News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by artemonster on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:10AM (#28918250)
arrrghhh this "find a niche" stuff again. what if I am a regular 9-5 engineer in a big company. where the hell am I finding those? By using random idea generator and getting "note taking add-in for excel for amputee ballerinas"? aw jeez, they dont have enough money, I must pivot to broker ballerinas
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by omarhaneef on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:19AM (#28918347)
I thought this was implicit: you find a problem you deal with on a daily basis.

This is probably why there are so many more startups pitching development tools than, for instance, something to make the lives of truckers a little easier.

If you work as a regular engineer, you must come across dozens of daily problems any of which are not properly solved by your current tools. Even simple things like following up consistently, or checking to see if someone responded to an email to a third party etc

Addendum: In response to many comments, I should add that this method is not supposed to guarantee you a good idea, but is a source for ideas to filter, refine, develop or abandon.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by artemonster on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:41AM (#28918607)
"you find a problem you deal with on a daily basis". Nope, not necessarily. Depends on where you work. If you are a cog in a big company, slaving away your 9-5, then no. You would NEVER get an idea that some finance folk would love to get an excel addin where you can click together in a simple GUI a data fetch from API, or whatever.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by grogenaut on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:30AM (#28919226)
not if you never go talk to anyonw but your direct team. when i was at a 500 person consulting team i would wander over and chat woth sales, finance, and hr. sales needed updated resumes and better writing and presentation skills. i pushes the engineers ro all do lunch and learns. finance i plumbed some extra metrics for. hr i got some data into excel for, amd figured out how to get our door badge system to accept building badges which saved money and let people carry one badge. all within 4 years of school.

at a game studio of 300 i would wander amd chat with the various non-coder teams and just watch their workflows. for the tech artists a big blocker was gui access to enums in shaders (custom engine). i just set several of them up to compile the engine and taught tyem how to link enums to the editor gui, saved them many weeks of wait time. saw the lighting bake loop would take 1 year to run fully and a local test loop was 8 hours. asked my boss for time and rigged up a cluster of 64 ps4 dev kits and brought that down to 45 minutes, going from less than one local iteration a day to 9, and less than one a year to 3 a week for full bakes (cluster would bake when it wasnt helping am artist).

at super large mega corp i do similar, constantly meeting people for coffee and understanding more than just my cog. Eventually I got good enough at it and a reputation for improving things that I just get pushed/pulled at problem/opportunities areas, but you have to work up to it.

while none of this is doing a startup, if youre not curious, youll never see the myriad of things that could be improved with software, nor will many non tech folks, or really anyone who doesnt think "outside the box" as the olds say. challenge for devs is understanding where that tech is worth it and how to sell it, and not become that angry dev who is just yelling at everyone and politics for not taking every one of their half baked ideas as words from on high.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:24PM (#28920775)
I think you need to look more closely. There are often problems all around, but they've been "solved." Thing is, very often the solutions suck and are wide open for improvement.

An example from my day to day in a large corporation: we have to enter time weekly: how much time did you spend on project X, Y or in training/meetings/etc. Sure there is software that does this, but it's terrible There are many issues with it that should be trivially solvable.

Now, I will admit that time tracking software is a huge field with lots of strong competition, so this may not be a field you'd want to enter, but it's an example of the problems you would come across during an average workday that are ripe for better solutions.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by count on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @02:58PM (#28922050)
Maybe this is an indication that you're not the right personality type for this sort of thing.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by edmundsauto on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:27PM (#28920821)
There are also routes outside your main 9-5 at BigCo. In fact, your employment agreement with BigCo probably is written so that you don't want to get an idea for an internal product!

