News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by maerF0x0 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:45PM (#29019966)
I'm actually in favor of this.

I've long held that there should be public liquidity in all companies over a certain valuation and the company should not be allowed to bar you from selling the stock (though it could retain right to beat any pending offers)

It's asinine that companies are allowed to treat equity pay as pay, and IRS can tax it as realized (AMT), but the worker does not in fact have any instrument with which to pay the bill.

Edit: Also this is a really smart tweet IMO

    Give yourself a salary that pays for your wealth tax obligations. You don't have to sell anything.
https://twitter.com/macrofacet/status/1453487461989076997

The valuation would grow slower due to burn rate, but the ownership % would not change.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by lavezza on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:07PM (#29020145)
Somehow I think Elon giving himself a multi-billion dollar salary to cover a jump in Tesla stock would upset a lot of people.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by cosmotic on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:23PM (#29020321)
I'd be in favor of this I think. It might force Elon, Tesla, or the shareholders to address the elephant in the room: Teslas market cap vs their revenue.

Teslas market cap is 1030m on 31.5m of revenue. GM is 79m on revenue of 122.5m. That's 50x the market cap per revenue.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by young_unixer on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:08PM (#29020746)
If a company is doing tons of R&D, and everything suggests that that R&D will give huge dividends in the future, then it seems perfectly normal for such a company to have a high market-cap/revenue ratio.

If having too big of a market cap relative to revenue is wrong, then you're basically saying that companies should not invest too much in their future, just use their money to sell as much as possible right now.

You know who else has extremely high ratios of mktcap/revenue? Pharmaceutical companies trying to cure diseases that have no available cure. Is it wrong to try to cure those diseases?

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by cosmotic on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:43PM (#29020961)
I think Tesla does a good job of making folks think they are doing a lot of R&D, but that's about it. Based on some quick internet research, Tesla is a quarter of the R&D of either Ford or GM...

Unless you think it's higher quality or in a different area... but the whole world is going toward electric cars and autonomous driving. Tesla AutoPilot comes in a distant second to GM according to Consumer Reports: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/28/gms-super-cruise-tops-teslas...

Tesla build quality also ranks low, even according to Elon: https://www.cnn.com/2021/02/03/business/elon-musk-tesla-qual...

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by mywittyname on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:44PM (#29021346)
There's a reasonable chance of Tesla creating patents that generate a license fee from every car produced, basically in the globe.

It's kind of the reason Toyota has a monopoly on hybrids: they have a patent on the best kind of hybrid system. Ford held a similar enough patent that Toyota entered into a license agreement with them.

Getting a 20 year monopoly on key EV/battery tech will be worth an unimaginable sum.

I don't agree with Telsa's valuation, but I can appreciate why investors support them at their current price.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by Ericson2314 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:38PM (#29020933)
If it's so perfectly reasonable, they should be able to take out cheap loans to pay this new Elon salary.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by maerF0x0 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @04:19PM (#29031350)
Revenue is an instantaneous metric of a company where as Market Value is a reflection of sentiment integrated over time and relatively compared to competing options for capital (such as other stocks, bonds, even present vs future purchases if inflation is material).

They will always be quite disjoint when viewed with an single/small number of revenue data points.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by ralph84 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:33PM (#29020427)
How exactly would you propose Tesla address it? Put out a press release that says "you people are paying too much for our stock, stop it"?
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by bjtitus on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:37PM (#29020477)
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by gtCameron on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:32PM (#29020415)
How would they “address” that? It’s outside of their control
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by MisterBastahrd on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:39PM (#29021731)
I think what most people want is for billionaires to pay their true rate of income instead of artificially low percentages because they have access to financial instruments that most don't.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by hncurious on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:37PM (#29020464)
Would SpaceX even exist if this law had been in place? Serious question. Let's think this through.

Also what if it had been in place during the dotcom boom and bust?

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by karkisuni on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:01PM (#29020700)
jesus christ, yes. Elon didn't become a billionaire including assets until 2012, well after nasa awarded them the cargo contract and two years after Falcon 9 started launching. Before that, he was barely a millionaire after PayPal and his investments in Tesla and SpaceX. This tax wouldn't have affected him at all until both SpaceX and Tesla were relatively healthy with both Falcon 9 and Model S.

