News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by yboris on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:15PM (#28830588)
Alex Tabarrok's Marginal Revolution write up on this:

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/10/th...

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by nabla9 on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:20PM (#28830642)
People familiar with statistics or data science may be familiar with the work of Angrist and Imbens. They developed 2SLS and CACE/LATE.

Check out Angrist's book: "Mastering 'Metrics: The Path from Cause to Effect" https://press.princeton.edu/books/ebook/9781400852383/master... https://www.masteringmetrics.com/

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by petters on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:26PM (#28830704)
Judea Pearl writes about these news: https://twitter.com/yudapearl/status/1447596402670903304?t=X...

Edit: downvotes suggest some context may be needed. Pearl win the Turing award for casual inference but has been critical of the current Nobel recipients' methods.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by tenkabuto on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:33PM (#28831374)
I'm curious to know what he means by that their work

> overlook[s] the two Fundamental Laws of causal inference.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by sjg007 on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:20PM (#28833744)
The two things that have to hold are:

1. The law of Counterfactuals and 2. The Law of Conditional Independence

You can find preprints from Pearl online or even some presentations that cover these definitions. His books as well.

I don't know how this applies to the work by the economists. I think Gelman at Columbia talks about Pearl and SCMs and the whole thing.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by originalvichy on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:07PM (#28832441)
That birthdate difference sounds like the difference in NHL kids' success that's based on how early in the year you were born. Statistically the earlier born kids get more mass and muscle and get moved to better teams faster.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by gbronner on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:25PM (#28830684)
So sad about Alan Krueger.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Godel_unicode on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:41PM (#28830854)
For those not in the know on econ research (like me!) I believe this comment refers to the fact that Alan Krueger was deeply involved in this work, but that the Nobel committee only honors living scientists.

https://www.jstor.org/stable/2118030

[dead]
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by dang on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:42PM (#28832175)
"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by legitster on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:17PM (#28830613)
You should actually read up on some of the work of some of these prize winning economists - lots of them actually have very insightful and useful contributions to society.

I cannot recommend enough the book "Who Gets What and Why" by Alvin Roth, a former Nobel Prize winner. Among other things, he created the world's first successful Kidney exchange program for donors. The book eloquently lays out how to design functional markets of exchange when money is not a resource available.

His work is easy to understand, eloquent, and literally saves lives. This is exactly the kind of thing worth celebrating.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by ncann on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:04PM (#28830480)
You expressed your opinion in a rather rugged way but I think many people share the same general sentiment, in that unlike physics or chemistry, economic and literature works are highly subjective and are often source of endless bickering.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by jjeaff on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:46AM (#28836159)
I think you should do a little research on the contributions of some of the Nobel laureates in economics. They have used novel economic theory to reduce world hunger, reduce childhood mortality by increasing vaccination rates, come up with clever methods to allocate public goods like the frequency spectrum and that's just the last 3 years.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by throwaway59553 on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:32PM (#28830764)
The reason why I put economists in quoatation mark it's precisely because most modern economists, that lean to any school, hammer their models to fit their theories, and have pretty much no practical value when you try to apply that in a real scenario with infinite variables. Unlike the hard sciences you mentioned, where every theory and model is subjected to intense scrutiny.

Meanwhile, real economists, with a proven track record: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_School_(economics)

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Mikeb85 on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:38PM (#28830815)
Economists in the public sphere are a fraction of practising economists and are often bought and paid for to push narratives. Or, as you said, hammer their models to fit their theories.

Economics as a field though does create good models and predictions, but most of those are in the private sector, where money matters and weeds out faulty models.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by jmeister on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:01PM (#28830439)
“The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else.

Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influences, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist. Madmen in authority, who hear voices in the air, are distilling their frenzy from some academic scribbler of a few years back.” — J M Keynes

http://www.equitablegrowth.org/the-general-theory-of-employm...

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by sudosysgen on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:15PM (#28830581)
I agree that economists have a lot of value as political philosophers. But that's largely not how economics operates nowadays, the field is mostly trying to operate as a hard science.
[dead]
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by legitster on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:02PM (#28830450)
But the award and prize are today managed by the same governing body?

