News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by waiseristy on Thursday December 23, 2021 @11:47PM (#29670330)
Which brings up a fun question; At which point does pressing buttons on a screen to play a video game while driving cause just as much distraction as pressing buttons on a screen to manage your windshield wipers / drive mode / HVAC / windows?

There used to be a lot of crashes attributed to "playing with the radio" in the 90's / 00's. Maybe all those buttons on the wheel and a display centered in the drivers cone of vision were actually huge advancements in safety...

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by warning26 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @11:53PM (#29670374)
Honestly, I wish the powers-that-be would crack down harder on touchscreens in vehicles. There is no case where manipulating a touchscreen while driving is safe, for one simple reason: you have to look at the screen to use it because there's no tactile feedback.

They are truly, as that one book title went, unsafe at any speed.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by jeroenhd on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:00AM (#29670418)
There have been some experiments with effective tactile feedback provided by touch screens, but they're complicated to produce and expensive. Most of the research seems to be aimed at providing touch screens to the visually impaired.

It's possible to get some kind of tactile response mimicking the edges of buttons well enough. I'd say a good implementation of this technology would be safe IF the position and availability of the controls would be static. I'm not sure what you'd get out of a touch screen with those constraints (less parts?), especially with the added cost and research, but that's the only way I can see a touch screen in a car that should ever be legal.

A Tesla driver in Germany already got fined for using the touch screen of his car while driving. It's strange how this obvious flaw of a car design has ever been allowed onto the roads.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by pxc on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:35AM (#29670614)
> It's strange how this obvious flaw of a car design has ever been allowed onto the roads.

It's strange that anyone thinks it's even desirable. Touchscreens aren't even pleasant to use in this context.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by DavidPeiffer on Friday December 24, 2021 @01:49AM (#29671029)
I hate touchscreens in cars, but I'll give Tesla the fact that their touchscreen is a modern screen that's not a complete piece of crap to interact with.

When phones can run at 30 fps and have no noticeable lag, it's infuriating to switch to a car which stutters on some ugly, unnecessary graphics and takes 0.25 seconds to respond to a touch input. Not to mention the whole "you're supposed to be driving a car" aspect.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:25AM (#29671228)
You phone doesn't have to survive 125C for ten years of continual vibration.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by DavidPeiffer on Friday December 24, 2021 @06:50AM (#29672843)
It doesn't. If you can't provide an adequate user experience free of large input delays, you should have never installed a touchscreen in the first place. Infotainment systems have gotten less bad, but I haven't seen notable advancement in reducing time spent with eyes off of the road the way a physical button or knob does.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by adamcstephens on Friday December 24, 2021 @09:37AM (#29673914)
They install touchscreens because they think people want them. The cars sell, because the only choice is touchscreens, and their decisions are validated. Rinse and repeat.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by warning26 on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:03AM (#29670432)
> ...safe IF the position and availability of the controls would be static

Agreed -- this was also why the Apple Touchbar failed, IMO.

Typically keyboard use relies on a lot of muscle memory, and so the touchbar's "you get a different set of controls with different shapes and sizes that do different things depending on which app you're using" design ethos didn't really fit with how people actually use keyboards.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by toast0 on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:51AM (#29670709)
Soft buttons aren't terrible. F-keys are an example where the same button could mean different things in different contexts, but they're tactile. Or if you had a Ti-85 (or 86), it had soft f1-5 and was a lot more flexible than the Ti-82 which had hard function keys. You could get muscle memory of entering menus and using the f keys that would be presented. Of course, hopefully a car doesn't have quite so deep of a menu tree.

If buttons are too expensive and you want to reduce the count, if I press radio and then F1, that could be radio preset 1, and if I press fan and then F1, that turns the fan speed to 1 of 6 (which could be off, I don't really care), that would be fine, and then you don't need quite so many buttons. Otoh, if I'm paying $20k or more for a car, you can afford some buttons.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by ehnto on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:03AM (#29670436)
If your eyes aren't on the road, you aren't driving. I have zero sympathy for any of the edge cases people tend to bring up except checking your speed. Just drive the car. Take your tech-addled brains out of dopamine acquisition mode for the duration of the drive, then have a big 'ol binge at the end if you must.

It's such trivial things that people risk their lives for too. A sort of trashy naivety. Like smoking at the gas pump.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by perl4ever on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:50AM (#29670695)
>If your eyes aren't on the road, you aren't driving.

>I have zero sympathy for any of the edge cases people tend to bring up except checking your speed.

You're saying the speedometer is the only instrument that needs to be scanned regularly?

I would've said that the speedometer really isn't needed - if you go with traffic and don't hang out in the passing lane, you're never going to get in trouble.

It's a lot more important to me to know if I've lost oil pressure or am overheating.

And if the HVAC controls are unnecessary to mess with while driving, they are still not an "edge case". Nor is the radio.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by metaphor on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:17AM (#29671912)
> You're saying the speedometer is the only instrument that needs to be scanned regularly?

In practice, I'd hazard a yes.

Keyword: regularly...unless you're driving something that's pissing oil all over the place and/or has a cooling system that's out of service, at which point you clearly have much bigger maintenance problems and probably shouldn't be on the road with that vehicle anyways (perhaps even in a lawful sense).

> I would've said that the speedometer really isn't needed - if you go with traffic and don't hang out in the passing lane, you're never going to get in trouble.

