News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by tobyjsullivan on Monday November 01, 2021 @04:45PM (#29072853)
Possible scenario A: Teslas have a fundamental flaw that causes a single driver to have several accidents. Multiplied by the number of Tesla drivers who use Autopilot, there must be hundreds of thousands of unreported and uninvestigated auto-pilot accidents. Most certainly a conspiratorial cover-up by Tesla, the NTSB, and the NHTSA.

Possible scenario B: The driver of the Tesla has misrepresented or misunderstood the facts of the situation.

Possible scenario C: The driver of the Tesla doesn't know that she should take her foot off the accelerator pedal when using Autopilot.

I suppose any of these (or several other) scenarios are at least possible. I'd probably apply Hanlon's razor here before anything else.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by pessimizer on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:06PM (#29074463)
> Most certainly a conspiratorial cover-up by Tesla, the NTSB, and the NHTSA.

You're just adding the word "conspiracy" to imply blaming the car is insane.

You skipped "Possible scenario D: It's the car's fault, and the NTSB and NHTSA didn't respond due to a lack of interest, an incompetent person handling the complaint by the OP, the OP not being able to communicate what happened well enough, or a procedure at the agencies which requires the driver to make a complaint rather than an observer or a victim."

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by practice9 on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:40PM (#29074210)
I would assign a large probability that Autopilot wasn't even engaged and it's driver's fault.

Accidents with Tesla (many of those that make the press) are often caused by not being accustomed to the car's acceleration.

There is Chill mode that decreases max acceleration, but I wouldn't expect the driver who manages to get into 2 accidents with a same car to read a manual

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by filoleg on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:53PM (#29074331)
Yeah, the first thing that came to mind was that one valet who claimed that it was not his fault, but the autopilot that made him accelerate heavily and crash inside a parking garage.[0]

People called out bs on it instantly, as it would make no sense for autopilot to suddenly accelerate inside a garage until the crash, but the driver defended himself to death.

Only for the formal investigation to happen and confirm that the driver did it himself by fully pressing on the acceleration pedal instead of the braking pedal without any autopilot engagement, and was just trying to shift blame. And no, it wasn't just Tesla's legal team claiming that. The guy went to a third-party service that could decode the blackbox data from the car (again, that was his own technician, not requested by Tesla or anything), and the evidence clearly showed that the driver pressed the accelerator full-on. The raw log that is relevant to the situation is included in the link as well, in case someone wants to see it with their eyes.

Almost every single article I've seen that features bizarre accidents like this ended up being bs, and I am seeing the "accidentally pushed the accelerator instead of the braking pedal" vibes here as well. Will be eagerly awaiting for the results of the investigation before I make my own judgement though. Note: I am not claiming that autopilot is infallible, and there were indeed some legitimate incidents a while ago. But this specific one in the OP? Yeah, I call bs.

It also helps that NHTSA has already investigated such claims before[1], so they looked into hundreds of cases that were claiming Autopilot suddenly accelerating and causing crashes, and they discovered that not a single one happened due to autopilot, but due to the driver misapplying acceleration and braking pedal. Direct quote from their investigation summary (emphasis mine):

>After reviewing the available data, ODI has not identified evidence that would support opening a defect investigation into SUA in the subject vehicles. In every instance in which event data was available for review by ODI, the evidence shows that SUA crashes in the complaints cited by the petitioner have been caused by pedal misapplication. There is no evidence of any fault in the accelerator pedal assemblies, motor control systems, or brake systems that has contributed to any of the cited incidents. There is no evidence of a design factor contributing to increased likelihood of pedal misapplication.

0. https://insideevs.com/news/496305/valet-crashes-tesla-data-r...

1. https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2020/INCLA-DP20001-6158.PDF

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:00PM (#29073036)
One concern I would like investigated is that it appears Tesla's Autopilot can't detect (or can no longer detect?) stationary objects.

Until fairly recently, I believe that the RADAR, which used to be in all their cars, would have detected the stationary object (me) and applied braking force to at least reduce the impact.

Now, though, Tesla has stopped installing RADARs in their cars and apparently also disabled existing RADAR in cars that have it (because they all are using the same camera-only software).

If this has also removed the ability to detect stationary objects and the corresponding emergency braking functionality, this is a really serious problem and needs to be addressed, perhaps with a recall to require installation of RADAR in all the new cars and re-enabling of it.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by eightysixfour on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:18PM (#29073235)
> Until fairly recently, I believe that the RADAR, which used to be in all their cars, would have detected the stationary object (me) and applied braking force to at least reduce the impact.

