Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece
by simonh on Saturday October 09, 2021 @03:45AM
(#28807848)
I think it's that this comes off as being unnecessarily caustic:
>Now we can easily claim it could have been silver or copper, no real proof required.
Nobody is claiming anything has been proved. It's just a theory.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece
by Talanes on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:26PM
(#28806173)
And if you had an example that was attested in the region by that time period, you would have the start of a convincing theory.
Re:Byzantine warrior with gold-threaded jaw unearthed in Greece
by DoreenMichele on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:29PM
(#28806184)
You seem to have missed the part where I stated bluntly I'm not pretending to have a better theory. I'm only pointing out that "It was gold" is supposition, not fact.
I'm hardly the only person here making that point. I don't know why it's getting so much push back. The article itself makes it clear they don't actually know, but then wants to talk as if the conclusion is certain. It's absolutely not.
I used the word chelation as a convenience, shorthand for "some means to remove metals from the system."
I'm not positioning myself as smarter than any experts. I'm positioning myself as critical of the flaws in the article.