https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rai_stones
These were discs of a special stone used as stores of wealth by the Yap Islanders. Over time, both because of the difficulty of moving such a large stone, and to protect it from damage, it became customary to simply keep the stones where they were and maintain an agreed upon (oral in this case) log of the history of ownership of the stone. There were even stones that sank in transit between the islands, and since everyone agrees the stone existed and no one has a way to pull it up, you can just keep the log of ownership going even with no people having physical access to the stone.
Where the comparison falls flat for me is that those stones started as a (at least for the purposes of this conversation) fairly traditional currency that large chunks of their economy depended on, before transitioning to a more abstract concept. Not that many people's retirements are tied up in beanie babies (albeit probably non zero) so there isn't that structural and heavily collective force of will to maintain value. That's what NFTs look like to me.
Of course, that's not how the world works. I wish provenance of something was not as valuable when we're talking about art made by dead people (or already reach and famous). I wish art was not used as a money store. And I feel that NFTs - and this PGP-based idea in particular - offer a possible solution to this, due to this one bug-that's-a-feature:
>Without a published chain of transactions, there is no guarantee that the artist hasn't sold the same item multiple times.
In short, the value cannot be driven up by scarcity, because there is no way to verify that. What you pay for is the record of paying someone.
We kind of have this with political donations already (public rosters of donors serve that purpose), and we have Patreon, but if I wanted someone to take pride in supporting my art with $5 - and make them able to publicly show off, which helps me too - there's no obvious way to go about it without physical tokens, or relying on 3rd parties, like Patreon, which may or may not exist in 10 years.
That's one reason vinyl and tapes are taking off like crazy. It's not just about the medium. The physical token matters.
The inherent flaw of NFTs-as-stores-of-value (and digital signatures/provenance proofs in general) may also be their saving grace.
But that's not anywhere near as good as buying it from the artist.
"Buyer agrees as an unalterable condition that:
if Buyer or Buyer's estate sells, gifts, donates, or transfers the Artifact in any way, Two Percent of the Current Market Value of the Artifact is due to the Artist or the Artist's Estate within 30 days of such sale, gift, donation, or transfer. The Current Market Value is the higher of the most recent price paid for the Artifact or an appraisal made by an independent, reasonable expert up to 1 Year prior to the sale, gift, donation or transfer."
Or the like, as adjusted for jurisdictions.
Yup, that's the point.
What value is there in a receipt that says "I paid money to the person that supported the artist"?
Because that allows more people to support artists in the first hand. If the art was guaranteed to lose value, or keep the value but not increase in value, then fewer people would want to buy art from artists directly.
So it's fair to say that a blockchain can serve as a ledger of possession of those things that are themselves on the blockchain, but not of any thing that is external to the blockchain.
Besides hardware wallets, most people wouldn't take the risk of buying a wallet since the seller could then send the NFTs to a different address they control, thus leaving you with a worthless wallet you paid above market price for.
> If I steal your wallet, am I also stealing your NFTs?
(once again, besides hardware wallets) stealing a wallet itself is only possible if the owner doesn't have the private key / secret words jotted down somewhere. A much more likely and common attack after finding a private key is to immediately transfer all NFTs to another address for cheap.
If I sell you my car, there's no way of you knowing if I gave you all the copies of my keys. I could steal the car anytime in the future.
I agree helping those that need more than you is very noble and I aspire to do more of it, but it's not because it has some deeper meaning, I'm just human and have compassion.
It's not just rich people. Pretty much everyone living in a developed country from the 20th percentile up pisses away an inordinate amount of their income on stupid shit. Why? Because it's fun!
People die of blacklung, scurvy and smallpox, they die in slavery...
Oh wait, they don't any more. Later generation will look down at our barbarism the same way we look at tribes of cannibalistic neanderthals.
I believe this is true of any philosophy that believes itself the path to progress.
If I believed my philosophy would result in future generations looking back at us as a pinnacle of human rights and technical progress - I’d look for a different philosophy.
It’s also fair to say the path to that progress you referenced in comparison is historical record - we know the societal structures in place when we accomplished that.