Try meeting people not in your field. Yes, it will take effort. Yes, it will be uncomfortable. Because of those challenges, fewer people have explored that space - so there are still fertile grounds for new products.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by axegon_ on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:17AM (#28919021)
Most problems we all face on daily basis are completely trivial and those which aren't are often solved by someone. Which is something people often overlook and end up making products which no one really needs. Here's an example - I broke the remote for my AC earlier this year but I managed to salvage the codes and program a wifi-enabled ESP32 to communicate with the AC over wifi remotely, I made a crazy stupid UI for my phone so I can control it remotely(though I spend 90% of my time at home). Sounds like a brilliant product, doesn't it? Is there a market for it? I haven't bothered to check but my bet is that there might be 3000 people worldwide that would consider getting one, out of which maybe 50 would end up buying it. So no, this probably won't break the front page of Amazon to put it lightly.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:29PM (#28920854)
That's actually a good idea.

Was the original remote app enabled? If not, now you have a potential product for those people who would rather use an app than the manual remote. Are spare remotes hard to get or expensive? There's another market that might want to buy from you, especially if the AC unit that is old or obsolete.

Spare parts/retrofits with new features is big business. There's a good chance that if you dug into this particular problem you'd find that it could be profitable. Not quit-you-day-job profitable, but at least enough to bring in a few extra $k per month.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by axegon_ on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:37PM (#28923442)
I never said it wasn't a good idea. Almost 6 months later it serves me perfectly well. There was no original app. The AC itself was here when I moved in, it's an obscure manufacturer no one has ever heard about and I recon it's been here since the building was built around 2007. All I could find out about it was that it was made in South Africa and that's it. Infrared communication is incredibly simple on those devices and it's a matter of two hours to reverse engineer them(no shifting, rotations or any of that fancy stuff). All in all it cost me around 20 bucks and ~day to get it to work+the crazy stupid ui running off an actix webserver. But if I had the option to buy a remote control which works with it, I would have gladly done that instead(tried several universal remotes, none of which worked).

My point was that this does solve my problem but it's an incredibly niche problem for an even smaller niche market. The owners of this AC from the same unknown manufacturer, that either can't find a spare remote or want to make it wifi enabled. It's insanely specific, isn't it? Let's not fool ourselves, writing the software is the easy part and fairly inexpensive when you can do it yourself, get a cheap stm32 board and flash it. Manufacturing on the other hand is a whole different ball game and honestly I can't justify the work of developing, manufacturing, distributing and dealing with taxes at the end of each month, all for 300 bucks tops(I'm probably far too optimistic).

edit: esp32, not stm32(I'm mostly playing with stm32 lately).

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:45PM (#28923519)
Understood. We all do what we're comfortable with.

> an incredibly niche problem for an even smaller niche market

These are my favorite because no one "big" wants to get into them. I make a device that converts signals from heavy machinery that uses a specific type of almost-obsolete sensor to let it use a modern control that you can buy off the shelf. A friend of mine used to have a nice side business (was full time for a while) selling a replacement timer for a specific type of industrial printer.

I like markets like that. The biggest problem I'd see in your case is that it's a consumer item, not industrial. Most customers just don't want to spend a whole lot unless they have to.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by skeeter2020 on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:52AM (#28919514)
>> Most problems we all face on daily basis are completely trivial and those which aren't are often solved by someone.

Resptfully disagree. There are a lot of non-trivial problems that do not have good solutions. If you look for niche manifestations of hard problems, you can both find something with appropriate scope AND a good value proposition. You also don't need to solve problems, just make them better/easier.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by axegon_ on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @04:58PM (#28923681)
I genuinely can't remember the last time(or if there ever was such an event) I saw something new and thought "Hey this solves/helps with X, I gotta have it". Software is easy when this is all you do so when I have a problem I can solve with code, I go on and do it. Manufacturing, you are either a large corporation(apple, samsung, etc.) or you are a black swan. Most simply fail.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by nocommandline on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @02:38PM (#28921720)
1) >>> you find a problem you deal with on a daily basis. <<<

Agree with this. As they say - necessity is the mother of invention. A lot of the episodes I listened to on the Podcast - How I built this with Guy Raz - were about people getting frustrated with a problem they faced on a daily basis and deciding to fix it (usually starting quite small).

