News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by tw600040 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:05PM (#28762216)
I don't understand which of these accusations are actually breaking the law. They all imply that Facebook isn't being a Good Samaritan, but that isn't actually illegal.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by alfalfasprout on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:28PM (#28762592)
Whether or not anything here is illegal is for the courts to decide. But the hearing is for policymakers. If there's grossly disagreeable and unethical conduct then it's up to policymakers to create new laws or modify existing laws to prevent these things in the future.

This is why hearings like this are important.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by tablespoon on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:54PM (#28763001)
> I don't understand which of these accusations are actually breaking the law.

You misunderstand: this isn't so much about enforcing existing laws, rather it's about advocating for new ones.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by sv123 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:11PM (#28762292)
If everything that Facebook does to maximize profits is legal, but some of it is horrible, then we should write new laws to make the horrible stuff illegal. If Facebook does things that are bad for the world then policymakers should try to make it stop.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by tw600040 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:14PM (#28762338)
By all means. But you can't write laws targeting one company..

For example.- from what is being discussed - "Requiring Facebook to publicly disclose its internal research". -- either make all companies disclose internal research or none of them. You can't just pick and choose.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by oarabbus_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:17PM (#28762402)
Precisely. Passing legislation regulating all social media companies is valid. Targeting a specific company in legislation, in addition to not making sense, will quickly be struck down by courts.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by some_furry on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:21PM (#28762463)
Easy workaround: Any publicly-traded company worth more than $1B in total stock.

Now you aren't targeting Facebook, you're targeting all wealthy corporations.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:23PM (#28762513)
Why should we not also apply these laws to companies worth 100M that are doing the same crap? We gain nothing by finely targetting these laws especially if it allows some facebook-like clone to enter the market and change one minor thing to dodge having the same oversight.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by oarabbus_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:24PM (#28762521)
I mean, sure, then it isn't targeting a specific company. But it baffles me why you'd want to put a Market Cap threshold instead of regulating all social media companies evenly regardless of size. Your "rule" wouldn't have applied to Parler, for example.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by some_furry on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:35PM (#28762689)
We need to be careful with regulations. It's good to regulate giants, but creating barriers to entry that prevent new players from competing with the giants is a bad outcome we need to remain cognizant of.

Maybe $1B is too high. Maybe $1M is too low. Somewhere in the middle is a sweet spot.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:46PM (#28762879)
Why stop at social media? Imagine that 50 years ago, Big Tobacco had to disclose its research. Imagine the same for Big Oil. Wouldn't that have been a good thing?

Now, you can go too far. You don't want to make every tech company disclose their research on, say, improved silicon layout algorithms. But if it involves harm to customers or the public, yes, they should have to disclose it.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by ensignavenger on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @04:23PM (#28765110)
Do you think if all companies are required to disclose such research, that they are still going to conduct it to begin with? If they don't already know the answer, they will just not ask the questions- just like a trial lawyer.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by Qi_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:24PM (#28766502)
A regulation like that has to be examined for the incentives it creates, not just the goal. If companies are forced to disclose research that involves customer or public harm, they will probably just stop doing the research, or fabricate false results. Thus, information is lost rather than disclosed. No companies want to say “our product is harmful to our customers.”
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:22PM (#28762480)
You can, however, closely examine a company[1] and the horrible things they're doing to create sane laws to restrict the whole market. Any anti-facebook law will probably strongly impact twitter and reddit among others - but it still can reasonably affect facebook in the largest manner. If it affects facebook in the largest manner because we all hate facebook then that's a load of horsedung - but it can affect facebook in the largest manner because they're doing all the stuff we don't want anyone to do.

1. (formally "a near monopoly" instead of "a company" - edited for clarity)

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by oarabbus_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:30PM (#28762623)
>closely examine a near monopoly

Facebook is a near monopoly? In what? Ads? They're not even the biggest advertising company, Google is bigger.

"Social media"? There's Twitter, Reddit, Snapchat, Tiktok, Tumblr, Youtube and dozens of others.

Can you clarify what you mean by "near-monopoly" in this context?

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:32PM (#28762640)
I'm sorry - that's the only part of my statement you're going to read? The throw away context at the beginning?

