News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by edent on Thursday December 09, 2021 @10:55AM (#29498862)
Good?

What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free".

Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by whimsicalism on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:41AM (#29499570)
> Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

???? Did I miss the part where Google announced they were adding searchable metadata at the same time they eliminated adding this info to the title?

If not, seems like a clearly anti-consumer move.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by tomc1985 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:01PM (#29499879)
App titles not being filled with a bunch of promo crap sounds pretty pro-consumer to me

"It is what it says on the tin"

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by whimsicalism on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:19PM (#29500168)
Unless the tin says anything about whether or not it includes ads.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by tomc1985 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:26PM (#29500257)
Referring more to the title field merely being a title, and not some banner to fill with attention-grabbing crap
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by downWidOutaFite on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:03PM (#29502208)
It's Google's fault that the title is the only field that is searchable. They're never going to add a searchable "ads" field.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by kroltan on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:36PM (#29502581)
Yes, because "Verby Noun" game titles and "<Word>-ly" app titles are incredibly informative at first glance.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by jimmaswell on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:52AM (#29499712)
Listings show whether they have ads, in-app purchases etc. on a separate screen
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by megatoaster on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:54AM (#29499766)
Searching 'no ads' seemingly won't query that tag, seemingly.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by drusepth on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:34PM (#29500354)
Seems pretty trivial to eventually add, compared to trying to enforce correctness on results from user-provided tags in titles.

I'm a little surprised you can't search for "no ads" apps outside of e.g. Pass listings, but I'm really glad they're not defaulting to just a title text search and cluttered listings of Farming Simulator [NO ADS] [NO IAPS] [NO REFERRALS] [NO TIMEWAITS] [NO DLC].

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by tyingq on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:16PM (#29500909)
It's not searchable for a reason. Ad free apps don't generate revenue for Google. So devs added it to the title. Google is now closing that loophole.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by drusepth on Thursday December 09, 2021 @08:38PM (#29505474)
Given that they already highlight ad-free apps, prominently display ad-or-no-ad statuses at the top of every app detail page, curate specifically-ad-free lists of recommended apps, and use "ad-free" verbiage as a selling point to promote individual apps (as well as lists of recommended apps), I don't think it's fair to just jump to assuming Google's purposefully against making it easier to find ad-free apps.

I'm not even sure I'm convinced that ad-free apps don't generate revenue for Google, even ignoring the ad-free apps that DO generate revenue for Google through IAPs and other non-ad means.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by tyingq on Friday December 10, 2021 @07:40AM (#29509173)
They don't highlight ad-free apps. They put a "contains ads" note on the others. You mention IAP, which is also a tag you can't search for. I remain skeptical that a company specializing in search won't let you search on that data, 13 years after launch, for any reason other than money.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by drusepth on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:33AM (#29518981)
You can't search/filter for anything other than type-of-app/game. In fact, they added the tags for ads/IAPs and hoicked them to the top of the page, rather than sticking them with the rest of the app metadata below the fold. I'd be more willing to think a lack of ad-status filters was nefarious if it was suspiciously missing from a list of other searchable filters.

The fact that they don't have any support for filtering just says to me that they don't really care about app discovery outside of what they build suggested lists for, which seems orthogonal here since some of the suggested lists they curate are literally titled "Ad-free games" (plus "Offline games", "Premium games", "No-interruption games", etc which are also all largely filled with no-ad games, with a few exceptions).

Maybe they're omitting entire features / filter systems just so they don't have to add the sub-ability to just see which apps don't have ads, but I doubt it. As other comments have stated, a lot of people just don't want Amazon-like product titles crammed with keywords on keywords, especially when they're not even checked for correctness. I'm one of those people.

I'd say this probably boils down to a differing fundamental assumption we have: your comment seems to imply you might think big companies are inherently out to maximize profits through manipulating people, even if that means intentionally making a product worse for customers. If that's the case, there's really no point in debating here since that's a completely different conversation and I doubt either of us have the necessary internal evidence needed to convince the other of the real intentions behind withholding this specific feature.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by throwaway2048 on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:08PM (#29500821)
its trivial to add, yet hasn't been added in almost 15 years, it is very much a title text search and nothing about this move indicates otherwise.

there is no economic interest from google to make ad free apps actually findable, and no chance somebody making a better play store is going to usurp their position.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by handrous on Thursday December 09, 2021 @03:07PM (#29502250)
Even Apple doesn't have a "show only actually-free" toggle on their store for free apps with no IAP and no ads. Which sucks.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by MereInterest on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:42PM (#29501209)
User time is valuable, and must be respected. Data being present somewhere, in some form, doesn't mean that it is in a form that can be reasonably used. If I want to find an application without ads, requiring me to open every search result and manually check whether there are ads is very anti-consumer.

My opinion here would be different if an alternative search interface existed. However, the Google Play Store's API is focused on developers and doesn't allow for making searches. In addition, the Terms of Service forbid redistribution of content, so a third-party API that scrapes the results would be forbidden. By removing alternatives, Google has taken responsibility for a good user interface (and blame for a bad user interface) onto themselves.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by mthoms on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:14PM (#29501613)
Would building a Play Store search index that contains metadata and snippets (just like Google itself) be considered "redistributing" that content?

