In the article, it’s also mentioned that Hippocrates recommended using gold, and many of his teachings were still followed in Byzantine times.
So what’s your next theory? Gold sounds fairly plausible to me.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catgut_suture#History:
> Gut strings were being used as medical sutures as early as the 3rd century AD as Galen, a prominent Greek physician from the Roman Empire, is known to have used them.[4]
It couldn't be an organic suture, unless it was supposed to last very little (on wiki it says 90 days). Also only something study like a metal could hold a bone in place reliably, I imagine.
The assumption that it had to last X amount of time is questionable.
The other point I'm less certain of is that the discovery was based on dental calculus... I suspect that this wouldn't have been so pronounced if the thread was replaced frequently.
"In one of the dentitions, I saw that the tooth was filed a little bit so that the knot that was tied in the wire would not scratch the cheek," Agelarakis said. "It's very sophisticated — it's flabbergasting."
I have no idea either way, and in fact the researcher may have even been extrapolating too far in this case as well.As for a metal, silver would have been a better choice than gold for both mechanical and anti-infective reasons.
Now we can easily claim it could have been silver or copper, no real proof required.
I'm not trying to pretend I have a better theory. I'm only trying to point out that our knowledge of what actually happened is limited and the article could be better written.
I don't know why people here seem to have an issue with those criticisms. (shrug)
Why don't people like your criticism? Maybe because you're trying to position yourself as smarter than the experts, but with ideas that take 30 seconds research to prove unfeasible.
I used the word chelation as a convenience, shorthand for "some means to remove metals from the system."
I'm not positioning myself as smarter than any experts. I'm positioning myself as critical of the flaws in the article.
>Now we can easily claim it could have been silver or copper, no real proof required.
Nobody is claiming anything has been proved. It's just a theory.
I'm hardly the only person here making that point. I don't know why it's getting so much push back. The article itself makes it clear they don't actually know, but then wants to talk as if the conclusion is certain. It's absolutely not.
So it's not a big leap that medical staff at that time were experimenting with sutures.
Only in the territories of the former Roman empire. Usage of obsidian blades has been recorded elsewhere in the world in the intervening time.
So I could well imagine ancients doing things that would count as "plastic surgery". I rather doubt they "perfected" it, though...
[1] Wikipedia says so, must be true :-) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plastic_surgery
However, the Romans had enough patients over a continuing period of time to perfect plastic surgery.
So I think you're confusing emergency surgery and piercings with the art of plastic surgery.
If you think anatomical knowledge was universal, that's not true either. Japanese doctors were ashamed when they saw the first anatomy book - they had known nothing beforehand.
The US had to dig up bodies from graves at night for decades to draw those books.
"It must have been some kind of gold thread, a gold wire or something like that, as is recommended in the Hippocratic corpus that was compiled in the fifth century B.C.," Agelarakis said. Gold is soft and pliable but strong and nontoxic, he added, making it a good choice for this type of medical treatment."
That's pretty thin evidence, it may just as easily have been sheepguts (used for violin strings, for instance, in spite of being called catgut!).