I'll remove the mention of it being a near monopoly since that's really unnecessary for the main statement.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by oarabbus_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:36PM (#28762716)
Well yes, alleging a monopoly implies they are running afoul of anti-trust laws but the whistleblower is alleging FB made false statements to investors. The hearing does not have to do with monopolies/antitrust.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:38PM (#28762748)
Hrm - that's fair. I've adjusted my statement to remove any mention of monopolies.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by angelzen on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:12PM (#28767924)
Not the OP, but I think Facebook is a near monopoly in 'posting vapid selfies for likes' category via Instagram.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by ur-whale on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:36PM (#28764502)
> But you can't write laws targeting one company..

Why not?

And it's certainly been done in the past, see the history of Standard Oil.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by r00fus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:43PM (#28762843)
Government can regulate markets. If Facebook is a monopoly then by regulating the market, you regulate FB.

Thoroughly agree all social media should show more transparency on the kinds of things FB is alleged to be doing.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by stale2002 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:25PM (#28766511)
> You can't just pick and choose.

Actually we can just pick and choose. Targeting the largest actor has the most effect.

Our court system uses subpoenas all the time to get access to important information.

And right now, it seems that facebook has some important information that our lawmakers should know.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by danny_taco on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:15PM (#28762365)
The breaking the law bit comes in the form of an accusation to the SEC that Facebook misled investors by not disclosing that they are in fact not doing everything possible to combat the spread of extremism and radicalization through their platform as they claimed - that they decided to ignore this because it would impact their profits.

Misleading investors is a crime from what I understand, so if found guilty on that account, they did break the law. Now, if they will be found guilty is another matter. Personally I don't think they will even be prosecuted for it.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by tw600040 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:20PM (#28762453)
One can pick and choose statements like this and put tailored spin on it and make any statement a lie. example, Apple says this is the best iPhone ever. False , I like the one with headphone jack better. Are we going to put all statements by all companies to this level of rigor?
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by ARandomerDude on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:08PM (#28763217)
"Best phone" is clearly subjective.

"Doing everything we can" is at least somewhat objective. If a contractor says he's painting your house as well as he can, when he's actually on vacation in Hawaii, that statement is clearly false.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by im3w1l on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @07:00PM (#28766813)
As long as facebook remains online there is a chance that someone, somewhere could post bad opinions. Doing everything they can would therefore mean shutting facebook down. The literal interpretation is ridiculous and no one could believe it. So we have no choice but to interpret it as "doing everything reasonable that they can". But what is reasonable? That is where subjectivity enters.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:30PM (#28762626)
The statements Facebook is being judged on very well may also be too vague for anyone to find real fault - I can't tell if there's anything there to specifically prove that facebook were directly misleading investors while privately chatting about how awesome it is that radicalism drives engagement - if there's a memo to that effect they could be in real trouble.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by sp332 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:13PM (#28763290)
They probably didn't put that in their 10-K though.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by _-david-_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @04:56PM (#28765511)
>they are in fact not doing everything possible to combat the spread of extremism and radicalization through their platform as they claimed

The only way they could claim they are doing everything possible would be by not having a platform or by reviewing every post prior to people seeing it.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by mike00632 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @07:33PM (#28767115)
Bingo. So what's wrong with that? Take what happened in Myanmar for example. The government was using Facebook to commit genocide against the Rohingya people. Facebook could have just turned it off in that country. At some point Facebook should just turn itself off. The leaks allege that insiders at Facebook have more or less argued the exact same thing: turn off or greatly tone down profitable features like groups that are routinely misused.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by bcrosby95 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:08PM (#28762253)
You could have said the same thing about cigarette companies half a century ago.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by dcgudeman on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:33PM (#28762669)
You really think Facebook is the equivalent of Big Tobacco? This moral panic is really reaching a feverish crescendo.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by RosanaAnaDana on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:53PM (#28762979)
That's actually a great analogy.

Years of social media and misinformation resulted in an attempted coup and insurrection earlier this year, the major contributing factors of which are still ongoing. I don't think phillip-morris ever got that far.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by ARandomerDude on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:05PM (#28763160)
While FB no doubt contributed to the Jan 6 riot, it's too simple and tidy to blame it on social media. There is a complex web of factors, including interpretation of the Constitution, view of history, fear of tomorrow if the other side takes over, frustration with a sense of powerlessness, etc.

Frankly, the Jan 6 episode is not all that different from the BLM riots last year, in that their causes are analogous and the sense of powerlessness led to rioting.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by stephencanon on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:48PM (#28763836)
> sense of powerlessness led to rioting

Middle-class and rich white people from politically-advantaged parts of the country, that famously powerless group.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by evnc on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:09PM (#28764142)
I don't mean to defend those who stormed the capitol, who to be clear I don't agree with, but the important thing to note here is sense of powerlessness. These people felt powerless, regardless of whether or not they were in any kind of objective sense, and that feeling motivated their actions.

