Unfortunately, higher education will be completely opposed to this plan, because they get paid upfront, take on zero risk, and can charge whatever they want. (Yet another example of moral hazard. When the loan cannot be repaid the taxpayers foot the bill. Remember, “gains are privatized and losses are nationalized.”) Also as incredibly flawed as the present system is, I wonder if it provides an avenue to higher education to students that would otherwise have no such path. I propose that the universities should be financially responsible (instead of the federal government) when the student cannot repay the loan. That would provide a strong incentive for universities to have A. the student graduate B. have a manageable amount of debt with respect to future income.
With all that said about how drastic it would be, I agree with GP that it is the only real solution, and everything else is either temporary or addresses a symptom instead of the cause.
Prospective students, their families, and the schools all responded rationally and predictably. Funding either needs to remain consistent with inflation or slowly phased out.
Good schools do worry about repayment of applicants, but not all schools are good or in a financial position to worry about that.
What most schools are trying to do right now is rapidly expand their endowments with the hope to be able to consistently and sustainably offer tuition discounts and aid to students. The schools with the largest endowments are already essentially free if your family makes below a certain threshold, however this is only a handful of elite schools. For most schools they have what is called a “discount rate.” That is, the rate of students that receive a discount on the sticker price of tuition. These days most families receive a discount to most schools, which is a pretty dramatic from even 10 years ago when most students paid the full tuition price.
I suspect there would be widespread opposition to this idea on the grounds that "education is about more than getting a job".
If universities were paid based on students' future earnings, would they still teach liberal arts?
It is a bit unfair to go to a teenager, set them up with debts in exchange for something that doesn't measurably impact their earnings and turn them loose. The reason they are even in education is because their brain isn't fully formed yet and they have no practical experience. Relying on their judgement of what is a good long-term idea is a bad move.
Absolutely, but that's not what was proposed above. This quote suggests the usual model in which the government pays for education (which I support, most nations use, and even the US uses for K-12), not the income dependent repayment model proposed by julienchastang.
Was that not the original purpose?
School are dropping standardize test in the name of fairness (of the skin color).
First, I completely get how some people feel this way. It's valid.
However, as someone who's almost paid off their own student loan, I would not feel punished by student loan forgiveness. I would be glad to see it. The money I have repaid is already gone; yes, if I could turn back time knowing it would be forgiven, I needn't have repaid it, but if I could turn back time there are lots of investments or choices I would do differently. Student loan forgiveness would take a huge existential burden off an entire generation. It would do so much for mental wellbeing of so many of my peers. I can't think of something I'd rather see. And the truth is, I've almost paid off my loans because I'm doing alright. I'll be fine.
Now, the fact it got this bad to start with...doing student loan forgiveness without also making serious reforms is just promising it will happen again. But that doesn't mean we shouldn't help people who are suffering today.
Many working class 18 year olds will be punished for making what they thought was a pragmatic choice.
You might be fine right now, but what about all the people who scrimped and saved for years to pay off their student loans. Are their efforts for nothing?
So would having you pay my mortgage.
Forgiving debt isn't about you, it's about unburdening an entire generation of working people so they aren't forever under the thumb of financial institutions. Undoing federal guarantees is also about rightsizing academia, which has bloated itself on these ever growing loan numbers.
Another reason that loan forgiveness would be unfair. And what about people who learned a trade instead of paying for an overpriced college? Or poor people who didn't go to college because their underfunded neighborhood high school didn't prepare them for college?
America has already had too many bailouts to save the privileged from the consequences of their own decisions.
You're helping to make GP's point. You are saying that those who owe money are more important to this conversation without knowing anything else about them.
People with massive, life-ruining debt are more important for us to help than people who graduated debt-free or who got jobs/careers that let them pay off their debt.
If you can divorce yourself from a kindergarten-esque "fairness" complaint, it's pretty obvious that yeah, we should (unfairly!) help people who are being destroyed by debt.
