last time I had to do more was when the phones changed from a standard SIM to a mini SIM - the old one wouldn't physically fit. That was some years ago, though.
I'd think the bigger issue might be with the US phone networks: Do they still force you to use your phone with the carrier even though this isn't necessary at all? And if so, why haven't folks protested since it is obviously a way to trap people into one carrier.
Also, since folks in non-US countries can just buy a phone and put a sim card in, Apple won't have any issues adjusting whatsoever.
Another issue is probably the "incentives" provided through the network providers and their partners, especially when an iPhone is traded in. Often times it results in significant "savings" for the consumer. (I imagine Apple could implement something similar, if not superior if they wanted)
Finally it's physical presence. Apple has done a fantastic job of creating a physical place to serve your needs, and of course you can always buy online, but there are those that prefer or require going to a place to take care of their phone needs.
I also shudder to imagine what the Apple stores would look like if they had to deal with and resolve the kinds of network issues (not to mention some of the characters that need the help) I've seen the superabundance of network provider mall/strip-mall stores deal with.
Hopefully all of these are just remnants of a time we'd all like to put behind us.
There is no need to buy a phone from the mobile network in the US. People have been able to pop a SIM into a phone and call the mobile network and have them add the IMEI for many years.
> People would need to buy iPhones from Apple and then replace the SIM cards themselves.
The horror! We've been doing this the entire time here in Russia. Carriers have always had exactly zero say on what phones can and can't do.
Or the other cellular networks could start running ads touting that they let iPhone users use all of the iPhone features.
"Does your cell phone company hold you back? With Cincinnati Bell, you can do things with your iPhone that T-Mobile won't let you."
Apple could even help pay for the ads. It's not like companies with aligned interests don't do ad cost-sharing all the time anyway.
Edit: Wikipedia says Cincinnati Bell sold its mobile network to Verizon in 2014:
Now whether Apple shareholders want Apple operating a mobile network is a completely different question.
TMobile has numerous pay-for-play access contracts in place for companies like netflix and hulu. in return they get a QoS tier and guaranteed minimums for their subscribers.
conversely, as others have mentioned and the article itself, private relay is absolutely haram. it damages tmobiles ability to deliver edge content from their contractually obligated players like netflix (without a region netflix quality might suffer) and it completely sidesteps all of TMobiles lucrative user plans that include access to streaming media as a feature relative to the users data cap.
increasingly private "anything" on a cellphone is becoming a hostile proposition for carriers as their revenue is largely based on predatory surveillance capitalism. without metrics and metadata, theyre no different than the water company.
Please correct me if I'm wrong. If that's the case, I believe most/all iPhone users watch Netflix/content sites via an app, so that traffic would not be routed via Private Relay.
This may affect Mac Safari traffic, though. I am curious if they have any exceptions on the backend for edge content providers.
Yeah, that's not Apple's style. Besides, they don't want all of the legacy crap that comes with owning a cell phone carrier.
I suspect the issue is making its way up the corporate ladder through various directors and Vice Presidents.
And I'm sure Apple's got a business plan for running their own MVNO they could dust off if things get out of hand. But let's hope it doesn't come to that.
But this would be rewarding existing ownership with a buy-out.
This blocking is a net neutrality issue. Hope it doesn't hold, at least in Europe.
Changing sims is VERY easy, but a sim that doesn't match an approved phone is also easy to block?
No, because then people will ask why they also don't use the leverage to enable this feature in China/Russia/...
It doesn’t have the ability to give a middle finger to both those governments and still be able to sell devices to Russians and Chinese people to use Private Relay on.
If Apple really wanted to force the issue, they could tell T-Mobile no more iPhone contracts unless you do it. Apple can survive and thrive on fewer networks - the iPhone was AT&T exclusive for a long time at the beginning.
If that happened, there would be no way for T-Mobile to get a supply of iPhones. People would need to buy iPhones from Apple and then replace the SIM cards themselves. It would make T-Mobile bend pretty quickly unless they managed to get Verizon and AT&T to join them on the issue.
But then Apple has a second card to play, and that's the court of public opinion. If Apple wanted to make a public ad lambasting the carriers for undermining people's privacy, the damage would also force them to bend.
Finally, of course, there's the fact that carriers need Apple just as much as Apple needs carriers. However, between the carriers and Apple, who has $200 billion in the bank to do things themselves if they wanted?
Edit: Heck, T-Mobile has a market value of $130 billion. AT&T has a market cap of $188B, and Verizon $223 billion. If Verizon and AT&T joined T-Mobile in protest, Apple could theoretically attempt (or at least threaten) a hostile takeover of any of them. That would cause a lot of discussion among the carriers and send a strong message very quickly.