News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by dredmorbius on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:29AM (#29703243)
Any system capable of running OpenWRT.

https://openwrt.org/supported_devices

You might find / inquire about specific devices at the OpenWRT subreddit:

https://old.reddit.com/r/openwrt/

The Turris Omnia is priced above your preferred range, but is effectively a small server and has excellent capabilities. It runs a specifically-tuned and live-upgradable version of OpenWRT:

https://www.turris.com/en/omnia/overview/

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by ramphastidae on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:08PM (#29704285)
IMHO, skip OpenWRT. It is much more difficult to get working correctly than HN likes to admit. There’s a non-trivial chance you will spend hours and hours reflashing your router and reading forum posts until you eventually brick it. It’s just like Raspberry Pis. Theoretically the right choice but practically speaking a huge time sink and poor, unstable experience that is best left to hobbiest tinkering or networking professionals with a lot of spare time.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by fartcannon on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:04PM (#29704918)
Forgive me if this sounds arrogant, but I think the general HN user is capable of handling the relatively simple UI based download and flash required to use OpenWRT. Likewise, using a raspberry pi is probably trivial for most developers. If not, I'm being under paid.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by garbagecoder on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:51PM (#29705467)
I think most people are capable. It’s whether it’s worth it. I loved learning more about Linux and networking with it, and loved having automatic cell failover, but at the end of the day, it was too unreliable.

So, forgive me for how this sounds, but the general HN user probably needs a reliable as possible internet link.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by fartcannon on Monday December 27, 2021 @05:02PM (#29707359)
Again, it's a download and a 'flash' in a GUI. Probably couldn't be simpler. As for reliability, my house has two of the same routers - one runs openwrt, the other runs the factory default (unfortunately it's not mine, so I can't just change it at will). Can you guess which is unreliable? It's the factory default.

This is not to mention the security implications of having a non-open source router. Never trust a third party like that. Some even try to get you to use an app.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by garbagecoder on Monday December 27, 2021 @05:10PM (#29707419)
“Works on my machine” isn’t a very constructive response. You have a lot more work than that to do if you don’t get the right hardware. It’s decent if you don’t change the defaults, I guess but then what’s the point?! Try installing almost any package and sometimes it will just lock up.

An actual misconfigured/buggy router is a bigger security concern for me than a potential back door. Also, what makes you think open source software matters if the hardware is closed? Do you have a pine router or something?

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by fartcannon on Monday December 27, 2021 @07:01PM (#29708497)
I wish! That'd be rad.

There was an article just the other day about how google is sunsetting a mesh router they built. That's what you get if you don't take the frankly small amount of time to wrench control of your hardware from its parent companies. You're worried about security? Bad news, if you're not doing your own updates, your security can and will be sunset.

But I get it, you don't wanna. Not much more to be said than that I suppose.

... Does pine make a router?

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by numpad0 on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:35PM (#29710042)
Say you pick up an average HNer and if they couldn’t pick up a Pi make it do a barrel roll in couple days, you might be disappointed. But if you could give them an Amazon URL and he could set up a Wi-Fi infra with >95% SLA in 5 minutes, there can literally be cost difference measured at $10k range, for a minor detriment of having an annoying router in the household.

There are the other kind of HNer who are that pillar in xkcd Dependency comic, but for the former kind, OpenWRT as it is right now is just waste of their time.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by fartcannon on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @01:45AM (#29711150)
I just don't believe this is true.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by JeremyNT on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @10:30AM (#29714637)
This is very different from my experiences. You need to spend a little time setting up any router, and the only meaningful added step for a basic working configuration when compared to stock is the flashing process. Once you have it working, in my experience, it's incredibly reliable.

Whatever issues you had are not the common path IMO. I've run openwrt essentially for as long as it's been a thing and the only instability I ever had was due to my ISP. I'm sure if you end up with some esoteric, poorly supported, or flaky hardware things can be different, but this is far from universal!

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by Faaak on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:21PM (#29704415)
I don't really see what you're talking about. I've flashed all of my routers and _never_ had a problem.