The plans are to forgive 10K of debt per person. There is a crazy suggestion of forgiving 50K of debt per person but let's just ignore that (it costs more than a trillion).
People who owe 100K are still fucked. They did go to better schools, though, so they have better jobs. Many also have good connections, because they have an easier time networking with their connections.
Wanna know who is more fucked?
Many people who didn't take loans and went to no-name schools and are working low paying jobs and have few social connections.
If we give money to either group it's a handout. For these politicians to pretend it's not a handout because it's forgiving a loan is disingenuous.
Elon Musk isn't wrong to poke fun at Elizabeth Warren. Let's just hope it doesn't result in another Trumpist president.
If they went to school, got a degree, and a job, then they got what was promised and need to pay their commitments.
Which is why I think forgiveness should be an option ~7 years after leaving school. You still have to convince a bankruptcy judge that you can’t pay but wrecking your finances at 30+ would discourage most from going down that path.
It costs money to forgive loans, which either could have been spent elsewhere or must be raised in new taxes.
The analogy is if you build a house with plumbing, and your neighbor builds without, then the city uses tax money from you to pay for their upgrade.
Anybody currently holding student debt is required to pay the US government an interest rate exceeding what the Fed gives banks. Student loan interest a tax on the poor levied by the US government. My wife and I have the same degree from NYU: her parents paid her tuition, I took out loans. Over time I pay more for the same degree because of interest.
Furthermore, we already do wealth redistribution via corporate welfare of all varieties. There's countless subsidy programs for all manner of environmental harmful activities that will pass huge financial burden to my kid. A small fix to loan interest isn't much to ask.
If you are going to focus on other people getting windfall they don't deserve, there are much better places to focus your energies - I am sure anyone here has a few candidates, but in UK we had government award multimillion dollar contracts for COVID supplies to companies started a month ago, who copied their terms and conditions from a pizza delivery company.
I don't think this 'zero sum' view is helpful, but what I have a real problem with is when people only apply their 'beliefs' selectively - you have to logically consistent.
If this is your view, surely you should be More offended about extremely rich people paying zero tax, getting government bailouts when they mess up, than you should be concerned about poor people being slightly less poor? Is this actually a view you believe in, or is it just an excuse to keep poor people down?
This is like 'pro life' people not supporting healthcare, or 'freedom' libertarians supporting civil forfeiture and surveillance or 'personal responsibility' people making up excuses for why executives shouldn't be charged after they make a decision that kills several hundred people.
"elevating the people that have behaved less responsibly"
We don't actually know that, maybe person A was on track to pay off his student debt, and then someone in his family had cancer or got hit by a bus. Person A might actually be more responsible, being able to solely focus on your career is a privilege that some of us don't get
And consider this other view: It's not a perfect analogy but imagine that the federal government decides to give $10k to every white man. Of course everyone would scream that was racist and sexist. But nobody is being punished by giving a reward to one race and gender and not the others. There are obviously issues with the analogy, but it might at least show another angle of why some people don't want others to get loan forgiveness when they get nothing.
This is such an incredibly lazy answer. Why reply if you're not going to even attempt to interact with the points put forward?
The owners of corporations already pay more taxes than most of the so-called "working class." In fact, if you earned over $118,000 in a year, you pay 70% of the tax burden in a country where better than half of the adult residents pay no income tax at all.
Owners of any corporations pay a variety of taxes, some paid regardless if you turned a profit, such as property tax and employment tax. They also pay state/fed income tax on profits, regulatory fees, and a host of other liabilities that get paid to the state.
To wax on "corporate welfare" is to say you really don't know how it all works.
If student loans were made dischargeable in bankruptcy, I don't foresee many people with good jobs quitting those jobs just to declare bankruptcy. Furthermore, that feels like the kind of thing a bankruptcy judge would see right through. Rather, those borrowers will continue to service their debt as per their agreement.