This is relevant to the current discussion inasmuch as FB (and social media generally) may have contributed to, stoked and fomented said feelings of powerlessness for the sake of engagement / eyeballs / ad clicks.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by stephencanon on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:02PM (#28766250)
I don’t think I believe that they actually feel powerless, though. The right-wing and centrist press spin that narrative, because it’s the only way to justify their actions, but it doesn’t square with reality: people who feel powerless do not violently threaten the workings of government, believing that they will succeed and avoid any negative consequences if they fail. Those are the actions of people who are used to getting their way all day every day, who cannot believe that they won’t get their way again.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by angelzen on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:33PM (#28768109)
I will never forget the exhausted desperation in the voice of a young woman talking to her parents in an undisclosed middle America location: 'there are no jobs'. The words are cliche, I know. Nonetheless I'd recommend taking a few days and visit such a place as opposed to yet another scuba trip in French Polynesia. Won't get as many likes on Instagram, but may give a bit of a perspective. There are vast swaths of this country that are not thriving.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by stephencanon on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:46AM (#28771470)
(a) I live in rural America. (b) That has almost nothing to do with Trump support, despite what the media says. (c) Those are not the people who broke into the capitol. They can’t afford a trip to DC.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by beambot on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:12PM (#28763275)
Except that one of them occurred at the time & place of the major transition of power and actively stormed a congressional session resulting in deaths in a core federal government building. But sure... other than that "not all that different".
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by angelzen on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:17PM (#28767962)
I remember a church being set on fire across the street from the White House. I guess arson, especially if directed at Christian churches, is just the way we exercise our 1st Amendment rights in this country.

https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/historic-church-nea...

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by ARandomerDude on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:18PM (#28763370)
No disagreement there, and for the record I am glad the Jan 6 rioters are being prosecuted.

The point I was raising is that "Facebook = riot" is too simplistic an explanation. Moreover the contributing factors are not isolated to one event or political persuasion.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by atonse on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:57PM (#28763040)
Facebook has a much wider reach than Bic Tobacco could dream of.

As far as actual impact on thousands of lives, it's probably a tossup since Facebook has many means of ruining lives (psychological manipulation, distrust in government, pandemic misinformation, political misinformation). But I'd wager that Facebook has probably already caused way more harm than tobacco. It's hard to measure though.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by raxxorrax on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:41AM (#28770288)
Distrust in government is a democratic necessity. There were more insidious source for misinformation on vaccines than Facebook, although some of the worst cases were favored by government (lab leak suppression).

Tendency is that the parent comment is correct and the proposed solutions are practically bretty bad.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by irrational on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:12PM (#28763267)
It's worse, right? Other than second-hand smoke, tobacco for the most part hurts just that person. The same can't be said for social media.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by mFixman on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:04PM (#28764055)
Tobacco kills 8 million people per year, and that's with over half a century of regulation and cessation problems taxation. It's also a disgusting habit that destroys any area smokers step in.

HN is at its worse when fuming over Facebook, and comparing the tragedy caused by smoking companies with social media is a good example of how uninformed the site can get.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by satellite2 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:29PM (#28764421)
With only 10 years of existence and already to its palmares a genocide in Myanmar and making the worst pandemic since the plague much worse, I think the comparison is not so far fetched.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by mFixman on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:42PM (#28764584)
So the Burmese government and military junta had nothing to do with the genocide. The local media, endemic discrimination, local warlords, international support, nor the people actually guiding and doing the genocide had any responsability.

Was social media the cause for the 1994 genocide in Rwanda too?

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by shadilay on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:53PM (#28764721)
"Cut the tall trees" Mass media sure helped.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by satellite2 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:52PM (#28764714)
As with cigarette seller, it was never in their best interest that their product cause cancer. But it does. In top of that they had evidence of it earlier than the public and chose to hide it.

Facebook had many internal whisteblowers that the platform was used to shape the public opinion and facilitate the genocide and choose to do nothing.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:36PM (#28762709)
I think Big Tobacco is still worse but honestly? The extreme radicalism we're seeing in our modern society is pretty terrible - I just don't think it's fair to blame all of that radicalism on Facebook, even if it has played a role in nurturing it.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by marvin on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:16PM (#28764240)
I'm fairly confident that widespread internet-based multicast communication is almost solely responsible for many of the profoundly weird things that have happened in global politics for the last six years. It's a very powerful new tool for communication that has hit very fast and without enough time for society to adapt to the change. A textbook example of accelerating technological change throwing a monkey wrench into what seemed to be a well-oiled machine.

