News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by oxymoran on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:09AM (#29840771)
Forget diesel trucks and piss, ya’ll are overlooking that urea is a major component of fertilizer.

Higher urea prices->higher fertilizer prices->Less fertilizer demand->less food supply->more suffering via sick and hungry people->more potential for confrontation and war.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by eloff on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:38AM (#29841220)
This is probably a question easily solved by querying Wikipedia, but I'll ask it here so the answer benefits others as well, where does the urea used in fertilizer come from?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by lcam84 on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:42AM (#29841295)
Urea comes from the Harber process [1] Basically most of food fertilizer depends on fossil fuels.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by fennecfoxen on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:40AM (#29841249)
The usual chain is natural gas -> ammonia -> urea. Thus, one of the key factors influencing the supply is Hurricane Ida, which led to remarkably long shutdowns in natural gas production. https://www.eia.gov/naturalgas/weekly/archivenew_ngwu/2021/1...
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by selectodude on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:42AM (#29841285)
Ammonia (made from natural gas) and carbon dioxide.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by beambot on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:27AM (#29841069)
Related article from yesterday that specifically calls out urea: "Global farmers facing fertiliser sticker shock may cut use, raising food security risks"

https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/global-farmers-f...

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by fennecfoxen on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:23AM (#29841000)
> urea is a major component of fertilizer

Oh yes. And alarm bells are ringing.

"I want to say this loud and clear right now, that we risk a very low crop in the next harvest. I'm afraid we're going to have a food crisis." — Svein Tore Holsether, CEO and president Yara International. https://fortune.com/2021/11/04/energy-crisis-food-shortage-s...

"Major fertilizer producers Yara International ASA and CF Industries Holdings Inc. said soaring energy costs are forcing them to halt some output of nutrients crucial for growing crops." https://www.bloombergquint.com/business/europe-s-energy-woes...

"In the fall, soaring electricity demand led the southwestern province of Yunnan, a key phosphate producer, to order drastic production cuts by energy-hungry industries, including fertilizer." https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/06/business/urea-fertilizer-...

"Farmers in India are desperate. Trucks in South Korea had to be idled. Food prices, already high, could rise even further." https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/06/business/urea-fertilizer-...

"Among farmers and ranchers, very few topics are being discussed as much as the skyrocketing cost of fertilizer and increasing concerns regarding availability." https://www.fb.org/market-intel/too-many-to-count-factors-dr...

"High fertilizer prices could exert inflationary pressures on food prices, compounding food security concerns at a time when the COVID-19 pandemic and climate change are making access to food more difficult." https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/soaring-fertilizer-pric...

"Higher farm input costs, expensive shipping and good demand provide for a grim combination... We are under La Niña conditions, the second such event in as many years, and the weather cannot be expected to be normal until Q2 2022 at the earliest." — Rabobank Outlook 2022: Hell in the Handbasket. https://research.rabobank.com/far/en/documents/842941_Raboba...

Hell in the handbasket here we come!

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by JohnJamesRambo on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:29AM (#29841099)
This is why I don’t buy the Bitcoin “mined with free energy” narrative. Put a fertilizer plant near that hydro dam instead of doing proof of work calculations.

Ethereum 2.0 (uses proof of stake- doesn’t do energy intensive mining) can’t come soon enough for me.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by pulsarmx on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:02PM (#29841580)
> uses proof of stake- doesn’t do energy intensive mining

I have an honest question that I haven't seen answered anywhere, and I'm not smart enough to answer it for myself by reading papers and whatnot.

Assume whatevercoin currently uses PoW and takes X energy to mine a single coin, but would take X/100 energy to mine it under PoS.

What stops people from simply throwing the 99/100 leftover energy from X into more mining operations, rather than just being content with the one and the leftover energy?

Or put another way, if mining a single coin suddenly costs 1/100 of what it used to, why would I not just mine 100 coins now?

It just all sounds to me like what happens when there's an increase in computational power/speed/capacity/whatever in PCs. When you can process a thing ten times as fast, you don't just do one thing ten times faster; you do ten things at once.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by aqme28 on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:20PM (#29841792)
Because it's not really an efficiency upgrade like you've envisioned.

