Let me give a concrete example: The first time I used Stripe and Uber, I immediately wanted to invest. But I couldn't because I wasn't wealthy nor well connected enough. If they had been a DAO, I could have invested $100 and paid off my student debt and theoretical mortgage AND probably covered losing investments. One winner covers many losers, which is how VCs play the game. That's the power of early investment.
Those kind of returns are only available to the already wealthy under our current laws. Why should that be? By the time a company IPOs most of the opportunity has already been extracted. How many of us have wanted to invest in Stripe for years now? We still can't. We can only sit and watch as its largest growth years go by and the rich get richer. In the eventual IPO they'll sell their shares to us now that they've appreciated by orders of magnitude. These laws should be abolished, but I wouldn't hold one's breath. So I'm in favor of the cryptoeconomy being an alternative that one can opt into.
You can’t really have it both ways, you can’t have a super strong social safety net for people who lose it all and a system where it’s easy to gamble your life savings on incredibly unregulated markets and incentive all the scammers to come out of the woodwork.
There’s a reason IPOs are much later these days than during the Dotcom boom precisely because too many retail investors lost their shirt to pump and dumps which at scale leads to broader social instability.
I really liked this point. Then I thought about it more and I think the reason why we have accredited investor laws is because we don't actually have that strong of a social safety net. For example, I've often wondered how much risk people would be free to take if we had a UBI or government dividend or whatever ya wanna call it. If people had a guaranteed income (or guaranteed home or guaranteed other basic service), how much more risk would people be able to take? I imagine a lot.
Conversely, I've worked in entrepreneurship in the US and in East Africa. In East Africa, I think because there's very little social safety net (government provided, there's more social safety in family networks), it can be really really risky to try to be an entrepreneur.
All that to say that I think if, frankly, the ones who win the bets they place would put more money into social safety nets, then others could take more bets as well. I just think sometimes the people who win the bets they place think they won because they're skilled not because of mostly random luck and then don't contribute to government or non-government social safety nets, thus we make laws preventing the majority of people making bets that could drop them through the safety net that currently exists.
Yes, and then what do you do when they have taken all that risk with their UBI? UBI only works if you draw the line there - you have to tell people there is no other support. Otherwise they will just gamble their UBI away and fall back on the same safety nets that currently exist.
Very comparable: the idea of just letting unvaccinated people die in hospital parking lots. Yes, they were stupid. Yes, they were told about as much. But no, that's not the sort of offense that warrants the death penalty. No, not even if you suspect they'd gladly let you die of your delayed reaction to the vaccine, if that were actually a thing.
The real problem is that we need much more investment in ideas that are considered good/useful by some kind of democratic standard. This is a monstrosity of a puzzle to figure out. It would take a long quest transforming the questions it raises to the quality required and much effort in gathering usable data before any kind of possible answers (read 'bad') could be considered.
Seems like you could have it both ways, if you wanted
Accredited investor laws exist to protect common people from the endless amount of scams we see crypto have today.
If you don't like the laws then petition to have them changed, but simply ignoring them will probably result in the SEC knocking on your door.
More profitable but more risky is the most you can hope for. There is competition in private equity market so it's not like it's profitable unicorns for everyone who has access to those opportunities. If anything you should be able to invest in a private equity firm to begin with so they can balance the risk for you by investing in portfolio of assets and guess what - you can do just that as some are publicly traded!
It's really not an evil plan. The regulation is just common sense to protect you from big risk of going bankrupt.
There is plenty of opportunity in public market btw. Some examples of x20s from recent years: SHOP, AMD, TESLA. Some examples of very recent although smaller multipliers: NET (really, if you just read HN once a week you know they are awesome), Unity. I mean if you are so confident about picking Uber it shouldn't be rocket science to pick one of the above either.
The risk of going bankrupt is part and parcel of trying to suceed and live the life you want, whether in business, investing, day trading, or even just getting a university education in some places…
You probably don't have a sustainable investment strategy if bankruptcy is a likely outcome. You may have a gambling problem that involves securities, but that would not be "investment".
