Without the premium content, it’s hard to do that. I think the content providers know this and are trying to squeeze YouTube into giving more of their profits to the content providers. Either that, or to raise prices to be similar to cable.
YouTube TV is claiming Disney content added $15/month to the bill, so they’re dropping the price by $15/month as long as Disney is out:
> “We will be decreasing our monthly price by $15, from $64.99 to $49.99 while this content remains off of our platform,” YouTube TV said in its Friday night statement.
These aren’t really comparable to standard Hulu or Netflix or Amazon Prime etc. It’s for people that want to pretend they’re cord-cutting while buying the exact same thing from a streaming company.
It legitimately is way better than cable, though. Ignoring the disputes over fees, I once tried Spectrum's TV Android app (probably 3-4 years ago, I gave up on getting it to work), and this is what I experienced:
* Refuses to work if a VPN is on
* Must disable developer tools (doesn't matter if you changed any settings in there or not)
* Root check
* Must be from a Spectrum home IP (and remember, you can't VPN to your home network to use this app)
* Must allow access to all contacts, all texts, etc or the app would close itself (there is no legitimate justification for this, unlike potential contract stipulations requiring no root, etc - it's purely for selling all your data)
* Didn't even work after I installed it on a totally stock Android device on my home network
* No web interface; if you can't run the app, too bad
Compared to that, YT TV's app is a breath of fresh air. But ignoring the streaming convenience, you also have:
* No ads in the TV guide (which is also more responsive than any DVR I've ever experienced)
* Unlimited DVR is nice (and it's not utter dogshit hardware that would've been considered unimpressive in the 90s)
* You don't need a cable box - just a Chromecast (which is absolute tiny by comparison) or a TV with Chromecast built-in
* The pricing is much easier to understand
Of course, I don't actually pay for it. My mother does, and she put my Google account as an allowed user. I just use it to watch hockey.
It's true that you're paying for the same product, but it's delivered in a package that doesn't scream "fuck you, pay me."
I stuck with that for years until fiber was available in my area since a threaten-to-cancel call got my TV price down to $0/month (on top of internet).
Pretty much the worst of all worlds.
I checked the Spectrum website, and the cheapest TV-only package they have is $77.11 for the first month, $66.40 for the next 11, and $98 thereafter. (First month has $9.99 self-install fee - you already pay every month for the cable box and install it yourself, but they charge you even if you pick it up from the store!)
But that's "Mi Plan Latino" - no sports channels. The cheapest with sports, TV Select, is $87.71 for the first month, $77.10 for the next 11, over $110 thereafter. I'm sure I could get better rates by calling them, and I have some competition in my area so I know I could actually get them, but I value my sanity too much for that.
Spectrum also doesn't have any 4k, not even through their app, though they say "we're working to add it soon" [0]. Also no surround [1]. For me, it would make no sense to go with Spectrum even if the alternative was me paying for Youtube TV.
[0]: https://www.spectrum.com/cable-tv/apple-tv-faq
[1]: https://www.spectrum.net/support/tv/spectrum-tv-app-troubles...
They are lowering the price when one channel leaves but you can’t pick which channels you want.
Lastly YouTubeTV doesn’t solve any problems. For instance local channel access is limited to one location.
As a content package, it's evolved to be something largely different from what you get from the streaming services like Netflix. It's largely sports, news/talk shows, and reality TV and other relatively low-cost lightly scripted/unscripted content, some documentaries... You still have some traditional network content but it's been a while since I've even heard of a network drama or comedy of note.
Remember Netflix' incentives are very different from a network. Netflix wants to acquire and retain subscribers which tends to favor stickier content rather than filling up a schedule with programming that people will tune into out of habit.
Put another way, the network business model is essentially a legacy model. I'm not sure why Netflix would want to recreate an uber-Network.
YoutubeTV lets you create 6 accounts and use 3 simultaneously. I live in NY and share my account with 2 friends in CT for <25$ a person. Absolute steal and a really great product.