Maybe the thing that took me the most time was to decide which version to use or whether I should use openwrt vs tomato vs other competitors

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by ramphastidae on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:40PM (#29704648)
Your post history says you use Dvorak and Vim, and were tinkering with your school’s network at 15, so I think my point stands :)
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by yladiz on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:43PM (#29704673)
I would second the parent, I installed and use OpenWRT on my router without much issue. Flashing and configuring was quite easy, and really the most difficult part was actually getting the router because the local shops (MediaMarkt) don’t have many/any compatible routers.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by MandieD on Monday December 27, 2021 @06:24PM (#29708228)
If somewhat recently, which model, because MediaMarkt is also my main local option (RIP, Conrad)
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by Faaak on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:49PM (#29704736)
Well, indeed you're right on this point but on the second hand flashing a router is just selecting the firmware and clicking on "Flash". I never had a bricked router. I didn't flash a lot, but at least 6 or so. Maybe I was lucky
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by tomc1985 on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:14PM (#29705035)
Everyone should strive to this level of competence, and I like that some of the posts here (like advice for installing OpenWRT) kind of force it

Breaking stuff and then fixing it is the fast track for learning

If you're not a smart computer guy then maybe this isnt the forum for you

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by D13Fd on Monday December 27, 2021 @04:27PM (#29706961)
Being efficient is part of being smart. Sadly the older you are the less time you have to spend time trying to fix things that you don't care about, and the less the knowledge you gain is worth to you (simply because you have less career- and life-span left to use it).

Yes, I've flashed routers in the past, including the Linksys WRT54G, and in some cases I've even built a dedicated PC to run as a router, back when that was a bit more in vogue.

But is it worth the time to do it yet again? Probably not. I'd rather get an Apple-like router that works perfectly out of the box, with sensible defaults and little configuration necessary, and which is regularly auto-updated with security fixes. That way I can spend my time on new things.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by karmakaze on Monday December 27, 2021 @04:43PM (#29707131)
Tomato, is that still going strong? I remember using it for its MLPPP capability. The QoS never worked that well with it as I recall.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by Rebelgecko on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:34PM (#29705244)
FWIW I've had the opposite experience. The stock firmware on my TP-Link router was awful. It was a pain to update and I frequently had to reboot the thing because it decided to stop working. Installing OpenWRT took maybe 15 minutes and an hour or so of fiddling and setting up my port forwarding and static IPs. Now my router's uptime is measured in months (and that's only because of power outages)
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by howdydoo on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:42PM (#29704663)
Nothing in life has a 100% success rate. But I think the fact that most people recommend OpenWrt, shows that most people don't have these crazy problems. Buy well-supported hardware, follow the directions carefully, and you'll be just fine.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by ramphastidae on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:49PM (#29704735)
Certainly. But I had a very difficult time. I purchased an ASUS router recommended by the OpenWRT website, followed directions but struggled for hours, and eventually bricked it only to find out later via searching forum posts that some routers with that model number are not supported if they were made in a specific year (of course, this was discovered via trial and error by other frustrated forum members, no one had updated the original recommendations to reflect this, and installing the recommended firmware destroyed the router irreversibly).
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday December 27, 2021 @03:27PM (#29706415)
Really irreversible, or could it be reflashed via so called 'JTAG-cable', and serial terminal, tftp, or maybe even https://www.flashrom.org/Flashrom (but then with other cables and plugs, because most likely directly writing into the chip without any intermediaries)?
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by opan on Monday December 27, 2021 @04:50PM (#29707219)
I would personally avoid ASUS as they tend to use Broadcom NICs, which never have good free software support. If one was recommended, maybe it was an exception, but I'd still try to avoid ASUS.

If you want a cheap rec that's easy to get OpenWrt on, get a Netgear R6220 off eBay. I've gotten 3 of them for $20 each or so.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by 042 on Monday December 27, 2021 @05:05PM (#29707379)
This was exactly what happened to me. Certain tp-link routers made specifically for Italy got bricked if you installed OpenWRT on them.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday December 27, 2021 @03:12PM (#29706267)
If you manage to brick your router by messing with OpenWRT, you're maybe better of with the factory default 'for dummies' interface. Most cheap plastics have something like 'recovery' built in. It's like rescue 'BIOS' becoming active after a while, or via some reset button push code, where it is accessible on a default IP, and reflashable via browser. This seems to be the case since at about 10 years? What sometimes is lacking, is the documentation about the specifics of factory defaults for different devices and revisions thereof.

I never felt the 'instability', at least not when I limited myself to the basics a thing like that should do, and not trying to turn it into a server for all sorts of things.

