News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @06:11AM (#28967098)
It would be great if folks could think beyond questioning the business model in terms of what (controversial content) increases user attention and think about questioning the model itself: using the internet to sell attention. There is nothing that demands the internet must be used this way.

The big tech companies like to combat the possibility of any such thinking by invoking people's fear of change. Something like "The internet would not be as you know it today if advertising decreased." The reader is supposed to think, "Oh my gosh, what a scary thought." However the internet as we know it today is not necessarily the best the internet could be. That should be obvious. Tech employees are having a crisis of conscience.

Tech companies and their investors want everyone to presume the way things are now is the best possible outcome. That is because they know they have a money printing machine (see, e.g., Tucker Bounds quote) so long as the internet remains open for unregulated advertising. They will keep advancing this idea that the internet would suck without unregulated ads, but there is no evidence that is true. No one can predict the future. Tech company spokespersons try to paint a picture of a possible future where web users would have to pay for using websites. There is nothing that indicates that would be the outcome. Tech companies do not control the internet. They do not own the internet. Tech companies might die without advertising, but websites might flourish. Both commercial and non-commercial. People might find relief from excessive screen time. The mom and pop retailer or SMB/SME are not going to charge customers to use their websites. Users will continue to pay access fees to ISPs. "The tech industry" !== the internet. It uses the internet to advance its own interests (these may be aligned somewhat to those of advertisers, but they often conflict with the interests of users). Tech companies must use the internet for advertising or face an existential crisis. That is not true for users. We can use the internet for whatever we want. We pay for it. Generally, advertisers do not pay our internet access fees.

We pay for access to a network that tech companies usurp to sap our attention for a fee, paid by advertisers. We do not get a cut of those payments. The whole system is incredibly one-sided and should be questioned. It is far from ideal.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 23, 2021 @08:27AM (#28967755)
> sell attention

This is the fundamental problem. People think they should be able to do that. They should not.

It is extremely dehumanizing when some stupid ad works its way into my mind. I never asked for this. I never wanted it. They just keep forcing it. They feel entitled to it. They think it's their right to keep showing me this stuff. They think they own my senses. A couple seconds ago some asshole with a huge speaker just drove past my house blasting ads for what I assume was a local supermarket. Everybody thinks it's great. It's a nuisance but it creates honest jobs, right? How will the poor little companies get consumers otherwise?

Attention is precious. It should not be wasted on advertisers and their little brands and products. It's a privilege that must be freely given and punished severely if violated without consent. Like rape. That's what advertising is really. Mind rape.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by sershe on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:49AM (#28968442)
You are not forced to use the pages/apps that are ad-funded you know ;) Traditional advertising that intrudes on public spaces is much more "evil" by that standard.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 23, 2021 @10:02AM (#28968602)
> You are not forced to use the pages/apps that are ad-funded you know ;)

It's not like they warn me beforehand. How am I supposed to know that clicking a link will lead me to a place where I will be assaulted by countless ads?

I'm done with that approach. I block all ads. If people send me free web pages, good. If they send me ads as well, they're gonna get deleted before I even see them. Anyone who wants to get paid for their pages can make the HTTP server return 402 Payment Required.

> Traditional advertising that intrudes on public spaces is much more "evil" by that standard.

Absolutely agree. I hate that noise so much. It used to be somewhat tolerable but now I can't even cross a street without being advertised to. The companies will literally put up banners on both ends of sidewalks, near traffic stops. I swear to god they'd put up ads inside my goddamn eyelids if they could. I don't know what to do to make this stuff go away. It's gotten to the point I wish some gang would start vandalizing those signs. I could waste time trying to lobby my city government to ban this stuff but I doubt I can match their lobbying power. I wish I had some sort of ad blocking augmented reality glasses.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by vanilla_nut on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:46PM (#28970117)
I can't stand it either. Interestingly, a few states actually have ban billboard advertising:

https://99percentinvisible.org/article/clean-city-law-secret... (Alaska, Hawaii, Maine and Vermont).