It is the other way around. They've stopped using RADAR because RADAR has too many false reflections at speed and it was causing learning issues in the ML dataset. The vision based position detection is better (could argue about weather and visibility here, but it is irrelevant to this convo). Reliance on RADAR was causing it to hit stopped objects, because it was relying on radar data that was already too jittery and had to be ignored.

Regardless of the RADAR issue, the driver is responsible for the vehicle at all times. If someone hits you using cruise control they remain at fault.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:38PM (#29074193)
Nearly every major manufacturer has a separate emergency stop system that continually looks for an obstacle in the vehicle's path and applies braking force, overriding the driver and any cruise control or self-driving that is in use.

These often use RADAR, have worked for years, and are routinely tested by international agencies such as the IIHS.

See, for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJgUiZgX5rE

Teslas at least used to do this too:

https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/performance-of-pedestrian-c...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJJfn2tO5fo

If Teslas no longer have this functionality, is a serious problem that needs to be corrected. That could mean reprogramming existing cameras or adding a sensor if the system really did rely on the now-removed RADAR.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by eightysixfour on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:36PM (#29074843)
That's not true and you are confusing different features. AEB and Autopilot/Assisted Cruise Control do not behave the same. Here's some articles I found with a google of "radar cruise control stationary object."

https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/06/why-emergency-braking-s...

> But while there's obviously room for improvement, the reality is that the behavior of Tesla's driver assistance technology here isn't that different from that of competing systems from other carmakers. As surprising as it might seem, most of the driver-assistance systems on the roads today are simply not designed to prevent a crash in this kind of situation.

> Sam Abuelsamid, an industry analyst at Navigant and former automotive engineer, tells Ars that it's "pretty much universal" that "vehicles are programmed to ignore stationary objects at higher speeds."

Here's one with BMW owners asking about it: https://g20.bimmerpost.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1738458

Here's a review of Cadillac's SuperCruise: https://www.thedrive.com/tech/14830/i-wrote-this-in-a-superc...

> Related: All these types of semi-autonomous systems have a hard time identifying stationary cars—vehicles in stopped traffic on the highway, for example—as "targets" to avoid. Coming over a crest at 70 mph, I pick up the stopped traffic ahead of me far before the system does. I even give the system an extra second or two to identify that we're hurtling towards stopped traffic, but have to initiate braking. However, it's very likely that even at that speed, the car could have made the stop before an impact.

And the feature you're thinking of, AEB and its limitations are here: https://www.caranddriver.com/features/a24511826/safety-featu...

> If traveling above 20 mph, the Volvo will not decelerate, according to its maker.

> No car in our test could avoid a collision beyond 30 mph, and as we neared that upper limit, the Tesla and the Subaru provided no warning or braking.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:22PM (#29075240)
The Toyota Safety Sense system will slow the car down by 25MPH regardless of its initial speed (except possibly for "very high speeds").

It makes no sense to give up entirely when an application of brakes would reduce damage.

In the case of this accident, the vehicle not only didn't apply brakes but continued to accelerate after it hit me (the double hit).

This may or may not have been operator error, but the driver says she was on autopilot, that there was an OTA update issue, and that it has happened before. This all seems to suggest an investigation is appropriate and necessary.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by eightysixfour on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:49PM (#29075457)
I don't see why this has anything to do with Toyota's system, which by the way, had a recall for TSS braking due to stationary objects.

You're mad, I get it, but you need to take this up with the driver (who claims she had a failed OTA update, which caused her to wreck, AND THEN DROVE AND WRECKED AGAIN) whose insurance will take it up with Tesla. It isn't your job to figure out why the car did it.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @09:00PM (#29075524)
The point is that it not only didn't slow down but accelerated.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by eightysixfour on Monday November 01, 2021 @09:19PM (#29075659)
Okay, and?

The only point here is that you were hit by an inattentive driver who didn't maintain control of her vehicle twice in one day. She put you in danger and your life at risk, and you're blaming the car.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by yupper32 on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:55PM (#29073705)
> If someone hits you using cruise control they remain at fault.

That'd be relevant if they didn't call it autopilot. If they called it lane assist or cruise control plus or something then I'd agree.

Tesla is at major fault for implying that the Teslas can drive themselves, even if the driver is also at fault.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by mwint on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:01PM (#29073773)
Tesla could call it Egre-MuzzFlorp and it wouldn’t matter. The surveys showing people think “autopilot” means “can drive itself” were fatally flawed, in that they were done with non-Tesla owners.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by yupper32 on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:08PM (#29073865)
And yet, people drive their Teslas as if it means "can drive itself".