(Edit: Though you can also do that, if you know what you are doing. That's the advantage of things like these!)

Depending on which hardware/SOC you have, DD-Wrt may be a better option.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by globular-toast on Monday December 27, 2021 @03:06PM (#29706214)
I think you just need to go in with an understanding of what a router and related things (access point, switch, modem etc.) actually are. Too many people think router is just "that thing that gives me internet via wifi". If you are one of those, you might not have a good time with OpenWRT or Pfsense etc.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by dredmorbius on Monday December 27, 2021 @11:25PM (#29710376)
The Turris Omnia is preconfigured with OpenWRT, specifically tuned to the hardware, and auto-updates.

It's cloud-free, spyware-free, adware-free.

The default configuration works with the same basic configuration any consumer-grade system would require.

Extensive configuration capability is offered through either of two graphical front-ends, the basic Turris, the advanced Luci, or for those who prefer talking in words rather than gestures, a highly capable Linux system residing underneath.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by jcpham2 on Monday December 27, 2021 @02:10PM (#29705696)
OpenWRT is the only thing I would recommend - all the consumer routers have turned to trash.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by cpach on Monday December 27, 2021 @04:05PM (#29706762)
Eero is an exception there. Their quality is terrific.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by unmole on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:17PM (#29709924)
> IMHO, skip OpenWRT. It is much more difficult to get working correctly than HN likes to admit.

Does not match my experience at all. My router would regularly go offline with the stock firmware which never happened after I flashed OpenWRT.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by cyanydeez on Monday December 27, 2021 @09:33PM (#29709641)
took about q5 minutes to setup. perhaps you chose the wrong router.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by sircastor on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:47PM (#29704719)
I like the idea of running OpenWRT. I did it for years. I eventually grew tired of being my own Network admin. The risk of bricking my router, and having to review what felt like arcane update rules before every upgrade process made me finally cave and just get an Eero. I don't love the lack of features, and I really don't like Amazon owning the company, but it works for me.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by webstrand on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:48AM (#29703422)
The Omnia looks really nice. But in their advertising script they claim they have "LTE antennas", does anyone know what they mean by that claim? I had thought LTE was only a term used by the cellular telecommunications industry.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by cassianoleal on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:54AM (#29703490)
The way they phrased it could be clearer, but what they mean is that you can add an LTE modem and add 2 antennas on top of the regular 3 WiFi ones.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by FractalParadigm on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:53AM (#29703476)
It's possible they mean exactly what they're writing - my ISP has an option (usually part of their business package but can be had for home users by talking to the right person) where you can rent their WiFi modem that includes LTE/5G hardware and service as a backup connection in the event the main coax line goes down.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by mdavis6890 on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:54AM (#29703486)
Likely for a backup cell/LTE WAN connection. Sounds like a nice feature, if it's actually what I think.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by zx76 on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:39PM (#29704635)
Pretty sure this is the correct answer. I've had a D-link router in the past that could fail over from ADSL to 3G in the event that the ADSL stopped working.

If just one backup isn't enough for you then this article [1] about a developer at Gitpod who works remotely might be of interest. He has 6 redundant LTE and 5G connections on his van!

[1] https://ghuntley.com/internet/

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by SR2Z on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:54AM (#29703485)
There is a cellular LTE modem that can be used as a backup internet connection if the primary one goes down.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by dredmorbius on Monday December 27, 2021 @11:12AM (#29703659)
The device is hardware-hackable.

You can add additional rewritable onboard storage. And an LTE modem for mobile data.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by droningparrot on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:59PM (#29704860)
I've had good experiences running OpenWRT on the TP-Link Archer C7. It's a popular router and I've been able to find plenty of them used for around $40
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by clircle on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:11PM (#29705000)
I've got a C7 and it doesn't even need a cloud account to set up
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by cpach on Monday December 27, 2021 @04:07PM (#29706788)
The default firmware on C7 is quite nice and is good enough for most users. I guess OpenWRT gives more options for power-users though.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by dehrmann on Monday December 27, 2021 @03:09PM (#29706241)
I usually get a Mikrotik device when I'm going to use OpenWRT. Hardware support tends to be pretty good.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by shadowoflight on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:24PM (#29704488)
I'd personally recommend FreshTomato[0] over OpenWRT, as it has a more approachable UI, is still open-source, and (in my experience) tends to run a bit smoother while needing less babysitting.

