News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nkrisc on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:23AM (#29162895)
Perhaps my understanding of NFTs is lacking, but what prevents someone from pulling a scam like in The Producers and simply selling multiple NFTs for the same work of art, apart from people finding out about it? Is simply the fact that the artist publicly states “this hash belongs to this piece”? So if the buyer wasn’t paying attention or didn’t validate the hash there’s nothing stopping someone from selling as many NFTs as they want?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lapetitejort on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:41AM (#29163176)
You don't need to defraud people when you can just sell one with a primary color of #e0b0ff and another with #e0b0fe.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bravura on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:22AM (#29163750)
This is not unique to NFTs, and is based upon the trust you have for the artist / gallery that is selling the work.

If---in the traditional art world---you buy a $35,000 fine art photograph from a limited edition of 10 prints by the photographer, you also trust that the artist will not make a second run of 100 prints. Or if they do, that the second run will be denoted and priced differently, so that the original run retains most of its value.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by stjohnswarts on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:09PM (#29165128)
It's a lot harder to fake and fool people with the Mona Lisa than a fake of the original jpg of the yelling lady/cat meme.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nkrisc on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:46PM (#29164809)
Yeah, I understand that. That’s why I was wondering if NFTs solve that, if the uniqueness of an NFT provides any value.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tata71 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:28PM (#29165390)
Does phone/watch/card tap&pay provide any value over running a small chunk of plastic through a grinder on top of carbon paper....?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by 015a on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:55AM (#29163385)
Ultimately the system will evolve toward more centralized entities which can verify the providence of items. Whether that's an auction house, or a twitter verified badge. The sites which allow "viewing" and "transacting" the NFTs will display this "chain of authenticity".

Thus, its baked into the price; plenty of counterfeits exist, but the "real" one ("this is the one Deadmau5 tweeted about") will be worth the most.

The argument that this is antithetical to the distributed goals of blockchain are missing the point; its a marriage of old-school centralization and new-school peer-to-peer. Centralization is great for some things, like verifiable providence. It's been a negative force in other things, like limiting or taxing access to financial services & marketplaces.

Furthermore, if you're in the camp of "zero centralization"; it's great for that too. Imagine an artist publishing their GPG key, creating an NFT of a piece of art, then signing some part of the content of that NFT with their GPG key.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by logiczero on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:23AM (#29163765)
This idea of combining NFT and GPG to demonstrate both ownership and authenticity is very intriguing. Would the artist's public GPG key have to be something similar to a verified Twitter account, i.e. some kind of due diligence by a third party that the key actually belongs to a specific person/artist? How would the artist "sign" the artwork with the private GPG key in such a way that the signature wasn't simply duplicated when the digital artifact was copied? Is there a way to combine some identifier from the NFT with the GPG key such that there was a way to cryptographically demonstrate authenticity?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by 015a on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:09PM (#29164317)
All NFTs have a verifiable chain of providence baked-in; you can see the wallet address of the account which minted it.

So, I present GPG signing not really as a novel mechanism for establishing authenticity given a lack of any other method; the NFT itself is the authenticity. Today, zero-trust creators may publish their GPG public key; tomorrow, maybe they publish their address; "the only legit NFTs are the ones minted from this address"; this is cryptographically secure.

But, maybe a creator is more "well known" for their GPG public key, or wants to mint from a large number of addresses for whatever reason. They could sign a phrase which includes the wallet address which minted the NFT; when combined with the verifiable providence blockchain already offers, this is a compelling and secure solution for them.

Blockchain has all the same "zero-trust bootstrapping" problems as GPG does; where does the artist actually broadcast "this is my address", and how can fans know that it was actually the artist who said it? It's something GPG has struggled with for a long time. Ultimately it usually falls back to centralized authority; that doesn't mean GPG doesn't have value beyond the authority who told you "Yeah, this is Deadmau5's public key".

