News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by chickenpotpie on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:07PM (#29205557)
I for one am glad to see a company push back on blockchain technologies and their horrendous environmental impact. As an environmentalist in the computing space, it makes me so depressed to see our industry regress so much in environmental impact.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by colesantiago on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:23PM (#29205681)
Cryptocurrencies isn't the only space to have a poor environmental footprint, Machine Learning as well has a horrible record and contributes to harming the environment.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by bko on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:36PM (#29205784)
If there were only some way to allocate resources based on their most productive means.

Imagine if you could attach a number to a resource, like energy, that accounts for its various possible usages. If the resource becomes more available, this number will go down and if it becomes more scarce, the number would go up.

If you wanted to use the resource, you would have to pay this number. So naturally, you wouldn't pay to use the resource for something silly. Similarly, if it's important, you'd pay as much as you had to to use the resource. This would discourage people from using the resource foolishly.

The beautiful thing about this system is that you don't have to have moral judgements about what is or isn't worthy. It wouldn't be up to any one individual to say you should use resource for X and not Y. The number would be self adjusting as more or less resources become made available or more or less uses for the resources are discovered. And as the number went up, it would incentivize people to create more of that resource or create a resource to replace it.

If only such a number existed...

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by bfdm on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:41PM (#29205823)
Yea this doesn't really work when the resource is also necessary to live and in parallel has massive externalities not being properly accounted for.

This is some praise the market reductive lunacy. Obviously energy production, pricing and consumption needs to be heavily regulated in any sensible society.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by thinkloop on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:59PM (#29205964)
If only it were possible to adjust that number to better reflect these market failings through a shared elected body of some sort...
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Karrot_Kream on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:57PM (#29205958)
> If there were only some way to allocate resources based on their most productive means.

If that were the case, we'd have optimal formulas to allocate goods throughout the economy and market economics would be completely obsolete. Whatever your position on markets, the reason they exist is because we don't know how to most efficiently allocate goods a priori. Markets and prices offer us a mechanism, however imperfect and prone to externalities, to allocate resources efficiently. You'd also probably be able to solve the Knapsack problem and the Multi-Armed Bandit problem. I'd love something like this also, but I'm not holding my breath.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by hmrr on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:30PM (#29205725)
Also rebuilding the same docker containers 500 times a day…

We could do a whole lot better with our energy usage across the whole industry.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jnwatson on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:34PM (#29205754)
Let’s ban CI. Imagine all the extra CPU cycles we spend testing our software.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by pcwalton on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:49PM (#29205879)
The difference is that CPU cycles that go to CI have value in that they expose defects in software before users run into them, where they would cause more economic damage. If CI didn't exist, then the overall utility of software would decrease, so in effect CI pays for itself. This is not so with cryptocurrency.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Karrot_Kream on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:28PM (#29206181)
Do you have proof of this assertion? Otherwise it sounds like the Reduce, Reuse, Recycle greenwashing that corporations put out in the '90s to get us to believe that using plastic overconsumption wasn't really bad at all. All I'm reading is: it needs to be banned if I don't like it, but if I use it and like it then it's useful.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by pcwalton on Friday November 12, 2021 @08:03PM (#29206353)
I don't want cryptocurrency mining to be banned, since it's essentially impossible to do that, but I wish people would stop mining cryptocurrency as I don't see benefits that outweigh the costs. There's nothing wrong with expressing opinions as to what society's resources should go to.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by occz on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:46PM (#29205853)
The fact that you're trying to make anyone think that the two are comparable is ridiculous.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Ekaros on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:49PM (#29205880)
How much resources we spend on adds and tracking? What is the footprint of all the extra code that gets downloaded each time we load some website? Could we do better?
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by dagmx on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:56PM (#29205948)
I assume you're talking about training? But inference in turn can save many CPU cycles by reducing computation to get results.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by LurkingPenguin on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:31PM (#29205733)
"[Something else] has a bad environmental footprint too" is the most tiresome refrain from crypto boosters. It's nothing more than pure whataboutism.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Guest42 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:36PM (#29205779)
Personally, I get tired of the apples to oranges comparisons whereby bitcoins and blockchain have the same feature set as currency and banks.

