Also, as a carrier, I’m not worried about Google’s MVNO for one simple reason: Google hates humans.
For all that the carriers are bad to their customers, they at least have a footprint in meatspace. Google’s DNA finds physical footprint and real human interaction anathema.
I would gladly take Google in a customer foot race any day.
There's a difference between temporary sales presence contracted out and a permanent retail presence, though, you're right.
In other words, if they keep this behavior up, Google will begin to compete as well as advocate (fight for the regulation, laws, etc) for other, smaller, new ISPs to enter the market. Or fight harder on the net-neutrality front. Or potentially worst of all for the incumbent/monopolistic ISPs, fight to make them dumb-pipes.
Then again, maybe it's just another google product/service destined from conception for the graveyard...
If I were any of the carriers, I wouldn't worry about this in the slightest.
Apple attempting to gain ownership of a mobile carrier in order to impose it's will on the market would be met with incredibly harsh regulatory scrutiny.
Beyond that, there's a strategic reason Apple hasn't launched their own mobile offering. The minute Apple owns a particular mobile carrier, they would be pretty well cut off from the other mobile carriers, or they would have to negotiate deals that would probably be argued to be collusive trade practices.
The real solution is that the United States needs real data security and privacy laws that prevent network operators from reselling your usage history, location tracking, and other personal details. It's a national security issue at this point.