News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by romwell on Saturday December 18, 2021 @05:58PM (#29609488)
In defense of provenance, there's value in saying "I have contributed to this by chipping in". You can print off a digital painting on your inkjet, but paying for a signed print means you are enabling the artist to create more art, and you can justifiably take pride in that.

Of course, that's not how the world works. I wish provenance of something was not as valuable when we're talking about art made by dead people (or already reach and famous). I wish art was not used as a money store. And I feel that NFTs - and this PGP-based idea in particular - offer a possible solution to this, due to this one bug-that's-a-feature:

>Without a published chain of transactions, there is no guarantee that the artist hasn't sold the same item multiple times.

In short, the value cannot be driven up by scarcity, because there is no way to verify that. What you pay for is the record of paying someone.

We kind of have this with political donations already (public rosters of donors serve that purpose), and we have Patreon, but if I wanted someone to take pride in supporting my art with $5 - and make them able to publicly show off, which helps me too - there's no obvious way to go about it without physical tokens, or relying on 3rd parties, like Patreon, which may or may not exist in 10 years.

That's one reason vinyl and tapes are taking off like crazy. It's not just about the medium. The physical token matters.

The inherent flaw of NFTs-as-stores-of-value (and digital signatures/provenance proofs in general) may also be their saving grace.

Re:An NFT without a blockchain by williamtrask on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:05PM (#29609546)
This only counts if you’re buying it from the artist directly.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by dsr_ on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:18PM (#29609674)
It counts a very little bit if you are buying it in public while the artist is still alive and producing, because it helps establish the value of their art in a way that they can profit from.

But that's not anywhere near as good as buying it from the artist.

Re:An NFT without a blockchain by ganoushoreilly on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:30PM (#29609761)
Depending on the contract some nfts pay out the original creator a percentage every time it’s traded. That’s something you don’t get in most markets.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by dsr_ on Saturday December 18, 2021 @08:18PM (#29610453)
It's a thing which can be added to a real-world contract.

"Buyer agrees as an unalterable condition that:

if Buyer or Buyer's estate sells, gifts, donates, or transfers the Artifact in any way, Two Percent of the Current Market Value of the Artifact is due to the Artist or the Artist's Estate within 30 days of such sale, gift, donation, or transfer. The Current Market Value is the higher of the most recent price paid for the Artifact or an appraisal made by an independent, reasonable expert up to 1 Year prior to the sale, gift, donation or transfer."

Or the like, as adjusted for jurisdictions.

Re:An NFT without a blockchain by romwell on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:35PM (#29609804)
>This only counts if you’re buying it from the artist directly.

Yup, that's the point.

What value is there in a receipt that says "I paid money to the person that supported the artist"?

Re:An NFT without a blockchain by codetrotter on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:59PM (#29609989)
> What value is there in a receipt that says "I paid money to the person that supported the artist"?

Because that allows more people to support artists in the first hand. If the art was guaranteed to lose value, or keep the value but not increase in value, then fewer people would want to buy art from artists directly.

Re:An NFT without a blockchain by mwattsun on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:11PM (#29609607)
One thing I don't understand is that, afaik, and NFT and the record of transactions have no legal weight or enforceability like the assignment of copyright.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by judge2020 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:29PM (#29609754)
Sure it does, the NFT sales are like a bill of sale - both parties have to agree on a price before the money & item change hands. But the legal side doesn't really matter for what you'd traditionally want it for, as this public ledger literally cannot be changed by force nor the focus of an entire government attempting to do so (well, they could jail miners and people not using their fork with the forged transaction, but still).
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by dodobirdlord on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:43PM (#29609884)
That's the core issue though with ownership of NFTs. If a court says one thing, and the immutable ledger says something else, it's the immutable ledger that's wrong.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by mwattsun on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:54PM (#29609946)
Which confirms my suspicions that NFTs are not enforceable because they have no laws governing them, except by everyone agreeing to the rules of the game. What I don't know, but what I suspect, is that no one is getting arrested for not following the agreed upon rules.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by dodobirdlord on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:27AM (#29612799)
We can look to cryptocurrencies for precedent in how NFT ownership disputes will go. Courts have had no issue looking past meaningless technicalities about “immutable ledgers” and “key-based ownership” to adjudicate disputes about who actually owns cryptocurrencies, and have had no issue with reaching decisions that, for example, cryptocurrencies were stolen because they were transferred to a new address without the permission of the current owner.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by judge2020 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @07:00PM (#29609992)
Then perhaps it's a ledger of possession instead - a court can't alter reality and say "plaintiff is now in possession of item", however they can order the a defendant to give back stolen property.
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by dodobirdlord on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:41AM (#29612882)
A ledger of possession is certainly a much better model than a ledger of ownership, but it still falls a bit short because frequently when dealing with more abstract kinds of property than a literal physical object, like intangible property (intellectual property, mineral rights), immovable property (land, water sources), or property in the actual possession of a custodial third party (money in a bank account, a company in the care of the board of directors), a court order can change possession, since there's less distinction between possession and ownership of these less concrete forms of property.

So it's fair to say that a blockchain can serve as a ledger of possession of those things that are themselves on the blockchain, but not of any thing that is external to the blockchain.

Re:An NFT without a blockchain by criddell on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:38PM (#29609840)
Is an NFT different from other blockchain transactions? If I steal your wallet, am I also stealing your NFTs? If an NFT is designed to send some percentage of a sale to the person who minted it, is there a way to prevent me from selling you my wallet without going back to the blockchain?
Re:An NFT without a blockchain by judge2020 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @07:30PM (#29610188)
> is there a way to prevent me from selling you my wallet without going back to the blockchain?

Besides hardware wallets, most people wouldn't take the risk of buying a wallet since the seller could then send the NFTs to a different address they control, thus leaving you with a worthless wallet you paid above market price for.

> If I steal your wallet, am I also stealing your NFTs?

(once again, besides hardware wallets) stealing a wallet itself is only possible if the owner doesn't have the private key / secret words jotted down somewhere. A much more likely and common attack after finding a private key is to immediately transfer all NFTs to another address for cheap.

Re:An NFT without a blockchain by criddell on Sunday December 19, 2021 @08:49AM (#29613905)
So it would put you back into the realm of traditional transactions? That doesn't seem like a huge problem.

If I sell you my car, there's no way of you knowing if I gave you all the copies of my keys. I could steal the car anytime in the future.