News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by travoc on Monday October 25, 2021 @02:39PM (#28991478)
You can download some of the data that Verizon retains from your own cellular use here: https://www.verizon.com/support/download-and-view-vpd-file/

When I did it, I could see they recorded IP addresses, time stamps and data transfer volume of every web site that I visited over their network, along with cell tower connections. It was fascinating.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by hpoe on Monday October 25, 2021 @02:44PM (#28991530)
Just out of curiosity do you use a VPN, I always browse with a VPN on my phone for precisely that reason and am wondering if it actually works to help protect my privacy.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by kempbellt on Monday October 25, 2021 @07:02PM (#28994276)
I route all of my mobile data through a Wireguard VPN on my home's network, and everything on my home network is routed through PiHole where I block/disable a lot of tracking and extraneous junk requests.

Generally speaking, this makes me feel a better when using mobile data or any foreign network (public, friends, work, etc) since I know all of my outbound requests are coming from "one location".

I can reroute outbound access to an external VPN if/when needed, but it's really a crapshoot for who you trust to keep track of your outbound requests. I don't trust any VPN out there to be strong enough to say "NO" to an intrusive 3rd-party like the US gov. No more than my own ISP at least.

For someone overly paranoid about tracking, I would probably suggest just using Tor, but for basic consolidation of internet access, routing through a self-hosted VPN at home works great.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by mikeastock on Monday October 25, 2021 @07:17PM (#28994413)
Do you any recommendations for a solid getting started PiHole guide?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by kofejnik on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:21AM (#28998134)
Google wirehole, just needs a single docker-compose up
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by travoc on Monday October 25, 2021 @02:48PM (#28991574)
Using a VPN would protect the privacy of your IP sessions from Verizon, although your VPN provider would now be able to see all of your session information.

I suspect a VPN user would show up in the Verizon data file with many large TCP sessions to a very small number of IPs.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by gzer0 on Monday October 25, 2021 @02:59PM (#28991706)
I suspect that the effort required to succesfully produce viable evidence from a VPN provider such as Mullvad are significantly higher than the effort we see here from ATT, T-mobile, Sprint, and Verizon.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by flowerwolf on Monday October 25, 2021 @08:15PM (#28994929)
Also, don't use a VPN provider that knows who you are and don't use one in your own jurisdiction.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by travoc on Monday October 25, 2021 @03:13PM (#28991850)
That is probably true in most cases. Choose your poison.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by SavantIdiot on Monday October 25, 2021 @03:44PM (#28992205)
I am my own VPN provider. EC2 micro instance on AWS running StrongSwan. Sure, feds could dig that up, but it would be messier. I wonder what in/out logs AWS keeps on its VPCs....
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by zzyzxd on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:00PM (#28992402)
> EC2 micro instance on AWS running StrongSwan

Just curious, how many captchas do you solve with this setup daily? Or even IP bans?

I did exactly the same thing once and it was so annoying.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by SavantIdiot on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:53PM (#28992985)
None? I've had this for a long time with no issues. That's weird. I'm on it now listening to spotify, reading WaPo and browsing HN. What sites complain? I'll try it?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by rlt on Monday October 25, 2021 @07:10PM (#28994363)
You might have gotten lucky with the static IP / subnet assigned to your machine.

I set up a VPN on a Digital Ocean instance and got captchas all the time on various websites, especially ones using CloudFlare etc (I’m aware of Privacy Pass but didn’t bother setting it up as it was a temporary thing)

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by bklyn11201 on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:23PM (#28993320)
Why pay AWS $0.09 a GB tax to listen to Spotify?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by SavantIdiot on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:08PM (#28993749)
Yes. Spotify. Ahem. That's why I use my VPN... cough cough.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by beermonster on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:00PM (#28993067)
You can always use Privacy Pass as quite often you're dealing with CloudFlare protected sites.

That said, if you're using your own EC2/lightsail instance you won't see as many CAPTCHAs as, say, using a commodity VPN service.

Given you can't detect a VPN per-se (if configured properly) usually the way it works is that the destination node knows you're coming from a source IP from a known VPN-supplier's well-known IP-block.