The current PoW system turns energy directly into miner rewards.

A PoS system does not do that. You can't just throw more energy at the problem to get more rewards.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by renewiltord on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:00PM (#29842373)
Well, because it's not like PoS is just making PoW more efficient. You have no way to turn that extra energy into more stake.

It's like if I paid you previously for every strawberry you bring me, and now I pay you for how old you are. Previously, for 100 strawberries I gave you $20, and now for every 20 years you are old, I give you $20/hr. Now you need far fewer strawberries to make the same amount of money, but that doesn't mean you can now make more by giving me strawberries. You have no way of converting strawberries into age.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by pulsarmx on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:02PM (#29855568)
Thanks, I think I kind of get it now. But now my follow up question is, what stops me from just recruiting, say, nine other people at least as old as me, give them each 10 strawberries, and then collecting the payout afterwards?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by renewiltord on Saturday January 08, 2022 @10:46PM (#29859822)
Haha, I'm sorry, I didn't mean that as an analogy for PoS. Just to make the point that it's two resources which can't be converted.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:27PM (#29841896)
Mining economics depend on the mining reward. It doesn't get bigger if more people mine. The rewards just get spread out over more/larger participants until profits are tiny via difficulty adjustments.

The mining effort depends simply on the reward, and the reward is calibrated to the security needed. Bitcoin is highly secure, but the security model is essentially 1:1; if the network is secured with a billion dollars of mining effort, it will cost on the order of a billion to attack it. So it's expensive.

PoS can have a better security model, maybe 1:100 against network attackers. So you can reduce mining rewards and maintain a given security level.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by jccooper on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:18PM (#29841759)
Non proof-of-work "mining" typically requires another resource. Proof-of-stake rewards you based on your holdings, so additional mining compute power doesn't help.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by throwaway3b03 on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:43AM (#29841308)
I don't think Ethereum PoS is ever coming anymore, or at least it will not displace the PoW version. It's been coming (TM) for a few years now.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by nostrademons on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:55AM (#29841494)
Ethereum PoS is live now through the beacon chain. Merge just hasn't happened yet.

It's sharding that's probably never coming.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by JohnJamesRambo on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:00PM (#29842366)
Why do you think sharding is never coming? Don't tell me that haha!
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by nostrademons on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:39PM (#29842927)
L2s like Polygon and Arbitrum are doing a decent job solving the scaling problem and don't require changes to the core protocol.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by JohnJamesRambo on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:44PM (#29847656)
Well I own Polygon too, so guess I'm covered both ways.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by JohnJamesRambo on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:51AM (#29841424)
I get this comment every time I post about it also. It’s the only ammo they have left.

The difficulty bomb and merge is set for June 2022. Could it be delayed? Sure I guess but Bitcoin has absolutely no plans to fix its energy consumption.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by kragen on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:24PM (#29842718)
As you see, even in a price spike, urea only costs US$1/kg. That really makes it hard to produce urea in the middle of the Sahara; shipping it to the ocean would cost more than the price it would fetch. Consequently there are lots of places where producing energy is economical if used for Bitcoin but not for fertilizer and other low-value-density products.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by pfdietz on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:36PM (#29842891)
This is why Namibia is looking at making hydrogen (and presumably ammonia): the desert there comes right down to the ocean. There are desert sand dunes right at the shore.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by SilasX on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:02PM (#29842383)
I agree with your general point (that crypto mining does come at the cost of energy for other purposes) but I'm not sure that's a good example -- I thought the energy input to fertilizer plants was from all the oil they take in which is chemically necessary; the major input isn't electricity per se, so being near a hydro dam wouldn't help.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by iSnow on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:44AM (#29841331)
I agree but this seems bigger than finding arbitrary hash values - after all, China shut down crypto mining months ago I think and yet they had to shut down a phosphate factory in December.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by okl on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:10AM (#29840803)
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by lettergram on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:21AM (#29840963)
CO2 also helps plants grow.

We should increase the atmospheres CO2 and urea production. More food for all!

