News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by mateuszf on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @05:26AM (#28850058)
They're not healing bitcoin addiction but trading addiction. You can just buy bitcoin and hold it as store of value / investment.

That's a significant difference. And a misleading title IMO.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by enlyth on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @05:30AM (#28850076)
That is literally in the first sentence on the website: "Castle Craig Hospital provides treatment for people addicted to trading, spread betting and the trading of cryptocurrencies..."
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by mateuszf on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @05:31AM (#28850085)
I'm talking about HN title. The real problem here is trading addiction, not bitcoin itself.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by samhw on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:18AM (#28850375)
This is a bit like saying "The real problem is drug addiction, not heroin. Heroin just seems to be especially good at causing drug addiction."

Edit: I'm not going to respond to the replies. I'm just going to add that I used to be a heroin addict, and the replies are classic addict: semi-coherent, indulging in the "ordinary people are just the same as us" trope, moving the blame to other things (with drug addicts it's very often alcohol, with bitcoin addicts it's apparently fiat money). None of them engaging with the point in the context of the argument - just warding off any perceived challenge to their addiction.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by mateuszf on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:58AM (#28850643)
So why don't we say the same about trading gold, currencies or stocks?

Curing addiction of stocks, gold or currencies sounds as stupid as curing addiction of bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by brianwawok on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:10AM (#28851617)
I see no difference in day trading stocks, bitcoin, or forex. If you buy with the intent to "beat the market" and hold for less than a month-year, I see it as the same as going to the casino and playing a slot machine.

There are people sophisticated enough to have an edge in stock trading. Same for being a professional poker player. But this is a very very small % of the market.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by mateuszf on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:26AM (#28851789)
I also see no difference. What I meant is that the "trading" part is the problem, not a specific asset.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by pjc50 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:03PM (#28853919)
I'm old enough to remember the 2000-era of day traders, just as the internet took off and it was possible to enjoy the thrill of staring at a ticker from your own home. There was enough chaos that a minimum stake rule was made; https://www.finra.org/investors/learn-to-invest/advanced-inv...

And the seminal paper on the subject: http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/behfin/2004-04-10/barber-l...

8/10 day traders in their survey lost money. But there were a few that made returns that not only beat the market but the transaction costs.

(I wonder how that's affected by fee-less trading, which instead tends to make money on PFOF and may have larger spreads)

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by Chris2048 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:00AM (#28851517)
But the OP stated:

> You can just buy bitcoin and hold it as store of value / investment

I'm not sure there's a similar casual use for Heroin. Talk about Cannabis and the sentence starts making sense again.

Also, accusing responses of being semi-coherent, indulging and defensive (and implying responders are addicts to boot) isn't really acting in good faith, even if you don't intend to respond. In fact, especially since you don't intend to respond.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by mang0tang00 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:40AM (#28850530)
This is a bit like saying "The real problem is drug addiction, not chemistry. Chemistry just seems to be especially good at causing drug addiction."
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by herbst on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:44AM (#28850552)
That's true tho, isn't it? Heroin also helped millions of people against pain without getting everyone addicted before we found better opiods for daily use. There are also people using heroin as party drug without high risk of addiction (even thought that may not be a lot)
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by DonHopkins on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:10AM (#28850317)
Easy there big fellow. Bitcoin itself is certainly and undenyably a huge problem in and of itself, as you well know. Its horrible environmental impact is a huge problem, as are its effects on the mental health of the people who go online and shill it and rationalize it while ignoring and denying and marginalizing its environmental impact.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by bluecalm on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @08:38AM (#28851353)
I think focusing on environment when it comes to cryptocurrencies is not very productive. We waste a lot of energy and if cryptocurrencies could live up to their promise maybe the energy cost is worth it.

The main point against them is that the only use case they have is going around financial regulations. Buy drugs, transfer money to a gambling site, accept a ransom or go around capital flow regulations in your country. There is absolutely zero reason to use it otherwise. Some of those regulations might be unjust or bad but then we should address that. This is even before we enter more imaginative scam attempts based on popular blockchains.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by awrence on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:18AM (#28850379)
Easy there big fellow. The petrodollar is certainly and undenyably a huge problem in and of itself, as you well know. Its horrible environmental impact is a huge problem, as are its effects on the mental health of the people who go online and shill it and rationalize it while ignoring and denying and marginalizing its environmental impact.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by pjc50 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:54AM (#28850617)
> The petrodollar is certainly and undenyably a huge problem in and of itself, as you well know. Its horrible environmental impact is a huge problem

This isn't wrong, but this is also not an argument for bitcoin, it's an argument for Keynes' "bancor".

