News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @11:56AM (#29841511)
The conventional ag model where you have one farmer monocropping a thousand acres are the reason the #1 thing most farmers grow is debt. That requires expensive specialized equipment, and much heavier application of pesticides and fertilizers than a balanced system, so both your fixed and variable costs are high.

If you want to see a profitable, productive mid sized farm, check out Polyface. Joel makes a good living while treating his land and animals well.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:03PM (#29841602)
Thing is that conventional farming, as you call it, and startups have a lot of in common. The goal is not to earn a tidy profit each year, but instead to build up massive capital for one huge payday when you get bought out. I suspect nobody really cares to see a profitable mid-sized farm as that kind of misses the appeal of farming. If you just want a steady income there are much better paying and less stressful jobs out there.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:32PM (#29841966)
The interesting thing is that there are a lot of young(ish) people interested in farming, who really do want to run a profitable mid-sized farm. Most of these people just don't have the resources to buy into land, so most of the ones that do it have inherited derelict farms. A few of them do it with leased land, but that's risky as regenerative ag requires a time investment and getting the rug pulled out from under you can be a real bummer.

I'd argue that our mega-ag model is a big part of the problem, it's given us stupidly cheap corn/soy while causing a lot of health and pollution problems, and basically ruining farming as an actual profession.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @12:42PM (#29842099)
Corn and soybeans are cheap because they're really easy to handle. The process is almost entirely automated at this point, allowing one person to do what would have required thousands of people in the past. Other areas of agriculture have not been so easy to remove the human element, requiring nearly as many people today as a century ago. With reduced scaling potential, you don't see the same cost reduction.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:33PM (#29842853)
The problem is that the cost reduction is a bit of an illusion, since your fertilizer, pesticide and herbicide costs are going to go up over time as your land turns marginal, and since there are so many mega-farms running huge GPS controlled equipment you're never going to be cost competitive at a smaller scale for corn/soy, but you have to accept the market price, which leaves a razor thin margin (if any at all).

The economics of farming are all fucked up, because our current farming practices have a lot of externalities that aren't priced into conventional produce, and producers who try to improve things to remove these externalities either have to take a loss versus the producers who say "fuck the future, fuck everyone who isn't me" or create new markets for their goods (which is where the whole farmer's market movement and the local food guilt thing come from).

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:08PM (#29843339)
> you're never going to be cost competitive at a smaller scale for corn/soy, but you have to accept the market price, which leaves a razor thin margin (if any at all).

You don't really need to be able to compete if you aren't looking for a massive exit, though. My ~150 acres (most of it rented, no less) of corn/soy/wheat provides enough for me to live off of comfortably enough. For about a month's work a year, that's wonderful in my mind.

It seems you're just getting caught up in the capital building frenzy that I talked about earlier. If you want to have the huge payday when you sell then you take on huge debt, grow to massive scale, use all of your income to service the debt and then you're sitting on a fortune at retirement. This is what attracts most people to farming, seemingly you included, which is fair.

If you are content to stay small you can avoid the debt and what the big guy is giving to the bank you can pocket and live well off of. That's where I've settled and it works fine. I won't have the huge payday later, however. It's a tradeoff.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:38PM (#29844482)
Good deal that you're able to make corn/soy work without being massively indebted. How much are you paying per acre? Also, I assume you're not selling to a coop or other large scale buyer?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:02PM (#29845445)
> How much are you paying per acre?

For rent? $265-275/acre, depending on the landlord.

> Also, I assume you're not selling to a coop or other large scale buyer?

No, that's where it all goes. There is a co-op grain elevator. All of my IP soybeans go there as they pay a nice little premium. Pretty much everything else, including crusher soys, is sold to the closer-to-home commercial grain elevator.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by reducesuffering on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:46PM (#29843769)
How did you get into farming? Is the trade in your family? I'm surprised 150 acres is only a month's work a year.
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by randomdata on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:24PM (#29845699)
I'm the seventh generation to farm, or something like that. My parents ran a dairy operation when I was a kid (and still operate their own farm), so I did grow up in agriculture. But, being a tech nerd, I was always more attracted to the big field equipment.

In 2007 I invested $12,000 in a small parcel of land I found to rent, rent for the equipment I needed to do the job (along with hiring some customer operators), and lost money doing it! But then 2008 happened, sending commodity prices through the roof. I was able to turn a small profit the following year and used the proceeds to start to buy some equipment, and slowly started to grow from there.

So, some definite luck, an investment, and most importantly having family to answer questions. I think it would have been impossible for me without that wealth of knowledge to draw on.

Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by toast0 on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:17PM (#29842616)
If you're running multiple crops, don't you need specialized equipment for each? Making it a bigger investment in equipment, or more likely to not have the right equipment at the right time if you have to rent/borrow it?
Re:Urea prices increase 270% in 1 year by CuriouslyC on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:42PM (#29842976)
That depends on the crop. Tree shakers and orchard/tree nut related equipment tends to be pretty standardized, and a lot of crops can share a small(-ish) common pool of tractor attachments, but if you choose your diversifications poorly you could be on the hook for some hefty equipment costs. Also, I would lean on cash crops where the SoTA is harvesting by migrant labor. There is definitely a knowledge/planning component to multi-cropping.