News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by warning26 on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:03AM (#29670432)
> ...safe IF the position and availability of the controls would be static

Agreed -- this was also why the Apple Touchbar failed, IMO.

Typically keyboard use relies on a lot of muscle memory, and so the touchbar's "you get a different set of controls with different shapes and sizes that do different things depending on which app you're using" design ethos didn't really fit with how people actually use keyboards.

Re:Tesla bows to pressure, stops allowing drivers to play vi... by toast0 on Friday December 24, 2021 @12:51AM (#29670709)
Soft buttons aren't terrible. F-keys are an example where the same button could mean different things in different contexts, but they're tactile. Or if you had a Ti-85 (or 86), it had soft f1-5 and was a lot more flexible than the Ti-82 which had hard function keys. You could get muscle memory of entering menus and using the f keys that would be presented. Of course, hopefully a car doesn't have quite so deep of a menu tree.

If buttons are too expensive and you want to reduce the count, if I press radio and then F1, that could be radio preset 1, and if I press fan and then F1, that turns the fan speed to 1 of 6 (which could be off, I don't really care), that would be fine, and then you don't need quite so many buttons. Otoh, if I'm paying $20k or more for a car, you can afford some buttons.