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by awrence on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @07:03AM (#28850694)
I agree it's not an argument for bitcoin. Whether bitcoin is a net positive environmentally or not is a different debate. I was just emphasizing how people point fingers at Proof of Work without considering the immense negative environmental externalities generated by the current fiat system.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by undenyable on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @11:33AM (#28853478)
> undenyably

People still own phones without spellcheck?

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by mlang23 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:31AM (#28850477)
This finger pointing style of saving the planet feels so extremely juvenile, its no longer funny. Yes, bitcoin uses a lot of energy. But so does artificial snow. Or gaming for that matter. What would we see if we add up all gamers on the planet? All the VR and AR nonsense that is being developed and sold? We have chips, we have electricity. You will not regulate what people are going with these chips and that electricity. And wanting to do so makes you look pretty foolish.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by DonHopkins on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:58AM (#28850641)
And what you and awrence wrote is precisely what I meant by how Bitcoin shills and addicts ignore and deny and marginalize and whataboutify its environmental impact. Thank you two for such an unwittingly perfect and prompt illustration of my point.

Artificial snow doesn't cause shilling and gambling addiction, and HN isn't plagued by thousands of foaming-at-the-mouth Artificial Snow Shills who leap to its defense with rationalizations and excuses and whataboutisms and diversions like you and awrence just leaped to Bitcoin's defense.

awrence> I was just emphasizing how people point fingers at Proof of Work without considering the immense negative environmental externalities generated by the current fiat system.

No you weren't. Your comment didn't mention anything about Proof of Work or the current fiat system. We can all agree that it was pure unadulterated whataboutism, which proves my point (edit: as does your following reply. You even admitted yourself that what you wrote wasn't an argument for Bitcoin. It's pure whataboutism!). Thank you.

awrence> Whether bitcoin is a net positive environmentally or not is a different debate.

That debate is long over, and you already lost it. But you're trying to divert the conversation away from that debate you can't win, instead of offering any proof of your ridiculous theory that bitcoin is a net positive environmentally, because you and I and everyone else all know that bitcoin has a terribly negative environmental impact, and very few practical applications.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by Chris2048 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:10AM (#28851619)
Even if true, I don't think calling another poster a shill (or addict) is a good tone - you could have just countered all those points without the smug "Thank you for unwittingly proving my point.";

> When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by awrence on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @07:22AM (#28850829)
You made a straight up declaration about proof of work in a pretty condescending and unsubstantiated way. I literally applied your exact framing and wording to present that approach from my point of view, and you hated that version of exactly your text. I could reply it proves the exact same point about you. I think either of those versions are not helpful to anyone, which is what I was trying to illustrate.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by mlang23 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @02:36AM (#28861177)
Wrong. I am not defending Bitcoin. But I am opposing people like you who think they have some kind of monopoly telling other people what to use their silicon and electricity for. In fact, I couldn't care less about BTC. But I hate private police like you.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by awrence on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:48AM (#28850578)
It also demonstrates a basic lack of understanding of how the energy markets work and how as just about the only intermittent buyer of last resort, proof of work is about to positively impact the energy infrastructure in a pretty substantial way and will probably converge on tapping into exclusively stranded / wasted energy (about 30% of energy production vs less than 0.1% of global production used by pow today). If anyone is genuinely interesting in educating themselves on the topic I'd recommend the two fairly recent episodes of What Bitcoin Did with guest Harry Sudock.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by Majromax on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @08:58AM (#28851502)
> It also demonstrates a basic lack of understanding of how the energy markets work

Which energy markets?

It's not like bitcoin mining is legally or geographically constrained to countries with well-functioning energy markets and a reputation for environmental thinking.

Proof of work schemes could provide a positive marginal return when energy would otherwise be curtailed, but that's just a side effect of being a very price-elastic source of demand. These schemes can just as easily operate with polluting energy made cheap through local political corruption.

For that matter, the freest energy is stolen energy, so mining malware will forever have the edge on that front.