The idea is simply presented more-so as a bridge between the old and the new. Many people here understand what GPG is and why it is valuable, but don't understand how blockchain delivers an extension of that value. GPG is great at asserting authenticity; blockchain extends this and asserts both authenticity and providence ("is it real, and where did it come from?"); this is a critical addition required for a concept of ownership. But blockchain's ability to assert this ends at the blockchain, as you'd expect; the world will still need centralized authorities to jump the gap between the blockchain and a human being.

IF that matters in the context of a given NFT. There are tons of NFTs which created 'virgin value' so to speak; value of thin air. No one cares who minted them; the token itself is what is valuable.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by stjohnswarts on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:11PM (#29165150)
Wouldn't it be basically the same as a centralized blockchain that was exclusively used to verify "original" NFTs? That would seem to be a better way to me, IF the community could settle on a singular blockchain to hold it.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bodge5000 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:29AM (#29162996)
If I'm understanding you right, you can and its extremely common. I don't even think its a scam or frowned upon
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nkrisc on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:38AM (#29163129)
If that’s true, then it leaves me even more confused than before.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by snarf21 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:50AM (#29163321)
No, because it is a fake scarcity scam. People are selling art they don't even own. It is all a pump and dump scheme.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bodge5000 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:02AM (#29163496)
Same here, I only found out about it last night. I thought the whole point is that your buying something totally unique, apparently not
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by rhn_mk1 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:05PM (#29164273)
You are buying something unique, but what you're buying is not art. Instead it's more like... a receipt? A signed copy?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bodge5000 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:12AM (#29172641)
I mean the hash is unique, but the piece of artwork that hash is associated with isnt.

I'm not even saying something like "the artwork is all boring its not unique" or anything, or that someone could copy I it, I mean the seller is literally selling multiple of the exact same artwork.

But if the recipient being unique is all that matters, why have artwork associated with it at all? That's basically just a weird online packaging/box art at that point.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by throwaway744678 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:46PM (#29164817)
A certificate of ownership.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by rhn_mk1 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @03:23PM (#29166961)
That's my point though - it's not ownership of the artwork. It has no legal power, and multiple can exist, made by anyone. Ownership of what then? Of a receipt or a signature.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by brightball on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:09AM (#29163587)
Nothing. Literally nothing.

I've just enjoyed watching my Solana go up so that I have a way to make money off of this silliness. Just need to time the exit before the fad goes away.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tata71 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:50AM (#29164071)
Consider flipping it into Loopring, which strives to (and seems to be succeeding in) serving a much wider market, with custody staying on ETH network in case Loopring network eats shit.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by brightball on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:04PM (#29164267)
I'll check it out.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nikk1 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:19AM (#29163716)
Artists can already sell multiple NFTs for the same work of art. But this is information the buyer already knows.

Also to avoid scams as an investor, you'd typically want to invest in artists with a reputation.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tata71 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:50AM (#29164081)
Or sell the NFT and then put the painting through a grinder, like Banksy!
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by afoot on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:50AM (#29163324)
The marketplaces verify the collections. So if you're buying from a famous artist on OpenSea, you know the NFT is the one from that artist. There are copycat collections but it's no different from someone trying to flog a fake Banksy a the local shopping mall.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tshaddox on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:26AM (#29162937)
I imagine it’s no different than an artist selling a painting they claim is one of a kind but isn’t.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:36AM (#29163088)
Well, a painting is of one a kind. It can't be replicated with exact fidelity, unlike an abstract sequence of 1s and 0s.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by danpalmer on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:43AM (#29163216)
You're not even buying the "1s and 0s" with an NFT either. You're buying a record in a proprietary (albeit public) database that says you "own" it. There can be many records in many propriety databases claiming the same thing and none has any more legitimacy than any other technically speaking
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by maxwell on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:01AM (#29163470)
Why the quotes on "own"? You can hold it, trade it, or destroy it—curious what other factors you see as necessary for "full" ownership of a digital token?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Joeboy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:10AM (#29163605)
You own the token, but only "own" the art.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by yayitswei on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:22AM (#29163749)
By that logic, you only "own" your house.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Joeboy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:48AM (#29164041)
Legally speaking, the Land Registry (in my country) is the arbiter of whether or not I own my house. Because of, like, the law. There is no corresponding law that says owning an NFT means I own [any rights to] an artwork.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by throwaway744678 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:38AM (#29163927)
You can't duplicate or send your house by email. The "art" linked to the NFT can be duplicated bit-for-bit. What is unique is the NFT, that is, the certificate of ownership.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by maxwell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:18PM (#29177278)
Digital tokens aren't certificates of ownership, they're access credentials.