Words matter. You'd need real evidence to convince me that Tesla calling the system "Autopilot" hasn't significantly contributed to crashes.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by mwint on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:16PM (#29073932)
On the contrary, we need real evidence suggesting it does. Certainly the population level crash data doesn’t support it.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by simion314 on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:00PM (#29076404)
>The surveys showing people think “autopilot” means “can drive itself” were fatally flawed, in that they were done with non-Tesla owners.

Reality check: There are videos shown Tesla drivers sleeping in the car, or using the car from the back sit, so we have proof that a subset of Tesla users are using autopilot as "it drives itself and only laws forced Tesla to add those warnings". This videos are reality, no conspiracy, no subjectivity, no fake stats... some idiots are believing the marketing and some other idiots are still defending that marketing.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by josephcsible on Sunday November 14, 2021 @12:26PM (#29218707)
> some idiots are believing the marketing

That doesn't follow. Some people are definitely being idiots, but the marketing doesn't say that it's okay to do those things, so they're not "believing the marketing" by doing so.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by sokoloff on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:35PM (#29074158)
If an at-fault Tesla hits me, my legal beef is with the driver of that Tesla. They may in turn rely on insurance or on suing Tesla to recover damages from their own misunderstanding of the car’s abilities or improper marketing, but my beef remains with the driver of the at-fault vehicle.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by krisoft on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:17PM (#29073950)
Radar is not good for detecting stationary objects. Of course you get a nice reflection back from a stationary car but you get a similarly nice reflection from an overhead trafic light or a manhole cover or a dropped nail. Because of this every automotive radar ever fielded gates out the stationary objects. If you wouldn’t you would get a crazy amount of false positives.

They can do this because the radar measures the relative speed of objects via dopler shift, and you know the speed of your own vehicle. Anything which has the same speed as you have but goes in the other direction is most likely stationary. (Or moving perpendicular to you. The velocity difference is vectorial, but dopler can only observe the component along the observation vector, and civilian radars have terrible angular resolution.)

In short: nobody ever used radar to stop cars from hitting stationary objects. This is not a Tesla specific thing.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by awfml on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:03PM (#29073074)
I think its probably more likely the driver made a user error— tens of thousands of people use autopilot every day in stop and go traffic
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:08PM (#29073124)
Stop and go traffic is not the same.

In stop and go traffic, the car in front of you is visible to the camera at all times.

In this case, my car may not have been acquired by the camera before it was already stationary, in which case it might have been ignored, causing the accident.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by xeromal on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:35PM (#29073452)
We won't know until the lady provides you with evidence that her AP was actually on, but my guess is that she fucked up and she's just using AP to offset blame.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:59PM (#29073746)
Exactly: An investigation would find out what happened.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by practice9 on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:44PM (#29074239)
Please post an update when the investigation concludes
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:30PM (#29075308)
The main point of this thread is that I don't know how to actually get an investigation to happen!
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by xeromal on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:18PM (#29076543)
The insurance company handles it.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by jsight on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:01PM (#29073052)
To be fair to scenario A, I've seen one other video of a driver reporting AP hitting the car in front of them during a rapid slowdown in traffic. Its hard to say how widespread it is, if the NHTSA isn't wanting to investigate.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by throwaway0a5e on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:15PM (#29073196)
Or D) Tesla stops instantly when it hits OP once by itself and again when the person behind it hits it.

(Spare me the low effort comment about how everyone should be prepared for the car in front of them to stop instantly because it hit something, statistically nobody drives like that)

Edit: I misinterpreted the OP about it being an four car pileup.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by Zanni on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:20PM (#29073272)
Dude. It's not a "low effort comment" to point that out, it's literally the law. If you can't stop when the person in front of you stops, you're too close. Increase your following distance. Don't let others bad habits justify your own.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by throwaway0a5e on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:45PM (#29073582)
Yes, yes it is a low effort comment. And it is exactly what I was trying to preempt. It adds exactly zero to the conversation to say "but the law" or "but drivers ed" or "but some proverbial rule of thumb".

For better or worse neither your fantasy of how people ought to act nor the letter of the law is reflective of how the overwhelming majority of the human population operators motor vehicles or expects others to. Is it ideal? Probably not. But it's a decent balance between being somewhat prepared for the expected traffic oddities, leaving margin for some subset of the unexpected and efficient use of road space.