Bitcoin is neither clean nor dirty because it has no governance to make it such. At absolute best it is a neutral energy buyer of last resort, replicating all our political flaws on the world stage.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by pjc50 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:52AM (#28850605)
Bitcoin mining is not a buyer of last resort, it's a capital asset that the owner wants to be run continuously in order to make back the capital expense, and produces no ultimately useful output.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by awrence on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @07:17AM (#28850796)
It's a misconception to think a miner will only locate on energy sites with continuous supply. It can still make perfect sense for a miner to locate on a site with variable demand (which by the way is basically every energy production site in the world that is by design compelled to build to accommodate peak demand). What a miner will do is then negotiate energy costs (which are 80-90% of their variable costs) with the producer who is happy to sell his excess production at any cost above 0 for all excess power untapped. All it takes is enough excess production at a (much lower) price than conventional rates for this to breakeven positively vs full operation alternatives.

As chips commoditize and energy trends towards 100% of all costs, miners will step into these situations exclusively.

As far as your claim that bitcoin is useless that's a personal judgement. My personal judgement is that reintroducing sound fixed supply censorship resistant money to the world is of enormous benefit. But that's beyond the scope here. I don't think it's constructive to make judgements about what people value and chose to expend resources towards. If you have a problem with externalities then have a debate about that. But who are we to judge if someone wants to heat their pool? If they do so through carbon emissions then consider taxing that. The sustainability of the energy production is your issue really, not the energy use.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by lottin on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:44AM (#28851965)
Meanwhile, in the real world, bitcoin miners are buying coal plants to "mine" an imaginary mineral.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/bitcoin-miners-are-giving-new-l...

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by DonHopkins on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:19AM (#28864596)
Wrong. Stop making false excuses and rationalizations and shilling for Bitcoin's Proof of Waste. Bitcoin is China's way of exporting coal through the atmosphere. Bitcoin shills also produce huge quantities of hot air and CO2 by endlessly repeating false claims like "Bitcoin doesn't run on coal".

Why you’re paying Bitcoin’s energy bill:

https://review.chicagobooth.edu/finance/2021/article/why-you...

>The vast computing power needed to create new bitcoins has driven up energy bills for residents and businesses

>Millions of people who have neither mined nor traded a bitcoin are nevertheless paying for bitcoins to exist. That’s because the vast computing power needed to create new bitcoins consumes enormous amounts of electricity and has driven up energy bills for residents and businesses, according to University of California at Berkeley’s Matteo Benetton and Adair Morse and Chicago Booth’s Giovanni Compiani.

HN Discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28863445

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by elliekelly on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:28AM (#28851808)
> What would we see if we add up all gamers on the planet?

A gamer can only run one machine at a time and, as much as they might try, they can’t play 24/7. It wouldn’t even come close to the cost of powering Bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by Chris2048 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:05AM (#28851576)
> What would we see if we add up all gamers on the planet?

I doubt anything significant. Also I thing btc has the potential to explode (wrt usage) in a way gaming doesn't.

> All the VR and AR nonsense that is being developed and sold

^ also niche

> We have chips, we have electricity

mining is notably power intensive, relative to other chips/electricity usages. That said, so is heating, so maybe if miners replace their radiators?: https://news.bitcoin.com/the-crypto-heater-mines-digital-cur...

It's also notable that in developing nations (which are often the most populous) there maybe little appetite for luxuries such as gaming, but plenty of reason to invest in crypto precisely because of lack of faith in government/banking infrastructure.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by xiphias2 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:35AM (#28850497)
I agree, and I’m a long time HODLer, but most men friends of mine can’t handle the emotional roller coaster of just holding (I’m a guy as well). What’s interesting is that my female friends are perfectly capable of doing it…..they invested less money, but their patience easily makes up for investing less money originally.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by Chris2048 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:21AM (#28851744)
How do you know it's higher patience rather than the lower stakes (wrt initial investment)?

Also, I'm not sure I agree with the "HODL" philosophy. btc has fallen a lot too, and the assumption "it'll all work out in the end (long term)" is exactly what can't ever be demonstrated (tomorrow never comes) until it all crashes, after which it's too late.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by xiphias2 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @09:45AM (#28851978)
I’m talking to my friends. A male friend of mine started cocaine really hard when the BTC price crashed, another quarreling with his wife so much that their marriage failed. They are getting really depressed generally, as their self worth as the provider of their family is linked to their wealth.

About the HODL philosophy: I don’t understand any other. I bought for long term (10+ years) as an investment with high risk and high possible reward at $150/BTC. The 10 years haven’t passed yet (only 8), so we can come back to this thread to see if HODL works out or not.

Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by DonHopkins on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:04AM (#28850283)
They're also treating Bitcoin Shilling and Hyping and Rationalization and Excuse Making Addiction.
Re:Bitcoin Addiction Hospital by headmelted on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:01AM (#28850261)
You mis-spelled speculative tokens.