This seems incredibly nitpicky. We wouldn't say a Harvard degree in physics is not a real Harvard degree just because it wasn't offered by John Harvard himself.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by svachalek on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:16PM (#28830600)
It seems like that governing body should get to decide what it's called, and while this distinction is news to me it appears that they indeed do not call it a Nobel Prize.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by gojomo on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:52PM (#28830977)
The Foundation uses the longer name when being formal, but regularly includes the Economics Prize as a 'Nobel Prize' in headers & lists - such as their top-level menu 'Nobel Prizes' (which includes the 'Prize in Economic Sciences'), and their master list of 'Nobel Prize laureates'.

So headlines calling it a 'Nobel' match the Nobel Foundation's usage in similar summary/header contexts.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by oldgradstudent on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:54PM (#28831623)
But that's the name of the prize: Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel. Call it by its name.

The prize in Physics is the "Nobel Prize if Physics", and so are the other ones. The difference is intentional.

A self-respecting discipline starts its own prize instead of buying legitimacy.

Computer Science has the Turing Award, not the ACM Prize in Computer Science in Memory of Alfred Nobel.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by styren on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:04PM (#28830481)
If I create a school called "The University in Harvards Honor" and give myself a diploma, am I a Harvard alumni?
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by lowkey_ on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:07PM (#28830510)
Well this link is on nobelprize.org, the website of the official organization in charge of the Nobel Prize Committee.

Thus, it's more like the comment you were replying to — creating a new degree program within Harvard University that John Harvard didn't authorize.

Your analogy would be more accurate if this were not in fact created, endorsed, and run by the Nobel Foundation.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by styren on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:12PM (#28830565)
You're right, but it was endorsed as a prize in his honor, not as a Nobel Prize with all that entails. Therefore it's incorrect to call it such. It's never called (or at least very seldomly) a Nobel Prize in Sweden as that isn't true.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Godel_unicode on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:45PM (#28830892)
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by legitster on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:06PM (#28830493)
The Nobel Memorial Prize is still administered by the Nobel Foundation. This isn't a made up connection.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by mhh__ on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:07PM (#28830504)
If Harvard decided to give it to you, then maybe?
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by koziserek on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:13PM (#28830566)
well it somewhat works for some Oxford Brookes grads ;)
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by shapefrog on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:15PM (#28830587)
Ah a fellow Oxford alumni, which college were you in old sport?

Umm Brookes

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by nabla9 on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:21PM (#28830651)
It's irrelevant historical detail.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by tuberelay on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:43PM (#28830881)
There are big questions about the amount of gravitas that mainstream economists are afforded by people in power.

Misnaming the econ prize as a "Nobel" prize and placing it's winners on the level of great physicists, chemists etc risks in exacerbating this problem.

Much of the research done by econ memorial prize winners is walked back or proven false later. It isn't hard science. Much of it is politically driven and advice and practitioners are used by politicians to justify certain actions, many of them dysfunctional or corrupt.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by gojomo on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:06PM (#28831103)
What Nobel-in-Economics work has been retracted?

A Nobel-in-Chemistry went to an enthusiastic creator of chlorine gas chemical weapons (Haber). A Nobel-in-Medicine went to the inventor of the lobotomy (Moniz). Another Nobel-in-Medicine was awarded for false research about roundworms-causing-cancer (Fibiger). A Nobel-in-Peace went to the architect of secret carpet bombing that likely killed over 100,000 civilians in a non-combatant country (Kissinger).

The Econ prize's shorter, more modern history has a better record!

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by nabla9 on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:47PM (#28830917)
In quality metrics Econ Nobel is way ahead of literature and peace Nobel's.

> Much of the research done by econ memorial prize winners is walked back or proven false later. It isn't hard science.

This is not just true. Econ price almost always well earned, like now. Maybe there is some, but I can't think anyone who don't deserve it.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by gojomo on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:10PM (#28830542)
If the Economics prize is OK with the Nobel Foundation, which administers the prize along with the others, that should be good enough.

(Did you know that the "MacArthur Fellows" – sometimes called "Genius Grants" – were also invented by the board of the MacArthur Foundation after John MacArthur's death?)