[0]: https://freshtomato.org/

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by PaulKeeble on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:59PM (#29704853)
It has serious updating issues however requiring you to completely setup the router every time you update and the update process is entirely manual. I like FreshTomato I have used it for some years but the wifi performance sucks and the constant clearing of settings just grates over time.

This is something commercial routers get right, updates keep your settings. This requirement will cause you to delay if you use any of the complexity of the router and that leaves you open to attacks. IMO its not a great choice today due to this one fatal flaw.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by numpad0 on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:46PM (#29710118)
That is also something Cisco gets rightest.

hostname# _

hostname# sho run

This is all it takes to backup ALL config. Also a short form of “show running-config”. If you follow best practices and take logs of all ssh connection it’s naturally there a second after.

Restoring? Just paste it on HyperTerminal. Cisco sues anyone who dares to replicate this exact behavior(e.g. Huawei-3Com), but similar commands exist for most professional network equipment such as Vyatta/VyOS’ `show configuration commands`.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by shadowoflight on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:08PM (#29704965)
Updating FreshTomato has never cleared out my settings, is it possible your install is broken?

Manual updates don't bother me, personally, but wifi throughput is definitely a pain point (my understanding is the lower speeds are due to FreshTomato doing more with the CPU than stock firmware does, which decreases the amount of CPU time that actual routing gets).

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by pc86 on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:43AM (#29703367)
I'd never heard of the Omnia before, I'll have to check this out it looks pretty neat!
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by cassianoleal on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:49AM (#29703431)
I was also recommending it here (posted before seeing the parent): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29703321

I own one and it has not always been great. At one point their fork of OpenWRT was so different from upstream that upgrades were taking a long time and introduced lots of bugs.

Since the last major version or 2 though, they've upstreamed most of the drivers and custom code, so TurrisOS is just a few patches and packages on top of OpenWRT to better support the specific hardware and services, and it's been very stable.

One incredibly useful feature is BTRFS snapshots and the `schnapps` CLI to manage them. The hardware reset button can even be used to roll back to factory defaults, from where you can still access and restore any snapshot so it's very easy to unbrick the router if you make a mistake.

Add an M.2 NVMe card and you can run LXC containers (and in the next major release, even Docker).

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by SweetLullaby on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:10PM (#29704305)
the same, never heard about it
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by antihero on Monday December 27, 2021 @11:51AM (#29704079)
Does OpenWRT still mean that speeds are slower due to not having proprietary drivers?
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday December 27, 2021 @03:51PM (#29706633)
Doesn't matter, because you cän OVERCLOQQ!1!!

https://openwrt.org/docs/techref/bootloader/pepe2k

https://github.com/pepe2k/u-boot_mod

No, seriously ;-) What you are thinking of is probably described here https://openwrt.org/docs/techref/hardware/switch and has a long history.

Basically it depends on having opensourced drivers, or at least specifications for the internals of the affected switcheroos, which wasn't the case for many chips for a long time, and still isn't for all of them.

Then there is the part of writing a unifying and usable abstraction for all of that, which also isn't fully there yet, at least not for every device under the sun.

Read up here: https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/networking/switchdev....

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 29, 2021 @12:19AM (#29722161)
Not to any significant extent AFAIA, though specifics will depend on the device, components, and drivers in question.

In almost all cases, OpenWRT extends rather than restricts device capabilities.

That said: choose your hardware based on OpenWRT support if at all possible.

Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by NortySpock on Monday December 27, 2021 @12:13PM (#29704334)
I would also suggest dd-wrt as an alternative; it seemed a little easier to find a working build and I've eventually gotten used to the UI organization.
Re:Ask HN: Please recommend a router without need for a clou... by dredmorbius on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:38AM (#29733996)
I've used dd-wrt for over a decade. Issues:

- Seems very badly out of date.

- Far more limited capabilities

- Much less clear upgrade capabilities / path.

If it works for you, then sure. I'd lean strongly to OpenWRT.

Much of my dd-wrt comments also applies to Tomato from what I've been able to sort.

dd-wrt and Tomato were built for systems as they existed a decade or two ago, notably the venerable Linksys WRT54G router. These work, but have highly constrained hardware.