It's the people who are unemployed or underemployed that would be in the position to declare bankruptcy, and them doing so will result in the true value of their loans being made apparent to the bondholders. And for the cases somewhere in the middle, it will help with more voluntary restructuring (due to a real BATNA) which won't involve the courts at all.
In the 80s interest rates on long term treasuries were around 10%, so I imagine student loans were much higher. Very expensive to finance high dollar amounts with those kind of rates. Most of the gains in housing have been due to rates trending lower for decades, for example.
But I'd advocate a more radical change towards shorter term vocational focused programs (e.g. coding bootcamps) to college.
Many benefits to that, but shorter also means easier to switch professions if you feel you've made a mistake. Due to duration and financial commitment, college is hard to swallow twice through.
Really just need somebody in a position of power to advocate for this kind of radical change in education, to shift public perception and culture.
But I don't see this being a big part of current public discussion on education. So I doubt the idea would really get any traction without e.g. a candidate in a presidential election pushing for it.
Similar to Yang and Basic Income. Even though that idea is more far fetched/challenging to implement, he was able to give it a lot of public mindshare. I believe if somebody did the same for streamlining college education to make it more economical to students it would be a broadly popular position. That lights the match for the grassroots movement to kick off and grow.
It's only useful to talk about interest rates in the 80's in the context of fighting inflation. In other cases, it's a cherry-picked number.
So when people talk about how easy it was for the last generation to buy a house or pay for college, part of that was due to higher rates suppressing prices.
The lower rates go, the higher prices go, and the ability to live a debt free life becomes diminished. Some say it's ok because the lower rates offset the increase in price.
1) We've dumbed down public education to the point that college has become a near necessity just to function in society - or certainly to get a job in a society with over the top education requirements.
2) We would need to provide a "third way" where those skill paths that don't really belong in universities can be met. We'd need to further fix decades of telling our kids that they have to go to university and instead convince them that they will do just as well being welders and plumbers.
3) We'd need to accept as a society that there are worthwhile skill areas that just aren't profitable to higher education. For example, I'd argue society benefits from anthropologists and classicists, but if I'm being realistic I acknowledge that widely and cheaply available student loans make departments like these possible. So it brings up some uncomfortable truths about the society we want to be if loans are only available to those departments and future professions most likely to yield a profit - for the uni or the individual.
but the third way already exists? ie. vocational schools, community colleges, and apprenticeships. it's just that they're not as prestigious as university, and people go with university because they want the best.
Is this actually true? ie. are they seriously looking for welders that know how to weld and have a college degree? I doubt that's the case. My impression is that all of the "you need a college degree even though it's not really needed" kind of jobs are entry level service jobs, or jobs that otherwise have a flood of applicants. College degree is used as a filter in those situations just to whittle down the huge applicant pool, not because the applicants "simply aren't getting enough educational foundation in high school anymore".
Is it bad that some people have high student loan balances? Yes. But is it so bad that it's a crisis? I don't see why.
These loans generally have generous repayment terms, including income-based repayment, forbearances, etc. And the average balance is about $36k, which happens to be less than the average price of a new car sold in the past few years. A college education for the price of a car -- it's not the end of the world. There will always be some people who borrow too much, but the only way to prevent that is to get rid of loans altogether -- getting rid of Federal loans will simply push students towards private loans which are much worse.
What part of this situation is going to cause an economic crisis?
The problem isn't that "some people have made bad choices" it's that we are lending money to people they will not be able to pay back. When people default on their loans what happens to the lenders who are ultimately fed backed banks?
I don't think blanket forgiveness is a good approach partly because of unfairness to those without loan balances and partly because it would drive up the cost of education, but I would like to see some programs to reduce the burden of education expenses that both those who owe money for loans and those who don't would be eligible for.
there are maximums on the total that can be lent under federally organized and subsidized student loan programs. last i checked that was around $60k for an undergraduate degree. they are not the cause of outsized student debt.