Not allowing small investors to buy shares in non-public (and therefore not needing to disclose much information) companies doesn't sound like an especially radical idea. You just need resources to do due diligence to invest in such companies and as a small investor you don't. There is a common interests in preventing people from being idiots in the investment world.
First, just because people do it doesn't mean it 'should' be done. See the naturalistic fallacy.
Second, just because smaller investors lack resources, doesn't imply they should be prevented from acting with less information. This doesn't follow from your final claim that there is a common interest in preventing them from participating and this is unsubstantiated.
Let people make their own mistakes, you don't get to decide for them.
I struggle with this. I wish my mistakes didn't impact other people, and for a lot of things, they don't. But for some things, they really do.
What do you think we should do when one person's mistake impacts many others?
That being said, I think the individual vs communal risk decision and regulation is complex and really depends on the situation.
Joe Public needs to do better than the people who already have more education and tools and influence than the average person can ever expect, just to break even on their startup portfolio. And let's face it, Joe Public wants to "invest" whilst being so wilfully ignorant of basics like liquidity and adverse selection they think there's nothing to actually be protected from...
Not everyone wants a nanny state to dictate their activities.
In the absence of resources and desire to provide strong safety nets, such as the education and tools you describe above, one way is to just prevent people from doing it.
I agree with you, I'd rather have more freedom to experiment and take risks. I also don't want people to fall to their physical or financial death.
Actually, there's a book that kinda talks about this idea called Care to Dare by a former hostage negotiator named George Kohlrieser. I took his leadership training seminar and he strongly suggested that to encourage people to take risks, we must first build secure bases for them so they feel safe enough to go off and explore knowing they can come back home.
https://www.amazon.com/Care-Dare-Unleashing-Astonishing-Lead...
This is a truism that's not based on reality. You can question whether the protection is actually useful for the case, but there's a reason a bunch of professional licenses exist, and they do protect people. I don't want to "educate myself" to see if my doctor is competent to practice.
With the benefit of hindsight it's easy to see how you would have made a killing on Uber. But what you're not seeing the money you might have lost on Theranos, or Juicero, or WeWork, or any number of other hyped-up but ultimately worthless companies.
Maybe this analogy doesn't seem so applicable to you as it seems to more directly impact other people than one's permission to risk money on a stock, however, I'd argue that decision impacts family members and communities more than apparent at first.
As you acknowledge, the same goes for your speed limit example. It directly affects others and it could be argued it is necessary to protect their safety. Even though I acknowledge that, I don't think speed limits save lives over longer periods of time and could be removed. There would likely be a spike in accidents shortly after the transition but would normalize after. Having lived in several countries around the world, some with de facto no speed limits, people just avoided the left lane where the super fast people drove. I didn't see accidents everywhere.
But isn't that specifically the challenge, in defining what's a "clear and present danger to others?"
> There would likely be a spike in accidents shortly after the transition but would normalize after.
I agree that many things do normalize over time. We create informal rules on how to interact, embedded within morals, ethics, or just expectations of how one should behave in a society. I also think sometimes rules don't informally coalesce, that we don't always resolve conflict without outside guidance and more formal negotiation.
> Having lived in several countries around the world, some with de facto no speed limits, people just avoided the left lane where the super fast people drove.
From my (cursory) understanding of at least German law, while there may not be a speed limit on some roads, those roads often have very strict laws about passing on the right, and one might get their licensed removed for doing so.
You may be a conscientious person and take responsibility for outcomes which arise out of your "freedom". But not everyone would take responsibility and that is why these laws are there.
Me too, because the "cryptoecomony" has been an endless series of painful lessons on exactly why we need those laws. And not even in new ways! Just literally the exact same kinds of scams and abuses that led to these laws being passed in the 30s.
Cryptocurrency is the first modern wave of unaccredited wealth generation that is beyond regulatory control. Many people were fleeced by alt coins and get rich quick schemes. Academics have more than enough examples to draw conclusions from and use to advise policymakers, if they were so inclined to. Poor rubes didn't bet everything they had on crypto, although there undoubtedly is anecdotal evidence of some doing so. Losses were actually quite within the band of acceptance. Homes weren't lost. Family fortunes weren't wiped out.