If you go for this kind of setup (running your own VPN on AWS) you're simply changing your ISP to Amazon. They still might (and probably will) be monitoring egress traffic at the very least to perform any kind of incident analysis.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by flowerwolf on Monday October 25, 2021 @08:19PM (#28994966)
The big providers are definitely monitoring, and are probably working with NSA/FBI, if nothing else then at least to look for APT CNE/org.crime.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by gtsteve on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:18PM (#28993873)
t3.micro = $0.0104 x 750 = $7.80/mo without taking your bandwidth into consideration.

Lightsail costs $3.50/mo with 1tb transfer bundled or $5/mo with 2tb.

If your setup is scripted then it probably makes sense to switch over to save a bit of cash. Others following the same path could save some money by using Lightsail as opposed to EC2.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by SavantIdiot on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:55PM (#28994211)
Yeah, but I wanted full control...
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by mnahkies on Monday October 25, 2021 @07:16PM (#28994401)
Can you please clarify what control you are gaining using EC2 over lightsail? (And why it's useful for your stated purpose)
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by SavantIdiot on Monday October 25, 2021 @10:35PM (#28995781)
I know I'm not selling my requests? I don't have to trust lightsail. Sure, I have to worry about AWS keeping logs of my requests but that seems less likely? Is that your argument?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by mnahkies on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:15AM (#28997709)
Lightsail is basically an EC2 instance packaged with an ipv4 address, storage and bandwidth to compete with low cost VPS providers.

I personally use lightsail for most always on things and then just use ec2 for on demand workloads, because it works out far cheaper (these are just random personal projects so I'm heavily optimising for low cost)

You can't configure the lightsail instances as much as an EC2 instance, but otherwise it's essentially the same product (both operated by AWS).

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by fomine3 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @01:37AM (#28996771)
AWS operates LightSail and LightSail is cheaper for who use bandwidth a few TB. That's why the question.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by koheripbal on Monday October 25, 2021 @08:27PM (#28995022)
I have been considering setting up a dedicated lightweight node on some cloud server just for VPN.

I'm curious if other have done the same.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by aksss on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:45PM (#28994110)
Assuming your VPN isn't owned by or in cahoots with the NSA too, you're dns lookups would be shielded from view, I guess.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by murat124 on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:10PM (#28992524)
Does anyone know the AT&T equivalent of this URL?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by mrtksn on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:11PM (#28993181)
Wouldn't that kind of data be massive? Any idea on what kind of infrastructure they use?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by sixothree on Monday October 25, 2021 @09:59PM (#28995576)
On my work computers I have an app that screenshots all of my desktops every 30 seconds. I have literally years of screenshots. The cost is miniscule.

Meaning, the cost to record everything a person does all day, every day of the year for literally forever is not very much at all.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by NoPicklez on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:26PM (#29007169)
It might not cost much for yourself, but when we're talking millions of people. Data points being recorded multiple times per day per customer, the size of that data would be huge.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by electrondood on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:32AM (#28996421)
Interesting, what's the purpose?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by kolla on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:03AM (#28999858)
I've used such an app myself on my work environments and if anyone ever questioned what I did a certain day I could always go back and look.

Very helpful when filling out the time report if you are reporting time on many different customers.

If a company force installed it on your PC it is probably not a good place to work at.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by sixothree on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @01:43PM (#29003541)
This is exactly the reason.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by sixothree on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @01:19PM (#29003198)
The purpose is for time tracking. I am a developer but I go through periods where I work on _many_ different projects. And also I sometimes get pulled in (without warning) to support the team on client calls.

It is not uncommon for me to have 15-30 different time tracker entries for things I worked on in a single day. This is not an exaggeration. Then other days I will work on a single task for entire day.

So all of this unscheduled stuff gets lost pretty easily. Calls scheduled for an hour run only 30 minutes. Client A needed 10 minutes of support here, 20 minutes there, 5 minutes there. I want to be as fair as possible to our clients.

And related to client support, there is often the question of "who owns this bug" and who pays for the call. So I can use screenshots of the client environment to relate to the team and get more information about whether we should really be billing for the call or if that's something that needs to be improved in our software.

Also I support other developers. Skype calls with developers tend to be short. But boy can they add up. If I'm spending 3 hours a day on support overall, I really need to track that. That time needs to go into the right project at the very least.

So that's where the screenshots come in. This is not something the company asked for or have ever requested access to. They know I do this. So when I say I spent two hours supporting a client, they feel confident sending out that bill.