> and make the loans dischargeable in bankruptcy
non-dischargability of private student loans (i think was a rider on a budget bill under bush ii) opened the borrowed money spigot which then allowed cost of attendance to accelerate into high six digits territory unchecked.
professional schools like law, medicine and business have typically been powered by these sorts of loans. whether or not fully grown adults should be allowed to make big bets on themselves like that is debatable. (i'd argue that there's something of an information asymmetry. people looking to enter new fields don't know how they work and higher education brands are often seen as highly trustworthy institutions where acceptance is the main hurdle and financing would be fair and reasonable given the acceptance bar has been cleared.)
it is pretty clear, however, that encouraging it in high school seniors for undergraduate degrees is ethically problematic.
But students choose NYU over those schools…
Liberal arts education in universities is a disaster. 10% of the students are actually passionate about it, take it seriously and go on to contribute to the society. Rest of them are rich kids who are out there to party.
We need to push students to think about their career choices before picking them.
A more focused system could be much more economical and societally beneficial.
You can always elect to "broaden" your education on the side, but should not be the baseline path. Most would not be willing to pay for the extracurriculars, if you gave them the choice.
Need to think through the exact mechanism, but at least public schools should operate this way. Once college has skin in the game, education would change so fast for the better your head would spin
But there are always second order effects and perverse incentives to any system. I agree if it were enacted as I stated that outcome could be something along lines of what you're suggesting.
Of course, we already have that now with the university of Phoenix type of schools.
I meant moreso aligning incentive of school and student. But exact mechanism of implementation would need to be refined to avoid any obvious perverse incentives
Not sure that is the problem of universities though. Look at computer science, I wish I would be able to apply my bsc/msc education in my job but that simply is not the case.
Sure, university taught me how to think in a different way but the actual course work is not so helpful. I would not fault the university for this.
It sounds like what you want is an apprenticeship-system and not a university.
The answer to that question should motivate the shape of the education system. The answer is implied, of course, but pretty obvious people go into debt for hopes of better employment opportunities.
But it sounds like you want universities to change
I am sorry people, what the fuck is going on over there, slavery-lite? The bank's job is to access risk, if I want to get a loan that will knee-cap me for the rest of my life I might as well go to the Mob.
It's not like it's physically impossible to provide education at $10k/year. I live in Europe, I went to a normal university, and I think the "market rate" for non-EU students was something like that.
If you capped it to $10k/year, are you saying there simply wouldn't be anyone around to give you an education at that price in the whole country?
For example, this is the tuition and expenses for CSU East Bay, one of the less expensive public universities in California: https://www.csueastbay.edu/financialaid/prospective-students...
A tuition of about $7k balloons to over $20k when the cost of books, housing, etc. are added.
I remember talking to some exchange students from Greece. There, college is 100% free (no debt). This is guaranteed by their constitution, and the system simply has to adapt. For example, nearly everyone lives with their parents, books are free because they have to be, etc.
More broadly, all of these costs seem like they could be reduced, if you had the proper incentives.
"Food and housing" comes to $900/month, living with parents. Are they suggesting students are eating $900 worth of food ($30/day!), or does this include some type of rent paid to their parents as well? I spend about $300/month on food, and I'm not even that stingy. Where does the extra $600 go?
The average high school in my country spends $4/student/day on providing school lunches. This includes labour costs - we're talking basically catering. Naively extrapolating this, we get $12/day ($360/month) for three proper meals a day.
For that matter, why are the dorms so expensive? Isn't it their land? Why don't they just lower the rents? $1200 food+rent implies $900 rent, which is obviously way more than you need to maintain a dorm room.
If they're living on campus, why do they need to spend $135/month on transportation anyway? Isn't the entire point that the place they need to be is right there? A bicycle works out to $50 one-time cost, plus let's say $10/year in repairs.
What's the $1000/year on books get them? Why can't the university simply use cheaper books? Wikipedia tells us: "East Bay has a student body of almost 15,000". That's $15 million per year. For that much money, couldn't you just buy up the rights for all the books you needed and put them into the public domain?
I just don't understand why you couldn't simply make the schools more effective.