It's fair enough to say that Facebook is only responsible for a significant part of this, as there's also Twitter, YouTube, Instagram (pre-acquisition), Snapchat, TikTok and so on, and there would be others if these did not exist. The root cause is smartphones, the Internet and cheap bandwidth & servers.

But in the context of regulation, finding out how to deal with this new weapon of communication, starting with a case study of the biggest seems like an excellent beginning.

I honestly think unregulated social media has the potential to do more damage than unregulated tobacco sales, if by regulation we mean "government-enforced rules". But I don't mean to frame it as a context; it seems obvious that both are a good idea.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by dntrkv on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:17PM (#28763351)
> The extreme radicalism

What do you think FB's role is in that? Do you think the "algorithms" are to blame?

Seems to me that unmoderated online discussion will always be toxic. Take a look at the chan forums for an extreme, anonymous version of social media where there are no algorithms to blame.

When you bring the general public online and give them a platform to voice their insane ideas they never discussed before, you get the internet in 2021.

Combine that with the fact that until recently, people on the opposite sides of the political spectrum rarely interacted. The division was there, but it was masked by the inability to directly attack each other. Now, I can go on Twitter and argue all day with the other side in a thread below a Senator's tweet.

Unless you are suggesting Facebook begin heavily moderating what people say, there will be no other outcome until we as a society collectively learn to 1. Have empathy for others when conversing online, 2. Stop participating in discussions that make you feel terrible, and the classic, 3. Don't believe everything you read online.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:42PM (#28762827)
It wasn't fair to blame all of cancer on Big Tobacco, either.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by heavyset_go on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:36PM (#28765939)
Read "A Genocide Incited on Facebook, With Posts From Myanmar’s Military"[1] and "Facebook Admits It Was Used to Incite Violence in Myanmar"[2].

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/06/technology/myanmar-facebo...

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by aaroninsf on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#28763036)
Facebook is much, much, much worse.

Assuming general equivalency in manipulation of public opinion to hide their malfeasance,

the impact of that malfeasance is orders of magnitude worse for our society, democracy, and world culture.

If you have any doubt about this, you haven't looked at any of the reporting, not just from this latest data dump, but from any of the other whistle-blowing, leaks, third party investigations, etc.

It's not just that they bury and spin any internal findings which may compromise their ability to pursue "engagement," it's so so much worse.

Look at the documents. This whistleblower brought the receipts.

Their continued operations as a monolith represents an acute and active threat. They should be broken up and subjected to transparency requirements.

That's what you get when you pursue profit and power at the expense of social cohesion, functioning government, and in the case of many in harsh realities outside the US, assistance in brutal political suppression and worse.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by aaroninsf on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:09PM (#28765668)
LOL downvotes are the surest possible sign of unsettling and upsetting those who are complicit.

Work for them? Quit. Do business with them? Don't. Think access to clients and relationships with them depend on participating in this ecosystem? It doesn't.

Break the monopoly.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by oarabbus_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:11PM (#28762295)
And Philip Morris/Altria Group has vastly grown in size since half a century ago. It seems you are proving their point?
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by munk-a on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:37PM (#28762727)
They have - though they've diversified domestically in a significant way and while cigarettes (and vaping!) is still a major societal problem it's not nearly as bad as it was in the 80's and earlier.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by kaesar14 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:31PM (#28762629)
Is that true for domestic sales?
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by r00fus on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:40PM (#28762793)
While cigarettes are no longer a threat to societal health. We have monitoring programs in place, insurance costs (smokers pay higher premiums) factored, and ways to prevent our kids from being marketed to.

The alternative is we go the banhammer route, and as we learned with prohibition era, that had unintended/undesirable consequences.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by oarabbus_ on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:40PM (#28763707)
>While cigarettes are no longer a threat to societal health.

Cigarettes are the leading cause of preventable death in the USA (even moreso in countries where smoking is far more accepted widespread) so I don't believe this to be even remotely true.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by Alex3917 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:45PM (#28762870)
> The alternative is we go the banhammer route, and as we learned with prohibition era, that had unintended/undesirable consequences.