Also get tired of the aspirational rants of how it is going to fix supply chains and offer banking to the underserved communities. And yes, I understand banking, supply chains, and crypto enough to know that that will never happen.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by beckman466 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:50PM (#29205886)
> Also get tired of the aspirational rants of how it is going to fix supply chains and offer banking to the underserved communities. And yes, I understand banking, supply chains, and crypto enough to know that that will never happen.

agreed. have you heard of hREA [1] and http://valueflo.ws, led by Bob and Lynn from http://mikorizal.org, and others? it's sort of an open source SAP alternative designed as local-first networked software. "Radically distributed supply chain systems". it uses the REA accounting method [2] to implement LETS and mutual credit type economic networks for cooperatives / small business ecosystems / commons based peer production / any transitional/solidarity economies.

Bonfire is also implementing the Valueflows vocabulary on ActivityPub [3].

[1] https://github.com/holo-rea/holo-rea

[2] http://www.jeffsutherland.org/oopsla97/haugen.html

[3] https://bonfirenetworks.org/

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Guest42 on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:34PM (#29206207)
I appreciate the response and will have to investigate these. My more recent jobs have taken me away from these areas but they are very interesting topics.

I think that there are many valid ways to improve business systems software, but that the current leaders are entrenched to a level that they won’t be replaced, similar to libre office not taking off regardless of its rich set of features. I am glad that open source databases have done well though.

I recall working at a large manufacturing warehouse that switched systems, 2 years into the schedule they had to continue to push out the changeover for a variety of issues.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by colesantiago on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:34PM (#29205764)
I don't understand, I actually agree with the OP? unless it's also bad to list facts?

I don't see any 'whataboutism' with my statement.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by LurkingPenguin on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:42PM (#29205836)
So what's your intent in calling out machine learning?
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by toolz on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:34PM (#29205753)
There's really no excuse for this kind of strawman this late into the game. For one, Proof of work blockchains are migrating to first world countries which are moving to renewable/nuclear energy quickly, so even if proof of work was the only consensus mechanism in the blockchain space, this sentiment would be horribly outdated and uninformed.

Secondly, the vast majority of the market cap is in crypto that isn't proof of work. So the first point doesn't even matter. Even bitcoin is moving towards a layer2 solution with the lightening network that means the settlement layer won't continue to put more pressure on needing more and more wasted energy.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by gitfan86 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:45PM (#29205851)
This is my biggest problem with crypto. It is all about how in the future all these problems will be solved. I've been hearing about how it is the future 'of micro payments', or 'the future gold', or 'the future of legal contracts'. You are saying the energy usage problem will be solved by 'moving towards a layer2', in the future.

https://www.businessinsider.com/marc-andreessen-tells-us-why...

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jimkleiber on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:58PM (#29205963)
Same for me. I'm intrigued by the tech and the geopolitical and cultural change that may result from such tech. I can feel really frustrated with the certainty with which people seem to declare that this tech has already solved future problems when it sure doesn't seem as if it has.

At the same time, I see this overhyping hyperbolic forecasting in more and more things these days, especially when people are trying to convince other people to invest money, time, and/or other resources in their endeavor. I roll my eyes if I don't outright feel angry and disgusted, because the faux certainty often spreads to many people. I try to imagine why they may express 100% certainty of future events, and often struggle to do so.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by hunterb123 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:49PM (#29205884)
That's not what he said. Lightning network is now and has been. Proof of stake is now. ETH2 has $5+ billion staked on it. Many ETH competitors are out there that are pure PoS. It's an outplayed talking point that gets more irrelevant with each passing day.

To the topic of Zulip, I find it funny they aren't on the crypto bandwagon but they are on the talking point bandwagon of crypto must be for criminals, anti-environmentalists, or scammers. Those are the only 3 points. Whew, you'd think it was 2010.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Zamicol on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:56PM (#29205947)
Ethereum is solving the layer 1 energy problem with PoS, and solving scaling with sharding, L2's, and new types of zero knowledge proofs.