You can duplicate or send the keys to your house by mail, and if the recipient changes them, you lose physical access.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:43AM (#29163978)
Ownership is legal right, so to own a digital token you would need some kind of title to the token. Without a title you don't really own it, just like you don't own a house without the proper paperwork that says you own it.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by maxwell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:14PM (#29177223)
Even with a title or other legal means of asserting ownership, in the end with digital tokens you're still dependent on their network continuing to exist.

If a national highway system goes down, your house is still there.

If a digital token network goes down, be it a token-based centralized SaaS company with an API or token-based decentralized blockchain, goes down, your assets go down with it, regardless of legal abstractions.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NikolaeVarius on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:05AM (#29163538)
Right Click -> Save As
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by maxwell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:25PM (#29177362)
NFTs aren't digital media, they're digital tokens.

You own the token as you own an API key for a service, except since decentralized there's no network operator who can revoke your key ("suspend your account") as with, say, centralized SaaS REST APIs.

You're not buying the JPEG, you're buying an API key that happens to be linked to the JPEG.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by DSMan195276 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:57AM (#29164164)
The fact that something is or isn't one of a kind doesn't make it valuable though. If value only came from the art itself then whether something was one of a kind shouldn't matter - especially so if a reproduction is close enough that they are visually identical. For expensive paintings the value of the painting is completely separate from the art itself - I think we can agree that a Picasso would sell for a lot less if you didn't tell people it was painted by Picasso. That's despite the fact that who painted something is not a physical aspect of the painting.

An NFT is basically like a 'certificate of authenticity' - whether you think it's BS or not depends entirely on who issued it. A item that includes such a certificate from a known reputable source may be extremely valuable to a collector, where-as the regular item may be practically worthless, and that can be true even if nobody can tell the items apart. At the same time, John Doe down the street signing 'certificates of authenticity' doesn't provide any value because nobody cares who John Doe is, in the same way that some random person signing an NFT doesn't automatically make it worth anything since anybody else can just come along an do the same. But if the author of an artwork came by and produced an NFT of it, that's unique in a way that people may care about.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tshaddox on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:24PM (#29164490)
It all comes down to technology. If we had the technology to create an atom-by-atom replica of a painting, then this justification would need to change. People would probably say “but these atoms are still the original ones.” Of course the only way to verify that at this point would be to have evidence of a chain of custody, which would likely be very difficult to establish with any confidence.

So paintings just “lucked out” and already had a convenient scarce item that interested parties could agree represents the “original act of creation of the work of art,” because the technology to create an exact copy doesn’t exist, and it’s extremely expensive and difficult to create a convincing forgery.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:03PM (#29165933)
An NFT cannot be a certificate of authenticity, because the content is hosted by a third party. The third party can replace the supposedly original content with a non-original copy at any time.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by DSMan195276 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:32PM (#29166313)
I'm not saying they are a certificate of authenticity, I'm saying the value it creates is similar in concept. A certificate of authenticity has value based on the issuer of the certificate of authenticity - if the issuer is some random person it doesn't create any value because anybody can create such a thing, but if it is someone important/relevant in that field then it can be very meaningful.

