I certainly don't look at my heating bill every month.
But inflation is devastating to the working poor. Funny that it's so easily brushed aside by those who claim to advocate for them.
Consumer perception of the economy is roughly equivalent to 2009 numbers now, in a recent study. The public by and large thinks the economy is terrible, primarily due to the inflationary pressures.
Consider that unemployment affects the marginal job seeker, but inflation affects everybody. From a purely political lens, vying for higher employment at the expense of inflation, once past a reasonable threshold, seems like a losing move.
Source? Searching for "Consumer perception of the economy" leads me to consumer confidence index, which seems to be significantly higher than in 2009.
https://www.conference-board.org/data/consumerconfidence.cfm
If it's demand-side, then their wages should rise up together with inflation so they don't win or lose (except for whatever savings they have and whatever time it takes for wages to adjust).
So wages are rising, but slower than inflation, e.g. people getting poorer. And of course, many stay in the same job and don't get a raise, or get a paltry raise.
Many seniors living off of fixed income investments which are yielding lower than ever. And so on...
Workers are only better off if wage is strongly above inflation. I do see people cheering on wage gains, even though they've been persistently below inflation, which is a bit of a headscratcher.
It seems the public perception is finally starting to bubble up though, rather than the headline narratives.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/06/upshot/inflation-psycholo...
I'm not arguing that inflation is good for poor people, just that "Inflation = Bad" is reductionist. There are winners and losers with inflation, and the lives of most individuals are affected in nuanced ways, both positively and negatively.
who's claiming that?
For a young family that is interested in buying a house, food/gas does not even register.
By galloping inflation, I hope that means wage increases. Inflation is neither bad nor good, until it changes people's behavior. Even then, it's not strictly bad until it spirals out of control. Until then, inflation is in many ways a good thing: higher wages, higher revenues, transferring money from creditors to debtors. These are things many people want more of.
I also know people buying cars at or close to MSRP that would have gotten them for much less before. So the sticker prices might be the same, but actual prices paid are going up.
https://www.apartmentlist.com/research/national-rent-data
There's a huge lag to reflect certain data in the headline numbers. Owners equivalent rent measurement technique, only sampling 1/6 of housing stock per month and so on lead to about a 12 month lag in cpi.
Rents alone will fuel high baseline inflation for at least a year or two, once the value starts getting priced in.
You are right that we'll likely see some decline from cars normalizing, but not enough to offset rents and more broad based pressures. Baseline inflation will likely remain well above the Feds 2% target
Doesn't square 17% and 3%, but it could definitely mean the lagging CPI rent growth we see over the coming year is more like 9 or 10%.
If market rate of new units is 20% higher, almost by definition you'll see 20% higher rents for all in the long run.
Why should we use backward looking methodology in computing the CPI? It's an extremely flawed way to analyze the state of the market. Forward looking metrics are more useful to policy makers.
The methodology for OER and rent analysis in the CPI acts to suppress true price increases. Though those price increases eventually materialize as people renew their leases, move etc. It comes with a year or longer lag though.
The Fed drives their policy based on this data. Why should the data have a one year lag and potentially put them behind the curve?
If we used the same CPI formula as in the 70s, we would be seeing similar CPI numbers too.
Well, yes, but that's not very meaningful without knowing over what time period you'll see that increase.
> Why should we use backward looking methodology in computing the CPI?
I mean that's literally just what CPI is. You're welcome to use leading indicators if you want, and economists certainly do. One slight problem with predicting the future is we don't know what will happen then.
> If we used the same CPI formula as in the 70s, we would be seeing similar CPI numbers too.
This is completely unsupported by the data. Yes, the switch to geometric mean effectively deflated CPI when compared to measures taken using the previous formula, but not remotely close to a level that would bump our current ~6% rate into the high teens.
Not OER, but actual home prices.
But even if CPI reflected rents fully, today, we would be at similar numbers.
And the Fed primarily looks at core PCE which is based on the backward looking CPI data. It's very obvious from a policy perspective, they should be considering market rate and not existing tenant rates for forecasting forward inflation.
Yes, the Fed forecasts the backward looking CPI, but their forecasts were also so far off this year, I wouldn't put any stock into them. I believe they predicted 3% inflation for 2021 earlier this year.
