News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by nijave on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:16AM (#29518643)
Im not a huge fan of leetcode or work samples but on the receiving end it weeded out a huge number of bad candidates. We'd get tons of copy/pasted together infra as code from top Google results that wasn't even close to runnable (usually being close to runnable with a few small bugs was a good submission and runnable with no bugs was a great submission)
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by vanusa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:33AM (#29518709)
On the receiving end it weeded out a huge number of bad candidates.

Along with (as was the main point of the original blog post) probably quite a few false negatives, Like the author of that post, for example.

Meanwhile, you can achieve the same filtering benefit by far less obnoxious and more accurate means (a cursory glance at their repo, fore example).

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by wiseowise on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:58AM (#29519077)
I'd rather filter out good candidate than let bad in. It's a domino effect. You let one bad, he will hire more in the future.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by Supermancho on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:05AM (#29519350)
> You let one bad, he will hire more in the future.

When your organization can recognize a poor investment but cannot act on it, you have an organizational problem. Why would someone get to hire more "bad" (for whatever that means) if you can recognize it? Even if you're doing all the hiring yourself, it's unlikely you'll have a 100% record over time.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by quietbritishjim on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:32PM (#29523080)
For one thing, in many countries it's hard to get rid of a poor employee unless they're malicious or really exceptionally terrible.

For another, even if "an organisational problem" or inconvenient labour laws don't get in your way, firing employees can have a serious effect on the morale of those left behind. And for good reason! Usually companies that regularly fire people for poor performance has a different sort of culture than companies that don't. In my experience, that's the worse organisational problem.

The right solution is just to be more careful about who you hire in the first place.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by marcinzm on Saturday December 11, 2021 @06:33AM (#29520146)
Most companies have organizational problems. So a system that only works if you don't will fail for the majority of companies.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by vanusa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @08:43AM (#29520772)
Most companies have organizational problems.

Right. But we can't talk about that, of course.

Instead the corrective strategy seems to be: "Let's torture some more candidates. It's cheap and it's easy, after all."

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by klipklop on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:41AM (#29519270)
I always hear this but never seen proof. If they are bad how do they get into a position that lets them make hiring decisions?

Everyone likes to think they are the good candidate and not the bad one that slipped through…

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by GoOnThenDoTell on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:11AM (#29519379)
When they put it in the promo committee calibration doc that X level has done Y interviews per quarter, they end up on interview loops but then feel they must say no to Z% else they’re not “raising the bar”
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by wiseowise on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:05AM (#29519351)
> If they are bad how do they get into a position that lets them make hiring decisions?

We have flat hierarchy. Just volunteer to interview because your voice is on the same level as others.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by sofixa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:06AM (#29519358)
Isn't this why there are trial periods ( no idea if it's a thing in the US with the "right to work" thing)?. Over here in the EU a work contract can't be terminated from the company just like that, there needs to be a specific reason ( like downsizing, or a serious error), and you can't quit just like that a mandatory notice period is required ( of course negotiable depending on the situation), usually in the 1-3 months range. Therefore there's a trial period at the beginning, 3-6 months usually, during which any party can end the employment with a very small notice ( a day or two).

So if someone lied their way through interviews, in the first couple of months you should be able to detect that and terminate their trial period.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by Jensson on Saturday December 11, 2021 @03:21AM (#29519417)
> So if someone lied their way through interviews, in the first couple of months you should be able to detect that and terminate their trial period.

Managers hates firing people, it is really uncomfortable. So instead of firing this person to look for a new, they keep the person and say they need even more headcount and hope the next one is better.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by marcos100 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @06:13AM (#29520052)
Totally, it's like admitting that you don't know how to hire. And it's worse if HR is involved.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by marcinzm on Saturday December 11, 2021 @06:31AM (#29520135)
In the US you are always on a trial period. The problem is that firing people is annoying and bad for team morale. More importantly even dealing with a bad coworker is really bad for team morale. No one wants to join a company that is likely to fire them in 3 months because the company f-ed up their own hiring process. No one wants to recommend their connections join a company where that is likely to happen. Made worse due to a lot of compensation is tied to staying a year at a company so leaving early is basically getting paid 50% for that time.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by baskethead on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:59AM (#29521779)
What is bad for morale is keeping someone around who is a bad fit. Netflix has solved this problem by paying everyone at the top of the scale and firing everyone who doesn’t meet their bar.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by baskethead on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:57AM (#29521762)
The question is whether or not your interviewing practices filter out bad candidates. If your entire company has no employees then maybe but I find that hard to believe.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by nijave on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:27AM (#29521067)
A lot of candidates don't have public repos and you need an equal comparison across all candidates (you can introduce a lot of bias trying to gauge two candidates against different sets of criteria)
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by vanusa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:56PM (#29522830)
A lot of candidates don't have public repos