In a similar way an NFT has value based on particular details about the NFT such as the author and database it is in, not just the bytes themselves. You can certainly create the same NFT with a new author, or on a new database, or etc. but it's no longer the same NFT at that point, it's a replica and can be distinguished from the original. And while an NFT published by the author of the art might be a interesting thing to own/control, the same NFT published by a random John Doe doesn't carry the same relevance. And fundamentally you still can't change the properties of the original NFT in the original database.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @03:34PM (#29167100)
I don't think that certificates of authenticity work like that. A certificate of authenticity has value in as much as it certifies authenticity, not because someone important has signed it. That would be an autograph.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by DSMan195276 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @07:37PM (#29169584)
> A certificate of authenticity has value in as much as it certifies authenticity, not because someone important has signed it.

I think you missed the point, someone has issued the certificate and it only matters if you value that person's or entity's opinion. If you don't then it's just a meaningless piece of paper.

For example, PSA grades playing cards. A rare card that is graded highly by PSA will generally make it much more valuable than an ungraded version of the same card. However, if someone send me a card in the mail and I grade it a 10 and send it back, that means nothing because nobody cares about my opinion on cards.

Similarity, if PSA were to issue NFTs, they would have value specifically because it was PSA who authored the NFTs. I could take the exact same data and author an NFT myself, but nobody would care because they specifically want the one that was created by PSA, and that is something that is verifiable and that I cannot duplicate. They don't want it for any real tangible reason, they want it so they can say "I own an NFT from PSA".

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:33AM (#29175724)
Of course, because a certificate is a statement about some fact. Therefore a certificate is useful as a certificate to the extent that the issuer can be trusted about the statement that is being made. But that doesn't apply to NFTs because the issuer of an NFT is not making any statement. An NFT is more like a blank piece of paper that has been rubber stamped by somebody.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by DSMan195276 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:32PM (#29181157)
> An NFT is more like a blank piece of paper that has been rubber stamped by somebody.

Well it has something written on it, but yes pretty much. If the "somebody" is someone you care about though, then that can make it more than just a piece of paper, in the same way that if you care about the issuer of a certificate then it is more than just a piece of paper. I get the distinction you're trying to make, and I don't think it really matters, but perhaps it was a bad example and autographs would have been a better one.

To be clear, I don't own NFTs, I get the idea but they don't appeal to me. But I also don't own any expensive art either for the same reason, so to each his own. I do own a bunch of trading cards, and I'm sure plenty of people would just view them as pieces of paper. Point being, people value plenty of silly things, NFTs are just one of them.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nybble41 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:02PM (#29170269)
> … the content is hosted by a third party. The third party can replace the supposedly original content with a non-original copy at any time.

Generally the content is hosted in IPFS and identified by a content hash which was recorded as part of the transaction which minted the NFT in a blockchain, which makes it somewhere between "difficult" and "impossible" for any third party (or first or second party, for that matter) to replace the content.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tshaddox on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:34AM (#29163877)
It can be replicated in such a way that you cannot apply a test to determine whether it is original, unless you’re one of a very few experts who can distinguish highly skilled forgeries from original paintings. Historically there have been forgeries that have fooled all experts and thus the entire art world for some time. This is a much more difficult and less reliable process than checking a digital signature in a public database.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by capableweb on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:43AM (#29163197)
NFTs are based around the idea that you create a new cryptocurrency for each object you want to sell on a chain, for example Ethereum. When you do this "creation of a non-fungible token", your token gets an address that is essentially an "ID" for the token you've created.

Every token you create gets a unique ID, that only that token has.

So with that in mind, a NFT is as unique as a painting in your example, as a NFT is always "one of a kind".

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by professoretc on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:16AM (#29163687)
But the actual image data isn't stored in the token, just its URL (usually). So what you own is not the image, but rather, whatever resource resides at a particular URL, with there being no guarantee that that resource doesn't also live at some other URL.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tshaddox on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:50AM (#29164076)
But everyone knows that. No one is claiming that an NFT literally is a digital image.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by zohch on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:49AM (#29163300)
And what value does this unique NFT have if it has no enforceable or enforced relation to reality?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by capableweb on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:54AM (#29163378)
Not sure how this is relevant to the discussion at hand. Either you think it's valuable, or you don't. I happen to think NFTs are not as valuable as others seemingly think, but they do have some use cases (apparently).