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by nsajko on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:03PM (#28831728)
Absolutely.

The current title ("Nobel Prize for Economics") is simply false. The official name is "The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 2021", which can be shortened to "Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences".

Note that this is meaningfully and on purpose unlike the Physics or Chemistry prize situation.

What's more, even the current name is controversial, seeing as it misappropriates the Nobel name with the goal of elevating the social status of some economists. Peter Nobel, for one, seems to be furious about it, and it definitely isn't done according to the wishes of Alfred Nobel.

Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Memorial_Prize_in_Econom... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Prize_controversies#Econ...

Also see Monocasa's comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28830961

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by TomVDB on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:41PM (#28830850)
When 1999 rolls over into 2000, you’re going to be telling everyone that we should be celebrating 2000 rolling into 2001 instead, right?
[dead]
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by mjw1007 on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:43PM (#28830882)
I like to imagine the following conversation taking place around 1968:

"There are some things money can't buy."

"Like what?"

"A Nobel prize, for example."

"We'll see about that."

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by AnimalMuppet on Monday October 11, 2021 @12:56PM (#28830385)
Which, for shortness, we call the Nobel Prize in Economics.

When someone says "North Korea", do you inform them that the correct title is "The Democratic People's Republic of Korea"?

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by cpach on Monday October 11, 2021 @12:58PM (#28830394)
Another option is to call it The Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by nsajko on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:07PM (#28831774)
What if someone just says "Korea"? Seems like a better comparison.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by YorkshireSeason on Monday October 11, 2021 @12:59PM (#28830410)
When someone says "The Democratic People's Republic of Korea", you don't inform them that the North Korea is not a democracy?
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by styren on Monday October 11, 2021 @12:59PM (#28830418)
The prize wasn't conceived by Alfred Nobel nor endorsed by him. Can I come up with my own computer science award and name it a Nobel Prize as well?
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by beebmam on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:04PM (#28830479)
The Nobel Prize committee could, if they wanted
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by styren on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:07PM (#28830514)
Well they didn't for the Economics prize, the Swedish Riksbank asked the Nobel family for approval for an award in his honor, which they approved.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by AnimalMuppet on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:25PM (#28830692)
So there's your answer. If you can get the Nobel family to approve your award that is in his honor, then yes, you can.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by monocasa on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:51PM (#28830961)
The family actually protested pretty much immediately, not knowing that Sveriges Riksbank was trying to make another Nobel. That's why the name 'Nobel' was stripped from the prize in 1971 while it was working it's way through the court system.

So no, the Nobel family isn't going to approve another because they didn't really approve of this one and aren't likely to sign anything anymore that's trying to sneak one in.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by styren on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:38PM (#28830819)
If the Nobel Foundation endorses a prize in his honor, then you can call it a prize in his honor, that doesn't mean you can call it a Nobel Prize. No Swede, nor any reputable newspaper or the Nobel Foundation would ever call it a Nobel Prize since it has never been recognized as one by the foundation, why would we call it that on HN?
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by mindcrime on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:44PM (#28830883)
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by legitster on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:08PM (#28830518)
He likely would have endorsed it - it was a field that did not really exist at the time but did fit in well with Nobel's other awards and his person legacy.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by gojomo on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:18PM (#28830621)
A better title might name either the honored area-of-work, or the honorees. EG:

"2021 Economics Nobel: Natural experiments help answer important questions" (an in-page header)

...or...

"2021 Economics Nobel: Card, Angrist, & Imbens"

...or even if it fits...

"2021 Economics Nobel to Card, Angrist, & Imbens for natural experiments"

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Mikeb85 on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:48PM (#28830934)
Gotta love it when the prize document itself highlights the pitfalls of the methodology used by the winners...

> Despite the enormous increase in labour supply, Card found no negative effects for Miami residents with low levels of education. Wages did not fall and unemployment did not increase relative to the other cities.

> while people who immigrated at an earlier time are negatively affected. One explanation for this is that the natives switch to jobs that require good native language skills, and where they do not have to compete with immigrants for jobs.

If this isn't terrible methodology I don't know what is.