Buying things that need to be produced is the real problem. When you buy a new private jet, you're adding demand to an industry. That transaction re-allocates tens of thousands of man-hours to aircraft production, man-hours that could instead be going towards any other cause that has marginally more utility to the rest of society.
Provenance isn't the issue, the issue is people with money paying others to work on projects that solely benefit themselves rather than benefiting the less fortunate.
When you make a Golden Toiler, you don't give a fuck about stashing wealth. You do because you can. Same goes for casinos, etc.
Bought a smartphone for $200? You are supporting modern slavery in China with your consumerist demand for cheap goods!
Oh, you bought a premium smartphone for $2,000? Congratulations, you are still supporting slavery, the company lied, have a nice day!
Stop this charade, it's only purpose is to shift blame while those that created the problem are making a killing.
There is nowhere I can buy food without plastic within a 5 mile radius. What am I suppose to do, buy a cow, slaughter it myself in my apartment?
Whats's the point of this criticism that does not address the substance of my post whatsoever?
What's next on this train of thought, 'if you cared about the environment you would commit seppuku and save the world your carbon footprint'
We can do something, but it is ok if it is not the absolute best. The absolute best for the environment might not be too healthy for you :)
Owning scarce items gives them status.
Ergo, money is spent to secure these items to signal the owners status.
NFTs are not scarce. A painting is scarce because you can never replicate the original painter physically impressing whatever they see in their mind on a blank virgin canvas. If the original painter happens to be on the right side of the Power law and becomes famous, then the painting value also skyrockets because said canvas was touched by them (e.g. Leonardo da Vinci)
Stuff on the internet cannot be scarce, you'd need the metaverse with its own rules to create scarcity. E.g. "Ferraris" and "Lamborghini" cars in GTA V. Their rarity is enforced but as soon as the internet gets hold of it then the scarcity is immediately eliminated on the PC version with mods
This is why provenance matters. The NFT with the same provenance is scarce. When an artist mints an NFT and sells it, the NFT provenance is part of the value.
If I mint an NFT pointing to a frame in Pulp Fiction, no one cares. If Quentin Tarantino mints one, now it has value.
Except when I buy a painting I can lend it to a museum and get a steady income, with NFTs you are only hoping that some bigger fool will buy your jpg, because everybody sees what you see, and a jpg is not a painting, you don't have to stand in front of it to appreciate it.
An example was the recent sale of the original picture from National Geographic 1983 issue. The "Afghan girl" is one of the most famous pics of 20th century if not the most famous.
The "original" sold for a mere 63k, that's because it doesn't give you anything more than the pic which was on the cover of NG or you have seen countless times on the internet since. Compare it to famous paintings or even a Banksy and it's a very small sum of money.
Most famous jpg sells for less than 1/10 of a mediocre painting
Also most importantly once you have taken the painting from the artist hands you are in power. With NFTs the artist needing money can and will mint the exact same JPG undercutting all the fools who bought the previous NFT.
He will get the money and the praise (ohh distributing his work to everybody instead of select few how cool is him!!!) and you'd get a huge financial loss.
People will still be able to ascribe meaning to which NFT was minted when. So an earlier minted NFT may be more valuable to some than those that were minted later.
Just like when Banksy “destroyed” that piece by shredding it half way, the “destruction” actually worked to increase the value of the piece. In the same way, conceivably, a first batch of NFTs that supposedly should lose value after the artist starts minting a bunch more, could turn out to instead increase in value, because of their history of having been minted and sold before the event of the artist minting a bunch more.
Are dollars printed during the 2008 recession more valuable than those printed during the 2020 recession?
> In the same way, conceivably, a first batch of NFTs that supposedly should lose value after the artist starts minting a bunch more, could turn out to instead increase in value, because of their history of having been minted and sold before the event of the artist minting a bunch more.
But why? It's the same JPG.
No because dollars are not used the way that NFTs are.
> But why? It's the same JPG.
But it's not the same NFT.
We are really latching onto the pipe smoke here.
But, as you point out, people will pay for social status. Thus, my hope is that the elites will come to view paying obscene amounts of money for provenance as exceedingly lame. Totally agree, people should be free to spend their money on whatever they want. And to me, if you spend a ton of money on an NFT for the purposes of telling people "I've got the only one of these" (instead of its current primary purpose of looking for a greater fool - that reasoning I understand), it just tells me you're an asshole with no imagination.