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by beaconstudios on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:54AM (#29841474)
there's really more than enough CO2 in the atmosphere right now. The plants aren't struggling for it.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by mrfusion on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:33PM (#29841979)
Can you point to any research showing what the optimum level of co2 should be for plant growth?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by kragen on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:04PM (#29842431)
It depends on the plant. Most plants grow faster at higher levels than the current 400ppm, so CO₂ supplementation in greenhouses is a thing, which you can read about if you like. Some plants grow fastest at levels around 1000ppm, and I think for others it's closer to 10'000 ppm, at which level it starts to become toxic for the humans. Of course if Earth's atmosphere were 10'000 ppm CO₂ we would see mass extinctions, major ocean acidification, etc.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by beaconstudios on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:43PM (#29842117)
Can you? You're presumably the one arguing, in the face of the majority of climate scientists, that more CO2 is actually a good thing.

For what it's worth, no gardener or farmer is having to pump CO2 into the air because their plants are dying.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by mrfusion on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:45PM (#29842147)
Your claim was “plants aren’t struggling for it”

I’m asking if you can back up that claim. I guess not.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by beaconstudios on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:51PM (#29842225)
Struggling as in dying. I've seen no evidence that plants are dying of lack of CO2. In my research into permaculture I've never seen any issues with plants lacking CO2 - primarily plants struggle for nitrogen, hence the use of fertiliser (or in the case of permaculture, other nitrogen fixing techniques like using bacteria or cycling legumes, or cool stuff like using aquaponics to recycle fish poo into fertiliser).

Maybe they could grow even more successfully with some kind of CO2 biodome, I don't know - but my point was that lack of CO2 is not causing problems with plants growing, but it is causing problems with our biosphere slowly dying.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by renewiltord on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:02PM (#29842385)
Water helps people live. We should all be constantly drinking water. We will be so much more alive. Every living moment: drinking water.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by dane-pgp on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:24PM (#29844271)
Indeed. To be even more ridiculous: Being too cold kills people, therefore we should set ourselves on fire so we live forever.

If someone wants to argue "more CO2 is good for plants", they really need to provide a number for what atmospheric concentration they think is optimal, and what the costs/benefits of reaching it are. Would increasing the concentration by 10% make food 10% cheaper, for example? What sort of effects on the Earth's climate are historically associated with CO2 levels that high?

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by hypertele-Xii on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:41PM (#29845204)
That's not ridiculous, that's literally ancient history ongoing. Those early human tribes that managed to keep a fire going forever are us, today. Still living theoretically forever, as long as the water and fire (and the amazing combination thereof, hot water) keep on going.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by SavantIdiot on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:07PM (#29842474)
After watching people lose their minds over toilet paper, this is not going to be pretty.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by tastyfreeze on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:23PM (#29844264)
Indeed. Lack of food is, historically, the fastest way to revolution and war.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by xibalba on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:10AM (#29840791)
Wouldn't a 270% increase indicate a huge demand spike?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by colechristensen on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:16AM (#29840886)
No it’s a supply side problem, urea is synthesized from ammonia which is synthesized from methane and atmospheric nitrogen. Methane and in general fossil fuel prices spiked and brought fertilizer prices with it. There is probably also a covid labor component as well.

The family farm is planting a lot less corn as a result.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by short12 on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:34AM (#29841172)
The family farm is a thing of the past. They are called hobby farms
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by colechristensen on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:47AM (#29841366)
My father farming on ~400 acres purchased from the government ~140 years ago isn't a hobby. The records for the deed have only my relatives after the Louisiana Purchase. There aren't a whole lot of family farmers left out there, but they do exist (regardless of large operations branding themselves as "family farms" because "I have a family!" and what others classify them as).
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by rcpt on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:04PM (#29841608)
How do I interpret this?

https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/even-mega-farms-are-mos...

Most farms are "family" owned but perhaps OP was trying to communicate that nowadays farm owners are rarely farm workers?

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by colechristensen on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:12PM (#29841697)
A very large proportion of farms of any size have a single owner or are split between e.g. brothers.