I will also say Youtube TV is not the "Exact same thing" that the cable company offers. Fundamentally the product/channels are, but youtube TV gets all the tech right.
FWIW, I can’t see any traditional cable TV provider doing this. They might even charge an extra fee as a cherry on top.
It's a retention move that they accept a short lack of their cut of the Disney portion in exchange for not losing customers entirely.
ABC
ABC News Live
Disney Channel
Disney Junior
Disney XD
ESPN
ESPN2
ESPNU
ESPNEWS
Freeform
FX
FXX
FXM
National Geographic
National Geographic Wild
SEC Network
Of those, the Disney bundle would only cover the sports channels on ESPN+ (I'm assuming it has all the cames broadcast on the channels.)Edit: according to other comments ESPN+ doesn't even cover all the sports on the ESPN2 and ESPN3 channels.
Thanks for the clarification. It probably adds to the confusion that the landing page for "YouTube TV" goes to the "youtube.com" domain:
How about Google Play, Google Fi, and countless others? They all share the same domain
https://www.espn.com/espnplus/schedule/_/type/upcoming/categ...
But I am not going to jump through hoops and pay for stuff I do not want, and most importantly, I am not going to spend time researching what is and is not available on + versions versus not +.
Same with NHL. I would pay to watch ice hockey, I will not pay to risk being unable to watch because I live too close to the stadium and hence should be blacked out.
I also will not pay to have advertisement breaks shown to me.
Technically YouTube Premium is a package designed to bolster their failing YouTube Music product that few want.
I'd gladly pay $7.50 a month for AD Free YouTube, but $15 is too much.
In some regions you can actually get this. It’s called “Premium Lite”.
https://www.youtube.com/premiumlite
I’m paying 69 NOK which given currency conversion is roughly $7.60, so it’s more or less literally what you ask for.
For those outside the offered regions (thus getting geoblocked) this is literally what the page says for me (copy & paste):
—————————————-
FAQ
What is included with Premium Lite?
YouTube
• Ad-free videos: Watch millions of videos uninterrupted by ads. Learn more
YouTube Kids
• Ad-free in the YouTube Kids app
Premium Lite doesn't include ad-free access to the YouTube Music app.
That was a pretty good deal for me. But without Play Music (YT Music was awful at the time), I couldn't justify the cost.
Are you that surprised? The branding is a complete mess. And Youtube TV is not available in most markets so many people have never heard of it.
And the sooner that dies, the better. Cable TV is crap and I don't want to see that model of media succeed into the internet era.
I do think I'd rather pay YouTube than ESPN directly, because the latter's video services have never worked well for me. Part of me wishes the various services would just tell Disney to get lost, and let them see how much they like providing that service on their own. Though, the conventional wisdom seems to be that live sports programming can't exist on it's own, and that 'regular TV' can't exist without live sports.
It feels that way. On the one hand, it seems like you have to be something of a super-fan to subscribe to one or more of the sport/league-specific sites/apps. On the other hand, local sports availability or even just sports as TV on in background seems like a pretty significant sweetener for a lot of people who might not pay for TV just for the occasional late night talk show, local news broadcast, or reality show.
Sports isn't enough for me to pay for cable any longer. But, if I did, watching a game now and then would probably be what would push me over the line to pay up.
It's much easier to just find pirated live game streams than it is to figure out the cobweb of television rights, which service actually shows local sports, if you're "in" or "out" of market, etc.
I'm sure the economics are still strongly in favor of the TV licensing deals but this has to turn at some point, I'd think, where leagues can go direct-to-consumer across all markets or they just sign deals with streaming companies directly, which Amazon is already doing with the NFL.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tying_(commerce)
> Tying (informally, product tying) is the practice of selling one product or service as a mandatory addition to the purchase of a different product or service. In legal terms, a tying sale makes the sale of one good (the tying good) to the de facto customer (or de jure customer) conditional on the purchase of a second distinctive good (the tied good). Tying is often illegal when the products are not naturally related. It is related to but distinct from freebie marketing, a common (and legal) method of giving away (or selling at a substantial discount) one item to ensure a continual flow of sales of another related item.