Hasn't Google itself argued that such activities are explicitly not redistribution?

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by npteljes on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:18AM (#29499192)
The alternative I'd like is making common user expectations into formalized properties of the software, making them visible and searchable. Like how it lists "Offers in-app purchases" currently, it could also list "Ad-free", "Free", etc.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by chalst on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:27AM (#29499361)
F-Droid does this already with its listing of 'anti-features' for each app.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by medstrom on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:47AM (#29499645)
Yes, what I've sometimes done is search F-Droid first, then find that same app on the iOS app store.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by npteljes on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:32PM (#29501836)
Yes, and I love it! I'm using LineageOS for the third year now.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by tut-urut-utut on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:50AM (#29499680)
> What's the alternative? Have a crappy, paid-for, add filled, bloated app promote itself as "Cauliflower Cooker Lite - the #1 free cauliflower app. 100% ad-free".

That's what we have on Amazon now. Looks like every single product contain all the metadata in product title. SEO spam from top to the bottom of the search results page.

I hate it, but given how crappy filtering on both Amazon and Play store is, I still prefer to see more information about a product in the search result list than less, even if that means bloated titles.

On the other hand, if both Amazon and Play store had usable filtering, all these bloated names would not be needed.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by discreditable on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:55PM (#29500650)
Google themselves have mildly loaded app titles too.

Google Chrome: Fast & Secure

Google Go: A lighter, faster way to search

Gboard - the Google Keyboard

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by rpdillon on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:54AM (#29499748)
What information folks are allowed to supply is distinct from ensuring its accuracy, I think. Misleading app names are a problem regardless, but given that many apps have ads and charge for the ad-free experience, it seems odd the developer isn't allowed to highlight that in the title.

But Google can do as they wish: another reason alternative app stores have an important role to play.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by j1elo on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:38AM (#29499525)
> Metadata like file size, whether there are in-app ads or purchases, etc, should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

Well yeah, the theory is easy. I'd say "Yes" to what you say, IFF the metadata is usable as a search filter. Otherwise, it's of no use, thus not a better solution in practice.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by hdjjhhvvhga on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:18AM (#29499199)
> should be part of the store's listing - not the title.

How long has Google store been operating (under various names)? Over a decade I think. Do they know people would love to choose between apps with and without ads? Of course. Why they decided not to implement it in the listing? Because they live from ads. There is exactly zero chance they will do it as you propose.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by Kylekramer on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:28AM (#29499374)
They've shown whether an app has ads for over five years: https://www.androidpolice.com/2016/04/28/the-play-store-star...
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by addingnumbers on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:54AM (#29499758)
They won't have my appreciation or respect until they let me permanently filter out paid or adware apps and keep them filtered out until I choose to see them again.

It would be so easy to implement, it seems scornful not to. When I want a needle, they hand me a haystack and say "we etched 'this is a needle' into the needles for you so you'll know when you find one. Good luck."

I admit I haven't used android for three or four years so maybe they have this capability now, would love to be corrected if so.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by dotancohen on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:01PM (#29499881)

  > I admit I haven't used android for three or four years so maybe they have this capability now, would love to be corrected if so.
Nothing has changed.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by xnx on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:02PM (#29514800)
You could do a Google search something like this: [inurl:https://play.google.com/store/apps/ -"Contains Ads"]
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by skratlo on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:45AM (#29499608)
Absolutely NOT! It's waaay better to have huge multinational corporation dictate what's right and what's wrong and what's good and what's bad! And they do it for you my friend! For FREE!
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by krolden on Thursday December 09, 2021 @11:48AM (#29499651)
Well its their platform
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by carlhjerpe on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:06PM (#29499968)
It doesn't work like that when you're one of two players in the segment, that's what antitrust is about. "It's their platform" would work well if there were any significant alternatives, which there aren't.
Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by drusepth on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:38PM (#29500417)
There are many popular app stores on Android and you're free to use any of them (or none of them, if you just download apps directly from websites) without rooting your phone, jailbreaking, etc.

A recent list of someone's favorites: https://42matters.com/blog/?p=the-best-of-2020-a-list-of-app...

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday December 09, 2021 @01:29PM (#29501063)
Apple and Google together have 95% market share.

From the perspective of an Android user, a lot of the alternatives are interesting. Especially F-Droid.

From the perspective of the app developer, it doesn't work. You use Apple and Google or you lose 95% of the market.

And the same constraint keeps it that way. You lose most of the Android market if you're not in Google Play, so nearly everything that isn't explicitly banned can be found in Google Play, so most users have no occasion to install any other app store and the friction to developers using another one to the exclusion of Google Play remains high.

Re:Tell HN: You can't add “no ads” in your Play Store app's ... by entropicdrifter on Thursday December 09, 2021 @12:43PM (#29500481)
I'd agree completely if you were talking about Apple and the App Store here, but this is Android. You can install alternative app stores on it without rooting it or any sort of advanced user skills. F-Droid is pretty great IMO.