What is reality anyway? We have a distributed, decentralized database (Ethereum) that people can set/get data in/from. Now we also have a abstraction on top of that that allows us to have unique data. What can we do with this? Fuck should I know, also I don't really care. Think of it what you want.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by zohch on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:02AM (#29163480)
> What is reality anyway?

Have you not heard of this concept? Seems to be a bit of copout to explaining the value of an NFT given an NFT, by it's mere existence, has no bearing on anything outside of a blockchain. But if you are unclear on the concept: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by capableweb on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:15AM (#29163667)
We seem to differ on the definition as I'd call blockchains and cryptocurrencies real (part of reality), but you somehow don't.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by DSMan195276 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:26AM (#29163796)
I feel like you're trying to find a more concrete reason than is necessary - the fact that it is unique can be valuable on its own. I can go buy a reproduction Picasso that looks identical to the original and from an art standpoint it's effective equivalent, but it's still worth nothing compared to a "real" one. The fact that the original was painted by Picasso is what provides it so much value, even though who painted a particular piece of art is not a physical part of the art itself. A unique NFT effectively provides value in the same way, it is valuable as long as people care about who/what issued it and thus want to be able to say they own that unique one.

And while it's notable that digital art can be duplicated perfectly and physical art cannot, I don't personally think that matters all that much. People who are buying a Picasso aren't doing so just for the art, they're doing it so they can say they own a Picasso. In the same way you're not buying an NFT for the art itself, you're buying it because it's uniquely identifiable in a way you and others care about.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by TylerE on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:46AM (#29164019)
The value of being used in money laundering.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:51AM (#29164092)
No, the ID is not unique. It might be unique in a particular database, where the software enforces such uniqueness, but that doesn't mean the ID unique. Anyone can make an exact copy of the ID, which will be undistinguishable from the original, or they can copy the entire database, any number of times, at a negligible cost. You can't do that with a physical object.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lalaland1125 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:42AM (#29163196)
NFTs are technically one of a kind too since they have an exact timestamp ordering creation. A second copy would have a different timestamp.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:55AM (#29164142)
> A second copy would have a different timestamp.

No, you can copy the timestamp as well.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by cyber_kinetist on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:39AM (#29163135)
In current capitalist societies, ownership of property is fully secured by the military (police) and judicial (law) power of the state. NFTs provide you with neither of these (not even copyright protection), so yes: there's no one stopping from doing a right-click on your image.

Maybe if everyone was really "believing" that ownership really originates from the Ethereum blockchain (just like beliving that strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is a basis for a system of government), then the ownership could be recognized socially without any coertion or violence. But so far the only people really beliving in this system of values are elites and crypto enthusiasts, so if you really are one of those people who want NFTs to be a basis for ownership, you've be better off pandering to the government to enact laws to arrest people for right-clicking.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by afoot on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:54AM (#29163377)
The market dictates the value. As a test, create and mint an exact replica of a Bored Ape NFT and try to sell it for the current minimum price of 32 ETH or around $150k.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by mym1990 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:58AM (#29163428)
I know nothing about NFTs but if I was to forge something for a test, it probably wouldn’t be something that is high profile. I would pick something in the 1-10k range and start from there. /cluelessrant
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by afoot on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:01AM (#29163468)
The result would ultimately be the same, just a less extreme example.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by mym1990 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:56PM (#29179775)
I doubt this. I imagine it is easier to create forgeries of low profile things, lets say a Thomas Kinkade painting vs a Monet. Its also more likely that as the price of an item goes up, the buyer would be more interested in verification.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by zohch on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:48AM (#29163286)
For context:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ownership

> Ownership is the state or fact of exclusive rights and control over property, which may be any asset, including an object, land or real estate, intellectual property, or until the nineteenth century, human beings.

In light of this

> In current capitalist societies, ownership of property is fully secured by the military (police) and judicial (law) power of the state.

Any examples of non capitalist societies that actually governed more than just a city for more than just a couple of months where there were no enforcement of exclusive rights over anything?