Literally using bad data to say immigration doesn't affect the labour market, then saying it does for same-language jobs. So it obviously does but language is a barrier to entry for some jobs. Literally invalidates the first point.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by shkkmo on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:18PM (#28831215)
I don't understand how this is bad data? It seems to me that you are asserting a claim "immigration doesn't effect the labor market" that was never made.

> Card found no negative effects for Miami residents with low levels of education. Wages did not fall and unemployment did not increase relative to the other cities.

Additionally, the claims about specific types of effects on the labour market that you quote were from follow up studies and also don't conflict with the results of the earlier study.

Low-income residents on average, had no negative effects but follow up studies split up that low income group and found that one subgroup benefits and another subgroup suffers.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Mikeb85 on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:39PM (#28831440)
Edit:

The line above the first I quoted: > Despite the enormous increase in labour supply, Card found no negative effects for Miami residents with low levels of education.

Then a few lines down (my first post), it said there were negative effects for previous immigrants with low levels of education. They made the assertion, then disproved it in the same paragraph, supposedly this is a highlight of the award?

It literally says an increase in immigration negatively affects the labour market for previous immigrants/workers who speak the same language. This != no negative effect...

The previous conclusion ignores a bunch of other factors.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by shkkmo on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:21PM (#28831949)
I still fail to see how this is "bad data"?

You seem to be asserting that you can't make a statistical claim about a larger group unless that claim applies to every single possible subgroup? That is a rather ridiculous standard that would invalidate pretty much every single statistical claim ever made...

> The previous conclusion ignores a bunch of other factors.

Which ones?

Edit: You significantly edited your comment during my response. My response to your edits follows:

> They made the assertion, then disproved it in the same paragraph, supposedly this is a highlight of the award?

There is nothing disproving the original claim. The follow up studies performed more detailed analysis that looked at effects on subgroups to increase our understanding of the effects of immigration beyond what the original study found. This is a highlight because the original study was valuable not just for its results but for the methedology that facilitated a bunch of further research.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Mikeb85 on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:06PM (#28832431)
Go back to what's in the article:

> To examine how this huge influx of workers affected the labour market in Miami, David Card compared the wage and employment trends in Miami with the evolution of wages and employment in four comparison cities.

> Despite the enormous increase in labour supply, Card found no negative effects for Miami residents with low levels of education. Wages did not fall and unemployment did not increase relative to the other cities. This study generated large amounts of new empirical work, and we now have a better understanding of the effects of immigration.

Look at the conclusion: "Card found NO negative effects for Miami residents with low levels of education." NO negative effects is quite the statement.

Now, the follow up studies:

> or example, follow-up studies have shown that increased immigration has a positive effect on income for many groups who were born in the country, while people who immigrated at an earlier time are negatively affected. One explanation for this is that the natives switch to jobs that require good native language skills, and where they do not have to compete with immigrants for jobs.

Now that's a negative effect. He made the assertion of NO negative effects.

In second year economics my prof would have failed me for such a basic conclusion. Look at influx of people, compare unemployment rates to other cities, make conclusion from that.

When immigration happens there's things happening on both sides of the supply/demand curve. Immigrants bring money, they also are labour. Different groups bring varying amounts of supply/demand. They compete for various jobs depending on their level of education (including language). There's also undocumented employment.

Anyhow, there's no mention of the wealth of the immigrants (often western nations are recipients of capital flight), no mention of aggregate demand, it says wages didn't fall but no mention of inflation and wage growth (ie. real wages), etc...

And if a study is so easily invalidated (sorry, elaborated upon), what's the point? Anyhow, it stuck out to me because it's an oft-cited study despite being incredibly basic and flawed (and many studies since more or less disproving it).

Anyhow, it's bad data (well, bad methodology from start to finish) because it draws a conclusion based on correlation between immigration and unemployment/wages without considering a ton of factors in between. It's like taking a chart of AAPL, GOOG, saying one depends on the other because they both go up during the same timeframe, ignoring everything else that's happening in the economy and tech industry.