2) >>> This is probably why there are so many more startups pitching development tools than, for instance, something to make the lives of truckers a little easier. <<<

This makes sense if you're a developer or work in software. Eg, I'm a Product person who built tools on the side to scratch my itch. My platform was Google App Engine (GAE). When the GAE GUI was deprecated, I realized that I really found a GUI much more convenient and so built - https://nocommandline.com and in the process fixed stuff I didn't like about the old GUI.

I think the trick here is to set right expectation i.e. recognize that not every idea is going to be a Unicorn or a big business. It could remain 'just a side project' or turn out to be something that just brings you extra income (pay your rent, weekly gas bill, etc).

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by cvhashim on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:27AM (#28918453)
Here’s a midly annoying problem I’m currently facing with Slack. Getting annoyed of jumping between DM’s and channels where I end up losing track of a channel I may have needed open or was going through. I feel like having tabs in slack would fix this? Not sure if it makes sense for the app to have this feature but something I’ve been thinking about.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by philsnow on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:13PM (#28920609)
I cling to using Chrome's support for shortcuts-as-apps: go to whateverteam.slack.com, hamburger menu -> "More tools" -> "Create shortcut..." -> "[X] open as window". At least on Mac, it creates a .app in "$HOME/Applications/Chrome Apps" that works like any other app: it shows up in the cmd-tab switcher, you can open it with spotlight, etc.

The best part (and the part relevant to your comment) is that this just opens a Chrome window and you can open (cmd-N) as many windows into the same slack team as you want, and it behaves like you expect a Mac app to behave: cmd-tab goes between teams and cmd-backtick goes between windows of a single team.

I gather that there are some Mac apps or extensions or something that let you gather windows of _any_ app into tabs, so you could likely use one of those here to get tabs instead of windows.

Supposedly Chrome is getting rid of support for Chrome Apps, I think that's what these things are called (?). If so, I'm going to be impacted when it finally goes away.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by Ozzie_osman on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:09AM (#28918920)
Slack has a history button. It's not perfect but it does the basics of what you describe https://www.howtogeek.com/668154/how-to-quickly-access-your-...
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by _jal on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:56PM (#28921224)
I encourage people to move to email. I know people hate it, but I'm serious.

Threading suddenly works in a non-stupid way, search suddenly works, and you can manage your own windows.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by nadagast on Thursday October 28, 2021 @08:05PM (#29033667)
We're working on task management + email, I kept your comment [1] from awhile ago. I don't see any way to contact you in your profile, are you interested in trying an alpha? Email me at garrett at twobird.com

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23693582

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by boredumb on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:59AM (#28918783)
I have the same problem and honestly just a 'recently used channel' history would solve it easily.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by lewisjoe on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:26AM (#28919157)
pg has an excellent essay on how to fine niches or startup ideas in general.

My thumbrule: 1. Pick a market that already has money-making companies. If you can beat them by price & quality, even after considering the first-mover advantage - go for it.

2. [From pg's essay] Just experiene more in life, with different people facing different kinds of problems from different sectors. That's a sure shot way to eventually run into a market with less competition.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by GGfpc on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:25PM (#28920788)
Can you link the essay? Or even expand on what is pg?
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by pramodbiligiri on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:57PM (#28926584)
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:31PM (#28920887)
pg == one of the founders of YC.

http://www.paulgraham.com/articles.html

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by hugs on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:35AM (#28918540)
I used to be a "9-5 engineer in a big company". But I always loved playing with robots. It took me years to a) learn how to build robots (started as a self-taught weekend hobby), and b) find companies that want to buy robots I can make. Now my niche is making and selling robots to companies. (My specific niche is shoebox-sized robots for testing/automating touchscreen devices.) The "niche eureka moment" was when I realized the "hardware testing with robots" niche was very similar to my existing "software test automation" 9-5 big company job skill set (modulo electronics+mechanical skills).