Try visiting one of those states, and you'll be amazed at the difference it makes. Vermont and Maine are very high on my list of "next place to live."

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 23, 2021 @03:28PM (#28971457)
I'll always be impressed by São Paulo's advertising ban. I have no idea how they pulled that off.

> The law was (predictably) fought at all stages by business groups with a vested commercial interest in buying and selling prime public ad space.

This doesn't inspire me to try...

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by mrtesthah on Saturday October 23, 2021 @10:59AM (#28969142)
> I could waste time trying to lobby my city government to ban this stuff but I doubt I can match their lobbying power.

Never underestimate the power of NIMBYs to influence zoning ordinances.

Barring that, repeated persistent drive-by paintball defacement of the articles in question may sap the companies’ will to carry on.

https://streetartutopia.com/2013/03/28/graffiti-just-do-it/

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 23, 2021 @11:14AM (#28969284)
> Never underestimate the power of NIMBYs to influence zoning ordinances.

I shouldn't underestimate the corruption of these politicians either. It's reasonable to assume the companies are paying them for the privilege of polluting my town. They've even taken over road signs, I can't even look at a stop sign without getting an eyeful of brands.

> repeated persistent drive-by paintball defacement of the articles in question may sap the companies’ will to carry on

... Has anyone ever done that before? What a hero!

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by vanilla_nut on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:44PM (#28970098)
Y'know, unless I want to participate in community events in my town, which seem to only use Facebook these days.

Or find out the hours of a local business, which only has a Facebook page (or worse, instagram!) and no website at all.

Or use a phone or tablet that can connect to the internet -- turns out both of the companies that make 99%+ of smartphones have advertising businesses. And nobody makes apps for any other platform, so they aren't viable.

It's a lot like riding public transit, or using public highways, all of which are plastered with ads in the vast majority of the US. These are things you really can't avoid, so the advertising has essentially become mandatory.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by freen on Saturday October 23, 2021 @01:45PM (#28970662)
Wasn’t this way before, doesn’t have to be this way now.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by vanilla_nut on Saturday October 23, 2021 @02:19PM (#28970937)
Agreed. The question is, how do you get individuals and organizations who couldn’t care less about tech monopolies and advertising ethics to switch away from private social media owned by ad companies? Like it or not, Facebook is “sticky” for those who don’t think about these things, and it requires a lot of convincing for people to move away from dependency.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by runamok on Sunday October 24, 2021 @02:45PM (#28980780)
Totally agree. I am a runner and most running clubs no longer have their own website. Often events are behind a Facebook paywall and I deleted by account in 2016... Many many others niche interests have the same issue.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by Lamad123 on Monday October 25, 2021 @08:40AM (#28987095)
No true!! Those ads didn't follow you to the toilet and didn't jump before your eyes!! You had to look up to see them, and you could easily ignore them!!
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by xg15 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @01:31PM (#28970521)
Actually you are if you want to take part in modern life.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by euroderf on Saturday October 23, 2021 @01:13PM (#28970367)
Why is selling attention suddenly bad ? We're living in the Attention Economy. Time is money. Ads support free content. TV programming exists to keep people in their seats between commercials. Et cetera et cetera ad nauseum. Putting a halt to selling attention is attacking not just Faceborg, it's attacking the entire modern media economy. That's not to say it would be a bad idea :)
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by matheusmoreira on Saturday October 23, 2021 @03:09PM (#28971307)
What do you mean suddenly? It has always been bad. It took time for me to realize it and start posting about it. I'm sure others will eventually realize it too. Especially since companies keep ramping up the abuse.

That's what this industry is all about really. Doing things we don't want. Making us see and hear things we never asked for. Sucking up information we never wanted them to have. It's basically abuse incorporated but society forgives them because they pay for all the media we consume.

Let the media companies go bankrupt. We don't need it to survive. It's entertainment.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by xg15 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @01:30PM (#28970516)
It has always been bad. The term "attention economy" has been coined to describe the current situation, not to justify it.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by strogonoff on Saturday October 23, 2021 @06:42AM (#28967222)
The root issue seems to lie, in large part, in the normalization of “free”. It is very, very good to established big social, but it breaks how the market is supposed to work.

