News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by tptacek on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:53PM (#29506537)
It's hard to take EFF seriously when they write so hyperbolically. What's clearly also the case is that Chrome extensions are one of the great modern security and privacy challenges --- to the point where multiple tech company security teams have people whose job it is just to screen them. Another detail that EFF doesn't want to share is that ad blockers are some of the worst offenders --- they demand maximal access to user data (think about how they work), and there are lots of them, not all of them, uh, implemented scrupulously.

EFF doesn't want to give you the other side of this story, because they're not an honest interlocutor.

If you had the other side of the story, you might still think Manifest v3 was a bad deal. Random ad blockers are very dangerous, but there are ad blockers that everyone trusts, and you might not want to make it harder for them to maintain their projects.

But EFF doesn't trust you to make that decision on your own.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by raxxorrax on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:16AM (#29508318)
I think this comment doesn't portrait the situation with abusive tracking honestly and I fail to see how this could get so many upvotes. No, adblockers are certainly not the worst privacy offenders. Sure, there are bad plugins, but that isn't an issue exclusive to blockers and the problem with infromation extraction is mostly relegated to malicious scripts on the websites themselves, as the article points out.

The worst privacy offenders are ad trackers and I don't think it has to be explained that Google has an interest in putting constraints on them. How much that influences Manifest v3 is everybodies guess of course.

But your framing is dishonest as Manifest v3 does take away user choice. A choice that allows you to install bad addons with all the implications. But turning that around and saying the EFF tries to take away choice is just false in this context.

I also fail to see hyperbole, I think this is the usual relativization that puts users in a worse spot than before.

> EFF doesn't want to give you the other side of this story, because they're not an honest interlocutor

And who would that honest interlocutor be in your opinion?

The best and most user oriented ad blockers will be affected by this and this is the actual security issue here. No other scenario comes even close.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by veeti on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:31AM (#29507375)
There is no decision left to make once this change goes through. You can talk about improved security all you want, but the fact remains that uBlock Origin will be permanently crippled. This by far negates any security or privacy gain that Manifest v3 could possibly make.

Switch to Firefox.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by hyperman1 on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:45AM (#29507802)
This is in fact one of the best arguments pro to do the change:

* Chrome destroys ad blocking

* Advanced users now suffer the same internet as everyone else

* Advanced users will find a solution, and that solution can't be chrome anymore

* This starts an exodus of advanced users .

* Advanced users configure the browsers for everybody else, hence everybody else also joins the exodus

The end result is less of a monopoly.

This is the same mechanism that ultimately killed of IE and moved everybody to chrome: The monopoly of the time got so arrogant they didn't listen to their users, so users fled to a better alternative.

The strange thing is, groups of people have more or less the same tolerance for abuse, know their limits have already been violated for a while, and learn alternatives from each other. As a result, It takes a long time of abuse to trigger an exodus, but when it started, it starts everywhere at the same time. Then the abuser tries stopping the exodus by rolling back only the last change, but that's not enough anymore.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by 74B5 on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:38AM (#29508119)
Unfortunately, Mozilla does not have a track record of listening to their user base too and afaik they never had any monopoly. They just pushed their Track/Ad-Features out of desperation(?), which leads to the root of the problem: commodification of common goods like privacy and its resulting degradation.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by piokoch on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:00AM (#29507886)
Looking in the internet I see that "94% of Mozilla revenues came through royalties received by search engines to be featured on its Mozilla Firefox browser" I am afraid that at some point Mozilla can be forced to comply and cripple ad blockers too.

Hopefully someone will decide to come up with a totally new browser. I remember times when BitKeeper told Linus that they will somehow try to charge for using their tool to keep Linux kernel source code (can't remember the story, but they managed to irritate Linus, delicately speaking).

Linus sat down and started coding... and created Git.

Unfortunately browser is a more complicated piece of software, but maybe this is also a problem we should solve.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by Vinnl on Friday December 10, 2021 @06:10AM (#29508580)
Alternative sources of income are growing - the share of search engine deals was down to 86% last year, apparently: https://www.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/rcc7m6/mozilla_aga...
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by vin047 on Friday December 10, 2021 @08:15AM (#29509455)
Perhaps Mozilla should put the more advanced features and customisation options behind a monthly subscription. I know people dislike monthly subscriptions, but the browser is perhaps THE most important tool you can use. Maybe it's time we start valuing it properly.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by belorn on Friday December 10, 2021 @10:32AM (#29511038)
The share of those profits that goes to Firefox development is far less than one might think, especially if one consider the many millions that goes to management of Mozilla foundation. Firefox would be a very different project if all the royalties received by search engines featured in the Firefox browser went to improve Firefox.

As long profits from Firefox does not goes back into developing Firefox, a monthly subscription wouldn't change things.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by EMM_386 on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:18AM (#29507997)
> Hopefully someone will decide to come up with a totally new browser.

The enormous complexity of browsers these days makes this almost impossible.

A better solution would be for Mozilla to direct all funding directly to Firefox and try to find other ways to monetize the browser.