> Some kinds of tying, especially by contract, have historically been regarded as anti-competitive practices. The basic idea is that consumers are harmed by being forced to buy an undesired good (the tied good) in order to purchase a good they actually want (the tying good), and so would prefer that the goods be sold separately. The company doing this bundling may have a significantly large market share so that it may impose the tie on consumers, despite the forces of market competition. The tie may also harm other companies in the market for the tied good, or who sell only single components.
> One effect of tying can be that low quality products achieve a higher market share than would otherwise be the case.
> Tying may also be a form of price discrimination: people who use more razor blades, for example, pay more than those who just need a one-time shave. Though this may improve overall welfare, by giving more consumers access to the market, such price discrimination can also transfer consumer surpluses to the producer. Tying may also be used with or in place of patents or copyrights to help protect entry into a market, discouraging innovation.
> Tying is often used when the supplier makes one product that is critical to many customers. By threatening to withhold that key product unless others are also purchased, the supplier can increase sales of less necessary products.
> In the United States, most states have laws against tying, which are enforced by state governments. In addition, the U.S. Department of Justice enforces federal laws against tying through its Antitrust Division.
HBO on the other hand was constantly fighting for subscribers not just viewership. For them every viewer was worth more money so they had a high bar without much filler.
1) on demand whatever you want to watch whenever you want to watch on whichever device you want to watch
2) no advertisement breaks
3) no mandatory long term contract (maximum length 1 month)
Though I suppose with a happier ending.
And it has been dying. Look at the ads the roll between the shows and it's clear that TV watchers are aging out. It's all hearing aid commercials and malpractice lawsuits' the only people watching TV through a settop box anymore are the elderly. Bringing that same format of content to youtube's platform, to be watchable on the devices young people use (smartphones, laptops, etc) is a play to make this format relevant to young people again. I hope they fail.
Now, it's hard to argue that people shouldn't be able to pay for just what they want. But now you're effectively arguing for relatively expensive a la carte rentals/purchases which I'm guessing people wouldn't want either if you want to keep revenues neutral. People may want to pay only for the media they watch. But they may not want to pay $5 for a TV show even though I was probably paying way more than that per show when I had cable TV.
If I'm inherently after a passive entertainment experience, there are situations where I want the decisions made for me. If I put on the TV while I exercise, or for background while cooking or cleaning, I don't need it stopping every 30 minutes asking me to choose something else to watch, and yet I also don't want it showing 23 seasons of the Great British Bake Off in a row either. I'll put on a broadcast channel instead.
my physical cable to my house is provided by Altice One, I have no option to switch that at all (no there's no FIOS or fiber option here). that's a monopoly.
Inside the US, the term swapped to refer to social-liberalism rather than classical-liberalism during the great depression.
Last mile infrastructure is not what I find objectionable about cable TV, and last mile infrastructure isn't going anywhere anyway. I want this to die: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broadcast_programming and I don't care what medium is used to transmit it. Whether it's a coaxial cable, radio transmission from terrestrial tower or satellite, or the internet, it makes no difference to me. The format itself is what I find awful.
> Sony Vue (they're gone! heh)
Yeah, because broadcast programming is a dying format for boomers. I celebrate the demise of all of it, and any company that produces it.
> I don't get the hate.
I live in a society with people who do watch it. I don't like the way broadcast TV turned people into numbed couch potatoes watching hours of ads a day.
YouTube TV is basically cable TV delivered via the internet with some on-demand content and an “unlimited” DVR system. There are multiple tiers via add-on packages (just like cable), and there is no ad-free offering.
YouTube is the video sharing website everyone uses. The ad-free version of which is called YouTube Premium.
These two services have very little in common besides the obvious branding and parent company. The contract/fee dispute is between Disney and YouTube TV, and the result is that YouTube TV is currently not broadcasting Disney-owned television channels. Disney content is still all over YouTube itself via their YouTube “Channels.”