Edit - it should also be mentioned, that literally the last ~5 or so years of politics in the west have centred around inequality, the plight of uneducated workers in the western world, globalism's effect of living conditions in the western world, etc... Populism on both the left and right is a thing because of it. It's pretty clear that a significant segment is being left behind. Wage stagnation IS a thing, and we know it because there's a lot of hindsight in the last 30 years. And Covid exacerbated inequality, with educated workers increasing their net worth drastically while lockdowns wreaked havoc on large segments of the economy. The cited study says absolutely nothing about the labour market, except that in one time and place, unemployment and wages didn't go down.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by huitzitziltzin on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:29PM (#28833328)
>> In second year economics my prof would have failed me for such a basic conclusion.

This is a hilarious comment. You are saying that your economics professor would have failed you for making a claim akin to what one of these three Economics Nobel laureates claimed in a very well known, classic article in the labor literature? I'm an economics professor and I would be delighted to see work like this from an undergrad!

>> Now that's a negative effect. He made the assertion of NO negative effects.

What you and later studies have identified is that there may be heterogeneous causal effects across groups. There is a large literature on this topic!

>> if a study is so easily invalidated...

I'm not worried about this. You have not "invalidated" this study with five minutes of thinking!

>>> it's bad data (well, bad methodology from start to finish) because it draws a conclusion based on correlation between immigration and unemployment/wages

1. It is not bad methodology. That is literally what half of the prize which went to Imbens and Angrist is about. This is a methodology which permits making causal claims in the absence of an experiment!

2. It is not drawing a conclusion based on a correlation.

For more information about what they actually did and how it works (and this is a big interesting topic!) you might benefit from the Nobel Foundation's scientific background paper on this prize, here: https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2021/10/advanced-economic...

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Mikeb85 on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:32PM (#28833836)
So an appeal to authority? The same organization that thought a US President that destabilized the middle east and assassinated people via drones deserved the Nobel Peace prize?
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by huitzitziltzin on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:35PM (#28834652)
I'm not sure what point you are trying to make, but you may be under some misapprehension about how the prizes are awarded.

The Nobel Peace Prize is awarded by the Nobel Peace Prize Committee, which is appointed by the Norwegian Parliament. They decided Obama was worthy.

The Nobel Prize in Economics (or, as everyone is fond of pointing out: "the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Science in Honor of Alfred Nobel") is awarded by the central bank of Sweden.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by shkkmo on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:11PM (#28834549)
As far as I am aware, the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has no involvement in the selection of the recipient of the Nobel Peace prize.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by shkkmo on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:26PM (#28833789)
> It's like taking a chart of AAPL, GOOG, saying one depends on the other because they both go up during the same timeframe, ignoring everything else that's happening in the economy and tech industry.

That's funny because the reason these researchers are so lauded is precisely because they found novel methodologies to avoid doing exactly the sort of purely correlative analysis that you describe.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Mikeb85 on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:33PM (#28833839)
Read the whole paper or at least article. This year's prize is laughable compared to everything else that's happened in economics in the last decade.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by huitzitziltzin on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:29PM (#28834637)
To put it extremely, extremely politely this is a minority opinion in the economics profession. (More accurate would be to say no one thinks this.)

I don't do reduced-form causal inference work myself, but I recognize that it is widespread and extremely influential throughout the profession.

You can of course argue that someone else should have received the prize. My own preferred candidates did not win. But this work was going to win eventually for sure and to argue that there's a lot of work from the last decade which deserved to win is not credible.

Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by imtringued on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:03PM (#28834095)
Every human has needs and desires that translate into demand for work. Immigration not only supplies more work it also results in more demand for work. You earn $15 per hour and you spend it all. People trade their time because they want other people's time. Nobody is really worse off here. If employers abuse their power to pay the immigrants less then the surplus ends up with the employer. It's the employers turn to spent all his money. If he doesn't there won't be any opportunities for regular citizens.
Re:2021 Nobel Prize for Economics by Mikeb85 on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:00PM (#28834480)
There's definitely negative externalities.

The original nation of the immigrant loses workers and consumers. Some workers in the host nation lost bargaining power. There's lost efficiency as the newly arrived immigrants generally accept a worse job than they had back home (see all the immigrants with degrees working menial jobs).

Free movement is a great idea, but it's essentially colonialism version 2. We take the best and brightest from developing nations and make them servants.