Brave is trying one approach but now they are also tied to the underlying Chromium engine. I am not sure what the effort will be like to try to maintain a fork that ignores Manifest v3.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by amelius on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:22AM (#29508018)
> Switch to Firefox.

And if you're a webmaster, add some crippling/inconveniencing logic if user agent equals chrome.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by knob on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:56AM (#29508512)
I despise Chrome.

Yet I oppose your suggestion. Lets be above that.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by amelius on Friday December 10, 2021 @08:41AM (#29509682)
You don't win this fight for freedom by not playing the same game as the big corporations.

> Google throttles the load time of non-AMP ads by giving them artificial one-second delays in order to give Google AMP a “nice comparative boost.”

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28975443

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by qiqitori on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:59AM (#29506873)
The EFF doesn't need to give "the other side" because the other side is mostly obvious to the target audience (which isn't random people, Google itself is a huge part of the target audience). Note that Google doesn't give the other side either. Also, nothing in politics works like that, if you want to get people to join your cause you don't end everything you say with "But keep in mind that $foo".
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by extropy on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:52AM (#29507842)
Still not giving the other side and using "dangerous" and other "think of the children" terms triggers my bullshit and what are you hiding detector. And the only thing vouching for them is their reputation.

Speaking of reputation EFF has been doing this shady speak for last few years and my respect for them is quite diminished. I suppose they can still do it because they have practicality a monopoly to "protect privacy online" with Apple being a distant second player.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by fsflover on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:16AM (#29507988)
> monopoly to "protect privacy online" with Apple being a distant second player

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29506994

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by tssva on Friday December 10, 2021 @07:00AM (#29508896)
I used to donate to the EFF on a recurring basis but there behavior over the last few years brought that to an end last year.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by aesh2Xa1 on Friday December 10, 2021 @09:13AM (#29510050)
I still donate to the EFF.

What have they done this last year to change? Is there another organization you could recommended supporting?

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by wccrawford on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:44AM (#29508165)
So long as they're only interested in preaching to the choir, that's true. If they want to reach other people who are as zealous, they could stand to give a better full of the landscape.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by wccrawford on Friday December 10, 2021 @11:45AM (#29511972)
Ugh, typo: Who are not as zealous.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by cookiengineer on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:26AM (#29506994)
Every time someone mentions this I have to think about the messed up ecosystem of Safari Webextensions.

Safari only allows extensions installed via the apple store, but every single adblocker there is a scam.

I'm not kidding you, I audited most of them. Chances are it's either a three years outdated list of adblock plus that doesn't catch anything or it's an extension that replaces all google analytics identifiers with their own to make money (even when it's a paid extension).

The only thing worse than Chrome is Safari at the moment. And Apple doesn't give a shit about anything there, I reported the malicious extensions to no effect at all.

So when thinking of the other side and "removal of choice" I don't have a healthier, audited ecosystem in mind...I have Safari in mind, which right now is a worse attack surface than IE6 back in the days when it comes to Privacy or Security.

Malicious extensions (as answer to comments). DONT install any of them, as I think they're scamware.

[1] AdBlock for Safari and Adblock for Mobile, which is an outdated AdBlock Plus fork: https://apps.apple.com/de/app/adblock-for-safari/id140204259...

[2] AdBlock Plus (which is the same scam model as other eyeo GmbH products): https://apps.apple.com/de/app/adblock-plus-f%C3%BCr-safari/i...

[3] Stop Ads https://apps.apple.com/lu/app/stop-ads-der-ultimative-ad-blo...

[4] 1Blocker https://itunes.apple.com/app/id1107421413

[5] Wipr doesn't do anything, literally https://appsto.re/us/thAB9.i

[6] Ad blocker https://apps.apple.com/de/app/ad-blocker-remove-ads/id153692...

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by 1_player on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:16AM (#29507982)
You can't list these apps, say they're scam or they don't work with no proof whatsoever except your word, especially when there's counter arguments they actually work.

Explain yourself, or are we supposed to take your word for gospel?

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by cookiengineer on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:51AM (#29508477)
> Explain yourself, or are we supposed to take your word for gospel?

Not gonna waste more time on this tbh, as I'm building a competition to those products. If you don't believe me, stay in your walled garden. I've given you hints, start checking them for yourself or don't.

If I would post screenshots of MITMProxy, Little Snitch or something else, people would try to discredit them as fake anyways.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by 1_player on Friday December 10, 2021 @08:10AM (#29509405)
> If you don't believe me, stay in your walled garden. I've given you hints, start checking them for yourself or don't.

There's no need to be so confrontational. You made the claim, you'll probably be asked to show the technical reasoning behind your statements on a forum called Hacker News. But since you're working on competition, it's in your best interest to discredit similar products.

> If I would post screenshots of MITMProxy, Little Snitch or something else, people would try to discredit them as fake anyways

Sounds to me you're not prepared for people to show you might be incorrect. Honestly, I never doubted your position, I just wanted clarification for my own intellectual gratification. But you sound really defensive for some reason.