There's a reason CEO's at this level take $1 in salary.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by dsizzle on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:04PM (#29020120)
He could also himself shares with super-voting power, like what Facebook and Google have done.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by quickthrowman on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:26PM (#29021228)
Companies don’t do this anymore because S&P and other index creators will refuse to add your company to their indexes if you have multiple share classes. It’s much better to be part of an index than to retain founder control, for shareholders.

https://www.ft.com/content/993e4c11-8729-3168-a280-69e1d400b...

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by dannyw on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:34PM (#29021293)
Plenty of IPOs this year had dual class shares (~20% I believe). Founders are often billionaires; money is now measured in log terms, but control is a boolean.

If they already have control, they'll want to keep that control.

Investors (VC, etc) have made 20x or more on their investment already and no one is going to go on a fight with successful founders, for a variety of reasons but primarily, they don't care how a company performs in the long run because their fund has already sold their stake and closed already.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by dsizzle on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:57PM (#29021450)
The price boost from being added to the S&P is temporary and small (~5%) https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/spphenomenon.asp

The person controlling the company potentially has a much greater and longer lasting influence on the stock price!

Epic isn't going to be part of the S&P when it's private anyway, so obviously that's not a top concern for Sweeney.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by DennisP on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:26PM (#29020849)
Is it possible to do that after taking outside investment? I always assumed share classes like that had to be set up at the beginning.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by mardifoufs on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:59PM (#29021068)
Almost everything is possible you manage to get the other shareholders to agree. That might happen when some early investors sometimes want the founder to have more control especially before going public. The theory is that you'd rather have a founder you invested on in the first place steering the company than let your generic wallstreet shareholder without a vision(tm) take over a unicorn still full of promise.

Sometimes the bet pays off, very very well. Take for example Musk. You can say whatever about him, but it's extremely clear he has a vision, and does pretty much anything to get there. I'm not sure tesla or spacex would've survived 2018 with someone else at the helm or if a shareholder revolt happened. Just by that metric he is already worth dozens of billions to the rest of the shareholders.

Zuck is also a good example of investors trading off votes for a more wall st. independant, steadier long term eadership.

Now keep in mind those are exceptions. Having supervoting shares orbmultiple classes of shareholders is very often not a good thing and usually leads to less value being generated.

Accountability to shareholders is usually good and very important to ensure sane corporate governance. Which is why CEOs and founders absolutely love having ever less powerful shareholders and we end up in situations like now where even the crappiest IPO has absurdly overgeared supervoting classes. Who doesn't want to buy in a deeply in debt, cash burning ipo with very questionable growth who's founder has a perpetual 80% of the votes?

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by dsizzle on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:38PM (#29021310)
Yes, it's possible: Google, for instance, did it not only after taking outside investment, but after it went public (in 2014, 10 years after it went public) https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/052615/whats-differ...
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by DLTADragonHawk on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:03PM (#29020117)
I think it is a smart way to handle it and it would work for some CEO/founders however, some founders operate as board members that still influence much of the direction and operation without the same possibilities for pay rate increases to cover the gains. I think this could work under specific ownership scenarios but, for high p/e ratio companies this will likely requires ownership sales.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by grayfaced on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:41PM (#29020512)
It would likely increase pressure for stocks to pay dividends at a rate that covers taxes on the gains. Which would probably be a good thing.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by fallingknife on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:50PM (#29020593)
That's ridiculous. Tesla's market value gain since it went public is around $1T. The aggregate profits since then are at most a couple billion and may even be a loss. Paying out a salary to cover the gains is impossible.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by refurb on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:24PM (#29020835)
Why do you think this requires public liquidity?
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by TedShiller on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:29PM (#29020374)
I assume you’ve never founded a successful company
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by threeseed on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:37PM (#29020466)
This comment adds absolutely nothing to the discussion.

Is there some specific critique you have of what OP has said ?

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by TedShiller on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:17PM (#29020802)
It’s like saying “I think all music rock stars could improve their music by doing X.”

That statement could be interesting if you’re a rockstar. If not, then not so much.

Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by setpatchaddress on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:45PM (#29020977)
That doesn't make any sense -- something that applies to "all music rock stars" would have to come from a mastering engineer or someone at that level and even then it wouldn't be universally applicable.
Re:Tim Sweeney: Tax bill would likely end founder control of... by whateveracct on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:43PM (#29020520)
few have at the relevant magnitude