Sorry, I thought you were making the geometric mean argument. Yeah that would definitely add significantly for this year in particular. Home price inflation is about 20%, and is replacing housing inflation at maybe 3% in the CPI calc. Owner occupiers are ~64% of the housing market which contributes around ~33% to CPI. So including that would add (.2 - .03) x .33 x .64 = .036 so 3.6% to CPI.
So around 10%. Comparable to most of the 70s, but not the high-teens emergency points.
And yes the Fed doesn't always accurately predict inflation, but in the long run no one else does either (and one could make billions doing so, it's not like no one's trying).
Except this is not comparable to most of the 70s at all.
Household leverage and disposable income change how serviceable debt is at different rates.
The numbers I saw puts a 2021 mortgage rate of 3% at an equivalent benchmark rate "in your pocketbook feels" as a 6% rate in pre gfc 2007.
Are you sure 10% doesn't warrant the same emergency as the high-teens of the 70s?
I’m also seeing my health plan options are a lot worse. High deductibles me co insurance with prices staying the same.
On the plus side all the restaurants around us are terrible now due to lack of workers, so we cook at home much more.
For example, lumber is still priced fairly high, but far far down from its peak level. And if this podcast is to be believed (and I think it is), mere lack of metal trusses for home building is holding back a lot of builders from continuing with their projects, meaning a ton of lumber is being held in places that it's not usually held, which will lead to further bull whip price swings:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-08/stinson-d...
Inflation due to large monetary stimulus may appear through a bullwhip affect as demand eventually stresses fixed-capacity capital intensive industries. Once these industries are strained higher costs may radiate outwards.
What evidence is there that it will radiate outwards at a rate significantly above the Fed’s target for an extended period of time?
Offhand however, the top capital constrained industries that I can think of (in rough order) include.
1. Semi 2. Housing 3. Automotive/heavy manufacturing 4. Energy
Which are all experiencing shortages/rapid price increases. If the hypothesis holds we would see price increases in other fields which depend on the above. If the supply disruption/demand disruption hypothesis holds then we should see a normalization of prices in the above industries.
A single advancement in worker automation could easily provide enough productivity gains to offset wage growth. A single plant disease or new political treaty could massively effect food and or energy costs. The system is chaotic.
It is still less of a school to the economy than the beginning of the pandemic was. Threading the needle to manage this period has to be extremely difficult for policy makers.
That's when considering "stimulus" as broader than the unconditional (but means-tested) direct payments--colloquially "stimmy checks." Following is from a quick search and to the best of my knowledge; I'm in a high cost of living area and fortunate to have kept a job past the individual cutoff for stimulus checks:
Direct stimulus was $3200 to eligible individuals across three checks. Some amount of that was banked for dependents too.
Increased refundable child tax credit was increased from $2000 to either $3000 or $3600 per child per year and the Democrats are trying to persist that in the build back better act.
The US also did increased unemployment -- $300 a week in extended unemployment benefits. Which totals $15,600 a year on top of existing amounts. The first $10k in unemployment was made tax-free. I've heard e.g. Canada had a high percentage of salary backed by the government in unemployment, however there was a total dollar cap that was fairly low.
US had PPP loans that lefties (disclaimer: I'm one) on social media (disclaimer: I'm not) complained about going to businesses, but very likely let some business keep people on the payroll in the first place as intended.
Mortgage forbearance, eviction moratoriums.
Freezing of payments and interest accrual on student loans that is still going on, and when (if?) it restarts will have stopped the accrual of interest for about two years.
I take issue with this. Hotel rooms and airfare can often be forgone for the average American. New (or used) cars to a lesser extent. However we are seeing increases in prices of ag commodities increasing dramatically. On a year-on-year basis, prices were up 32.8% in September[1]. Oil prices are at a three year high[2]. Not to mention soaring housing costs. It may indeed be to early to predict disaster, but things are not as good as your comment seems to suggest.
[1] https://www.reuters.com/business/world-food-prices-hit-10-ye...
[2] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-prices-rise-tigh...
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/consumer-price-index-shows-fo...
Not predicting disaster, but what's going on is very unusual and no one can predict how or when it will shake out.
In the Netherlands it's about 20% YoY. And this is starting to become true all throughout the country even though it started in urban areas. I really feel bad for people who aren't homeowners yet, because becoming one right now is getting damn near impossible.
If I were middle class and saving for a home, I think I would be angry to the point of revolution and violence right now. There are people who have worked like crazy their whole lives and they just had their hopes and dreams set on fire by runaway money creation and the resulting inflation.