As someone watching the space since the beginning, imho, Ethereum has it in the bag.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jimkleiber on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:03PM (#29206001)
I'm really curious, because I'm often much more cautious and qualified in how I speak, why do you seem to be 100% certain that Ethereum is solving and has it in the bag?

Do you have zero doubt? Do you have a lot of doubt and speak so certainly to mask your own self-doubt? Do you have a lot of money riding on it being successful therefore afraid Ethereum won't solve the problem? Maybe none of those things or a combo?

I really really struggle to know why people speak about such things with near certainty and maybe you won't answer but I hope you do and help me see what may contribute to you expressing such certainty.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Zamicol on Friday November 12, 2021 @10:00PM (#29207003)
I feel that I'm usually pretty cautious with my "bets". I would not have bet Microsoft would be implementing Linux in any capacity in 2021, even though I would consider myself a Linux fanboy since ~2002.

I have zero doubt. It's like debating if the sky is neon pink or blue. They're way ahead of everyone else.

Take just fees. https://cryptofees.info/history/2021-11-11. Ethereum is doing 77x Bitcoin, and that's excluding three other Ethereum projects ahead of Bitcoin.

I can express doubt about the success of something doing 2x of a market leader. I can't justify tempering my certainty when it's slaughtering its market peers.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jimkleiber on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:00PM (#29207250)
I think if I were to say I had no doubts and were 100% certainty about anything it would be that it is impossible to be 100% certain (even I qualified that with "I think if I were to say").

I can agree that they might be ahead in their development of new ways to address energy challenges or gas challenges or other challenges compared to other platforms, yet still struggle to imagine you have no doubt. Maybe I just consider too many variables that could come into play, such as government regulation, chilling effects, global wars, deaths of leaders, etc., that could throw off the inevitability of something achieving something in the future. To be fair, those and other variables could make it even more likely that Ethereum or cryptocurrencies in general will solve those problems, I just don't see it as 100% yes or 100% no.

Maybe I'm just built different.

That being said, I didn't know that Ethereum had such a discrepancy in terms of fee transactions compared to BTC, so I'm grateful you pointed that out and I could learn more about that aspect—thank you.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by vineyardmike on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:50PM (#29205888)
> It is all about how in the future all these problems will be solved.

Is this not all of technology in entirety?

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by gitfan86 on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:27PM (#29206172)
No. When google launched it was really good. It solved slow web searches immediately. Did it get better over time? Yes. But it didn't launch and claim that "in the future google will return results for billions of searches within milliseconds", and then keep claiming that for years
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by menzoic on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:51PM (#29205896)
As already stated the vast majority of crypto today is on proof of stake which has no energy concerns. And of course you'll always hear about the future when it comes to ground breaking tech. I'm sure you also always hear about the future of AI
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Animats on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:56PM (#29205949)
vast majority of crypto today is on proof of stake which has no energy concerns

Huh?

* Bitcoin - still proof of work.

* Etherium - still proof of work, switching to proof of stake on January 1, 2020. Or maybe December 1, 2020. Or maybe some time in 2022.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by hunterb123 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:59PM (#29205970)
ETH is transitioning. Multiple billions are staked on ETH2 already. It's not a hard switch all at once, don't suggest that.

I believe GP is correct that the majority market cap of crypto is more on PoS vs PoW, but I don't have a source readily available.

You only listed two coins, one you were wrong on as it's both PoS and PoW currently. Remember that most ETH competitors have billions in market cap and are pure PoS. Algorand, Cardano, Solana, Avalanche, Polkadot, etc.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Animats on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:20PM (#29206121)
Etherium is still mostly proof of work. Proof of stake is still Real Soon Now.

Cryptocurrencies by market cap.[1]

There's Bitcoin, Etherium, and then there's everybody else. Binance and Tether are centrally issued. Solana, #5, is the largest proof of stake coin.

[1] https://coinmarketcap.com/

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by paulgb on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:54PM (#29205924)
> Secondly, the vast majority of the market cap is in crypto that isn't proof of work.

Source? I haven’t added up the long tail but this seems dubious given the dominance of bitcoin/ethereum.

