News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by veeti on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:31AM (#29507375)
There is no decision left to make once this change goes through. You can talk about improved security all you want, but the fact remains that uBlock Origin will be permanently crippled. This by far negates any security or privacy gain that Manifest v3 could possibly make.

Switch to Firefox.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by hyperman1 on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:45AM (#29507802)
This is in fact one of the best arguments pro to do the change:

* Chrome destroys ad blocking

* Advanced users now suffer the same internet as everyone else

* Advanced users will find a solution, and that solution can't be chrome anymore

* This starts an exodus of advanced users .

* Advanced users configure the browsers for everybody else, hence everybody else also joins the exodus

The end result is less of a monopoly.

This is the same mechanism that ultimately killed of IE and moved everybody to chrome: The monopoly of the time got so arrogant they didn't listen to their users, so users fled to a better alternative.

The strange thing is, groups of people have more or less the same tolerance for abuse, know their limits have already been violated for a while, and learn alternatives from each other. As a result, It takes a long time of abuse to trigger an exodus, but when it started, it starts everywhere at the same time. Then the abuser tries stopping the exodus by rolling back only the last change, but that's not enough anymore.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by 74B5 on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:38AM (#29508119)
Unfortunately, Mozilla does not have a track record of listening to their user base too and afaik they never had any monopoly. They just pushed their Track/Ad-Features out of desperation(?), which leads to the root of the problem: commodification of common goods like privacy and its resulting degradation.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by piokoch on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:00AM (#29507886)
Looking in the internet I see that "94% of Mozilla revenues came through royalties received by search engines to be featured on its Mozilla Firefox browser" I am afraid that at some point Mozilla can be forced to comply and cripple ad blockers too.

Hopefully someone will decide to come up with a totally new browser. I remember times when BitKeeper told Linus that they will somehow try to charge for using their tool to keep Linux kernel source code (can't remember the story, but they managed to irritate Linus, delicately speaking).

Linus sat down and started coding... and created Git.

Unfortunately browser is a more complicated piece of software, but maybe this is also a problem we should solve.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by Vinnl on Friday December 10, 2021 @06:10AM (#29508580)
Alternative sources of income are growing - the share of search engine deals was down to 86% last year, apparently: https://www.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/rcc7m6/mozilla_aga...
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by vin047 on Friday December 10, 2021 @08:15AM (#29509455)
Perhaps Mozilla should put the more advanced features and customisation options behind a monthly subscription. I know people dislike monthly subscriptions, but the browser is perhaps THE most important tool you can use. Maybe it's time we start valuing it properly.
Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by belorn on Friday December 10, 2021 @10:32AM (#29511038)
The share of those profits that goes to Firefox development is far less than one might think, especially if one consider the many millions that goes to management of Mozilla foundation. Firefox would be a very different project if all the royalties received by search engines featured in the Firefox browser went to improve Firefox.

As long profits from Firefox does not goes back into developing Firefox, a monthly subscription wouldn't change things.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by EMM_386 on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:18AM (#29507997)
> Hopefully someone will decide to come up with a totally new browser.

The enormous complexity of browsers these days makes this almost impossible.

A better solution would be for Mozilla to direct all funding directly to Firefox and try to find other ways to monetize the browser.

Brave is trying one approach but now they are also tied to the underlying Chromium engine. I am not sure what the effort will be like to try to maintain a fork that ignores Manifest v3.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by amelius on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:22AM (#29508018)
> Switch to Firefox.

And if you're a webmaster, add some crippling/inconveniencing logic if user agent equals chrome.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by knob on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:56AM (#29508512)
I despise Chrome.

Yet I oppose your suggestion. Lets be above that.

Re:Chrome users beware: Manifest v3 is deceitful and threate... by amelius on Friday December 10, 2021 @08:41AM (#29509682)
You don't win this fight for freedom by not playing the same game as the big corporations.

> Google throttles the load time of non-AMP ads by giving them artificial one-second delays in order to give Google AMP a “nice comparative boost.”

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28975443