Of all the things you could choose to spend money on, be it helping the poor, starting a new company, a wild night out with hookers and blow, a brand new spaceship, whatever, all you could come up with is "I want to be able to tell people I've got the only one of something, despite that anyone else can download an exact, bit-by-bit replica for free". It's just pathetic honestly.
This is pretty much it for me. Some people have personal reasons to buy specific tokens for normal-goods prices, and I can still respect those people - but to spend thousands or millions on a few bytes is to advertise ridiculously poor taste.
Y > your pyramid scheme has no value, this is a dumb waste of money and it will collapse like suborime mortgages did in 2008
X > what are you, a communist?
Some-something Free Market praise the lord!
For 99% of the population, what you see is less substantial than what authority asserts. (authoritative individuals, the authority of consensus, mob-style-debate, the authority of the hivemind...)
Yes, it's fucked up. Anti-scientific. Psychotic even.
That money absolutely has tangible value. If Jeff Bezos is willing to pay $500 million for a yacht, but I'm willing to pay $600 million to build schools, the market should favor building the schools and society ends up with a bunch of schools rather than a single super yacht.
That's why we need some kind of significant wealth tax. Take the money away from people that will choose to allocate resources to yacht building and other frivolous things and spend it on stuff that has an obvious benefit to society.
Inflation may be a bitch, but last I checked I could walk into McDonald's with a green piece of paper with a "$5" printed on it and walk out with a Big Mac, no questions asked.
That's only because the super rich are dictating what's in demand. If you take all the money being spent on luxury watches and start spending it on dental care for children, the market should reduce the supply of watch makers and increase the supply of dentists in order to meet the demand for each.
I wonder how much of our problems arise because our intuitions and assumptions on the small scale simply fail on the macro scale
To me, it's obvious that owning an image or a song doesn't give you any advantage over just "right clicking" it.
I can look at it, the owner can look at it, that's basically what you can do with most media.
But there is so much more that can be done with NFTs. For some thing, ownership actually gives you an advantage.
I own my drivers licence and my bachelor degree. Other people can look at them too, like I can, but looking at them is not the actual value of them.
I have an unwritten blog post about what "ownership" means in the digital realm, but the gist is that ownership is control. This is complicated by laws imposing meatspace-minded artificial scarcity, mainly by forbidding the duplication and/or reverse-engineering of certain bytes on your own hard drive (programs which have restrictive licenses).
So NFTs have nothing at all to do with ownership because they don't touch those dynamics (at least not in a way meaningful to the end user). Even an NFT that granted you certain privileges would have those privileges enforced by some external system, so you're again only borrowing the authority from someone else so it's really they who own it and you're only buying a license to use it.
Open source software, on the other hand, is about ownership because the license is granted to users to assume full control of what they possess with no third-party arbitration.
You can certainly make a perfect copy from it, because it's a digital good, but the copy gives you nothing.
Just my opinion, feel feel to roast me.
But, I also think, the rest that is left when the bubble pops could be an improvement over the status quo.
You mean like this? https://stampery.com/
There's no reason for those to be an NFT.
At birth, you're incorporated. Instead of getting taxed, the state gets some portion of your shares as do your parents and you. The majority shareholders can make some important decisions. Additionally, if you want to go to college, you sell some shares of you that you own to the college.
That the book won the 2010 Prometheus Award from the Libertarian Futurist Society and a review of it is titled Anti-Corporate Libertarian Futurism in "The Unincorporated Man" ( https://gizmodo.com/anti-corporate-libertarian-futurism-in-t... )
I wish instead that there would be more discussion around how fucked up it is that provenance is a thing that has value to begin with, digital or physical. There are literally huge swaths of humanity that are nearly starving on a daily basis, yet others spend obscene amounts of money on things with 0 tangible value. Say what you want around billionaires blowing their wad on flights-of-fancy space projects, at least they are building something real that could have value to humanity. Paying for provenance is just a place to stash wealth, when extreme wealth inequality has made it difficult to find places for the wealthy to store their dough.
I don't really have any purpose with this post - human nature is what it is, and having value in displays of status is as old as the species. I still think it's horribly fucked up.