> Even bitcoin is moving towards a layer2 solution with the lightening network that means the settlement layer won't continue to put more pressure on needing more and more wasted energy.

Layer 2 doesn’t solve this. Only ~2% of the rewards that compensate miners come from transaction fees. At best, layer 2 could cut out that 2% of incentives.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by teraflop on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:01PM (#29205984)
> Source? I haven’t added up the long tail but this seems dubious given the dominance of bitcoin/ethereum.

I'm skeptical that such a calculation could even be meaningfully performed. The long tail of cryptocurrencies includes a great many whose volumes are so low that "market cap" becomes a nebulous concept.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jimbob45 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:40PM (#29205812)
>Proof of work blockchains are migrating to first world countries

The whole point of blockchains is that everyone has a copy. I don't understand why you think they're migrating unless you don't want third-world countries using blockchains.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by toolz on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:41PM (#29205820)
It doesn't matter what you or I want - I'm stating facts. and the fact is that technology is solving the dirty energy problem and miners are moving to cheap energy solutions because clean energy is cheaper.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jimbob45 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:46PM (#29205857)
No, put the energy stuff aside - I'm only concerned with learning what you mean by saying it's migrating to the first-world.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by randomhodler84 on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:01PM (#29205985)
The mining is migrating — as in the production of new blocks. The actual blockchain is free open and available to everyone in the world, with a computer and internet connection. It is not an exclusive technology for rich nations.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by vineyardmike on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:53PM (#29205920)
> I don't understand why you think they're migrating unless you don't want third-world countries using blockchains.

It has nothing to do with "want[ing] third-world countries using blockchains"

He means that more of the mining is taking place -due to natural market incentives- in 1st world countries. 1st world countries have "greener" energy production than not 1st world countries, so this is an environmental improvement

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by dnautics on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:39PM (#29205799)
the way I see it, complaining about the environmental impact of blockchain is a bit like complaining that a early adopter's toyota prius' car has more of an environmental impact. Sure, that's strictly speaking true, but you are helping make a point - at expense to you - building investment in infrastructure that someday result in a vehicle that IS less of an impact. In the ideal case (which I am not necessarily optimistic will happen) we have a global currency that respects that there are finite resources on the planet, and doesn't require a belligerent military that goes around littering depleted uranium around the world to back its value.

(fwiw, I'm working towards getting solar on my house and mining with my excess electricity)

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by mtchtrnr on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:05PM (#29206013)
I agree that it's bad for the planet.

Can we make a list of all the sectors that are consuming energy and determine which are providing the most benefit? Then we can focus on making reductions in the most harmful and the least important energy consumers.

Crypto is a big energy consumer, but I would prefer not to attack it just because it's new. It can provide some awesome things for humanity. I'd rather live in a world with crypto than one with massive military spending, for example.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by baby on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:48PM (#29205875)
I don’t understand though, most if not all modern blockchain technologies are pretty green.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by floatboth on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:19PM (#29206118)
Who cares?

The shitcoin economy can only be viewed as a whole.

Your new "green" shitcoin will be exchanged with Bitcoin and other dominant coins that use PoW mining. Your shitcoin's value will be based on that.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by baby on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:51PM (#29206301)
Who cares about protobuf if you have json amirite
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by macinjosh on Friday November 12, 2021 @08:38PM (#29206534)
I agree the petrodollar is much better for the environment.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by skratlo on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:33PM (#29205749)
Ever heard of surplus energy? Do you think miners would ever pay for non-surplus energy?
[dead]
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by joosters on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:39PM (#29205808)
I've no idea if their self-declared 'back of the envelope' calculations are realistic, but it doesn't really matter. The comparison is plain dumb because unlike Bitcoin, clothes driers actually do something useful with their energy.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by malikNF on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:48PM (#29205876)
No its not a dumb comparison. Most of the folks who peddle this bitcoin is bad for the environment narrative don't understand what exactly bitcoin mining is.