If very few have a degree, companies will adjust and people will end up in similar careers without the massive time/money investment of college.
Real solutions would be cost control or changing our economy so that useless degrees are no longer a requirement/advantage
I like history, however I also have to eat so I majored in CS and am content with reading books about history. If some rich kid wants to get phd in Classical Greek History or English Civil War era history and not be able to use that degree to get a job, let him. It is no difference than if someone wanted to buy a lambo. The rich people can buy it if they want to show off, but the government shouldn't subsidize poor people to get lambos. Some degrees are luxury goods.
I can probably get the same knowledge as any of those "luxury" degrees by my self via free books or videos online. Them going thru the motions to get the degree, which there are few jobs for, is therefore a luxury and should not be subsidized.
A GPA varies by school, private, public, etc.
kids in disadvantaged situations often have less support & less extra curricular opportunities. Also less opportunity for AP/IB which i think some colleges use as a GPA 'bump'
I did find research that shows the correlation to college GPA and high school GPA is way more than ACT. research says ACT doesn't predict success (defined as college GPA).
But that's part of my point in that GPA in college doesn't mean a ton from my perspective and doesn't factor in a bunch of way more important things like social, leadership, and the connections you can make by being born into it or ideally new opportunities from college that you couldn't get growing up.
in terms of strict future earning there is also research to back this up. The 2nd link says even IQ was only 1-2% bump in $.
I would guess that colleges and banks that use that type of strict minimum standard score would tend to discriminate against bright kids in difficult circumstances. Similar to not lending in D zip codes, which tended to be black (funny how that grade aligns).
https://www.k12dive.com/news/high-school-gpa-5-times-more-li... https://www.forbes.com/sites/theyec/2020/10/19/do-college-gr...
Pricing the risk of an 18 year old trying to get through school is a crap shoot, so banks just won't do it. That effectively shuts out kids from poor backgrounds. I know I wouldn't have been able to go to school without loans, and saving money for a few years wouldn't have been an option because of my area/family.
Current laws were made to solve a problem. Now we know that they create a new problem. Let's try something new rather than reverting back to the old problems.
You could divide it up into 4 equal parts for all I care: if someone has paid back at least 25% of their loan, and get want to declare bankruptcy, they should be allowed to do so, but the taxpayers shouldn't pick up the whole check. The bank should definitely eat some of it, and the university should take a financial hit as well.
I agree, the government should have no place in this whatsoever.
> and make the loans dischargeable in bankruptcy
Toss personal responsibility out the window? No, sorry, someone who wasn't financially prudent and _chose_ to attend a college that was obscenely expensive should be putting in 15 hour days until their loans are paid back in full. Why should society or the banks bear any responsibility here?
So restructuring of the loan program has to be in conjunction with other education and access reforms
I’m a big fan of the proposal that people should be able to pay down student loans pretax just as easily as investing in a 401k.
IMO, structure the payment as a mandatory 5% of your paycheck until it’s paid off.
> In total, then, only 25 of the approximately 1,100 schools across 102 conferences in the NCAA made money on college sports last year
1. Forgive all loans, or 2. Never receive any federal funding ever again
When lenders get more stringent about handing out hundreds of thousands of dollars to teenagers, colleges will automatically have to scale back fees in order to get people to apply. No more 5-star hotel rates for shoebox dorms and cafeteria food. No more multi-million dollar pay packages for administrators and sports coaches. No more textbooks which cost $300 per class and need to be "refreshed" every year to prevent reuse. Prioritize lending for degrees which have a higher earning potential and so a higher chance of paying back. Favor students with a better academic record. Enforce a minimum GPA in order to keep getting funded. Issuing loans is a business, so treat it like a business rather than a social service with privatized gains and public losses.
Conversely, the worst thing you can do for the problem is forgive existing loans. What do you then do when universities jack up tuition even more and students run up a tab of another trillion dollars over the next decade and refuse to pay, knowing that the government will bail them out anyways?