It’s a two-hit knockout:

1. Because users aren’t the ones paying, their interests and well-being fundamentally don’t matter. Paying customers are investors & advertisers, and the only thing that matters to them is that users don’t leave.

2. Because it’s impossible to justify switching (and convincing all friends & family to switch) away from a free solution, and because no honest business can compete with free, users won’t leave.

The vast resources big social accumulates from elsewhere, it can throw at optimizing the GUI and algorithms to keep eyeballs glued—suggest posts that are likely to trigger this individual, make them engage in another pointless argument or mindlessly like and reshare. Behold the eternal enemy of the market—information asymmetry—taken to a whole new level.

When a product with millions of users is inevitably user-hostile due to the fundamentals of parent company’s business model, I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to call it society-hostile.

Bringing the market back into the industry, turning users into paying customers and allowing them to vote with their money, could be the solution.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by austincheney on Saturday October 23, 2021 @08:12AM (#28967673)
Free could be part of the problem but it’s not enough to qualify a cause compared to other online companies.

I would say the greater problem is centralization. If user content did not go through Facebook servers, for example if Facebook were only a client application, this problems and concerns would not exist regardless of profit motive or free access.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by scotty79 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @08:19AM (#28967712)
You can argument like that against open source.

The problem is not that things are free.

The problem is that advertisement is almost completely unregulated.

I think whole advertisement industry should be nationalized and ran not-profit in strictly controlled manner in a way that more money doesn't translate to more eyeballs.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by strogonoff on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:47AM (#28968409)
Not saying we should make it illegal to give things away for others to build with. Open source code itself is not a product accessible by an end user, much less a service that connects many users and acts as a middleman in a two-sided market on which side of which are advertisers. I should clarify that I mean specifically the normalization of “free” in current context of big social.

I see we’re attacking it from different angles. I believe forcing big social to become paid by requiring it to open up is a better way, achievable with more narrowly focused, less far-reaching regulation.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by scotty79 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:09PM (#28969788)
I see making some service paid as more of a bandaid, and we'll get surprised by the next nasty thing fueled by advertisements that have all the incentive to enrage us and turn our brains into jello to opimize selling things.

Making Facebook paid doesn't help all that much because paid stuff also can have advertisements in them and they do. Also if somebody is selling something, they still want to play the same chords to keep us engaged and paying. Paying for something doesn't automatically make the seller work in your interest.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by strogonoff on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:03AM (#28975787)
There is a psychological aspect to this, I believe. Switching between cheap and expensive is less of an effort than switching between free and cheap. Similarly, competition-wise, competing with however low number is easier than competing with zero.

I really think FB’s domination hinges on “free”.

However, changing business model like that cannot be directly required. What can be required is openness.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by wintermutestwin on Saturday October 23, 2021 @11:40AM (#28969499)
>no honest business can compete with free

The resources required to provide the world with the valuable parts of these services are small enough to be funded through non-profits or benefit corporations. I'd gladly donate my time and money to a 501c3 facebook killer.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by freen on Saturday October 23, 2021 @01:45PM (#28970664)
Mastodon
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by wintermutestwin on Saturday October 23, 2021 @03:39PM (#28971558)
A self-hosted federated twitter replacement will never fly with the vast majority of potential users. It is also in desperate need of a name change. The first search result is to an awesome metal band.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by freen on Sunday October 24, 2021 @12:48PM (#28979614)
1: doesn’t have to be self hosted. 2: doesn’t have to be just twitter, it’s a federated protocol. Anything can go down the pipes. 3: doesn’t have to be called mastodon. How many forum users know the name of the software that runs their forum?
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by strogonoff on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:13AM (#28975849)
I also think self-hosted solutions can’t compete. Luckily, if hosted platforms (either non-profit or with true paying users) offer open API, there would be no issue interoperating with Mastodon et al.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by pjc50 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @08:47AM (#28967897)
> Bringing the market back into the industry, turning users into paying customers and allowing them to vote with their money, could be the solution

How exactly? Ban free content?

