* Law enforcement simply asks nicely: can render all message content for the last 1-7 years
Yet, I'm pretty sure all these are still happening, to a certain degree, to this day.
[0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-nsa-spying-idUSKBN25T...
Recent cases:
https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkppqk/court-throws-out-mess...
https://www.computerweekly.com/news/252503524/Berlin-court-f...
You know, like the US does in the countries of it's "allies" like Germany [0]
Do you really think the US would allow German intelligence agencies to build whole complexes, plugged right into the US's largest IPX?
That's why this situation is not nearly as "symbiotic" as it's often made out to be. At best that applies to Five Eyes countries, and even there only to a very limited degree as no Five Eyes member as as much foreign presence as the US.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON#Examples_of_industrial...
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/aug/01/nsa-paid-gch...
And then when they get caught, they do this:
It's funny how much this differs from my own personal experience with law enforcement. The friends I know are timid as hell and don't do anything without a warrant just to stay on the safe side- even if they probably don't need one.
In my case the government did violate the SCA and my constitutional rights, but two judges have looked at it and both stated the same answer - the police must be allowed to commit crimes to gather evidence. Next stop: appeal courts.
I was involved with a case that sounds similar - the judges don't care about your rights and blatantly missapply the law. Also, magistrates are also complete BS, and don't even know basic legal stuff. I had one think I called him prejudice when requesting a case be dismissed with prejudice... Complaints do nothing. There's no real oversight, leading to a completely incompetent system.
It's the system working as intended. If you want something that looks like justice, you'll need substantial wealth to get it.
So these kinds of claims just don't make any sense in a world where we know that government has conducted surveillance without a warrant, and where we know that the FBI has built entire programs designed to make it easier for them to conduct surveillance without a warrant.
From the article posted that you're replying to:
> What Administration officials tend to obscure is that what they seek is not immunity for future cooperation with lawful surveillance, but rather telecom immunity for assisting with unlawful surveillance conducted from October 2001 through January 17, 2007, as part of the warrantless wiretap program initiated by the White House.
I'm not sure I understand what your implication is. I don't understand how it's possible to respond to an article that is about telecoms seeking immunity for previous unlawful actions by saying, "the government/businesses would be way too scared to do anything unlawful." I mean... obviously not, they sought immunity for it. They wouldn't just randomly do that, the most likely explanation is that they made immunity a pressing issue because they thought they needed it.
It does not seem to me that the optimistic world you describe and the observable actions and lobbying efforts of companies/administrations line up with each other.
If on the other hand his friends are street cops tasked with clearing a corner of drug dealers because some neighbor complained to their council person who complained to the police chief then those cops don’t necessarily care about extrajudicial activities.
Having been harassed by street cops and interacted with homicide detectives, I can tell you they vary tremendously in professionalism.
This is terribly naive in my experience.
An EO making it lawful for a federal agency to collect doesn't mean it is lawful for a private company to disclose, it doesn't change when a company is permitted to disclose the content of messages under the SCA
This was for a startup.
I have no doubt they do the same for governments.
Still. It meant a very powerful API key had to be protected and never abused.
I can only imagine others obtain God SMS access like this with less than ethical intentions.
Nobody should make decisions based on this comment.
It doesn't matter where your data is held, locally or cloud, (if you are an American resident and your data is in the USA) as it is _your_ data and it is unconstitutional for them to read it without a warrant. In theory.
In the US it does
This ruling has been adopted by the US Supreme Court: https://privacylaw.proskauer.com/2007/06/articles/electronic...
https://www.nbcnews.com/technolog/how-long-do-wireless-carri...
Not counting media and assuming they are all 160 byte messages, that's 4 terabytes per day, or about 200 wikipedia's per day. I guess that's not too bad in terms of storage requirements, certainly a management amount of data for a telecom to store. But assuming that you want those indexed and easily retrievable somehow, it could get very burdensome to manage and interact with, and that tends to balloon the size at least a little bit as well.
The liability and legal issues around it (both externally and internally - don't want employees spying on their exes, leaking data from celebs, in addition to the policing issues, etc) makes it pretty undesirable to store though.
* Message content: All
* Subpoena: can render all message content for the last 1-7 years
* 18 U.S.C 2703(d): can render all message content for the last 1-7 years
* Search warrant: can render all message content for the last 1-7 years
* Vague suspicion plus a small fee to the carrier: can render all message content for the last 1-7 years