I wonder if skirting the law is the best way to change the law, as it seems to skirt the law-making and law-following process. At the same time, I believe in the principles of civil disobedience, in openly disobeying a law and facing the consequences for doing so in order to shed light on the unfairness of the law. I guess I just don't know how much, if at all, I believe in the skirting of laws.
It's 99% just evading existing laws. The best example of this is the browser Brave which only uses a cryptocurrency so that they could raise money without following the accredited investor laws.
The issues crypto can solve are 1) the government/bank can't steal your money, 2) the government/bank can't hide corrupt transfers, and 3) you don't need permission from the government/bank to exchange cryptocoins. If the government/bank wasn't a bureaucratic mess it could solve all of these issues centrally. Decentralization is good because it's hard to create a central agency without it turning into a bureaucratic mess.
Also, could an open ledger make corruption more visible and harder to get away with? Yes, it could. Will it? I'm not so sure.
They have no incentive to change how they've done things. I do think it would be cool if there was an automated solution for real estate transactions that didn't require crypto (or smart contracts). That would be great and I think someone should do it if they can.
> So maybe it's not so much skirting of laws, but sometimes also working around systems, not with a bad intention, but because things aren't necessarily keeping up with technological change.
I think this is right on the mark. The US banking system is a great example. Many of the arguments I see against the benefits of instant payments in crypto are from people in Europe, where instant payments are commonplace. I do think the competition and innovation in crypto forces existing legacy structures to innovate, which IMO is a good thing. The other thing is to consider those who are unbanked and unable to participate in existing structures, but do have smart phones. I think crypto can play a part in their lives as well.
> Also, could an open ledger make corruption more visible and harder to get away with? Yes, it could. Will it? I'm not so sure.
I agree. I'm not sure crypto will supersede all existing structures. I do like the idea of governments and politicians having to be more transparent, but I don't think they will give up what they have now.
From what I understand, and I admittedly don't feel certain on this at all, LLCs are private entities where ownership can only be offered privately, not open to be sold on a public exchange, and many DAOs plan to sell their tokens on public exchanges.
Again, I think laws can change and personally think we need more global overarching governance to deal with internet interactions, yet think that some of these things are quite incompatible/contradictory to current law.
LLCs are just one business entity type and a DAO does not have to be an LLC.
Also, to sell publicly, I'm pretty sure they need to register with the SEC, but unsure, do they have to list on a stock exchange?
They can be sold privately in a bunch of different ways and not necessarily just to accredited investors depending upon how the investment is structured and who it is offered to.
Despite that, I like what seems to be their intention around cooperatively-owned research, so I'll try to follow them to see what comes of it. Thank you.
edit: Also, maybe one of the problems is that the internet is global and most regulation is at most national, so even if it were to break US laws, does it break other national, regional, or local laws? Do DAOs and crypto lead to some larger global form of governance?
[0]: https://www.casebriefs.com/blog/law/securities-regulation/se...
For example, could organizations give stocks/shares/tokens/choose-your-security-name to users of a platform in the current (US) legal environment? I don't have the legal background to know. Can they sell private securities to any user? I think no because it would go against accredited investor laws. Also, I think if they're selling to an open public, it might violate SEC laws by being a public security, not a private security, unless they also reported truthfully about risks, etc., to the SEC.
So what if the law got rid of the accredited investor requirement? Or got rid of the reporting requirements for public vs private securities?
So I think one part is that companies aren't legally allowed to sell private shares to just any individual and if they do sell to any individual, they aren't legally allowed to not report to the SEC.
I think another part is that I wonder how many companies actually want more cooperative/democratic style ownership. Cooperatives (one member, one vote) have struggled to get investment because of that precise equality in decision making. [edit-added] And also, a more equal profit-sharing may not be in the interest of many people wanting to become the next unicorn billionaire.
So it makes me wonder how many of the orgs using DAOs are doing so because they want to become more equal cooperative-like orgs, and how many are doing so to skirt securities laws.