A rather small proportion of farms are singly/family owned and have a majority of the work done by that family.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:44AM (#29841321)
Hobby farms generally are run by an individual. Family farms are run by families, and thus tend to be much larger to be able to support families.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by fullstop on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:31AM (#29841124)
If I remember correctly, sheep urine used to be used to clean particulate traps in large diesel engines. I'm not sure why things moved to synthetic, but if it was for cost reasons then sheep urine may be more cost effective than it used to be.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by iancmceachern on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:49PM (#29842209)
It was never from urine. It was always chemically synthesized
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by fullstop on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:54PM (#29842273)
I work with the bus industry, so this sort of stuff is on my periphery. This is what I was thinking of: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2005/jun/10/transportintheu...
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by nwatson on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:17AM (#29840900)
Goods whose supply has a natural upper limit in what's easily obtainable (given current methods and infra) and no easy substitutes in their use up the supply chain often have price spikes when (non-spiking) marginal demand suddenly bumps into that limit ... or else when there's a sudden limitation in the ability to deliver the usual supply of the good. Neither of these is a demand spike, per se.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by dredmorbius on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:32AM (#29841149)
Or a price increase in inputs, or a reduction in supply.

Most nitrogen fertiliser is supplied via natural gas formation (Haber-Bosch process). I'm not sure if urea is HB-formulated nitrogen or comes from other sources, but this wouldn't much matter as HB-formulated ammonia is near-exact substitute for urea and would follow similar pricing patterns.

Reading at Wikipedia iforms me that:

- Urea is CO2(NH2)2.

- Production is from ammonia + carbon dioxide.

Given that natural gas prices are presently spiking, my presumption would be that urea prices are following natural gas.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urea

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by conjectures on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:15AM (#29840877)
Depends what the cause is.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by ren_engineer on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:49AM (#29841398)
thankfully the WEF has the solution, the plebes will just have to get used to eating bugs for their protein

https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/07/why-we-need-to-give-i...

Thesis -> Antithesis -> Synthesis

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by nefitty on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:37PM (#29842045)
People eat shrimp and crab and lobster. Bugs are arthropods as well. They seem to perform similar functions in different contexts, eg, they feed on the waste of other animals.

The difference is historical and cultural inertia. Buttered cockroach could be the next big thing in Brooklyn.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by kragen on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:06PM (#29842462)
Cockroaches smell terrible, but I suppose Stilton does too.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by GekkePrutser on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:36PM (#29842016)
These are the guys that want us all to rent our stuff instead of buying it. "You will own nothing and you will be happy". Uh no.

I'm not going to buy bug burgers nor rent my stuff.

What we should do is more population control. As a first step stop incentives for having children (Inn the Netherlands you get more child benefit per child the more you have!). It's tough for the people that want big families but we can't continue growing humanity like this.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by dane-pgp on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:49PM (#29844620)
The Netherlands has a fertility rate of less than 1.7 births per woman[0]. The only reason its population is slightly increasing is that people are living longer and people want to move to the country. In fact, the population of Europe as a whole actually declined slightly last year.[1]

So we shouldn't be worrying about "big families", we should be worried about voluntary self-extinction. What do you think the correct population should be for the Netherlands or Europe, and what do you suggest we do when we reach it? Obviously the current level of government benefits per child aren't enough to keep the population level stable.

[0] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/NLD/netherlands/fertil...

[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/EUR/europe/population-...

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by GekkePrutser on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:46PM (#29845271)
I'm speaking about the world as a whole there. If the population of the Netherlands would decrease it would be good for the world as a whole. Of course any measures in asia would be far more powerful. But we have to set the example.

We have to stop viewing world problems as national issues. Just like the climate problem, we can be 'green' because we externalise a lot of our carbon problems to other countries. That's not helpful at all. It's just smart bookkeeping to keep behaving as we are.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by arbitrary_name on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:29PM (#29842796)
Ever eaten shrimp or crab?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by GekkePrutser on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:45PM (#29845257)
No I don't like seafood.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by motohagiography on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:21AM (#29840975)
If the prices are denominated in USD, and the consumers are in countries with stronger (less elastic) currencies, it's likely caused by inflation pressure from obvious sources like QE-infinity policy, debt monetization, and de-facto negative interest rates. What we are watching is the controlled demolition of western economies. It's not a conspiracy, it's an ideology that has prevailed and this is all downstream of it. I hope you like eating bugs.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by fennecfoxen on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:38AM (#29841219)
> If the prices are denominated in USD, and the consumers are in countries with stronger (less elastic) currencies

Well, that's not what's going on in the market.

