It’s true that other terrestrial life forms possess some capabilities that we could call intelligence, but then we would just need to use another word that defines the special human je ne sais quoi.
Learning from non-kin isn't unusual in the animal kingdom. Monkeys seeing other monkeys drop a mix of sand and grain in water to separate them and then copying that is a classic example. But deliberate teaching of non-kin and the way we use language to help with that teaching is pretty unique. An octopus might have smarts comparable to a feral human, but not to an acculturated human.
Above the sea level, anyone who had it is either a part of “our” genome or extinct. Below it is a completely separate biome which may not yet had an event starting this type of evolution. It’s unclear if in a million years (in the absence of humans) squids would stay the same or evolve into walking and then moon-landing.
I think that only one species can do that, because the most energetic natural environment (free oxygen in our case), which is required for it, is usually only one per planet, and you have to fight over it, with hands, wood, metals, fire, ATGMs.
That's too vague to argue with but I'll do it anyway: No, elephants and crows as just two examples.
In terms of space, single called organisms have traveled further from earth than people have. So calling us spacefaring is kind of misleading in the context of alien life. I doubt we’re detectable outside of a 100 light year sphere from earth and none of those stars look like they contain any habitable planets. The only way to suggest alien intelligent life is meaningfully different than beavers in this context is to raise the bar far enough we don’t qualify.
The ability of humans to willingly create the technology to do it is what counts, in this case.
Do you have a source for that?
For comparison look at what we need to do to detect messages from the voyager 1 at 1/400th a light year, realize that’s sent from a directional antenna and we know exactly where to look for it. A signal that’s ~1/1,600,000,000th as strong would take some serious hardware even with more advanced technology because you can only collect 100% of the photons in a radio transmission quickly you need a physically larger device.
It strikes me as a pretty intuitive arguemnt to make and true by default, to show it wrong you have to find or somehow plausibly argue for the existence of some physical medium or process that human civilization (or even earth life in general) emit or modulate in unique, detectable-from-space ways other than electromagnetic waves and that we have been doing this since before radio.
Decidable radio signals on the other hand are far less ambiguous. I just can’t think of much that would be both detectable and a smoking gun.
In general, the signal from our most powerful commercial radio transmitters will go below the background noise floor well before 100 light years.
However, a very low bandwidth pumped through something on the scale of the Arecibo dish at the transmitting end, and a helium-cooled receiver, could bridge many more light years. But then we're no longer talking about a sphere of a signal or even a big cone, but in astronomical terms an extremely tight-focused point-to-point laser that is more apt to just intersect cosmic dust and gases than an alien civilization.
[1] https://www.quora.com/How-far-do-radio-signals-travel-into-s...
However if the aliens had a big telescope surely that radius would expand?
I think a more interesting question is how far away could we detect a civilisation equivalent to our own, using our current technology. Otherwise you can assume aliens (or our future selves) with arbitrarily sensitive detection equipment limited only by whether or not the detectors are inside the speed-of-light radius of the emitting civilisation.
IIRC our most powerful transmissions have been from NORAD radars looking for missiles coming over the north pole. In some ways we are now emitting less detectable signals, e.g. with lower power 5G cells and fibre broadband replacing good old radio.
Because that wasn't providing any evolutionary benefit. Take a group of chimps, and make offspring of those who communicate more often to have a higher chance of survival, and voila -- they will develop an urge to communicate!
Perhaps it should be done.
Of course, it’s so much easier to simply imagine such things. All that ‘scientific method’ stuff is just a nuisance when it comes to evolution.
Somehow humans started cooperating in large groups, planting the seeds of civilization, outcompeting (or possibly exterminating) our less social brethren. We can't know if the first human capable of leading large groups was a genius or a psychopath, but without people like him/her humanity probably wouldn't be very ambitious.
Might that not imply that intelligence is pretty frequent, but that what we're looking for isn't intelligence per se, but a bunch of other very specific qualities and factors that channel intelligence to express itself in high tech spacefaring ways? Seeing how much had to fall into place just so in the last 100 000 years so we could put someone on the moon, I guess that seems plausible?