The mining process is what makes bitcoin valuable, the energy is what's used to secure btc, there is "USE" to the energy used.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by colecut on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:41PM (#29205821)
How can you send thousands of dollars across the globe faster with less fees?
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by dogecoinbase on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:46PM (#29205854)
Given blockchain transaction fees, pretty much any way up to and including just buying flights, taking cash and bribing everyone along the way.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by colecut on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:01PM (#29205987)
I think you are referring to ethereum fees. Bitcoin is much better, and many others are even better. So, no, there isn't anything better than crypto for the purpose of efficiently transferring value across the globe.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by thesausageking on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:11PM (#29206049)
It’s costs roughly $5 to send $1m in Bitcoin. And you can it from your phone, in minutes, any time day or night, and to anyone in the world with a phone.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jdub on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:35PM (#29205773)
Dryers and video games are useful.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by lukebutton on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:33PM (#29205747)
Too true, wondering when this absurdly off target talking point is going to be discarded
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by encryptluks2 on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:15PM (#29205621)
This is an assumption that all blockchains are a PoW, which isn't accurate.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by basilgohar on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:19PM (#29205646)
With all due respect, that is similar to someone saying we need to get off of fossil fuels for the benefit of the environment, and complaining that that assumes all fossil fuels contribute equally to climate change.

Technically right but distracting from the point that the most significant blockchain usage is PoW or some other methodology that massively wastes resources of some kind, such as Chia that wastes storage space for no good purpose.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by culi on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:01PM (#29205990)
Not to mention that storage space is also an environmental impact. I think when thinking about environmental impact we're often too focused on emissions during usage and not looking at the environmental impact of manufacturing and recycling the objects themselves.

Solar panels, for example, look a lot less eco-friendly when you realize their lifespans are about 20 years and our recycling solution is to... not recycle them. Not to mention precious metals like lithium are getting harder and harder to mine, meaning more and more emissions are required to acquire those materials in the first place. It's estimated that around 46% of an EV battery's carbon footprint is in the factory itself before it's even travelled a single mile. Which is part of why total lifetime GHG emissions for EVs are still around 65% that of gasoline powered cars.[0] and only 5% of lithium-ion batteries are recycled in the US (compared to 99% of lead-iron batteries).

Sorry I'm rambling. I think my point was that we need to think more about where the materials come from and what happens to them afterwards if we want a more complete picture of the environmental impacts of a technology

[0] https://theicct.org/publications/global-LCA-passenger-cars-j...

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by ajkjk on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:32PM (#29205742)
Nobody who is complaining about this is making that assumption. PoW continues to exist, and they know that as well as you do, and it's really bad.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Ekaros on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:54PM (#29205922)
Bitcoin sadly isn't going anywhere. And if it does it will take the whole thing with it for years.

If PoS was winning why doesn't it control most of market cap?

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Zamicol on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:02PM (#29205993)
PoS is winning on almost every metric.

https://money-movers.info/ https://cryptofees.info/

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by floatboth on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:45PM (#29205848)
It does not matter that some don't. Most do, especially the biggest one, so the shitcoin economy as a whole does.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by Karrot_Kream on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:42PM (#29205830)
Look can we stop this idiotic greenwashing? I get it, you don't like crypto. But stop trying to act like it's an environmental imperative to stop using crypto. When mining crypto becomes an environmental imperative, that's when we'd have both removed emissions from our automobile usage _and_ switched to hydrogen based factory processes and _then some_. We're not even close to those goals.

Stop it. Hijack some other cause for your anti-crypto views. You don't get to make people feel good about emissions by writing anti crypto blog posts; you do it by actually advocating for lower emissions in activities that are in regular use that are _actually polluting_.

Someone is going to say something about incremental emissions reduction and to that I say, be my guest. The world is full of people selling magical products and ideas that claim to be green. The truth is, decreasing emissions is hard. Stop distracting people from the hard work needed to actually decrease emissions. If you want to help emissions out, go advocate for more buses and fewer automobiles in your community. Advocate for hydrogen subsidies for factories. Advocate for raising the gas tax. Advocate for tax rebates on weatherproofing houses. Advocate for heat pump installation. PoW cryptocurrencies are table stakes.

EDIT: The score on my post is fluctuating wildly and I'm flagged now lol. I've obviously touched a nerve here.