This crisis is caused by a reduced supply of inputs, mostly natural gas and energy. One of the direct causes is Hurricane Ida, which had a massive impact on natural gas supplies. China has also experienced a coal shortage, and also a drought that reduced hydropower generation. Europe has done a lot to switch to renewables, but they've suffered low winds.

So no, the people who are going to hurt aren't rich Westerners, who are best positioned to ride this out. It's the poor people (mostly in the "global south") who already spend massive portions of their income on food, who will bear the brunt of this crisis.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by piva00 on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:56AM (#29841510)
Reading about this and considering the current price shock and inflation in Brazil makes me worried.

Right now, even before this fertiliser crisis materialises, there's already been a sizeable increase in food prices there, the pandemic pushed a new wave of homelessness and food insecurity after already some bad years before Bolsonaro came to power. Coupled with higher unemployment and overall loss of competitivity of Brazilian industry there just seems nowhere to go for society... If there is another food price hike it'll very likely cause massive social strife, I really don't see a way out if this crisis materialises in next year or so.

It will be brutal for the global south.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by motohagiography on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:44PM (#29842136)
I would agree that energy costs are a signifcant factor in fertilizer prices because slim margins mean significant price volatility as a result of the input factors, but what upper percentile of westerner qualifies as rich enough to ride this out, and what happens to the rest?

Given US economic policy directly caused this, wrapping it in climate narrative merely post-hoc justifies that the humans who will suffer from this deserve it because of climate change, and that the humans who are positioned to weather it deserve to have their resources and land redistributed to said victims because of climate change. If I had to guess who makes those redistribution decisions, because their divine authority comes from climate change, I would say committees of appointed politically aligned experts.

On this inflationary policy issue, the climate emperor is naked.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by dane-pgp on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:04PM (#29844796)
> the humans who are positioned to weather it deserve to have their resources and land redistributed to said victims because of climate change.

I mean, can you really disagree with the logic of this? The richest are likely to be the ones who have consumed the most and who have thus contributed most to climate change, and also they have the most resources available to help mitigate the problems they've caused. Given that they've benefited most from society, and have the most to lose if society collapses, they should be keen to pay their fair share (i.e. in proportion to their net wealth).

You may not like "committees of appointed politically aligned experts", but if they are appointed by democratically elected representatives (and unless you can point to some experts that are free from any political alignment), I'm not sure who would be better at making decisions for how resources are distributed to solve societal problems.

(For what it's worth, I thought your earlier comment about "controlled demolition of western economies" was thought-provoking, so I upvoted it).

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by motohagiography on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:52PM (#29845335)
Indeed, the point I was making was that the experts wouldn't be experts at all, they will be aparatchiks and party loyalists who can be trusted to maintain the narrative and ideology, just like they have been in every other variation of this scheme in the last 100 years.

What started with, "hey, maybe we shouldn't litter, and maybe we should stop companies from poisoning watersheds and wrecking land," has become, "we must centrally plan all economic activity according to political exigencies," and I'm saying this has precedents that ended terribly and I don't see it working this time either.

The issue of fertilizer prices is the effect of these policies designed to orchestrate a controlled demolition of the economy, which is a necessary step to disenfranchise the specific class of smallholders and business owners who naturally resist living under the regime of a planned economy, which operates on hallucinatory narratives designed to atomize and subjugate people. It's called "de-kulakization," and it's straight playbook.

The kaleidescope of absurd narratives we see right now are designed to "neutralize" people, that is, to make them believe nothing is true and trust nothing enough to resist what this cadre of terrible people are creating. It's a trip to watch it happen in real time after only having read about it in history, and to have the opportunity to provide commentary while it's happening, but this goes so badly, if a few more people can see wtf is happening, maybe we can mitigate the consequences.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by dane-pgp on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:31PM (#29845786)
> has become, "we must centrally plan all economic activity according to political exigencies,"

Could you give some examples of popular Western politicians currently advocating for centrally planning all economic activity?