Social media adds gasoline to the fire, but that fire was already burning, in part due to the middle class getting wiped out.
The ends are expanding and middle is disappearing.
Would they be happier under a repeat of 2008 or 1928 instead?
Of course if the hypothetical aspiring homeowner with excellent market timing lost their job the point would be moot, but if their income stayed the same and they put 20,000 down their monthly payments would have gone from $1,302 to $994.
[1]http://www.fedprimerate.com/new_home_sales_price_history.htm
[2]https://www.fhfa.gov/Media/PublicAffairs/Pages/FHFA-Reports-...
[3]https://www.marketwatch.com/story/us-mortgage-rates-hit-2007...
Is it advantageous to a new graduate who will see no work, and maybe a decade of depressed wages (which, between loans and compounding interest in savings, is devastating to their future prospects)?
Is it advantageous to a new homeowner that just lost their job?
Some people got burnt by that flood of money that stabilized the economy. Some people benefited. Some people avoided harm. Focusing on the first group without regard for the latter is missing a large part of the picture - which was that the economy as a whole remained more or less stable through this crisis.
Whether that's fair vs protecting those who already have homes and other assets is I suppose a different question. I agree things have remained fairly stable so far as the result of printing but I suspect we likely haven't felt it's effects yet and the stabilization will continue well into the next year, though the future is always fickle to predict.
Right now we're fueling a tsunami of moral hazard which will eventually bite us in the ass anyway. We're just prolonging the inevitable and making the crash even worse when it finally appears.
As for punting the problem back, no, that does not follow as a required consequence of QE.
I think this is part of the rampant speculation on crypto and the like - $1,000 isn't really going to do me that much good, but if I hit a 100x I could be a homeowner.
I have never heard of this type of rental agreement. Your contract says you can stay indefinitely if you pay $250 per month extra over the expired contract’s rent?
I suppose the downside is they could give me the boot with 30 days notice. FWIW I've contacted them several times to try and just sign a lease but the property has been bought out and had it's management office staff swapped out a few times so the whole thing is a mess.
[1]https://www.city-data.com/forum/renting/1261828-fixed-term-l...
[1] https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/cpi.pdf, Table 1
https://www.apartmentlist.com/research/national-rent-data
OER is a hugely flawed metric that is somewhat designed to suppress true cost increases. E.g. they include rent controlled units in the figure. Small portion, but clearly that's not a useful lens to analyze through.
Many other methodological flaws that can be enumerated
(I'm not in NYC, but also in that category: I've rented my place for years, and my rent has increased 0.0% this year.)
The much more useful number is, what is the cost of living for somebody plopped into the economy. Because eventually almost everybody ends up moving and bearing that cost.
Should our price data be forward looking or backwards looking? Obviously from a policy perspective having forward looking pricing data is much more useful and relevant.
Including rent controlled units and existing leases is a methodological flaw of OER. You're right though, if you game the measurement and design the methodology just right, you can produce lower numbers.
If the CPI formula were unchanged from the 70s, we would have roughly equivalent inflation numbers now that we had then.
The Fed is meant to head off inflationary pressures. If they take a full year to materialize in the data, that's a flawed metric IMO. A 20% market rate rent increase will almost by definition feed into a 20% rent increase for everybody in the longer run.
The market rate rent will dictate rents for all over the longer run. Yes, maybe 10% of the population got a good deal on their renewal or whatever. Including that information is not useful or helpful from a policy perspective.
At the very least, they should produce two figures. Market rate CPI and existing tenant CPI.
On the other hand fuel prices are up considerably too.
If your prices went up by $60 this year, it wasnt because the oil is more expensive.
I’d recommend your local dealership or Walmart in the future. Oil changes might be the only thing dealerships typically have reasonable prices for.
If those labor costs drive the price of goods and services beyond some psychological tipping point, you then have more demands for higher wages, at least until those start to get rejected and we find a new zone of relative pricing stability.
I'm not arguing for hyperinflation or anything, but I don't think we'll see the price increases of the last year go away. If you're like me and had your assets in cash, well, a good percentage of that buying power is gone and not coming back.
...measures home ownership (asset) prices, CPI housing measures housing consumption (rent or imputed rent) prices.
“In the quarter to August used cars, hotel rooms and airfares made up less than 5% of America’s consumer-price index, but together accounted for the majority of overall inflation”
If we’re having inflation due to a tiny number of goods having large price spikes, it might be too early to predict disaster
https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/11/06/a-handfu...