Prohibition never banned a specific delivery mechanism but not the actual drug, so it's never been tried.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by midasuni on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:30PM (#28765873)
Weed was banned for a significant time
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by dragontamer on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:57PM (#28763953)
Congress is where new laws are enacted.

If a law was broken, it's be a judicial branch / trial. The topic of discussion here is what future laws should be.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by invalidname on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:15PM (#28762363)
As a public company they need to disclose information to investors which in some cases they didn't disclose. This is a SEC violation that might be hard to prove since it's hard to say what's OK and isn't.

Also Facebook reps lied to congress which is criminal. The studies show they clearly knew a lot more than they were admitting to about the impact they had and lied under oath.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by not2b on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:38PM (#28762746)
Congress is not a court. Congressional hearings aren't about determining whether someone broke the law, but rather about whether laws need to be changed.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by somedude895 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:38PM (#28762737)
She's accusing Facebook of withholding information on these issues from shareholders. Now whether the information was relevant or significant enough to announce to shareholders is another question. I guess the media awareness of the whistleblowing did lead to share prices dropping, so kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy?
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by not2b on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:39PM (#28762770)
She's also handed over lots of material to the SEC, which has the responsibility of deciding whether there have been any violations. But that's a separate track from congressional hearings.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by raxxorrax on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:37AM (#28770260)
I think the "solution" she proposes is much worse than Facebook showing questionable advertising and general content to be honest. A ministry to institutionalize a line of communication between Washington and socal media? That is much worse.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:31PM (#28762628)
My response is by no means a whole response, but I share my amused surprise given that 'shareholder value' argument gets trotted out the moment company does anything that upsets society a little. This suggests that it is not about the good of the society, but that of a specific power center. Normally, as you said, pursuit of profit is cool in US.

Here, FB, if you listen to some of the commentary, is not doing 'enough' to combat 'hate' and 'disinformation'. In short, FB does not do enough about wrongthink to use 1984 terms.

Now, there are arguments to use against FB for the impact on society, but the fact that everyone appears to be surprised that company, gasp, chooses profit over society, is beyond hilarious. No fucking shit.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by asabjorn on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:38PM (#28764533)
Her testimony seem designed to provide cover for increased viewpoint censorship on the facebook platform. Her explicit examples are "hate speech" by conservative dissenters that cause people to disagree with narratives she agrees with.

Facebook has applied some of the most heavy-handed and widespread politically motivated censorship that the west has ever seen. If anything, increasing this censorship is likely to increase cronyism and division more than anything.

And their censorship has often not been correct in the past, when being wrong caused real damage. E.g. the now mainstream lab leak hypothesis was censored in a way that may have delayed a more effective response.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by shadilay on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @03:56PM (#28764763)
It doesn't matter which side the censorship falls on. No one entity should have the power over the speech of millions. Break up facebook.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by asabjorn on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:53PM (#28766763)
The people involved also cause me pause, and indicate she is not a moderate seeking measured change good for all viewpoints. Her lawyer is Andrew P. Bakaj, an attorney and former intelligence officer with the Central Intelligence Agency. He was the principal attorney representing the whistleblower who filed the initial complaint that led to the launch of multiple investigations by the United States Congress into the Trump–Ukraine scandal, the impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump, and, ultimately, the first Impeachment of Donald Trump.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_P._Bakaj

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by LatteLazy on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @02:12PM (#28763277)
They're really not breaking any laws.

They might be doing some things which are questionable ethically. But stopping that would require new laws. And that's very hard because you can't really make a case to target FB in particular (and not also a bunch of other harmful media). But other harmful media (eg Fox "news") is protected by the 1st amendment. And likely so is Facebook for that matter.

But pointing at unethical behaviour and pretending you're outraged is very in vogue. Doubly so in big tech.

Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by vijaybritto on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:13PM (#28762328)
Yeah that means that the law is inadequate and that a company can get away with killing people
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by mike00632 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @07:29PM (#28767077)
Facebook knowingly facilitated a genocide of the Rohingya people. That is a lot different from just not "being a good Samaritan".
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by raxxorrax on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:27AM (#28770555)
Without facebook or free internet platforms in general you might not even know they exist. It is difficult to assess your own knowledge.
Re:Facebook whistleblower hearing: Frances Haugen testifies ... by mike00632 on Sunday October 10, 2021 @02:50AM (#28816344)
Oh great, so Facebook made that genocide happen but I should thank them because they helped me be informed about it after the fact. What a fantastic Facebook world we live in.