It actually started as one of those experiments into time lapse video. But I multitask way too much for these to be usable videos. Though I have hand picked select days and turned them into something very cool.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by raxxorrax on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:05AM (#28997638)
Employee surveillance in a low trust environment and bad working conditions I would assume.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by sixothree on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @01:22PM (#29003240)
Quite the opposite here. I did this myself without any sort of request. This is one of the highest trust environments I have worked in. If this were forced (or expected) in any way I would be looking for a new place to be.

Please see my answer here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29003198

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by fouc on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:51PM (#28994169)
120 million verizon customers * 100 daily entries (on average) of "ip address, website, total_data, time_stamp, cell_tower_connections"

4.4 trillion database entries in a year

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by adolph on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:26PM (#28993337)
Prolly just "borrow" NSAs.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by OneLeggedCat on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:35PM (#28994025)
Prolly just being indirectly paid by NSA to run it themselves.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by adolph on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:59PM (#29002919)
I wonder if this sort of activity would be detectible on publicly available balance sheets?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by danuker on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:35PM (#28994031)
I guess that is part of why Internet is so expensive in the US.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by fulafel on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:09PM (#28992512)
Wow, that's invasive.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by jamesfe on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:17PM (#28992601)
Is it? How do they bill you without knowing how much data you transferred? How do they debug what went wrong with your connection without logs?

This stuff is barely scratching the surface of the data those companies collect and maintain, likely for long periods of time, just to analyze and improve customer experience.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by unethical_ban on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:51PM (#28992954)
As if ATT gets on the line with end-users to debug site-specific issues!

Aggregate data usage is one thing, but retaining any kind of detailed logs on where one goes or how much data was used on a specific site is unnecessary for the base provisioning of network connectivity.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by fulafel on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:26PM (#28992690)
I interpreted this to mean they log traffic per web site:

> data transfer volume of every web site that I visited over their network

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by snuser on Monday October 25, 2021 @06:04PM (#28993714)
without net neutrality this could be useful for future billing arrangements
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by jjulius on Monday October 25, 2021 @09:46PM (#28995476)
>This stuff is barely scratching the surface of the data those companies collect and maintain, likely for long periods of time, just to analyze and improve customer experience.

Heh, just to analyze and improve customer experience? Nothing else a bit more unsavory?

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by tablespoon on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:18AM (#29000717)
>> This stuff is barely scratching the surface of the data those companies collect and maintain, likely for long periods of time, just to analyze and improve customer experience.

> Heh, just to analyze and improve customer experience? Nothing else a bit more unsavory?

The point is this data would get captured regardless, surveillance or no. Mass surveillance (at least in this matter) often isn't so much about what gets captured, but how long it gets retained and who gets access to it.

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by LatteLazy on Monday October 25, 2021 @04:26PM (#28992699)
Actually it's very transparent. They're required to keep that data by law, they're just making it easy for us to see that.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by mikem170 on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:59PM (#28993656)
I was curious about this. I knew that logged data has to be turned over if there is a warrant. I wasn't sure if logging was mandated.

I found this article [0] describing the situation in various countries, with the following info for the United States:

> Data Retention Period = 1 Year for Internet metadata, email, phone records

> Authorization required to access the data = Various United States agencies leverage the (voluntary) data retention practiced by many U.S. commercial organizations like Amazon through programs such as Prism and Muscular.

> Status Of Data Retention Regime = No mandatory data retention regime

I'm guessing the above means that metdata (user ip and also user web and email destinations) are held for a year, but retaining actual user data (email contents, etc) is not mandated.

[0] https://www.privacyend.com/mandatory-data-retention/

Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by rlt on Monday October 25, 2021 @07:07PM (#28994325)
FWIW I think all ISPs that employ CGNAT are required by law to retain “NAT binding records” that are essentially this.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by NavinF on Monday October 25, 2021 @08:05PM (#28994861)
I used to be an ISP and I'm not aware of any law like that in the US.
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by rlt on Monday October 25, 2021 @08:50PM (#28995146)
Maybe a DMCA safeharbor thing?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by NavinF on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:46AM (#29001061)
Nope
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by rlt on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @01:55PM (#29003749)
I mean it may not be explicitly required by law but if you can't identify which customers broke other laws then aren't you opening yourself up to liability?
Re:The FBI's internal guide for getting data from AT&T, T-Mo... by chriscappuccio on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:42AM (#28996474)
There is currently no federal rule, law or other mandate for US ISPs to develop, construct or keep CGNAT translation records. The laws that apply in this area only apply to records voluntarily created by the network operator.