(By the way, I do not work in ad-tech nor in ad-blocking tech and I have no stake in anything slightly related to the matter at hand.)

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by chrisoverzero on Saturday December 11, 2021 @07:52PM (#29525951)
> Not gonna waste more time on this tbh […]

Much better to waste everyone else’s time, right?

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by tblt on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:39AM (#29507764)
> Wipr doesn't do anything, literally

As somebody currently using Wipr and not seeing any ads, would you mind bridging the gap between your assertions and my reality? Genuinely curious how we could be truthfully so out of step on this.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by 1_player on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:13AM (#29507966)
Wipr works for me as well. Not as good as uBlock Origin, but blocks most ads on my iPhone.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by DavideNL on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:03AM (#29507214)
So "Adguard for Safari" is a scam, for example ?
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by cookiengineer on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:45AM (#29507457)
You picked literally the only choice left that's not a scam.

I updated my previous comment with more details, hence the comment was written on mobile initially.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by less_less on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:10AM (#29507253)
Do you want to call out any particularly malicious ad blockers here? Just in case I happen to have installed one of them.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by blub on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:16AM (#29507286)
Since parent tested all of them and they’re not kidding, it follows that yours must be a scam.

Unless they didn’t test everything or were exaggerating that is.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by less_less on Friday December 10, 2021 @11:55AM (#29512126)
Yeah. Also I know that mine blocks ads, but parent alluded to a spectrum of malice and scamminess. If it cost $2 but it's a mediocre fork of ABP and that's all, then I'm already out the $2 and I might as well keep it installed. If parent claims it's outright malware that steals passwords, mines crypto and holds your cat pictures for ransom then I'm at least going to investigate.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by cookiengineer on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:44AM (#29507451)
Since you made up your mind, you must be one of those scamware devs.

Unless you were exaggerating and actually don't use MacOS or Safari anyways.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by blub on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:13AM (#29507621)
Not that hard to make ones mind when I personally use two perfectly fine blockers, you posted no proof of your hyperbolic claims that all Safari ad blockers are scams and at the time I replied you hadn’t even posted any names of problematic blockers.

And now you’re calling me a scammer for criticizing your statements…

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by blub on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:14AM (#29507278)
I’ve used Better for a long time and it’s not a scam. It also doesn’t have access to web content.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by greggh on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:18AM (#29521965)
I use Wipr and it is great. I don't see ads, which is the reason I use it. So I don't see your point. Other than the fact that you are making a competitor, so you are incentivized to post something like this.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by arthur-st on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:52AM (#29508202)
Time to share the testing protocol details, I think. Unless you want people to just believe that [4,5], two of 3 most recommended ad blockers for Apple devices, don’t work or don’t remain up to date.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by katbyte on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:16AM (#29507986)
could you expand on 3,4, and 5? you have listed them with no context as to why and the links are not helpful.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by marban on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:58AM (#29507882)
AdBlock Pro — Happy with it
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by belorn on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:56AM (#29508508)
Google could add a simple button in Chrome if they wanted to trust users to make their own decision about displaying Google advertisement on Chrome. Instead they went with a decision that results in more google advertisements reaching users, which means that it is EFF that doesn't trust users?

Technology changes means nothing without outcomes, or else it is just changes to electrical potential of positive and negative state. If extensions like uBlock Origin are crippled or forced to leave than the outcome is crap, which is what occurred when safari did a similar "step in the direction of privacy, security, and performance". I wonder if google was aware of this when making the decision.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by arepublicadoceu on Friday December 10, 2021 @07:06AM (#29508930)
> Random ad blockers are very dangerous, but there are ad blockers that everyone trusts, and you might not want to make it harder for them to maintain their projects.

The answer to "Random ad blockers are dangerous" is not: Let's cripple all adblockers to safeguard our "users".

The obvious answer is create a review process similar to what Firefox did. Maybe Google should use some of their 0.0001% annual income to contract a full time review team to protect us against rogue extensions.

I think an honest interlocutor would look at what's behind Big Corp double speech:

Google: Protect ad-revenue while pretending to protect users.

Apple: Protect Apple against government pressure while pretending to protect the children.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by kstenerud on Friday December 10, 2021 @01:16AM (#29506941)
The article talks about the extension review process at Mozilla (hint: It's manageable) and bad/malicious extensions. So I'm not sure where your "other side of the story" bit comes from...
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by mariusor on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:31AM (#29507374)
> But EFF doesn't trust you to make that decision on your own.

But neither does google on the other hand, and they're the ones that can actually do something more about it than writing a blog post.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by extropy on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:55AM (#29507855)
I think we should expect EFF being on higher moral ground.

That's kinda what we are paying them to be, no?

Google is just a for profit company.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by downWidOutaFite on Friday December 10, 2021 @12:55AM (#29506864)
That seems like an unnecessarily uncharitable reading of what they're saying.

We are constantly handing over power to big tech in the name of security, and they inevitably end up using that power against us.

Yes there are shady actors out there, but that doesn't mean we have to give the tech monopolies a monopoly over what are the capabilities of the internet and who can be trusted.