News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by jacquesm on Friday October 08, 2021 @05:56PM (#28804586)
"The wire is long gone, but Agelarakis suspects it was gold. There was no evidence of a silver alloy, which would have left grayish discoloration, nor were there traces of a patina or greenish cupric acid stains that would have been left by copper or bronze wires, he found.

"It must have been some kind of gold thread, a gold wire or something like that, as is recommended in the Hippocratic corpus that was compiled in the fifth century B.C.," Agelarakis said. Gold is soft and pliable but strong and nontoxic, he added, making it a good choice for this type of medical treatment."

That's pretty thin evidence, it may just as easily have been sheepguts (used for violin strings, for instance, in spite of being called catgut!).

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by cobbzilla on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:01PM (#28804633)
Wouldn’t using dead flesh increase the risk of infection?

In the article, it’s also mentioned that Hippocrates recommended using gold, and many of his teachings were still followed in Byzantine times.

So what’s your next theory? Gold sounds fairly plausible to me.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by tablespoon on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:07PM (#28804691)
I was kind of skeptical too, but then I found this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catgut_suture#History:

> Gut strings were being used as medical sutures as early as the 3rd century AD as Galen, a prominent Greek physician from the Roman Empire, is known to have used them.[4]

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by gnramires on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:28PM (#28804855)
> Catgut suture is a type of surgical suture that is naturally degraded by the body's own proteolytic enzymes

It couldn't be an organic suture, unless it was supposed to last very little (on wiki it says 90 days). Also only something study like a metal could hold a bone in place reliably, I imagine.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by klyrs on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:07PM (#28805665)
90 days would probably be enough for a bone to set. But given that the wiring was threaded between the teeth, the sutures would be subject to the digestive enzymes of the mouth, which are significantly more aggressive than anything outside of the digestive system.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by DoreenMichele on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:03PM (#28806053)
They could have periodically replaced it if it was only wrapped around the teeth. Changing a bandage is a pretty normal part of medical care. Changing the cast periodically is a routine part of modern treatments for club foot in children.

The assumption that it had to last X amount of time is questionable.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by klyrs on Saturday October 09, 2021 @01:00PM (#28811448)
I agree, but another problem with gut is that it stretches under load when moist -- one of the issues with catgut strings on instruments is that they can't hold a tune, and that's much worse on hot & humid days (digression, they sound great though... much like nylon). Gold is also malleable, but can take quite a bit more tension before failure and work-hardens where catgut undergoes plastic deformation.

The other point I'm less certain of is that the discovery was based on dental calculus... I suspect that this wouldn't have been so pronounced if the thread was replaced frequently.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by DoreenMichele on Saturday October 09, 2021 @01:12PM (#28811526)
Thank you for that very informative comment.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by Igelau on Friday October 08, 2021 @10:04PM (#28806359)
To make gut, you have to clean it and stretch it and dry it first. By then it's about as clean as anything was back then.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by jacquesm on Friday October 08, 2021 @10:33PM (#28806498)
Boil it just before use.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by simonh on Saturday October 09, 2021 @03:40AM (#28807830)
That might soften it too much.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by grp000 on Friday October 08, 2021 @11:58PM (#28806932)
They did mention that there were mitigations to prevent the knot tied in the wire from scratching the cheek. Would they have taken similar mitigations for a material like animal guts?

  "In one of the dentitions, I saw that the tooth was filed a little bit so that the knot that was tied in the wire would not scratch the cheek," Agelarakis said. "It's very sophisticated — it's flabbergasting."
I have no idea either way, and in fact the researcher may have even been extrapolating too far in this case as well.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by marginalia_nu on Friday October 08, 2021 @07:25PM (#28805331)
Indeed. Why would the gold vanish? Isn't the property it's most famous for that it's extremely resistant to corrosion and general unreactiveness?
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by robotresearcher on Friday October 08, 2021 @07:29PM (#28805381)
They took the wire wrapped around his teeth off once the bones healed.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by marginalia_nu on Friday October 08, 2021 @07:34PM (#28805422)
Hm, yeah, then it makes sense that there wouldn't be any traces.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by gumby on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:13PM (#28804733)
More likely gut, which was still used well into my lifetime.