Because if I can think of none, just for example, USSR would get real pissy real fast if you infringed on the exclusive rights which they thought existed over a whole host of things.

Sure, in most non-capitalist societies people had no exclusive rights to their own labor, or their own persons, but there were still many people who had exclusive rights over things that would be enforced by use of force. And the state did have exclusive rights over the person and labor of their subjects, which is a key differentiation from most "capitalistic societies" as you call them.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by cyber_kinetist on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:20AM (#29163734)
I wasn't talking anything at all about non-capitalist societies, don't understand where you're coming from.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by zohch on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:54AM (#29164122)
So then why did you qualify your sentence with "capitalist societies" if what you say applies to non capitalist societies also? And if it does not, give examples.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by cyber_kinetist on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:16PM (#29164391)
If you do believe the same thing applies with non-capitalist societies, then you then surely agree even more with my initial criticism with NFTs? (which was the primary thing I was talking about?) I don't understand why you're making such a big deal out of this.

Yes, I believe that my statement can be expanded into certain non-capitalist societies also, like in previous instances of feudalism and communism (where the state "owned" everything through military coersion). The reason I've brought out capitalism is because it's the environment in which NFTs were born, and therefore its relationship with it should be talked about it. But what you're talking about has absolutely nothing to do with the main discussion (which is, how state power and ownership is crucially interlinked, and NFT's failure to acknoweledge this is the problem).

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by zohch on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:44PM (#29164781)
> The reason I've brought out capitalism is because it's the environment in which NFTs were born, and therefore its relationship with it should be talked about it.

NFTs are a world 3 construct (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Popper%27s_three_worlds) and has no dependency on any economic system or even society to exist and the problem of using them to represent an ownership relation is not limited to any economic system either, but exists due to factors inherent in both the concept of ownership and what NFTs are. NFTs can't reach from world 3 into world 1 by themselves and this is no more or less a problem in any specific economic system.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by cyber_kinetist on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:29PM (#29166274)
So we seem to both agree that what NFTs (and blockchain) is doing is actually just bookkeeping, and this “data” cannot invade the physical world unless we actually act upon the physical world according to that data.

What I was talking is: the reaching from world 3 to world 1 (in Popper’s terms) in capitalist societies are often enforced with the absolute power of the state, and “free” markets emanate from that power. NFTs don’t add anything more to this current state of society, since it is just another way of bookkeeping, and the actual reaching from world 3 to world 1 is left unsolved (which for me, how to do this without relying on violence and coercion is the most important question of liberalism, and failure of this will lead to its demise). NFTs and crypto are still exchanged in US dollars, and people always talk about it in how many US dollars it represents. So value is ultimately delegated to the dollar, the dollar which holds its global monetary status via the US’s hegemonic military power, so we’re back to our current problem.

So, do you think NFTs can actually change the current status quo? Does it bring anything new to the equation?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by zohch on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @04:15PM (#29167593)
> So, do you think NFTs can actually change the current status quo? Does it bring anything new to the equation?

No, it does not change the status quo, and brings nothing new to the equation.

To kind of rephrase what you said slightly: All ownership relations exists in world 3, that is their nature, they can't act in world 1. NFTs don't bring anything to the table here, crypto does not bring anything to the table here. With NFTs, ownership relations is still a world 3 thing, and world 3 things still cannot act in world 1. And no enforcement mechanisms we currently have for ownership relations give any special recognition or consideration to NFTs, blockchain or crypto assets.

The only disagreement we have is that I don't think it makes sense to qualify sentences with "capitalist societies" when the claims they make are more broad. It's a bit like saying "all Furry mammals are characterized by the presence of mammary glands which in females produce milk for feeding (nursing) their young", it may be true, but the word "furry" in that sentence adds negative value:

http://www.biomedicaleditor.com/hedging.html

> To strengthen your argument and increase clarity, limit the number of qualifiers in each sentence to only those necessary for accuracy—the remaining qualifiers will then do their job well.