I'm sure this will be an unpopular comment because there is no shortage of people here who think humans adhere to laws the way a network switch adheres to its configuration but the reality is that there is not perfect alignment between how reasonable traffic participants behave and the letter of the law.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by trav4225 on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:00PM (#29073761)
I think that some of us would argue that these are not "reasonable traffic participants". People who do not maintain sufficient stopping distance are one of the most frustrating parts of the American driving experience and are (IMO) extremely disruptive to safe travel, especially on highways.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by throwaway0a5e on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:56PM (#29074373)
>I think that some of us would argue that these are not "reasonable traffic participants"

You're basically arguing that almost everyone else is unreasonable. That's going to be a very uphill argument.

Also there's no reason to hide behind "I think that some of us would argue". You clearly hold this opinion. Ask yourself why you have reservations about owning it.

>People who do not maintain sufficient stopping distance

Who defines "sufficient" because the consensus based on the observed behavior of typical traffic seems to be that "sufficient" is a few seconds where possible but always less than whatever the comments section on the internet thinks it should be

>American driving experience

The American driving experience is not particularly remarkable compared (except maybe in its low cost) compared to other developed nations. All of which are pretty tame compared to developing nations

I'm not asking you to like the way people drive. I'm just asking you to not assess traffic incidents based on the reality of how people drive and not the farcical assumption that most participants are following or can be expected to be following whatever rules are on paper.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by Zanni on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:58PM (#29073736)
You could have pre-empted it by not making such a claim in the first place, and I abhor your attempt to normalize this dangerous behavior. It is not a "delicate balance." Increase your follow distance. Driving closer to the car in front of you gains you nothing but sacrifices valuable reaction time in the event of an emergency.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by throwaway0a5e on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#29074390)
Take your high horse and turn it into glue. I'm not attempting to normalize anything. Look outside, it's already normalized. It is the current status quo. I'm not endorsing it. I'm simply asking you to not to pretend otherwise so you can pretend to be outraged at someone who failed to avoid an accident because they were driving like typical people drive.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by HWR_14 on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:38PM (#29073490)
> If you can't stop when the person in front of you stops, you're too close

If the other driver decides to randomly brake in the middle of the road (as some Teslas have been known to do), it's not necessarily the person behind's fault.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by diggernet on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @01:20PM (#29084327)
It absolutely is. If the person behind was unable to avoid collision, then the collision occurred because they were following too closely. It doesn't matter whether it was a Tesla phantom-braking, or a human slamming on the brakes to avoid hitting a dog. It is always the driver's responsibility to maintain enough distance that they can safely respond to any action taken by the vehicle ahead.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @01:37PM (#29084607)
>It absolutely is. If the person behind was unable to avoid collision, then the collision occurred because they were following too closely.

This is infantile circular logic. It makes for great internet feel good points an little else.

What the other car was doing absolutely matters. Plenty of people have brake checked their way into an accident and wound up paying for it because there were witnesses.

>It is always the driver's responsibility to maintain enough distance that they can safely respond to any action taken by the vehicle ahead

Citation please. I'm particularly interested in one that backs up the word that you thought was important enough to italicize.

My state places no specific requirement for following distance upon drivers. The state driver's manual states a suggested minimum of two seconds.

I spot checked two other states and their drivers' manuals advise similar (one advised three seconds, one advised a variable number depending on speed), neither said anything about being able to account for anything the car in front of you does.

Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by speedgoose on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @01:20AM (#29077394)
In my part of the world, it's always the person's behind fault.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @06:29AM (#29079263)
This is changing with dash-cams. If the other person has a dash-cam you are not free to do unreasonably things and then weasel out of being on the hook on the basis of the front of their car hitting the rear of yours. Of course, if there were witnesses this has always been the case.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by speedgoose on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @06:48AM (#29079382)
If the dashcam shown the driver following too closely and failing to brake in time, I'm not sure a dashcam will help. But sure you can't reverse into someone.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by HWR_14 on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @10:57AM (#29082206)
Really? In most states and EU countries its not. It's assumed to be the person behind's fault at first, but that's a heuristic, not a necessary assignment.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by raylad on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:18PM (#29073248)
No other car hit the Tesla from behind. It hit me with two impacts all by itself.
Re:Tell HN: Tesla rear-ended me on autopilot, no one will in... by TheParkShark on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @11:46AM (#29082972)
You said it was a 4 car accident? She hit you from behind and you hit the car in front of you which hit the car in front of it? Did you end up hitting the car in front of you twice because she hit you twice?