As for a metal, silver would have been a better choice than gold for both mechanical and anti-infective reasons.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by nielsbot on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:20PM (#28804803)
Article says they didn't use silver based on the evidence (no discoloration)
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by gumby on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:41PM (#28804956)
I saw that. If there is no residue gold is a good candidate. I merely meant that silver would have been better than gold.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by grosswait on Friday October 08, 2021 @07:14PM (#28805209)
Silver oxidizes readily however. Also more brittle.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by DoreenMichele on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:08PM (#28805672)
Silver, gold and copper are all known to kill germs, which would be a feature in medical uses. If we want to more or less wildly speculate (which the article is essentially doing), then let's guess that chelation was prescribed post surgery to remove the metal residue and this is the explanation for a lack of residue.

Now we can easily claim it could have been silver or copper, no real proof required.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by Talanes on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:21PM (#28805766)
I think it's vastly more likely they used a technique that had been around for at least 1,800 years over one that was going to be invented around 250 years later.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by DoreenMichele on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:35PM (#28805869)
I have no idea if your figures are correct and I'm not entirely sure what you think was invented 250 years later.

I'm not trying to pretend I have a better theory. I'm only trying to point out that our knowledge of what actually happened is limited and the article could be better written.

I don't know why people here seem to have an issue with those criticisms. (shrug)

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by Talanes on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:00PM (#28806038)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chelation_therapy

Why don't people like your criticism? Maybe because you're trying to position yourself as smarter than the experts, but with ideas that take 30 seconds research to prove unfeasible.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by DoreenMichele on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:07PM (#28806083)
Cilantro, coriander and coconut oil all move metals. I see no reason they couldn't have had a known means to remove metal stains from teeth well before we record the officially recognized modern discovery of chelation therapy.

I used the word chelation as a convenience, shorthand for "some means to remove metals from the system."

I'm not positioning myself as smarter than any experts. I'm positioning myself as critical of the flaws in the article.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by simonh on Saturday October 09, 2021 @03:45AM (#28807848)
I think it's that this comes off as being unnecessarily caustic:

>Now we can easily claim it could have been silver or copper, no real proof required.

Nobody is claiming anything has been proved. It's just a theory.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by Talanes on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:26PM (#28806173)
And if you had an example that was attested in the region by that time period, you would have the start of a convincing theory.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by DoreenMichele on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:29PM (#28806184)
You seem to have missed the part where I stated bluntly I'm not pretending to have a better theory. I'm only pointing out that "It was gold" is supposition, not fact.

I'm hardly the only person here making that point. I don't know why it's getting so much push back. The article itself makes it clear they don't actually know, but then wants to talk as if the conclusion is certain. It's absolutely not.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by et2o on Saturday October 09, 2021 @12:03AM (#28806951)
Chromic guy sutures are still used everyday in hospitals across the country in certain surgeries. They dissolve very rapidly.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by mensetmanusman on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:05PM (#28805650)
Silver is not stable and becomes reactive.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by redis_mlc on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:17PM (#28804775)
Romans perfected plastic surgery because of gladiators. (Owners take care of their slaves, which are valuable.) They even used obsidian blades, which reduces scarring. That skill was lost for almost 2,000 years.

So it's not a big leap that medical staff at that time were experimenting with sutures.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by MichaelZuo on Friday October 08, 2021 @06:46PM (#28804995)
‘That skill was lost for almost 2,000 years.’

Only in the territories of the former Roman empire. Usage of obsidian blades has been recorded elsewhere in the world in the intervening time.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by kadoban on Friday October 08, 2021 @07:07PM (#28805141)
I would imagine they meant the skill of plastic surgery, though I'm not sure either way if that's true either. I suspect not, depending on the definition.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by omnicognate on Friday October 08, 2021 @07:29PM (#28805375)
I always vaguely assumed "plastic surgery" had some relation to plastic the material, but it doesn't. It refers to shaping/remodelling of living tissue and the medical use of the term predates the invention of the material [1].

So I could well imagine ancients doing things that would count as "plastic surgery". I rather doubt they "perfected" it, though...

[1] Wikipedia says so, must be true :-) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plastic_surgery

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by Ar-Curunir on Friday October 08, 2021 @10:21PM (#28806442)
I mean various cultures have performed various kinds of cosmetic surgical procedures for centuries; the Romans weren’t even the first to do so
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by redis_mlc on Friday October 08, 2021 @10:38PM (#28806527)
After battle in most countries in the past, you either lived or died as one cohort.

However, the Romans had enough patients over a continuing period of time to perfect plastic surgery.

So I think you're confusing emergency surgery and piercings with the art of plastic surgery.

If you think anatomical knowledge was universal, that's not true either. Japanese doctors were ashamed when they saw the first anatomy book - they had known nothing beforehand.

The US had to dig up bodies from graves at night for decades to draw those books.

Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece by Ar-Curunir on Saturday October 09, 2021 @07:03PM (#28814134)