If you stretch "all direct CO2 emissions" to mean the same as "all economic activity", and "taxing after the fact" to mean same as "centrally planning", then maybe 10% of Western politicians and voters would support what you're afraid of.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by motohagiography on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:07PM (#29879952)
The most obvious examples of planned economy measures include internal passports, lockdowns, debt monetization (money printing), corporate ESG investment requirements, etc.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by shkkmo on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:04PM (#29841610)
Which will probably mean we are headed into another round of popular uprisings. Lots of hungry people inevitably leads to lots is political instability.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:30AM (#29841117)
Time for lazy/ignorant farmers to switch to cover cropping with rotational grazing, which is just a better system as long as you're not financially dependent on planting your entire acreage every growing season.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by pddpro on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:32AM (#29841147)
I think that you shouldn't call other profession lazy/ignorant in general. People only tend to maximize their profits and minimize efforts, and this is natural. This, in no way, means that farmers are lazy and certainly not ignorant. A better rephrasing would be: "Time for farmers to switch ..."
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:37AM (#29841208)
News flash: I'm not talking about all farmers, I'm specifically talking about farmers who are either lazy or ignorant. Rotational grazing with cover crops is vastly superior to running fields constantly by juicing them with fertilizer and tilling. It does require knowledge, however, and the will to move livestock around regularly, which a lot of bad farmers lack.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by pddpro on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:52AM (#29841436)
A general advice that I have found useful in life is that if you see something that requires a change (in organization, business process, lifestyle or just about anything that has humans as a component) that doesn't directly involve yourself, then the best way to point it out is never to start with the assumption that people are just "lazy/ignorant". This is hostile and will usually have a negative effect on the willingness of the concerned individual to change.

Even in this case, the farmer who are farming on their own land are under no obligation to change their way of life or farming process. Even though we know that the methods they are using may be sub-optimal and a net-negative in the long run, we simply cannot make them change it, and certainly never by labelling them negative. We can make them see the benefits, or how it plays out in the long run and help them choose a better solution but ultimately, it's them doing the choosing.

At the end, if something is really really required, then it must be the Governments making regulation. This is how it generally works (I'm not saying I like it).

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:02PM (#29841585)
Let's try this: There are lazy/ignorant software engineers who write everything in a single file with no function because it's the easiest to write/initially run & test. This is a known terrible practice, but if you never have to deal with the code down the line, you wouldn't know this. There's nothing wrong with calling out the fact that these people are being lazy/ignorant.

Can the bad farmers continue to farm debt (primarily)? Sure, but if they're doing it to themselves we shouldn't feel bad for them, or bail them out.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by pddpro on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:23PM (#29841838)
No. If the code they write works for them, then they have done their job. People only realized that it was a bad practice once they found that the code was NOT doing their job (i.e. it was difficult to fix/debug when error occurred, it was immensely difficult to update, and it was nigh impossible to make sense of by your cohorts reading your code).

People only do what a) They are taught in the first place (programming classes, reliable blogs etc.), b) Their work environment imposes on them (organizations having coding practices or standards), c) They, through some personal experiences, find out that it makes their job easier down the line, or d) It is the right thing to do.

Expecting everyone to follow (d) is out of the question and in my experience all "good" work happens via (b) i.e. rules, regulations and standards that have been enforced. If some sub-optimal choice minimizes effort while maximizing rewards, then that is not sub-optimal, at least for the individual, even though it clearly could be a sub-optimal for the collective.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:48AM (#29841378)
I plant cover crops, but have no interest in animals. I have a software job to worry about when I'm not on the land and it would be economically foolish to trade that for time spent in animal husbandry. Nobody seems to want to rent my cover crops to feed their animals either, so I'm guessing I'm not the only who doesn't see the economic value.

Crops prices have priced in the increased fertilizer cost already, so it is what it is. We're used to it.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by cal5k on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:46AM (#29841353)
It's common for one farmer to plant and harvest thousands of acres pretty much by himself, at least in North America. Labour, particularly up in Canada, is often in short supply which makes moving livestock around impractical - and not all of them even keep livestock, because it's not profitable unless you're keeping thousands of head.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:56AM (#29841511)
The conventional ag model where you have one farmer monocropping a thousand acres are the reason the #1 thing most farmers grow is debt. That requires expensive specialized equipment, and much heavier application of pesticides and fertilizers than a balanced system, so both your fixed and variable costs are high.