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by strogonoff on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:29AM (#28968200)
Mandating big social to provide interoperability seems like one way to go about it. Open APIs covering all functionality. Once proper cross-platform third-party clients can appear in which FB et al. can’t show ads, they will start bleeding users and perhaps be forced to change.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by freeflight on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:14AM (#28968079)
> Tech companies do not control the internet. They do not own the internet.

While I generally agree with you, sadly that hasn't been true for a few years already, by now a select few tech companies control the majority of the web and increasingly even own more and more of it [0]

In many developing countries Facebook is acting as sudo-ISP, for millions, if not over a billion, people, FB is literally the whole web they experience, they don't know anything else and they've been very successfully convinced that they don't even want anything else.

[0] https://staltz.com/the-web-began-dying-in-2014-heres-how.htm...

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by m0llusk on Saturday October 23, 2021 @06:33AM (#28967174)
What the unfollow everything app showed is that given some basic information and controls users can eliminate most of the problematic material in favor of what they actually want which is to keep up with friends, family, and other close relations.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by wayoutthere on Saturday October 23, 2021 @06:32AM (#28967167)
Almost there!

It’s like capitalism, without proper antitrust regulation, creates growth expectations such that even the most popular products will eventually plateau, but revenue growth is still expected, so how do you raise additional revenue? You sell access to your user base in the form of ads. The one-sidedness is entirely the point: you do not possess your own agency in this transaction as the company who makes the product you’re using literally believes they own your attention. All you can do is start ignoring the product.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by atribecalledqst on Saturday October 23, 2021 @10:33AM (#28968894)
> Tech company spokespersons try to paint a picture of a possible future where web users would have to pay for using websites.

If you think about it, we're already there. I think services like Netflix, Hulu, Spotify, etc. have normalized paying for websites. Maybe if social media had emerged later, the concept of paying for it wouldn't be so alien.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @06:10PM (#28972858)
Except unlike Netflix and Hulu neither Facebook nor Google produce any content.

Spotify is heavily dependant on advertising. Spotify cannot operate on user fees alone.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by pabenv on Saturday October 23, 2021 @07:59AM (#28967591)
Anyone know what happened with Jaron Lanier & Glen Weyls idea for data intermediaries - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Np5ri-KktNs

I thought that was a good idea. People get paid for all the attention suck instead of so much going to the tech firms.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by bo1024 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @09:18AM (#28968112)
There are lots of people working on versions of these.
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by JKCalhoun on Saturday October 23, 2021 @11:50AM (#28969592)
Some of us remember the Web before even banner ads. I would absolutely spend less time in a browser if we rolled back to the 90's ... but that might be. good thing. ;-)
Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday October 23, 2021 @06:06PM (#28972824)
The "roll back to the 90's" argument is a common (sometimes deliberate) misinterpratation of any suggestion for change to the status quo of the internet that supports "tech" companies.

We could not go back to old days even if we wanted to; no one is suggesting such an idea. We can however look back and learn lessons from the past. We can remember, for example, that neither Google nor Facebook required any business plan that included advertising in order to be created. We can contemplate how bad things have gotten.

The banners ads in 1994 had a CTR north of 40%.

http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/04/the-fi...

These days, it is less than 1%.

https://web.archive.org/web/20160302194635if_/http://www.wor...

https://web.archive.org/web/20150310125300if_/https://www.sa...

Some say online advertising today bears little resemblance to the online advertising of the 1990's, that it has been infiltrated by people who would otherwise be working in finance, e.g., "qwants", that online ads have become like HFT and that the market being run (unfairly) by its largest participant, Google, may explode.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by onlyrealcuzzo on Saturday October 23, 2021 @10:51AM (#28969068)
Look, I hate online ads as much as anyone.

But In this case - the problem isn't really the advertising. It's mostly the content itself.

Re:Facebook crisis grows as new whistleblower and leaked doc... by adgezaza on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:22PM (#28969905)
The nature of web3 makes this model difficult of not impossible