It doesn't have to be a public repo of course. They can just send zip file.

You need an equal comparison across all candidates.

"We'd like to see a code sample -- something we can build and compile, that you feel is representative of your skill level."

Sounds pretty straightforward and egalitarian to me.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by detaro on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:04PM (#29522894)
I'm curious, if we exclude all your open-source work (assuming you have some), what did/would you submit when given the question?
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by vanusa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:45PM (#29523200)
Floppy disk? A printout?

Long before open source was a thing, and repos were even thought of -- I always had a few 1,000+ line personal projects I could dig up and show people.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by detaro on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:48PM (#29523222)
right, and plenty people don't have large personal projects, or not personal projects that align with their work skillset, and the question is extremely vague what scope you're looking for.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by vanusa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @02:03PM (#29523333)
Right - it's a bar, and some people won't meet that bar. And that said - a pretty minimal bar.

1,000 lines isn't that large, btw - but yeah, maybe 500 would be a better number.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by nijave on Friday December 17, 2021 @06:23PM (#29599548)
Yeah, that's what Leetcode is. A bar. Some people meet it, some don't.

With Leetcode, everyone starts on equal footing (there's no bias towards people who code in their free time)

Yeah, it's extremely irritating as a candidate but it's something

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by kevinburke on Saturday December 11, 2021 @12:39AM (#29518748)
People say this but then they reject answers that e.g correctly code the brute force solution or they don’t provide an algorithm to code for, so it’s not just “can you code,” it’s can you find the optimal algorithm and also code it, and usually the algorithm isn’t trivial or one you’d ever run into at work.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by indymike on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:59AM (#29521289)
This is my experience hiring developers. If I hire without a code screen, it's a 50-50% chance the developer cannot close a ticket in their first month. With a code screen, I've had one developer not work out (personal problems). And I'm talking about "ensure that no trailing spaces are being inserted to the database in this csv import function" kind of tickets.

>usually being close to runnable with a few small bugs was a good submission and runnable with no bugs was a great submission

This is exactly what we do: check the solution, and if it's close we continue the hiring process. There is a huge difference between an almost working solution and what you get 70% of the time: code that will never, ever, ever work, even if it could run.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by gentleman11 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:04PM (#29524688)
> weeded out a huge number of bad candidates.

A lot of hiring managers have no concept of experiment design.

You can’t invent a measure (or copy it from a blogs about how other companies hire), look at who it rejects, and conclude they are bad. You don’t know if they were good or bad. You never worked with any of them. You only know that you applied your measure.

The only candidates you have any information about are the ones you hired, yet you are insulting the others on the internet today

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by vanusa on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:49PM (#29524997)
You never worked with any of them. You only know that you applied your measure.

What's interesting is that the people doing all this "weeding out" seem so sure that they're bravely defending the fort against an onslaught of incompetent hordes... and yet they're missing this extremely basic point about the nature of the process they've chosen to use.

Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by ipaddr on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:25AM (#29518949)
You wouldn't know if they are bad candidates because you didn't hire them.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by wiseowise on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:57AM (#29519067)
We do code submission instead of LC. Believe me, most candidate are complete, utter shit. And that's without even hiring them.
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by yosito on Saturday December 11, 2021 @06:04AM (#29520027)
Sounds like many competent candidates are dodging a bullet by not being hired by you. What's the turnover rate on your team like?
Re:Ten years of experience, still failing phone screens by wiseowise on Saturday December 11, 2021 @06:13AM (#29520053)
> Sounds like many competent candidates are dodging a bullet by not being hired by you

How so?

> turnover rate on your team like?

2 years since I joined, hired one dev recently, no one left so far.