If you want to see a profitable, productive mid sized farm, check out Polyface. Joel makes a good living while treating his land and animals well.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:03PM (#29841602)
Thing is that conventional farming, as you call it, and startups have a lot of in common. The goal is not to earn a tidy profit each year, but instead to build up massive capital for one huge payday when you get bought out. I suspect nobody really cares to see a profitable mid-sized farm as that kind of misses the appeal of farming. If you just want a steady income there are much better paying and less stressful jobs out there.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:32PM (#29841966)
The interesting thing is that there are a lot of young(ish) people interested in farming, who really do want to run a profitable mid-sized farm. Most of these people just don't have the resources to buy into land, so most of the ones that do it have inherited derelict farms. A few of them do it with leased land, but that's risky as regenerative ag requires a time investment and getting the rug pulled out from under you can be a real bummer.

I'd argue that our mega-ag model is a big part of the problem, it's given us stupidly cheap corn/soy while causing a lot of health and pollution problems, and basically ruining farming as an actual profession.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:42PM (#29842099)
Corn and soybeans are cheap because they're really easy to handle. The process is almost entirely automated at this point, allowing one person to do what would have required thousands of people in the past. Other areas of agriculture have not been so easy to remove the human element, requiring nearly as many people today as a century ago. With reduced scaling potential, you don't see the same cost reduction.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:33PM (#29842853)
The problem is that the cost reduction is a bit of an illusion, since your fertilizer, pesticide and herbicide costs are going to go up over time as your land turns marginal, and since there are so many mega-farms running huge GPS controlled equipment you're never going to be cost competitive at a smaller scale for corn/soy, but you have to accept the market price, which leaves a razor thin margin (if any at all).

The economics of farming are all fucked up, because our current farming practices have a lot of externalities that aren't priced into conventional produce, and producers who try to improve things to remove these externalities either have to take a loss versus the producers who say "fuck the future, fuck everyone who isn't me" or create new markets for their goods (which is where the whole farmer's market movement and the local food guilt thing come from).

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:08PM (#29843339)
> you're never going to be cost competitive at a smaller scale for corn/soy, but you have to accept the market price, which leaves a razor thin margin (if any at all).

You don't really need to be able to compete if you aren't looking for a massive exit, though. My ~150 acres (most of it rented, no less) of corn/soy/wheat provides enough for me to live off of comfortably enough. For about a month's work a year, that's wonderful in my mind.

It seems you're just getting caught up in the capital building frenzy that I talked about earlier. If you want to have the huge payday when you sell then you take on huge debt, grow to massive scale, use all of your income to service the debt and then you're sitting on a fortune at retirement. This is what attracts most people to farming, seemingly you included, which is fair.

If you are content to stay small you can avoid the debt and what the big guy is giving to the bank you can pocket and live well off of. That's where I've settled and it works fine. I won't have the huge payday later, however. It's a tradeoff.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:38PM (#29844482)
Good deal that you're able to make corn/soy work without being massively indebted. How much are you paying per acre? Also, I assume you're not selling to a coop or other large scale buyer?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:02PM (#29845445)
> How much are you paying per acre?

For rent? $265-275/acre, depending on the landlord.

> Also, I assume you're not selling to a coop or other large scale buyer?

No, that's where it all goes. There is a co-op grain elevator. All of my IP soybeans go there as they pay a nice little premium. Pretty much everything else, including crusher soys, is sold to the closer-to-home commercial grain elevator.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by reducesuffering on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:46PM (#29843769)
How did you get into farming? Is the trade in your family? I'm surprised 150 acres is only a month's work a year.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:24PM (#29845699)
I'm the seventh generation to farm, or something like that. My parents ran a dairy operation when I was a kid (and still operate their own farm), so I did grow up in agriculture. But, being a tech nerd, I was always more attracted to the big field equipment.