The obvious naivety here is a dependency on another driver ahead of you both maintaining situational awareness and doing the right thing...never mind sparse traffic scenarios, e.g. super late/early hours, neighborhoods, small towns, rural areas, etc. In the case of incident, the police won't care; your insurance provider won't care.

> It's a lot more important to me to know if I've lost oil pressure or am overheating.

Contrived. There's a reason why high-contrast event indicators (termed "telltale" as defined by US FMVSS statutory regulation[1]) baked directly into every passenger vehicle which control for permissible location, identification, color, and illumination targeting driver visibility. These discrete telltales are explicitly designed to ping a driver's peripheral vision with the intent of eliminating a need for active monitoring in practice.

[1] https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-49/subtitle-B/chapter-V/p...

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by perl4ever on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:08PM (#29678235)
I actually have had the speedometer break on my car. There's no idiot light to tell you it's broken, let alone that it's going to break.

I never had to use it as an excuse.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by ehnto on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:17AM (#29671187)
While you're underway there aren't many other things you should be keeping an eye on, but that was an absolutist stance to make a point. I know people are going to be glancing at fuel or temperature or whatever.

> I would've said that the speedometer really isn't needed - if you go with traffic and don't hang out in the passing lane, you're never going to get in trouble

That's really location specific, and situation specific. We can't go over ~5kmph faster than the limit here without getting fined by speed cameras. Also 10kmph faster on a highway versus 10kmph faster in town are very different. 10kmph faster in town could be the difference between killing someone or not hitting them at all.

I do somewhat agree though, I think "driving to the conditions" for me personally would be totally fine, I'd probably trend to driving slower than the speed limit. But if you had no limit and no enforcement, people would be abusing it all the time. Someone in a hurry in town would easily cause trouble. The tradeoff for limiting that is having to check your speedometer.

10kmph = 6.2mph.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by perl4ever on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:12PM (#29678259)
>10kmph faster in town could be the difference between killing someone or not hitting them at all.

I think of the difference between hitting someone and not hitting them as measured in distance, not speed.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by ehnto on Saturday December 25, 2021 @12:02AM (#29680589)
Speed determines time to stop including stopping distance and reaction time. For every second of reaction time per 10kmph you add about 4 meters of distance travelled before you even hit the brakes. So best case if you aren't looking at your HVAC, at 50kmph you will start the stopping process in about 28 meters, and at 60kmph it will be 33.3m and take longer to stop once you hit the pegs.

Doesn't sound like heaps but that is actually your margin for error, just 4m. If something jumps out in front of you at 28 meters away, at 50 you will have had 4 meters to stop, which modern cars can do, and at 60 you will hit them at the full 60kmph. The Australian government has some great road safety clips on the subject, I might try and find them.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by ehnto on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:49AM (#29672505)
> It's a lot more important to me to know if I've lost oil pressure or am overheating.

> And if the HVAC controls are unnecessary to mess with while driving, they are still not an "edge case". Nor is the radio.

I forgot to address these sorry.

I've driven some pants cars in my time so I get it, but I'd say you be the judge of just how distracted you are with mechanical worries and if that's a safe amount or not.

I think HVAC being on tactile controls makes the difference here, but ultimately you could check them when you've stopped if it's too much of a hassle. Sometimes I try to get it set, but can't figure it out quickly, so give up and just set it at the next point I'm idling.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by perl4ever on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:13PM (#29678267)
There's an implicit message from new cars having lane-keeping features that we as a society (whichever society) are going to compensate for distractions rather than cracking down.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by ehnto on Saturday December 25, 2021 @12:07AM (#29680614)
I agree. It's too hard to police without invasive cameras or tracking.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by 2muchcoffeeman on Friday December 24, 2021 @01:00AM (#29670756)
Unfortunately in AU too many people speed. Going with the flow would result in a few fines I’d rather not have.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by perl4ever on Friday December 24, 2021 @05:19PM (#29678320)
If you drive at the 49th percentile of speed, you would expect financially burdensome fines on a regular basis?

This may be naive, but I've assumed that it is practically impossible to enforce laws that a majority of the population habitually breaks.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by ehnto on Saturday December 25, 2021 @12:11AM (#29680639)
Australia is a unique situation, the fines are enormous, and policing speed is a top priority for law enforcement here. Lots of automated cameras and hidden mobile cameras. My last speeding fine for < 10km over was $786. You only get to do that four times before losing your license temporarily, so you can't just pay the fines and be on your way either. Their goal is zero road fatalities.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by SomeHacker44 on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:41PM (#29677536)
I hate the Tesla Model 3 touchscreen. No muscle memory. No haptic feedback. Using it almost constantly causes attention problems.

If it weren't for the ability of the car to alert lane departures, cars braking ahead of you, etc., I likely would have had many accidents already, just using the touch screen for things should be physical controls.

Best bet is to engage autopilot then do whatever you gotta do.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by pintxo on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:58PM (#29678164)
Would be interesting to know if Tesla counts lane departure prevention caused by driver-distracted-by-touchscreen across the fleet to showcase the safety of its car, while in reality it's the lack of safety introduced by the touchscreen which caused the issue in the first place?

btw: I had the exact same experience with another brand (rental car) where the touchscreen was so ill placed, that basically any interaction with it messed with the steering.