Unfortunately, my discovery and learning process also involved a good amount of luck and trying to describe it feels a lot like step #2 in the "How to draw an owl" meme. At some point, luck and hard work is involved, and there is no obvious playbook for your next step.

However, if there is a chiton of money to be made in Excel add-ins for amputee ballerinas, and you know how to make add-ins, and you know how to find and talk to amputee ballerinas, it might not be a bad career move, though...

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by foogazi on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:21AM (#28919069)
> what if I am a…

Why does advice have to apply to every scenario ?

What if you are a paraguayan field worker and this is not actionable for you ?

Anyways, I’d suggest you talk to others around you and see if you spot the pain points in their day

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by artemonster on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:29AM (#28919199)
>Anyways, I’d suggest you talk to others around you and see if you spot the pain points in their day

This is not a predictable tactic that would yield a viable SaaS idea, this is a gamble "go dive into the ocean, maybe you will find treasure"

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by lazide on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:49PM (#28935359)
If there IS no predictable tactic, and anything is going to depend on the skills, connections, and approach you bring to the job, then saying 'go dive in the ocean' will at least help someone find treasure, compared to saying nothing, or something so vague no one could be sure if it even applied?

It's up to the recipient if they find it useful or not.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by panorama on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:14PM (#28920627)
This tactic is exactly how I found our idea.

Of course you won't strike gold on the first person you talk to. Be smart about it, talk to people who work in an industry you would like to serve (doctors, lawyers, marketers, mechanics, etc.) and figure out the inefficiencies in their day to day life. It's not as hard as you've made it out to be.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by dinkleberg on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @01:49PM (#28921138)
There is no predictability in starting a business. If we could easily predict the idea for the next big unicorn everyone would be going in on it.

Starting a business is a gamble. If you don’t have some risk tolerance, starting a startup is not the right path.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by paxys on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @02:56PM (#28922007)
There is no "predictable tactic" for being a successful entrepreneur.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by yibg on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @02:42PM (#28921780)
Are you expecting a predictable formula for starting a successful business?
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by lazide on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:49PM (#28935367)
There are some folks selling some, only $499.95 up front, hah.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by ozim on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @02:59PM (#28922073)
By going to product hunt and making exact copy of something.

By lurking on HN and making a copy of one of "Show HN".

Just pick something that seems interesting for you.

Spend 2-3 years building it and marketing and if it works well you have it. If it does not work, start over again.

Unless you want a sure money making product - then stick to your 9-5 job that is money making product you have for sure.

Which is also like "find people that want something and build it for them" because that will be your next 9-5 job then.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by halfmatthalfcat on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:08AM (#28918907)
You listen to people around you either in the same or different industry. Finding an idea is a lot more about listening then it is you coming up with something.

Most of my projects have come from just listening to friends or families on their pain points (either in their jobs or life), evaluating the market around those problems and then taking action if it's a good idea.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by yibg on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @02:36PM (#28921702)
Then maybe you shouldn't do a startup? Not everyone can and should do a startup, lack of a good idea is probably a good reason.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by beaconstudios on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:13AM (#28918279)
yeah, the "find a niche" advice falls flat without an addendum entitled "how to find a niche". I think fundamentally it comes from talking to people rather than theorising in a bubble, but unless you're already talking to people it's tricky to know how to begin.
Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by lewisjoe on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:26AM (#28919152)
pg has an excellent essay on how to fine niches or startup ideas in general.

My thumbrule: 1. Pick a market that already has money-making companies. If you can beat them by price & quality, even after considering the first-mover advantage - go for it.

2. [From pg's essay] Just experiene more in life, with different people facing different kinds of problems from different sectors. That's a sure shot way to eventually run into a market with less competition.

Re:How to Create a SaaS and Compete with the Big Players as ... by MangoCoffee on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:46AM (#28918650)
>find a niche

i don't believe it have to be a niche. lets look at Zoom, its in a saturated market with a lot of established products that already have all the Zoom's functions built in but hide under complex UI that no one know how it work or its there.