In 2007 I invested $12,000 in a small parcel of land I found to rent, rent for the equipment I needed to do the job (along with hiring some customer operators), and lost money doing it! But then 2008 happened, sending commodity prices through the roof. I was able to turn a small profit the following year and used the proceeds to start to buy some equipment, and slowly started to grow from there.

So, some definite luck, an investment, and most importantly having family to answer questions. I think it would have been impossible for me without that wealth of knowledge to draw on.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by toast0 on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:17PM (#29842616)
If you're running multiple crops, don't you need specialized equipment for each? Making it a bigger investment in equipment, or more likely to not have the right equipment at the right time if you have to rent/borrow it?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:42PM (#29842976)
That depends on the crop. Tree shakers and orchard/tree nut related equipment tends to be pretty standardized, and a lot of crops can share a small(-ish) common pool of tractor attachments, but if you choose your diversifications poorly you could be on the hook for some hefty equipment costs. Also, I would lean on cash crops where the SoTA is harvesting by migrant labor. There is definitely a knowledge/planning component to multi-cropping.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by eloff on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:36AM (#29841193)
I think there are real serious trade-offs here in income to the farmer. It's nothing about lazy or ignorance. Honestly to make a comment like that, add if you know more about their business than they do is both ignorant and arrogant - unless that really is your business and you know what you're talking about. But this feels like armchair commentary to me.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:38AM (#29841226)
Looks like you're armchair voting without subject matter knowledge. Do some research on no-till rotational grazing systems for natural fertility.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by fennecfoxen on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:48AM (#29841379)
"Do some research?" Feh. Show us P&L statements for your choice of no-till rotational-grazing farm, or even this "research" is just a hobbyist diversion.

Now myself, I like hobbyist diversions that involve growing food, but farmers don't farm because they want to have fun. They farm so they can make money. If they stop making money, or if they don't make enough, they have to go into some other line of work, and typically sell the farm to someone who does make money.

And when you're not just selling gourmet vegetables to HN hackers making $200k+ a year, you're selling generic commodities like corn and grain and soy, where the competition is fierce.

And you're selling it to a world where the poor have a hard time affording food as it is. If this can't compete with conventional fertilizer, then even if everyone switched, people would starve.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:58AM (#29841537)
https://www.dnb.com/business-directory/company-profiles.poly...

Joel is the best known example of informed, conscientious farming paying the bills, but certainly not the only one.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by bazzert on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:40PM (#29842074)
I'm curious if you are a farmer yourself or in some other way qualified for such a pejorative statement.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by mellavora on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:09PM (#29841654)
So while I'd agree that no-till/rotational farming is superior in many many ways, and while I would very much like to see its wide-scale implementation, I also note your final line:

>as long as you're not financially dependent on planting your entire acreage every growing season.

which to me suggests that it isn't "lazy/ignorant" farmers, but rather farmers who are economically entangled in the current system.

Maybe the place to start would be objecting to i.e. Monsanto, or to producer demands such as McDonalds who require only a certain kind of potato grown under certain kinds of conditions (so all the fries look the same).

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by imtringued on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:53PM (#29844653)
They are not ignorant. They are following the discounting model imposed by "lenders".
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by Kletiomdm on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:34AM (#29841173)
Sounds to me like reducing the overall production.

What's the befit if fertilizer helps?

That it looks more natural?

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:46AM (#29841361)
Tilling and fertilizing gives you a great yield today, but damages the long term fertility of the land, and pollutes nearby waterways. The best analogy is buying things on credit. You might feel rich at first, but when the debt comes due and you can't afford it bankruptcy is a bitch.

It does require letting some land lie fallow to regeneration, so you need to devote more total land to agriculture, and it also requires fencing and for someone to go move the livestock to a new paddock every few days (though you save on tilling/herbicide application costs). On the plus side the unit cost of everything you produce is lower, and meat is typically much more profitable than vegetables so you've diversified.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by dev_tty01 on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:43PM (#29842987)
I've never met a single successful farmer that is either lazy or ignorant. Most people would never last a full week working on a farm. As far as rotational grazing, if you don't think modern farmers understand nutritional cycles you are sadly misinformed.