Not the most polished game but easily the best murder mystery and Twin Peaks style life sim I've ever played.
So if CDPR couldn't pull it off, they must have been asked to do it at an unreasonable scale or the requirements themselves were unreasonable.
Funny how reel-life and real-life collide into each other! :D
---
As an aside, after Ted Lasso (which gets all the well-deserved hype), Mythic Quest is a great trope-filled show esp. for anyone who's worked in tech in general (and game dev specifically).
Anyways, I think the big challenge compared to real time apps like Google docs is that game simulation is significantly more complex than synchronizing bits of text. One problem is that at a minimum, you have the round trip to the server as latency between “submit command” and “receive simulation result”. And this has to happen many times per second so that it looks realistic. And then on the server, it has to be processing the changes from N connected players M times per second, and then simulate what happens in the universe. And if simulation (M) drops too low, you get desync problems where players are rubber-banding and the AI gets very dumb. (An example is that star citizen appears to have great AI in demos, but in the live server, the servers can’t process changes fast enough for the AI to work well.)
And then, if you want a lot of connected players or a big universe, this just gets more and more complex, and you’ll eventually out-grow the ability of a single server to process changes. At which point you also need to handled data replication among multiple servers. For example, star citizen game servers don’t have capacity for more planets at the moment, either because of memory or cpu constraints. So sharding the universe into multiple servers is a pre-req for the next stage.
So to more directly answer your question, it’s definitely possible to implement. Many games have basic versions working. Minecraft is an example, but it can’t scale to hundreds/thousands of players. New World is another recent example, but even its servers have player caps. No Man’s Sky is sort of an example, but it keeps players spread out so that they rarely encounter each other. Eve Online is also an example, but I think it reduces the amount of nitty-gritty simulation details. (So it might not have a very in-depth physics simulation, or first-person-level details.)
So it’s basically a scaling problem, and even then still has limitations based on the speed of light (for internet latency) which limit how good it can get.
They received some AI-related grant[1] from the local government and did whatever they could to avoid penalties.
[1] https://www.cdprojekt.com/pl/media/aktualnosci/30-mln-zl-dla... - original source but in Polish
That CP2077 couldn't even reach that level remains kind of baffling.
I don't know why you'd build a game simulating more depth of interest in background characters than people actually possess, and it's not like occlusion culling is a foreign idea.
The big difference was that Radiant AI was fun. You could join the Warriors' guild, jump across the road to the Mages' Guild, use an enrage spell on them, the run out into the street. Instant chaos ensued.
[1] https://www.cdprojekt.com/en/media/news/cd-projekt-group-sec...
[2] https://www.pwc.pl/pl/pdf/alerty-innowacje/13-PwC-Alert-GAME...
It was, and still is, my assumption that there are penalties.
Also, this seems to be another grant - "City Creation" is documented separately[1] and with different amounts from "Animation Excellence", "Cinematic Feel" and "Seamless Multiplayer"[3]
[1] https://archiwum.ncbr.gov.pl/fileadmin/gfx/ncbir/userfiles/_...
[2] https://archiwum.ncbr.gov.pl/programy/fundusze-europejskie/p...
[3] https://archiwum.ncbr.gov.pl/fileadmin/gfx/ncbir/userfiles/_...
How can that be a thing of what you say is true?
Though, two through four can usually be handled without issue, provided the devs know what they're doing & architect the engine correctly. (edit: And keep the scope in check, which ultimately is the responsibility of the leadership.) Unfortunately, this appears to be where #1 messed things up for them.
definitely not trivially easy, but impossible!? nah.
Star Citizen's "Subsumption" and Quanta system is very similar in goal, and if it goes to plan will be one of the most engaging "AI population" simulations to date. It does't individually simulate every person in real time, but instead simulates a set of tasks and demands to be done, all the resource nodes, and an approximate population of simple entities carrying out those tasks, and when you spawn near said tasks, it spins up a "meta NPC" to represent in full 3D space, an agent of one of those simplified population entities.
So for example, you fly to a mine site, the system knows there are currently 40 miners here mining aluminium to take to the factory, it knows at what point they are at with their tasks, and so it generates 40 NPCs to represent those miners. At that point you can interact with them and influence the simulation, say steal their ship and minerals. That updates the simulation but the simulation need not care about the specifics of the NPC. Just that he has no minerals and he is no longer capable of mining.
You fly away with their ship, and all the other NPCs return back to simplified entities in the graph.
In regards to Star Citizen being vapourware, my recommendation would be to take a critical look at their timeline and what state the game is currently in and ask if you could really see it going any quicker. It's a controversial project, but I think calling it vapourware is just the industry being dismissive.
They had to build the team from nothing, now 700 people, and they are building two games not one, both are pretty groundbreaking in features and scope. That considered it is actually moving pretty quickly. They have already delivered a bunch of those groundbreaking technical hurdles to players. Of course the whole thing could implode yet, but it's looking good.
They deliver consistent progress reports and updates to the playable alpha, which has enough content for me and friends to play regularly for fun now. Updates every three months is the schedule, plus any in game content events that get run.
I tried this on a limited scale in a text-based MUD in the 90s, and even then it quickly became an ungodly nightmare. What sounds good in your head isn't always feasible in reality.
With current GPT-3 technology (or even GPT-2, accessible by then), it should be possible to create each agent unique. But if the research started earlier, I am not surprised by the dissonance between marketing and devs.
Rumour has it, management got extremely ambitious with AI. Every actor in the game world was to have a personality, daily routines etc.
The devs tried to explain how absolutely unfeasible that is, but management was convinced it's possible - and would indeed be ground-breaking.
After a large number of years of toiling with the problem, the writing on the wall was finally seen. The NPC AI was scrapped and replaced with crude "we'll just spawn the cops around you so they don't have to have a chase mode"-level hacks, to allow them to ship in 2020.
Now they're stuck in limbo, because the players are still waiting for those marvellous AI miracles that were promised, but they remain absolutely impossible to deliver. CDPR can patch things like the car physics, but people's expectations were thoroughly mismanaged and they'll forever be disappointed